Peb cov lus teb rau Rory Reid qhov "kev thuam" ntawm Nicole Prause 2013 EEG txoj kev tshawb no (Steele et al., 2013)

YBOP COV LUS QHUAB:

Hauv qab no yog YBOP Lub Xya Hli, 2013 teb rau "Kev Txhaum Cai ntawm Kev Tshawb Fawb" los ntawm Rory C. Reid, PhD (Lub Tsev Haujlwm Kev Puas Hlwb, University of California, Los Angeles). Yog vim li cas peb tau sau ib qho lus teb rau Rory Reid tus neeg thuam thuam ntawm Nicole Prause's "Kev sib deev siab, tsis yog Hypersexuality, muaj feem xyuam rau Neurophysiological Responses Elicited los ntawm kev sib deev“? Vim tias nws tsis yog cov lus thuam txhua. Hloov chaw, nws yog daim ntawv tiv thaiv veiled ntawm qhov kev kawm Prause EEG (Steele li al., 2013). Thawj qhov muab tam sim ntawd yog tias Rory Reid hais txog Gary Wilson kaum zaus hauv nws qhov hu ua "kev thuam". Thib ob, Reid hais 3 zaug uas Gary Wilson Psychology Niaj hnub no blog ncej kev ntsuam xyuas Prause txoj kev tshawb no tsis muaj luam tawm ntxiv. Ob leeg Reid thiab Prause paub zoo heev vim li cas nws ploj lawm: Siv sijhawm pressured Psychology Niaj hnub no kom tshem tawm tsis tsuas yog Wilson tus ncej, tab sis no ncej los ntawm ob tug lwm bloggers. Thaum kawg, Rory Reid qhov kev thuam tsis dhau rau txhua yam ntawm peb lub ntsiab lus tseem ceeb, lossis piav qhia tam sim ntawm Prause cov lus tsis raug rau cov xovxwm. Hloov, Reid deflects kev thuam los ntawm mischaracterizing qhov YBOP tsom xam tau hais dab tsi. Nco tseg: Rory Reid tau hais tseg tias nws lub chaw ua haujlwm UCLA nyob ze rau ntawm Prause's (thiab ob tug coj los ua chav nyob).

Hloov tshiab: Ua ntej peb yuav mus Rory Reid tus neeg thuam thiab Steele li al.'s qhov tseeb pom, ntau tau tawm txij Lub Xya hli ntuj, 2013. UCLA tsis txuas hnub nyoog Nicole Prause qhov ntawv cog lus (ncig lub Ib Hlis, 2015). Tsis ntev lawm Qhov kev kawm nce zaus tau sau tseg keeb kwm ntev kev thab plaub thiab defaming Gary Wilson thiab lwm tus, nrog rau cov kws tshawb fawb, kws kho mob, kws kho mob, psychologists, qub UCLA npoj yaig, ib lub chaw pabcuam UK, txiv neej rov qab, SIJHAWM magazine editor, ntau tus xibfwb, IITAP, SASH, Sib ntaus Tus Tshiab Tshuaj, cov phau ntawv qhia kev kawm Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam, nws lub koom haum niam txiv MDPI, tus thawj coj ntawm cov phau ntawv journal CUREUS, thiab phau ntawv sau tseg Kev sib deev sib deev & Kev xav sib ua. Saib: Cov ntaub ntawv pov thawj ntawm Nicole Prause kev thuam thiab ua phem Gary Wilson & ntau lwm tus (thiab tam sim no ib nplooj ntawv thib ob thiab ib tug nplooj ntawv thib peb).

Ib qho tseem ceeb: Txawm hais tias muaj kev cuam tshuam nws tseem yog dag tias nws yog "tus neeg raug tsim txom," nws yog Prause uas tau pib txhua tus neeg thiab kev ua phem rau cov tib neeg thiab cov koom haum teev npe ntawm nplooj ntawv no. Tsis muaj leej twg nyob hauv daim ntawv teev npe nram qab no tau ua phem rau Nicole Prause. Nws tau sau cov lus hais txog kev raug mob ntawm "raug soj ntsuam" lossis misogyny ntawm "anti-porn activists" tsis muaj iota ntawm cov ntaub ntawv. Tag nrho cov pov thawj uas nws muab yog nws tus kheej-tsim: ib daim ntawv info-graphic, ob peb emails los ntawm nws mus rau lwm tus txog kev ua phem, thiab tsib ntxias cease thiab desist letters nrog cov lus sib liam tsis tseeb. Koj tseem yuav pom cov pov thawj ntawm ntau cov ntaub ntawv tsis txaus siab Qhov ua ntej tau xa nrog ntau lub koom haum ntxawg - uas tau muab tso tawm los yog tshawb xyuas thiab tso tseg. Nws zoo nkaus li ua cov ntawv foob pob ntawv no kom nws thiaj li mus rau ntawm nws lub hom phiaj yog "tag sim neej."

Prause tsis muaj cov qauv piv txwv uas yog lub hom phiaj ntawm kev cyber-stalking seb lawv tweet, Facebook, lossis mus rau nplooj ntawv hauv YBOP. Ntawm qhov tod tes, Prause's Twitter pub ib leeg muaj ib zaug pua pua ntawm kev ntxias thiab tsis muaj tseeb tweets targeting Wilson thiab ntau lwm tus (Prause tau txij li deleted txog 3,000 xws li cov tweets). Muab qhov yooj yim, Prause tau tsim ib qho mythology nrog pes tsawg tus pov thawj, thaum zoo tuab dlhos rua kev ua luam yeeb, raws li tau pom los ntawm qhov no duab ntawm nws (sab xis) ntawm daim ntaub pua plag liab ntawm X-Rated Critics Organization (XRCO) khoom plig ceremony. (Raws li Wikipedia, tus XRCO Txeeb raug muab los ntawm Amelikas X-Rated Critics Organization txhua xyoo rau cov neeg ua haujlwm hauv kev lom zem laus thiab kuvt yog qhov kev lag luam loj tshaj plaws rau cov neeg laus uas tau muab tshwj tseg rau cov neeg koom hauv kev lag luam.^[1]) Rau ntau cov ntaub ntawv ntxiv, saib: Puas yog Nicole Pract Influenced los ntawm kev lag luam Porn?).

Peb cov lus teb rau Rory Reid (Lub Xya Hli, 2013):

Peb zoo siab pom cov lus teb rau cov lus nug peb tau tsa, txawm tias nws yog qhov kev thuam ntawm Prause ua haujlwm thaum tsuas yog thuam nws cov neeg thuam. Raws li feem ntau ntawm cov ntsiab lus peb tau tsa tau raug tsis quav ntsej, lossis spun kom muaj lub ntsiab lus sib txawv, peb xav tau Dr. Reid nug Dr. Prause teb cov lus nug ntxiv nram qab no:

1) Vim li cas koj tau hloov nws tias koj qhov kev tshawb pom pom tias lub siab lub ntsws muaj qhov siab tiag tiag "siab" thaum koj txoj kev tshawb nrhiav pom ntau dua lub hlwb ua kom cuam tshuam nrog kev muaj siab rau kev sib deev? Lus Cim Thov Siv lo lus ntawd hauv kev xam phaj no:

Qhov kev tshawb fawb hauv koj txoj kev tshawb pom yog dab tsi?
"Peb pom tias lub hlwb cov lus teb rau cov duab kev sib deev tsis tau kwv yees los ntawm ib qho ntawm peb qhov kev nug sib txawv ntawm qhov ntsuas qhov ntsuas siab. Lub paj hlwb cov lus teb tsuas yog kwv yees los ntawm ib qho kev ntsuas ntawm kev sib deev muaj siab. Nyob rau hauv lwm yam lus, hypersexuality tsis tshwm sim piav qhia lub hlwb txawv ntawm kev sib deev muaj ntau tshaj li muaj libido siab."

Tab sis qhov ntawd tsis tshwm sim, raws li John Johnson PhD tau qhia nyob rau hauv no cov neeg saib-xyuas dua:

'Ib qho tseem ceeb ntawm kev tshawb nrhiav hais tias tsis muaj dab tsi txog kev quav tshuaj. Tsis tas li ntawd, qhov kev pom tseem ceeb no yog ib qho tsis zoo sib ze ntawm P300 thiab muaj siab rau kev sib deev nrog tus khub (r = -0.33), qhia tias P300 amplitude muaj feem rau qis kev sib deev muaj siab; qhov no ncaj qha cuam tshuam tus txhais lus ntawm P300 ua siab ntshaw. Tsis muaj kev sib piv rau lwm pawg neeg quav. Tsis muaj kev sib piv los tswj cov pawg. Cov lus xaus los ntawm cov neeg tshawb xyuas yog ib cov lej tawm ntawm cov ntaub ntawv, uas hais tias tsis muaj dab tsi hais txog cov neeg uas qhia txog teeb meem kev tswj lawv cov kev xav ntawm kev sib deev muaj lossis tsis muaj lub hlwb lub cev zoo li cov yeeb yam los yog lwm hom addicts '

2) Dr. Prause, vim li cas koj thiaj tau hais txog pawg "nyob rau hauv-tswj" vim qhov no tsis cuam tshuam nrog cov Steele li al.Tsuas yog cov lus hais:

"P300 qhov loj tshaj qhov txawv ntawm kev ntxim nyiam deev stimuli, tus txheeb ze rau qhov tsis hnov mob ntawm lub cev tsis zoo, yog cuam tshuam txog kev ntsuas ntawm kev sib deev muaj siab, tab sis tsis txheeb txog kev ntsuas ntawm hypersexuality."

Neeg txhais lus: Cov tib neeg uas muaj ntau dua cue-reactivity rau porn tau qis dua kev muaj siab nrog kev sib deev (tab sis tsis qis dua kev xav masturbate). Txhawm rau lwm txoj hauv kev: cov tib neeg uas muaj ntau lub hlwb ua kom thiab xav tau rau porn yuav xum masturbate rau porn dua li muaj kev sib deev nrog tus neeg tiag. Tsis cuam tshuam rau Prause qhov kev hu ua "hauv-kev kawm" tswj hwm pawg.

3) Dr. Prause, vim li cas koj ho ua cov lus tsis txaus ntseeg hauv koj lub tswv yim Psychology Hnub no sib tham thiab lwm qhov? Lub Psychology Niaj hnub no kev sib tham:

Lub hom phiaj ntawm txoj kev tshawb no yog dab tsi?
Prause: Peb txoj kev tshawb nrhiav pom tias cov neeg uas qhia txog tej teeb meem no zoo li lwm cov neeg quav yeeb quav ntawm lawv lub hlwb cov lus teb rau cov duab liab qab. Kev tshawb fawb ntawm kev quav yeeb quav tshuaj, xws li cov yeeb yaj kiab, tau pom ib qho qauv ntawm lub hlwb lub cev rau cov duab ntawm yeeb tshuaj ntawm kev tsim txom, yog li peb tau pom zoo tias peb yuav tsum pom tib qauv ntawm cov neeg uas qhia txog teeb meem nrog kev sib deev yog tias qhov tseeb kev quav tshuaj.
Qhov no qhia tau tias kev sib daj sib deev yog qhov tswvyim hais ua dab tsi?
Yog tias peb txoj kev tshawb no rov muab dua los, cov kev tshawb pom no yog qhov teeb meem loj rau cov kev xav ntawm kev sib daj sib deev uas yog "kev quav tshuaj". Yog vim li cas cov kev tshawb nrhiav no muaj kev sib tw yog tias nws qhia tau hais tias lawv lub hlwb tsis teb rau cov duab zoo li lwm cov quav rau lawv cov yeeb tshuaj ntawm kev quav tshuaj.

Cov lus saum toj no hais tias cov kev kawm lub hlwb tsis “teb zoo li lwm tus neeg quav yeeb tshuaj yog tsis muaj kev txhawb nqa. Hauv Steele li al., cov kawm muaj cov EEG ntau dua (P300) nyeem thaum saib cov duab kev sib deev - uas yog qhov tshwm sim thaum cov neeg quav saib cov duab cuam tshuam nrog lawv cov yees (ib yam li hauv txoj kev tshawb no rau cov neeg quav yeeb quav tshuaj). Lus hauv qab Psychology Niaj hnub no kev sib tham ntawm Prause, senior psychology xib fwb emeritus John A. Johnson hais:

"Kuv lub siab tseem boggles ntawm tus Prause thov tias nws cov ntsiab lus 'plaw tsis tau hnov cov dluab ntawm kev sib deev xws li tshuaj lom neeg lub hlwb ua rau lawv cov tshuaj, muab hais tias nws qhia ntau dua P300 nyeem cov duab rau cov duab liab qab. Ib yam li cov neeg quav yeeb quav tshuaj uas pom P300 spikes thaum lawv nrog cov tshuaj lawv xaiv. Yuav ua li cas nws yuav kos ib qhov xaus uas yog qhov txawv ntawm qhov kev tshwm sim tiag tiag? Kuv xav tias nws tuaj yeem yog vim nws qhov kev nkag siab cia ua ntej - qhov nws xav pom. "

4) Dr, Prause, dab tsi yog qhov sib txheeb ntawm cov ntaub ntawv EEG thiab tag nrho 14 cov lus nug ntawm Cov Lus Qhia Txog Kev Sib Deev (SDI)? Kuv mam teb: tsis muaj qhov sib txheeb. Txoj kev tshawb no yog qhia cov neeg nyiam txiv neej xav sib deev, tab sis muaj qhov xaus lus no:

xaus: Qhov cuam tshuam rau to taub hypersexuality ua siab muaj siab, tsis yog kev tsis txaus siab, los sib tham.

Vim li cas lub ntiaj teb yuav koj thov kom muaj lub siab xav ua thaum nws kawm nrog ntau dua cue-reactivity tau qis qis rau kev sib deev nrog tus khubCov. Ib qho ntxiv, cov lus hais tias “kev muaj siab rau kev sib deev” rov qab ua dua 63 zaug hauv txoj kev tshawb fawb, thiab kev kawm lub npe (Txoj Kev Xav Sib Deev, Tsis Yog Hypersexuality….) Txhais tau tias lub hlwb ua haujlwm ntau dua rau cues tau cuam tshuam nrog kev sib deev siab dua. Ntxiv mus, tag nrho cov xov xwm muaj qw tias "kev sib deev quav" yog qhov muaj siab tiag tiag? Tab sis nws tsis yog lub siab xav tau!

5) Dr. Reid hais tias, "Ib qhov teeb meem kuv tuaj yeem tshaj yog kuv qhov tsis xis nrog Mr. Wilson kev tso tawm ntawm EEG los ua thev naus laus zis." Qhov twg peb tau tso tawm EEG ua ib qho technology? Qhov tseeb, peb cov lus teb tau txuas rau 2 cov kev tshawb fawb uas siv EEGs narrowly thiab competently rau kev tshawb nrhiav yeeb tshuaj. Peb tsuas yog taw qhia tias, tsis zoo li cov tshuaj muaj yees, kev sib deev-kev coj cwj pwm yeej siv ntau yam kev nkag siab. Ua cov ntawv thov sab nrauv raws li kev tsim kho EEG tsis zoo vim yog cov kev txwv ntawm kev siv technology.

6) Dr, Prause, qhov twg yog qhov pov thawj uas pom tias "kev txaus siab nyiam ib leeg" feem ntau yog siv los ua kev ntsuas ntawm "kev muaj siab rau kev sib deev?" Koj tsis lees qhov no, tab sis tsuas yog txhawb nqa qhov kev tshawb fawb tshawb fawb txog qhov kev thov no nws qhov nws tsis lees paub (kawm 1, kawm 2Cov. Ntxiv mus, yog li ua cov lus los ntawm ib qho ntawm SDI tus tsim tawm, Ilana Spector, leej twg peb tau tiv tauj kom nkag siab txog Prause cov lus foob (ib zaug peb pom cov kev tshawb fawb tau hais nyob rau hauv nws cuam tshuam nrog lawv). Spector, uas tau lees paub peb hais tias SDI yog npaj los ua ib txoj haujlwm nkaus xwb, hais tias, "Tau ntsuas tsuas yog siv tau siv tag nrho cov khoom ob leeg rau ib leeg thiab dyadic .... Cov nplai tsis yog tsim los siv [raws li nyob ntawm no] thiab tsis siv txoj kev ntawd. ”

7) Prause, koj yeej paub tias tus txheej txheem kev cai lij choj rau txoj kev tshawb xyuas kev quav tshuaj yog kev soj ntsuam qhov kev ua haujlwm ntawm lub hlwb. Vim li cas ho yog cov kawm txiv neej thiab poj niam, nrog rau 7 uas tsis yog-heterosexuals? Kev tshawb nrhiav tom qab kev tshawb pom tau lees tias txiv neej thiab poj niam muaj qhov sib txawv hauv lub hlwb rau cov duab ntawm kev sib deev lossis cov yeeb yaj kiab. Cov kev tshawb fawb lub hlwb muaj txiaj ntsig koom nrog hom kev kawm: hom kev sib deev, tib yam kev sib deev, nrog rau cov hnub nyoog zoo sib xws thiab IQ's. Ib leeg no txo koj cov kev tshawb pom.

8) Dr. Prause, koj yuav ua li cas tuaj yeem qhia txog tus neeg tsis yog poj niam txiv neej sib raug zoo hauv kev sim nrog tsuas yog kev sib daj sib deev - thiab tom qab ntawd kos cov lus xaus los ntawm qhov (paub tseeb) tsis muaj kev sib txheeb? Qhov no tseem hu koj cov txiaj ntsig rau lo lus nug.

9) Prial, yog vim li cas koj cov ntsiab lus tsis tau kuaj? Cov cuab yeej kev siv lub hlwb cov kev tshawb fawb soj ntsuam cov neeg mob rau cov mob ua ntej (kev nyuaj siab, OCD, lwm yam khoom siv, thiab lwm yam). Qhov no kuj hu koj cov lus teb rau cov lus nug.

10) Dr. Prause, vim li cas koj thiaj li siv SCS (Kev Sib Tw Txoj Kev Sib Deev Sib deev) thaum nws tsis yog qhov kev ntsuas uas siv tau rau kev tiv thaiv kev tiv thaiv kev tiv thaiv kev sib deev hauv Internet lossis rau poj niam? Nws tau tsim nyob rau xyoo 1995 thiab tsim los nrog kev sib deev tsis txaus ntseeg kev sib raug zoo hauv kev xav (nyob rau hauv kev txuas nrog kev soj ntsuam AIDS phaum mob). Ntxiv dua thiab, qhov no tsuas piav qhia vim li cas thiaj tsis muaj kev sib haum xeeb ntawm P300 nyeem thiab SCS.

Rov qab mus rau cov lus qhia txog lub siab xav deev (SDI), thiab Rory Reid thov hais tias peb xum tsis tau cov qhab nia rau SDI:Mr. Wilson tau sim txiav txim tias Dr. Prause tau ua tsis tau zoo los tshawb xyuas SDI qhov kev siv hauv nws txoj kev kawm“. Nyeem qhov peb tau hais tseg, pib no. Peb tau hais meej meej tias tsis muaj kev sib raug zoo thaum muaj tag nrho SDI tau siv. Qhov no yog qhov tseeb. Thaum Steele thiab Al tau qhia txog qhov tsis zoo sib xws ntawm EEG nyeem thiab koom nrog SDI cov lus nug, qhov kev txheeb xyuas tau nws tus kheej yog ib txoj kev kawm txoj kev tshawb nrhiav thiab xov xwm cuav txog “kev muaj siab rau kev sib deev“. Qhov tseeb tiag los ntawm txoj kev tshawb no:

"Loj P300 siab tshaj qhov txawv ntawm kev ntxim nyiam deev stimuli, ib tus txheeb ze rau qhov tsis hnov mob ntawm lub cev, yog negatively cuam tshuam txog kev ntsuas ntawm kev sib deev muaj siab, tab sis tsis muaj feem xyuam rau kev ntsuas ntawm kev ntsuas siab dua. "

Neeg txhais lus: Cov tib neeg uas muaj ntau dua cue-reactivity rau porn tau qis dua kev muaj siab nrog kev sib deev (tab sis tsis qis dua kev xav masturbate). Txhawm rau lwm txoj hauv kev - cov tib neeg uas muaj ntau lub hlwb ua kom thiab xav tau rau porn yuav xum masturbate rau porn dua li muaj kev sib deev nrog tus neeg tiag. Kuj sib txawv ntawm qhov kev xam phaj thiab cov ncauj lus zoo.

Tau saib Cov Lus 2 los ntawm tag nrho cov ntawv nyeem ntawm txoj kev tshawb no.

Nyem rau ntug 2

Ua ntej, "Cov Lus Cim" hais tias Cov qhab nia Kev ntsuas ua ntu zus yog "3-26," thiab tsis tau txhais tias tus poj niam ntau dua li nws. Nws yog 26.46 – raws cov ntawv qhia tawm. Dab tsi tshwm sim?

Tseem ceeb tshaj, txawm li cas los xij, yog tias SPAN Lab tau ntsuas qhov tseeb "kev sib deev muaj siab" siv SDI tag nrho, nws cov kws tshawb nrhiav yuav ntxiv qhov kev ntsuas siab ntawm lub siab-qhov kev xav tau qhov tseem ceeb tau qhab nia ntawm 23.92 (ntawm 26) rau hauv kev sib koom tes-kev xav tau txhais tau tias yog tus qhab nia ntawm 58 (ntawm qhov ua tau 70). Yog li, qhov tseeb "kev sib deev muaj siab" txhais tau tias cov qhab nia yog qhov tseem ceeb tshaj 82 (ntawm qhov ua tau 96).

Yuav muaj dab tsi tshwm sim thaum ib tus piv cov tseeb (14-nqe lus nug) "cov lus nug kev sib deev" xav tau nrog EEG cov ntaub ntawv? Nws tsis muaj qhov sib cuam tshuam tseem ceeb hlo liCov. Tsis muaj qhov tseeb uas tsis txaus ntseeg txog kev rhuav tshem lub tswv yim ntawm "kev quav yeeb quav tshuaj," tsis muaj qhov tsis txaus ntseeg, thiab tsis tas yuav muaj kev kub ntxhov rau txhua tus neeg ua phem kom sim pom qhov tsis pom. Hauv ntej, Steele li al. kev tshawb pom ntawm kev sib txheeb me ntsis ntawm EEG nyeem ntawv thiab cov lus nug yuav muaj qhov tsis txaus siab nrhiav tau (yooj yim piav qhia los ntawm lwm qhov tsis muaj zog).

Nws tseem ceeb uas yuav tsum nco ntsoov tias txoj kev tshawb no muaj qhov yuam kev thib ob hauv qhov SDI: “SDI ntsuas theem kev sib deev uas siv ob qhov teev muaj li ntawm xya yam khoom txhua.”Qhov tseeb, Cov Ntawv Sau Txog Kev Sib Deev muaj cuaj koom nrog cov lus nug, plaub lo lus nugs, thiab ib lo lus nug uas tsis tau categorized (# 14). Lub xov tooj uas nyob sab nraud blitz, uas tau nrog nws cov ntawv luam tawm txoj kev tshawb no, ua rau nws lub ntsiab lus ntsej muag nyob ntawm ib feem ntawm SDI. Txawm li cas los xij, kev sau ntawv tuaj yeem muaj teeb meem txog qhov SDI xwb, uas tsis muaj kev ntseeg siab rau cov neeg tshawb xyuas.

Psychology Niaj hnub no thiab Nicole Prause

Yog lawm, Peb Lub Siab Lub ntsws Niaj hnub no tau raug tshem tawm. Nws yog peb txoj kev nkag siab tias nws tau raug tshem tawm vim tsis muaj kev txhaum cai lij choj tawm tsam "Psychology Today," los ntawm Dr. Prause nws tus kheej. Qhov tseeb, ib hnub tom qab, PT tshem tawm ib qho ua ntej tshaj tawm ntawm peb… txog lwm txoj kev tshawb nrhiav SPAN. Tsuas yog cov posts peb tau muab tshem tawm hauv 4 xyoo ntawm blogging yog cov posts txog Prause. Hmm. Kev kawm tau zoo rau txoj kev sib cav tswv yim qhib, tsis yog qhov zoo li no-tus-neeg kev sib thab.

Reid (saum toj no) ob zaug txuas rau peb cov ncej ntawm "Psychology Today" (uas tam sim no nthuav tawm nplooj ntawv tsis tshaj tawm) thiab qhia tias nws tau raug tshem tawm vim yog "Psychology Today's" ntseeg tias nws muaj qhov yuam kev. Muab hais tias peb peb tus kheej tau txais kev ua phem, tsis muaj tseeb kev cai lij choj los ntawm Dr. Prause, peb heev tsis ntseeg txog qhov no.

Txawm hais tias peb ntxub los sau cov ntsiab lus ntawm cov email rau pej xeem, qhov no, peb xav tias nws tsim nyog ua kom cov neeg nyiam nyeem tuaj yeem tau txais cov duab puv ntawm Dr. Prause cov kev tawm tsam. Saib tag nrho kev sib pauv ntawm email ntawm peb thiab nws (hauv qab). Cov xwm txheej no tau tshwm sim ntau lub hlis dhau los, thaum lub Plaub Hlis, 2013, thaum nws "xau tawm" ib qho kev tshaj tawm, tsis tau rov tshawb xyuas dua ntawm qhov kev tshawb fawb no (tsuas yog) rau kev nyiam blogger David Ley, sau ntawm Lub tswvyim hais txog kev sib deev. Tom qab ntawd nws tau "Lub Siab Hnub Niaj Hnub" tshem tawm peb cov lus teb. Qhov tshwm sim tsis zoo, peb tom qab ntawd thov "Cov Neeg Niaj Hnub Niaj Hnub No" cov neeg kho kom tshem tawm Ley txoj haujlwm raws li qhov kev kawm paub xau (uas Prause tau tsis kam ua rau lwm tus neeg), thiab "Psychology Today" tau tshem nws. (Txiav txim rau koj tus kheej: Nyem no kom pom David Ley cov ntawv blog, peb cov lus teb blog, thiab cov lus hauv qab peb tus ncej - suav nrog Gary pauv nrog Nicole Prause.)

Thaum txoj kev tshawb nrhiav zaum kawg tawm, Prause tau caw Brian Mustanski los tshaj qhov kev xam phaj uas ntxim nyiam, qhov twg Prause tuaj yeem "yauv" qhov ua rau nws xav tau. Peb tau tshaj tawm lo lus teb rau nws cov ntawv, thiab qhov ntawd yog dab tsi Prause tau muaj “Lub Siab Niaj Hnub Niaj Hnub” tshem tawm.

Nco ntsoov tias Prause tau muaj sijhawm ntau los tawm tswv yim rau peb cov lus teb blog txog nws ob txoj kev tshawb fawb (ob qho tib si ntawm cov tuaj yeem nrhiav tau ntawm Porn Study CritiquesCov. Hloov chaw, nws tau xaiv tsis coj peb ncaj qha. Tam sim no, nws tau mus nkaum tom qab Dr. Reid lub vev xaib tawm lus, qhov twg tsis muaj lus teb ncaj qha los ntawm tus neeg tuaj thuam.

Hloov tshiab: Txij li nplooj ntawv no yog tsim thawj zaug ntawm Prause tau txuas ntxiv mus rau lub hom phiaj Gary Wilson thiab lwm tus, suav nrog cov kws tshawb nrhiav, kws kho mob, kws kho mob, kws kho mob hlwb, cov npoj yaig los ntawm nws tus cwj pwm luv luv ntawm UCLA, UK kev siab hlub, cov txiv neej hauv kev rov qab los, a SIJHAWM cov kws kho phau ntawv xov xwm, ntau tus kws tshaj lij, IITAP, SASH, Tiv Thaiv Cov Tshuaj Tshiab, Khiav Dim Quaj, phau ntawv journal Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam, nws lub koom haum niam txiv MDPI, tus thawj coj ntawm cov phau ntawv journal CUREUS, thiab phau ntawv sau tseg Kev sib deev sib deev & Kev xav sib ua. Saib: Nicole Prause Kev Ua Phem Tsis Zoo thiab Kev Txom Nyem ntawm Gary Wilson & Lwm Tus

Hloov tshiab: Nyob ib ncig ntawm Lub Ib Hlis 2015: Nicole Prause tsis ua haujlwm ntxiv los ntawm UCLA lossis lwm lub tsev kawm txuj ci.

Hloov tshiab: Muaj tam sim no 8 tus neeg saib xyuas kev soj ntsuam Steele li al., 2013. Tag nrho cov ntawv sib dhos nrog YBOP cov lus qhia hauv qab no. Tag nrho piav tag nrho cov kev tshawb nrhiav li cas Steele li al., 2013 qiv nyiaj yug rau tus qauv liab qab ua qauv. Ntawv #1 yog ib qho mob siab rau Steele li al. Cov ntaub ntawv 2-8 muaj ntu cais Steele li al., 2013:

Nicole Prause - Gary Wilson email pauv:

Lub peb hlis ntuj 5, 2013

Sau ntawm "Lub tswvyim ntawm kev sib deev," David Ley, thiab Nicole Prause pab pawg sau ntawv tuaj Psychology Niaj hnub no blog xa nrog lub npe xaiv yaam: “Koj Lub Hlwb Porn Hauv Paus - Nws Tsis Yog Dab Tsog. ” (Koj lub paj hlwb ntawm Porn yog ib tug website nrhiav tau los ntawm Wilson.) Nws yog hais txog Nicole Prause qhov kev tshaj tawm, tsis tas yuav tsum yog kev tshuaj xyuas-EEG qhov kev kawm ("Kev muaj siab rau kev sib deev, tsis yog qhov hws sib hais, muaj feem xyuam rau cov lus teb neurophysiological elicited los ntawm cov duab sib deev").

Nws yog ib qho tseem ceeb kom nco ntsoov tias tsuas yog Ley tau txais kev nkag mus rau Prause txoj kev kawm tsis raug tshaj tawm (nws tau luam tawm 5 lub hlis tom qab). Cov ntaub ntawv blog txuas nrog Wilson 'Koj Lub Hlwb ntawm Porn' lub vev xaib thiab tawm tswv yim tias YBOP tau pom zoo txwv tsis pub porn (tsis muaj tseeb).

Lub ntsiab lus tseem ceeb: Tsib lub hlis ua ntej Prause txoj kev kawm EEG (Steele li al., 2013) tau luam tawm, ob qho tib si Prause thiab Ley tau tawm tsam Gary Wilson thiab nws lub website.

Lub peb hlis ntuj 7, 2013

Wilson luam tawm ib Psychology Niaj hnub no blog xa xov rov los teb nrog cov ntsiab lus hauv David Ley post. Ley cov ntawv blog thiab Wilson cov lus teb tau muab tshem tawm thaum kawg Psychology Niaj hnub no cov neeg kho, raws li qhov kev kawm pib tsis tau muaj. Koj tuaj yeem nrhiav cov thawj Ley thiab Wilson blog cov ntaub ntawv khaws tseg noCov. Nws yog ib qho tseem ceeb kom nco ntsoov tias Wilson cov ntawv blog sau kom meej meej nws tsuas yog teb nrog Ley's piav qhia ntawm qhov kev kawm Prause. Tom qab ntawd Nicole Prause yuav hais tsis meej rau Wilson ntawm kev hais qhia qhov tsis zoo ntawm nws qhov kev kawm (tias tsuas yog nws thiab Ley tau pom, thiab tau ua rau pej xeem thov txog - uas yog tom qab pom tau tias tsis raug).

Lub peb hlis ntuj 7, 2013

Wilson cov lus nyob hauv David Ley cov lus thov txoj kev tshawb no:

"Hav David - Kuv xav paub seb koj tau txais koj txhais tes ntawm kev kawm uas tseem tsis tau tshaj tawm, lossis hais txog lwm qhov ntxiv. Koj puas kam xa tuaj rau kuv? ”

David Ley tsis teb.

Plaub Hlis Ntuj 10, 2013

Nyob rau hauv teb mus rau cov lus hais saum toj no, Ua ntej hu rau Psychology Niaj hnub no editors thiab xa tawm Wilson cov nram qab no. Hauv email, Ua tib zoo tawm tsam Wilson tus kheej, thiab ua yuam kev hais tias nws tsis thov txoj kev tshawb fawb. Nws tau, qhov tseeb, nug David Ley rau nws. Tus email:

Psychology Niaj hnub no ([email tiv thaiv])
4/10/13
Rau: [email tiv thaiv]
Los ntawm: Nicole Prause
Txog Mr. Wilson,
Nws yog ib qho txhaum cai yog tias koj hais tsis meej txog peb cov kev kawm uas tsis tau nug txog daim ntawv luam tawm. Nws yuav kho li zoj. Peb tsab xov xwm yeej yog xuas heev. Tsis zoo li koj, Kuv muaj kev tshuaj xyuas zoo nyob rau ob tog ntawm qhov teeb meem no. Koj tau sim ua kom poob ntsej muag los ntawm kev piav qhia txog tej yam uas tsis tau ua. Kuv tab tom nrhiav qhov no nrog Psychology Hnub no tam sim no, tab sis kuv xav qhia koj kom tshem tawm cov ncej koj tus kheej ua ntej kuv raug yuam kom ua raws li kev ua ntxiv.
Koj tseem tsis tau tso cai rau koj los tsocai rau ib feem ntawm qhov email no. Nws yog kev sib txuas lus ntiag tug.
Muag koj phau ntawv raws li qhov tsim nyog koj ua. Tsis txhob sim khwv kom tau nyiaj los ntawm cov kws tshawb fawb thaum lawv ua lawv txoj haujlwm. Kuv tuaj yeem qhia qhov kev kawm no kom meej meej txog koj vim tias tus qauv tsim thiab cov ntaub ntawv muaj zog, tab sis nws yog egregious muaj tsis txawm nug daim ntawv luam ntawm nplooj thiab tsuas yog ua cov ntsiab lus. Txaj muag rau koj.
Nicole Prause, PhD
Kev tshawb nrhiav kws qhia ntawv
UCLA

Nyob rau hauv tas li ntawd, Psychology Niaj hnub no editors xa email thib ob ntawm Prause:

Hnub tim: Lub Plaub Hlis 10, 2013 5: 13: 30 PM EDT
Ntsiab lus: Saib rau ntawm cov Blog
Los ntawm: Nicole Prause, PhD
Rau leej twg nws txhawj xeeb:
Kuv ceeb xav pom ib tsab xov xwm sau txog kev kawm ntawm kuv tus kheej los ntawm Gary Wilson rau Psychology Niaj hnub no.
Kuv tsis muaj teeb meem nrog nws tam nws tus kheej views thiab txhais ntawm kev tshawb fawb, tab sis nws tsis thiab tsis tau muaj kev nkag tau rau kuv. Nws yog nyob rau hauv kev ntsuam xyuas thiab nws yeej tsis tau thov ib daim qauv los ntawm ib qho ntawm cov sau phau ntawv. Kuv tau ceebtoom rau nws tias nws yuav tsum tau muab tshem tawm. Nws tseem tsis tau ua li ntawd. Ntawm chav kawm, thaum nws yog pej xeem cov ntaub ntawv, nws yuav muaj kev nkag mus rau nws thiab muaj peev xwm sawv cev rau nws (hopefully) ntau tshaj qhov tseeb.
Qhov tseeb, kev tsis qhia txog ib tug neeg tawm tsam lawv yog qhov txhaum cai. Kuv vam tias Psychology Niaj hnub no yuav siv qhov teeb meem no tiag. Kuv yuav hu rau lwm tus tswv cuab ntawm pawg thawj coj saib zoo li, yog tias koj qhov cue puv thiab yuav siv sij hawm ntev dua los teb.
Ua tsaug rau koj txoj kev pab daws qhov teeb meem no.
ua tsaug,
Nicole Prause, PhD

Kev ua phem tsis ncaj ncees, kev tsis tseeb, thiab ua si ntawm tus neeg raug tsim txom nws pib ua ntej nrog Wilson. Tsis muaj dab tsi Prause hais tias muaj tseeb:

Wilson tsis tau piav qhia txog txoj kev kawm Prause lossis piav qhia tsis yog rau hauv txhua txoj kev. Nws tsuas teb Ley's piav qhia ntawm txoj kev tshawb fawb. Nyeem Ley's thiab Wilson cov ntawv tshaj xov xwm blog thiab txiav txim rau koj tus kheej.
Txog rau hnub no Prause tsis tau hais ib lo lus hauv Wilson lub Peb Hlis, 2013 Psychology Niaj hnub no ncej, lossis tus tsom Wilson tau sau tseg hauv Lub Xya Hli tom qab nws txoj kev kawm EEG thaum kawg tau luam tawm. Tsis tau Prosed refuted ib lo lus nyob rau hauv plaub cov neeg saib xyuas kev soj ntsuam ntawm nws txoj kev tshawb 2013 EEG (1, 2, 3, 4.).
Wilson ua tsis tau nyiaj tawm ntawm kev ua haujlwm no.
Wilson tau thov kom tau ib daim qauv ntawm txoj kev tshawb fawb (Prause tsis kam muab).
Ua ntej pib ua txhua yam nrog Wilson.

Wilson email teb rau Nicole Prause:

On Wed, Plaub Hlis 10, 2013 nyob 3:14 PM, Gary wilson <> sau:
Kuv tuaj los Nicole,
Kuv tawm tswv yim hauv koj cov lus. Muaj qhov zoo.
Peb tsis tsuam khwv nyiaj rau qhov no. Kuv lub vev xaib tsis muaj kev tshaj tawm thiab peb tsis lees txais nyiaj pub dawb. Peb tsis muaj kev pabcuam muag. Kuv tsis muaj phau ntawv muag. Kuv tus poj niam phau ntawv, uas tshwm ntawm PT, tsis yog hais txog porn.
Yog tias koj xav kom muaj kev ncaj ncees tiag, thov xa peb qhov kev tshawb fawb tag nrho thiab muab kev tso cai rau peb blog txog nws - raws li koj tau ua nrog Dr. Ley.
Kuv yuav xav txog koj txoj kev kawm,
Gary Wilson

Plaub Hlis Ntuj 12, 2013

Ob hnub tom qab Ua ntej Wilson tau ntsib dua lwm txoj kev cai lij choj. Nws xyov khiav licas ib qho ntawm Wilson cov lus pom rau hauv lub xaib porn-rov qab Koj Lub Hlwb Raug TxoCov. Nws tau tshaj tawm ntev ntawm xov hais txog David Ley tus thawj blog blog. Wilson cov lus tau txhais los piav tias vim li cas ob leeg Ley thiab Wilson Psychology Niaj hnub no cov posts tau raug tshem tawm ntawm Psychology Niaj hnub no. Qhov no qhia tau Ua ntej tus qauv ntawm cyberstalking, raws li ib tug nrhiav tsis tau Google yuav nrhiav tau qhov kev xa no. Ua li cas ho tsis paub txog qhov xov no rau ntawm lub rooj sib tham txog kev tsim txom?

Qhov ua ntej email:

Nicole Pluas (nprause@_______)
4/12/13
Txog Mr. Wilson,
Hauv koj tus ncej: http://yourbrainrebalanced.com/index.php?topic=7522.50
Koj hais tsis tseeb: “Kuv tau teb rau tus e-mail tsis zoo es nws thov saib nws kawm ntawv, thiab tus poj niam tsis kam lees.”
Qhov no yog phau ntawv sau. Thov tshem tawm cov ncej no lossis kuv yuav ua raws li txoj cai lij choj.
Nicole Prause

Wilson teb:

Hnub Friday, Apr 12, 2013 thaum 11:09 AM, Gary wilson <> sau:
Nyob zoo Nicole Prause,
Tej zaum koj tsis paub tias kuv tus poj niam kawm tiav hauv Yale txoj cai tsev kawm. Kuv hais tias tsis muaj dab tsi libelous. Qhov tseeb tiag, kuv cov nqe lus muaj tseeb heev.
1) Koj tsis kam muab koj txoj kev tshawb nrhiav tsis tshaj tawm.
2) Koj tau phem thiab raug kev phem, zoo li koj tam sim no.
3) Ntxiv rau qhov no, koj tau hais tias kuv tau nyiaj los ntawm cov neeg tuaj yeem ua kom rov qab los ntawm kev tiv thaiv kev sib daj sib deev.
4) Koj kuj tau mischaracterized kuv PT ncej, vim nws tau teb meej rau David Ley cov lus piav qhia ntawm koj qhov kev kawm tsis tshaj tawm. Koj xaiv tsis raug Ley cov lus piav qhia lossis ua rau txoj kev tshawb fawb tag nrho muaj rau kuv, txawm tias thaum kuv nug txog nws hauv tshooj lus pom ib lub hlis dhau los.
Koj tsis tau teb kuv cov lus nug thawj (nyob hauv nqe lus):
1) Vim li cas koj thiaj li tso koj txoj kev kawm rau David Ley nkaus xwb? Raws li tus kws sau ntawv "Dab Neeg ntawm Kev Ua Si Kev Sib Deev," thiab ib tus neeg uas hais tias kev quav yeeb quav tshuaj tsis tuaj yeem muaj, vim li cas nws tsuas yog tus xaiv nkaus xwb?
2) Vim li cas koj ho tsis kho David Ley cov txhais los ntawm koj qhov kev kawm? Nws tau dhau los rau ib hlis, thiab koj tau tawm tswv yim ob zaug rau nws hauv lub hli dhau los.
3) Koj tawm tswv yim nyob rau hauv Ley txoj hauj lwm ib hlis dhau los. Kuv tam sim ntawd muab tso ib qho lus hais hauv qab koj kev tawm tswv yim, nrog rau ntau cov lus nug tshwj xeeb qhia koj txog koj qhov kev kawm. Qhov ntawd yog koj lub caij nyoog rau ob leeg teb thiab muab txoj kev tshawb fawb no. Koj yeej tsis. Vim li cas?
Kuv tau zoo uas ua rau peb kev sib pauv luam. Puas yog nws tsis txaus siab thaum koj foob foob ob peb ntawm PT bloggers uas twv kom coj koj txoj kev tshawb nrhiav?
Qhov zoo,
Gary Wilson

Thov siv email dua nrog kev thov dag ntxiv & kev hem kom raug cai [Faj seeb: Tsis yog Wilson los yog nws tus poj niam tsis tau ntsib nrog Prause. Nws yog ib tug uas pheej hais rau lawv thiab ua phem rau lawv nrog kev tsis ncaj ncees.

From: nprause@_________ Hnub: Fri, 12 Apr 2013 15:01:09 -0700
Subject: Re: [PT] Kev nug xov ntawm Psychology Niaj hnub no
Nyob zoo Gary,
Nov yog qhia rau koj thiab koj tus poj niam tias koj (koj thiab koj tus poj niam) kev sib cuag tsis yog yam xav tau. Qhia txiav txim raws li cov cai hauv koj lub xeev (http://courts.oregon.gov/Lane/Restraining.page), lwm txoj kev hu nkauj thab plaub yuav muab txhais ua kev ua phem.
Koj tsis muaj kuv qhov kev tso cai los qhia cov kev sib txuas lus no hauv lwm lub rooj sab laj.
Nicole Prause

Wilson xa nws qhov kawg email rau Prause, txhawm rau teev cov ntaub ntawv ncaj: tias nws yog ib tug tabtom tawm txhua tus neeg thiab tus tib neeg ua kev hem (thiab cov lus qhia cuav):

From: [email tiv thaiv]

Mus rau: nprause Subject: RE: [PT] Kev Xav Tau ntawm Psychology Niaj hnub no
Hnub Tim: Fri, 12 Apr 2013 15: 44: 12-0700
Nyob zoo Nicole Prause,
Kev Thab Plaub? Kuv tsis tau pib ib email pauv nrog koj, nrog rau no.
Ua ntej, pib los ntawm koj ntawm 4 / 10 / 13, qhov twg koj tau lub xeem email. Thiab ib qho nram qab no, qhov uas koj tab tom sim los ua qhov kev xav tsis zoo uas ib tug neeg puas thab koj, thaum qhov tseeb koj yuav hem kuv rau qhov thib ob.
Koj kuj yog tus tau tiv toj Psychology Niaj hnub no tus sau ntawv los cuam tshuam nrog kuv cov ntawv blog. Kuv tus poj niam twb tsis muaj kev sib cuag nrog koj li cas.
Peb tsis xav tau koj kev tso cai.
Gary Wilson

Nov yog nyuam qhuav pib rau Nicole Prause. Saib: