Nicole Prause 's kev tshawb nrhiav cov ntawv tshawb fawb txog kev nyab xeeb (Park et al., 2016) retracted

Park et al

Nov yog zaj dab neeg txawv txav ntawm qhov uas Nicole Prause siv txhua txoj kev siv tawm tswv yim los sim tiv thaiv cov ntawv tshaj tawm ntawm cov phooj ywg saib xyuas, Park et al, hauv phau ntawv xov xwm muaj koob npe. Daim ntawv hauv nqe lus nug: Puas yog cov duab liab qab hauv Internet Ua rau kev sib deev tsis sib deev? Kev Ntsuam Xyuas Nrog Kev Tshaj Qhia Cov Kuaj Mob (Park et al., 2016). [Raws li thaum ntxov 2020, Park et al. tau lawm muab los ntawm ntau dua 80 lwm cov ntaub ntawv saib xyuas cov neeg saib xyuas, thiab yog feem ntau saib daim ntawv hauv keeb kwm ntawm phau ntawv xov xwm Kev Coj cwj pwm Kev tshawb fawb].

tshiab:

Hloov kho (Lub caij ntuj sov, 2019): Lub Tsib Hlis 8, 2019 Donald Hilton, MD foob qhov khoom tsis muaj tseeb per se kev sib foob tawm tsam Nicole Prause & Liberos LLC. Hnub Tim 24 Lub 2019 Hli, XNUMX Donald Hilton tau kho nws cov lus tsis txaus siab tsis zoo los qhia txog (1) kev tsis txaus siab Texas Pawg Neeg Saib Xyuas Kev Khomob, (2) cov kev iab liam uas Dr. Hilton tau dag lub luag haujlwm, thiab (3) daim ntawv lees paub los ntawm 9 lwm tus neeg ua txhaum cai ntawm kev sib thab sib luag & kev hais lus phem (John Adler, MD, Gary Wilson, Alexander Rhodes, Staci Sprout, LICSW, Linda Hatch, PhD, Bradley Green, PhD, Stefanie Carnes, PhD, Geoff Goodman, PhD, Laila Haddad.)
Hloov tshiab (Kaum Hlis, 2019): Lub Kaum Hli 23, 2019 Alexander Rhodes (tus tsim ntawm reddit / nofap thiab NoFap.com) foob qhov tsis txaus siab foob Nicole R Prause thiab Liberos LLCCov. Saib cov court docket ntawm noCov. Saib nplooj ntawv no rau peb lub tsev hais plaub cov ntaub ntawv tseem ceeb uas Rhodes muab: NoFap tus tsim Alexander Rhodes foob kev foob tawm tsam Nicole Prause / Liberos.
(Lub Kaum Ib Hlis, 2019): Thaum kawg, qee qhov kev tshaj xov xwm muaj tseeb los ntawm tus neeg tsis txaus siab txog tus neeg dag, tus neeg dag, tsim txom, ntaus tus tswv lag luam, Nicole Prause: "Alex Rhodes ntawm Porn Kev Txhawb Pab Txhawb Pab Pawg 'NoFap' Sues Tsom Phem Pro-Porn Sexologist rau Kev Txom Nyem" los ntawm Megan Fox ntawm PJ Media thiab "Porn kev tsov kev rog tau txais tus kheej hauv Tsis muaj Kaum Ib Hlis", los ntawm Diana Davison ntawm Ncej ZebCov. Davison kuj tsim cov vis dis aus 6-feeb this txog Prause cov kev coj ua tsis zoo: “Porn Muaj Dab?”.
MDPI tsuas yog qhov kawg ntawm dej khov nab kuab xwb. Saib - Nicole Prause Cov Ntawv Tshaj Xo Phom Siab thiab Kev Ua Phem Tsis Zoo.
Nicole Prause & David Ley tau ua phem rau hauv Don Hilton kev foob kev foob.
Hloov kho (Lub Yim Hli, 2020): Lub Peb Hlis 2020, Prause nrhiav qhov tsis muaj kev txwv tsis pub siv nyiaj ib ntus (TRO) tawm tsam kuv siv cov "pov thawj" thiab nws cov lus dag niaj hnub (dag kuv ua tsis nyiam). Hauv Prause qhov kev thov rau qhov kev txwv tsis pub nws tawm tsam nws tus kheej, hais tias kuv tshaj tawm nws qhov chaw nyob ntawm YBOP thiab Twitter (kev dag tsis muaj dab tsi tshiab nrog Prause)). Kuv foob mus foob rau Prause txog kev siv cov txheej txheem kev cai lij choj (TRO) kom ntsiag to thiab thab kuv. Lub Yim Hli 6, Lub Tsev Hais Plaub Hauv Nroog Los Angeles Lub Tsev Hais Plaub Siab tau txiav txim siab tias Prause txoj kev sim nrhiav txoj kev txwv txiav tawm tsam kuv yuam ua tsis raws cai thiab tsis raug cai “txoj cai foob kev tiv thaiv pej xeem kev koom tes” (feem ntau hu ua “SLAPP nplua”)Cov. Hauv cov ntsiab lus, Lub Tsev Hais Plaub pom tias Prause tau tsim txom cov txheej txheem txwv tsis pub thab plaub rau Wilson mus rau qhov ua ntsiag to thiab rhuav tshem nws txoj cai rau kev hais lus ywj pheej. Los ntawm txoj cai lij choj, SLAPP qhov kev txiav txim siab them rau Prause kom them Wilson tus kws lij choj cov nqi.
Hloov kho (Lub Ib Hlis, 2021): Thov ib qho kev foob ob txoj kev cai lij choj taug qab ntawm kuv thaum Lub Kaum Ob Hlis, 2020 rau qhov kev iab liam. Hauv lub rooj sib hais rau Lub Ib Hlis 22, 2021 an Oregon lub tsev hais plaub tau txiav txim rau kuv txoj kev xav thiab ua tus them rau Pov Hwm nrog cov nqi thiab tus nqi nplua ntxivCov. Qhov kev mob siab rau qhov no yog ib qho ntawm kaum ob txoj kev foob Tiv thaiv pej xeem hem thiab / lossis ua ntawv thov hauv cov hli dhau los. Tom qab xyoo dhau los ntawm kev tshaj xov xwm tsis zoo, nws tau nce mus rau kev hem thawj ntawm kev foob tiag tiag los sim ua ntsiag to cov neeg uas qhia nws kaw kev sib txuas nrog kev lag luam porn thiab nws tus xeeb ceem tsis zoo, lossis tus uas tau hais tawm hauv 3 qho kev sib foob thaum tab tom tawm tsam nws.

LUB SIJ HAWM:

**"Leej twg saib retraction Watch? "**

(Tshooj no tau tsim tom qab chav 2-9 raug tsim.)

Kuv yog nyob rau hauv lub tswv yim uas tib neeg ntsia retraction Watch rau lub luag haujlwm, ntxig vetted cov lus hais txog kev tshawb fawb. Tom qab kuv qhov kev paub dhau los dhau los, Kuv tsuas tuaj yeem nug, “Leej twg saib retraction Watch? ” Rau leej twg los yog dab tsi retraction Watch kev lav phij xaub rau kev saib xyuas thaum nws koom nrog kev ua tub sab tub nyiag xov xwm?

Hnub Tim 13 Lub 2018 Hli, XNUMX retraction Watch (RW) luam tawm ib qho tsis muaj tseeb thiab ib qho kev qhia ntawm cov xwm txheej lwm tus Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam daim ntawv Park et al., 2016. Ntawm lwm cov kev sib txawv, lub thau muab cov ntaub ntawv hais txog Nicole Prause qhov kev ua tsis tiav (thiab unseemly) 3 xyoo kom muaj daim ntawv tawm (muab sau cia rau hauv 8 tshooj ntxiv).

Ua ntej, ib qho kev kawm yav dhau los, tau hu rau RW cov neeg ua haujlwm thiab muab lawv cov khoom nws xav luam tawm - thiab RW pom tias lawv muab tag nrho thiab luam tawm lawv. Kuv teb tshwm rau hauv qab Tshooj Cai Rov Saib Tshaj Tawm. Txawm li cas los, RW edited kuv saib tshuam ua ntej nws yuav tswg nws. Ntawm no kuv muab ntau yam tsis paub meej.

Ua ntej, kuv saib yog ib daim ntawv redacted ntawm tus email kuv xa mus rau Adas Marcus thiab Ivan Oransky ntawm RW tsocai tom qab daim pib. Tom qab 3 hnub ntawm cov email xa rov qab, RW kawg tau muab cov lus qhia tawm (ntawm kuv tus email), tab sis thov kom tshem tawm cov ntsiab lus uas tau qhia txog cov kev uas RW tsis tau ua nws cov ntawv xov xwm journalistic.

Nov yog ntau ntawm zaj dab neeg.

1) Senior sau, thiab Naval tub ceev xwm, Andrew Doan MD PhD tau thov kom Adas Marcus hais rau kuv kom paub meej txog cov ntsiab lus nyob ib puag hauv daim ntawv (tom qab Marcus tau ntsib nws). Doan ua li no vim tias nws thiab kuv cov 6 tus kws sau ntawv yog Cov Neeg Ua Haujlwm Sawv Daws hauv Teb Chaws Asmeskas Tub Rog thiab "tsis tuaj yeem hais txog daim ntawv raws nraim tsis tau tso cai los ntawm tsoom fwv Teb Chaws Asmeskas Tub Rog Pej Xeem." Marcus tsis xaiv hu rau kuv. Xwb nws khiav nrog txhua yam Prause nws. Los ntawm kuv tus thawj email:

Kuv tau nyeem koj daim, "Phau ntawv sau cia, tab sis yuav tsis rho tawm, muaj teeb meem ntawv hauv internet porn"Raws li lub hom phiaj tseem ceeb ntawm retraction Watch yog kev ncaj ncees hauv kev tshaj tawm, kuv ntseeg tias koj yuav xav kho cov tshooj no hauv ntau qhov tseem ceeb. Hauv nws daim ntawv tam sim no nws muaj ntau qhov yuam kev thiab ntau yam ntxub lus yuam kev. Kuv tu siab tias koj tsis tau hu rau kuv raws li Dr. Doan tau hais, yog li ntawd cov kev ua yuam kev no yuav tau raug zam.

2) RW cov thawj xibfwb Adam Marcus thiab Ivan Oransky tau muab luam tawm rau lub Tsib Hlis, 2018 MDPI-Prause email exchanges. Raws li kuv tau hais hauv ib qho ntawm kuv emails rau RW:

Kuv txhawj xeeb heev Retraction Saib siv cov khoom ntawm MDPI emails uas Dr. Prial theej koj. Raws li kuv tau xa cov emails, kuv paub tias muaj ntau ntau lwm cov ntaub ntawv hauv lawv. Cov khoom uas tau muab tshem tawm nrog cov lus dag thiab tsis ncaj ncees rau lwm tus los ntawm Dr. Prause. Txawm tias Dr. Lin lub hom phiaj yog tsis muaj hmoo (Lus Askiv tsis yog nws thawj zaug lossis ob hom lus), kuv xav hais tias nws qhov kev xav yuav tsum tau 'hnov' raws li qhov tseeb uas Dr. Prause tau ua phem rau nws lub tuam txhab ncaj qha, thiab ncaj qha ntawm COPE, yuav luag ob xyoos ncaj. Nws exasperation yog yooj yim to taub. Muab Dr. Prause ib "xeem" rau nws tus cwj pwm phem thaum nws tseem ceeb thiab nws tseem ceeb, thiab qhov tseem ceeb tshaj, tso koj cov neeg nyeem tawm nrog lub ntsej muag heev.

Nws yuav tsum raug sau tseg tias RW tsis tau muab luam tawm rau hauv qhov tsis xaus ntawm emails, los ntawm 3 lub xyoo dhau los, qhov chaw uas tau raug ua phem rau MDPI, US Navy, 7 Navy cov kws kho mob, Lub Rooj Sab Laj Foundation, tus tshaj tawm ntawm kuv phau ntawv, thiab lwm yam Tsis yog leej twg khib nws tus kheej ntiag tug xa tawm mus rau COPE thiab nws cov tub ceev xwm.

3) Hauv lub Tsib Hlis, 2018 MDPI-Prause email exchanges, Marcus thiab Oransky tau ob zaug no nplooj ntawv txheeb xyuas cov ntsiab lus ntawm nplooj ntawv ntev ntawm cov kws tshawb fawb, kws sau ntawv, kws kho mob, kws kho mob, kws kho mob, ib tug qub UCLA colleague, ib lub chaw pabcuam UK, cov txiv neej nyob rau hauv kev zoo rov, SIJHAWM magazine editor, ntau tus xibfwb, IITAP, SASH, Tivthaiv Cov Tshuaj Tshiab, MDPI, thiab lub taub hau ntawm cov phau ntawv journal CUREUS. Hauv qhov tseemceeb, RW tsis lees paub Ua ntej qhov sau tsis yog los ntawm kev ua txhaum los luam tawm nws qhov kev cuam tshuam.

4) Nyob hauv ib qho email tom qab nug tias vim li cas RW tau ua tsis tiav rau kuv (redacted) tawm tswv yim, kuv tau hais rau Marcus thiab Oransky tias qhov tseem ntsiab lus ntawm RW qhov ntaus tau muab yuam kev:

Raws li tej yam uas sawv ntsug, txawm tias qhov chaw ntawm koj tsab xov xwm tsis muaj tseeb. Kuv qhov kev koom tes nrog Kev Ncaj Ncees (TRF) yeej ib txwm hais meej, ob qho tib si hauv thawj zaug Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam tsab xov xwm thiab kev kho lus tsis ntev los no (tus thawj PubMed version). Lub hom phiaj ntawm cov tshiab kho lus kho yog yuav tiv thaiv Dr. Prause lub incessant defamatory claims tias kuv tau txais nyiaj los ntawm TRF, thiab tias kuv tau nyiaj los ntawm kuv phau ntawv (kuv cov nyiaj tau los rau, qhov tseeb, mus rau kev siab hlub).

5) Nyob rau ob qho kuv emails rau RW, Kuv hais meej hais txog qhov thib ob thawj kev hais hauv lawv cov ntawv:

Nws tseem ceeb heev kom paub meej tias Dr. Prause's "77 unaddressed points" claim yog tsis tseeb. Kuv muaj cov ntaub ntawv ntawm cov ntsiab lus thiab peb cov lus teb (thiab cov ntaub ntawv 25 ntawm 77 "cov ntsiab lus" tsis muaj dab tsi ua nrog rau Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam ntawv).

saib ntu no rau cov ntsiab lus ntxiv uas muaj puag ncig ntawm Prause qhov hu ua "77 cov ntsiab lus," thiab nws txoj kev koom tes nrog ib qho dhau los, ntau yam sib txawv ntawm peb daim ntawv, xa mus rau Yale Journal of Biology thiab Medicine.

6) Nyob rau ob qho kuv emails rau RW, Kuv tau hais meej tias Prause tau dag txog California tshawb xyuas:

Tom ntej no, nws tseem ceeb heev kom kho tau Dr. Prause txoj kev dag tias Kalifonias qhov kev tshawb nrhiav ntawm nws tus cwj pwm lawm thiab nws tau kov yeej. Nws tsis dhau; tus neeg tshawb xyuas tau caw kuv tuaj teev lus tim khawv hauv lub hlis tom ntej (hnub TBD).

Nws tseem qhia tau tias Marcus thiab Oransky

(1) tsis kho RW tsab xov xwm cov lus dag thiab cov lus tsis txaus ntseeg,

(2) cov ntaub ntawv pov thawj rau hauv kuv qhov kev xa xov tias lawv tau paub txog qhov kev tsis txaus siab nqe lus thiab ntev keeb kwm ntawm kev sib thab thiab pib mus lawm,

(3) xaiv tsis txuas lus nrog kuv ua ntej ntawv, txawm tias daim ntawv sau tus neeg sau ntawv tau thov lawv ua li ntawd,

(4) tau pom zoo tias kuv yog tus ua phem los ntawm qhov tsis tseeb hais tias Kalifonias cov kev tshawb nrhiav tau tiav thiab txiav txim siab hauv Prause tus haum, thiab los ntawm kev txuas mus rau Txhua hnub Beast account ntawm cov xwm txheej, thiab

(5) tsis tau kho los yog tsis tau luam tawm lawv cov lus thuam uas tsis muaj neeg sau xov xwm, tsis pub apologized rau cov sau phau ntawv thiab phau ntawv xov xwm nws lub npe uas lawv ua tsis tau.

Ob peb yam ntxiv txog RW tsab xov xwm tsis muaj nyob rau hauv kuv cov lus. Thawj nqe lus hais:

"Tom qab tshaj tawm, cov neeg thuam hais kom COPE saib cov ntawv."

"Critics" ntau tshaj? Nws tsuas yog ib qho "thuam" uas xa tuaj rau MDPI lossis COPE: Ua ntej. Nws xa tuaj rau Teb Chaws Asmeskas Navy ntau zaus, qhia txog 7 cov kws kho mob nyob hauv daim ntawv rau lawv cov kws kho mob, thiab tig mus rau kev tshaj tawm xov xwm rau kev puas tsuaj rau kuv, MDPI, thiab cov neeg soj ntsuam ntawm uas luam tawm hauv MDPI - los ntawm cov phiaj xwm ntev kom tsis txhob sau ntawv tus kws tshawb fawb teb rau daim ntawv thiab es tsis txhob sim ua kom nws rov qab los ntawm txoj kev rov qab-tus-scenes maneuvering thiab pej xeem misinformation.

Tsab xov xwm hais tias:

"COPE, uas tsis muaj txoj cai tswjfwm, hais hauv email rau tus tshaj tawm tias nws yuav pom zoo kom rov qab tuav tseg ntawm tsab xov xwm."

COPE tsuas txhawj txog ib qhov teeb meem (raws li cov "lus tseeb" pub rau nws): kev pom zoo. COPE tau hais tias:

"Yuav tsum muaj qhov teeb meem no tau tshaj tawm ntawm ib qho ntawm peb qhov kev sib tham hauv COPE, peb xav tias qhov kev pom zoo yuav yog los xav txog kev thim rov qab ntawm tsab xov xwm raws kev pom zoo yuav tsum tsis ua raws li kev cia siab"… ..

Thaum COPE lo lus teb yog hypothetical, raws li txawm tias "qhov tseeb" Prause tau muab los ntawm nws, cov sau phau ntawv thiab MDPI yeej xav tsis thoob los ntawm qhov lus teb. Qhov tseeb tiag, Teb Chaws Asmeskas Navy cov kws kho mob tsis txaus siab nrog lawv Cov Kev Kho Mob Nkeeg Nkoj - Cov Kev Cai San Diego txoj cai tso cai. Lub Chaw Kho Kev Mob Nkeeg ntawm San Diego txoj cai IRB tsis xav txog cov ntaub ntawv ntawm tsawg dua plaub tus neeg mob hauv ib tsab xov xwm los ua tib neeg kev tshawb fawb thiab tsis tas yuav kom cov neeg mob tso cai rau kev tso tawm hauv ib tsab xov xwm. Txawm hais tias cov neeg tshawb xyuas tsis tas yuav tau txais kev tso cai, rau ob leeg, tau hais lus thiab sau ntawv pom zoo. Nyob rau hauv rooj plaub thib peb uas tsis pom muaj kev nyuaj siab, tsis muaj ntawv pom zoo.

Incidentally, ntawm Dr. Prause tus insistence, tom qab ntawv tau luam tawm, cov dej num ntawm Navy tus kws sau ntawv sib fwm los ntawm txoj cai no tau muab rov los xyuas dua nyob rau hauv kev ywj pheej Navy tshawb nrhiav. Tshwm sim? Kuv muaj ib daim ntawv tshaj tawm los ntawm ib tus kws lij choj nrog Navy paub tseeb tias cov kws sau ntawv sau ua ke nrog tag nrho cov kev cai IRB.

RW tsab xov xwm kuj hais tias:

"Ntawm qhov kev thov pab them nqi yog tias ib tus kws sau ntawv, Gary Wilson tau ua tsis tiav los tshaj tawm nws txoj haujlwm nrog Lub Rooj Sab Laj (Reward Foundation), "

Qhov no yog qhov tseeb. Raws li tau piav qhia ua ntej, kuv qhov kev koom tes nrog The Reward Foundation (TRF) yeej ib txwm hais meej, ob qho tib si hauv thawj zaug Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam tsab xov xwm thiab kev kho lus tsis ntev los no (tus thawj PubMed version). Lub hom phiaj ntawm cov tshiab kho lus kho yog yuav tiv thaiv Dr. Prause lub incessant defamatory claims tias kuv tau txais nyiaj los ntawm TRF, thiab tias kuv tau nyiaj los ntawm kuv phau ntawv (kuv cov nyiaj tau los rau, qhov tseeb, mus rau kev siab hlub).

Thaum tsis muaj kev saib xyuas, RW nyeem cov ntawv yuav xav kom tsis txhob poob siab txog qhov kev xav hauv RW cov ntawv blog uas tsis muaj kev ywj pheej tshawb xyuas. RW zoo li yuav kam cia nws tus kheej siv los ntawm cov txheej txheem los ntawm lub hom phiaj txawm tias thaum tau hais tias yuav tsum tau tshawb nrhiav ntxiv.

Tom qab

MDPI yog Swiss niam txiv lub tuam txhab ntawm ntau cov kev kawm txhua hnub, suav nrog Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam. MDPI ua tsis luam tawm cov ntawv sau tseg. Nyob rau hauv qhov tseeb, nws tau tshawb xyuas lub xyoo dhau los tom qab nws tau yuam kev tso rau hauv ib daim ntawv teev tseg, thiab tau txiav txim siab ua ib tug neeg tsim nyog publisher. Saib: http://www.mdpi.com/about/announcements/534. Tus txiv neej (Jeffrey Beall) uas tau ua yuam kev nws thiaj li deleted nws tag nrho cov lag luam.

Ua rau muaj kev cuam tshuam nrog MDPI vim tias (1) Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam luam tawm ob yam khoom uas Prause tsis pom zoo nrog (vim lawv sib tham cov ntaub ntawv ntawm nws, ntawm ntau pua cov ntawv los ntawm lwm tus sau phau ntawv), thiab (2) Gary Wilson yog tus sau npe ntawm Park et al., 2016. Ua ntej muaj keeb kwm ntev txog kev cyberstalking thiab defaming Wilson, chronicled nyob rau hauv no heev heev nplooj. Ob daim ntawv:

Neuroscience ntawm Internet Pornography Addict: Xyuas thiab Hloov Tshiab (Hlub li al., 2015)
Puas yog cov duab liab qab hauv Internet Ua kom muaj kev sib deev? Kev Ntsuam Xyuas Nrog Kev Tshaj Qhia Cov Kuaj Mob (Park et al., 2016)

Qhov thib ob daim ntawv (Park et al.) tsis tshawb xyuas Prause txoj kev tshawb nrhiav. Nws tau tshawb pom hauv 3 ntawm nws cov ntaub ntawv. Hauv kev thov ntawm tus neeg saib xyuas thaum lub sijhawm saib xyuas cov neeg saib xyuas, nws tau hais rau tus thib peb, ib daim ntawv 2015 los ntawm Khawb & Pfaus, los ntawm xam rau a scholarly piece nyob rau hauv ib phau ntawv journal uas hnyav ncawv, raug thuam cov ntawv. (Muaj tsis txaus qhov chaw nyob hauv Park et al. mus rau qhov chaw nyob tag nrho cov weaknesses thiab unsupported thov Chaw Tsim Tshuaj & Pfaus, 2015).

Ua kom sai li sai tau hais tias MDPI retract Park et al., 2016. Cov lus teb rau cov kws tshawb fawb ib qho tsis pom zoo ntawm yog los luam tawm ib qho tawm tswv yim txog kev tawm tsam. Cov Cwj Pwm Kev Ntsuas niam txiv lub tuam txhab, MDPI, caw tuaj koom Ua qhov no. Nws tsis yeem. Nws yuav tsum raug sau tseg tias Tshaj tawm tsam Wilson thiab nws lub vas sab tas li thiab laj mej pej xeem.

Es tsis txhob luam tawm ib qho kev tawm tswv yim, nws unprofessionally nres mus hem thiab kev tawm xov xwm (thiab tsis ntev los no retraction Watch blog) kom thab plaub MDPI rau hauv kev tuav pov hwm Park et al., uas kuv yog tus sau nrog 7 US Navy cov kws kho mob (nrog rau ob urologists, ob lub hlwb thiab ib tug neuroscientist). Tsis tas li ntawd, nws tau qhia MDPI tias nws tau ua daim ntawv tsis txaus siab nrog lub koom haum American Psychological Association. Nws tau ua ntawv tsis txaus siab nrog txhua tus kws kho mob cov ntawv kho mob. Nws kuj tau txhawj txog cov kws kho mob qhov chaw kho mob thiab Lub Tsev Haujlwm Saib Xyuas Kev Txiav Txim Siab, ua rau muaj kev soj ntsuam ntev ntev, uas tsis pom muaj kev tsis ncaj ncees rau ntawm cov ntawv sau ntawv.

Prause tseem yws tsis txaus siab ntau ntau rau COPE (Pawg Neeg ntawm Ntawv Xov Xwm Kev Coj Ncaj Ncees). COPE thaum kawg tau sau MDPI nrog qhov kev nug txog qhov thim rov qab, raws li cov lus piav qhia ntawm Prause uas "cov neeg mob tsis pom zoo." MDPI ua tib zoo tshawb nrhiav qhov kev pom zoo uas tau txais los ntawm cov kws kho mob uas tau sau ntawv, nrog rau US Navy txoj cai nyob ib ncig kom tau txais kev pom zoo.

Thov nco ntsoov tias Naval Medical Center San Diego's IRB tsis xav txog cov ntaub ntawv xov xwm ntawm tsawg dua plaub tus neeg mob hauv ib tsab xov xwm yuav tsum yog tib neeg tshawb nrhiav thiab tsis xav kom tus neeg mob tso cai rau kev xam nrog rau hauv tsab xov xwm. Txawm hais tias cov kws tshawb nrhiav tsis tas yuav tsum tau txais kev pom zoo, rau ob kis, kev pom zoo ntawm ncauj thiab sau ntawv tau txais. Hauv rooj plaub thib plaub uas tsis qhia npe tsis zoo yuav tsis muaj kev cuam tshuam, tsis muaj ntaub ntawv pom zoo tau txais.

Incidentally, ntawm Dr. Prause tus insistence, tom qab ntawv tau luam tawm, cov dej num ntawm Navy tus kws sau ntawv sib fwm los ntawm txoj cai no tau muab rov los xyuas dua nyob rau hauv kev ywj pheej Navy tshawb nrhiav. Tshwm sim? Kuv muaj ib daim ntawv tshaj tawm los ntawm ib tus kws lij choj nrog Navy paub tseeb tias cov kws sau ntawv sau ua ke nrog tag nrho cov kev cai IRB.

Raws li, MDPI tsis kam los tuav daim ntawv. Qhov no tau piav qhia rau COPE, tsis muaj kev tsis pom zoo los ntawm COPE. Tsuav ntev li cov kws tshawb fawb tau ua raws li lawv txoj cai IRB tso cai (uas yog qhov teeb meem no), tsis muaj teeb meem. Ua Ntej tseem pheej hais tsis tseeb tias qhov teeb meem no daws tsis tau thiab tias "cov neeg tsis tau pom zoo" thiab qhov kev txiav txim yog qhov tsim nyog.

Ua ntej tseem tsis txaus siab rau COPE tias kuv muaj kev tsis sib haum xeeb ntawm qhov tsis txaus siab. Tom Qab: Kuv tau qhia tawm kuv txoj kev koom tes nrog The Reward Foundation hauv daim ntawv txij li pib. Qhov no tsis yog qhov tsis sib haum xeeb. Hauv 2018, phau ntawv tshaj tawm tau muab kho qhov uas tau hloov cov lus hais txog kuv qhov kev sib txuas lus kom nws ua tau tseeb tseeb (txawm yog mus Prause) uas tsis muaj teeb meem ntawm kev txaus siab. Nws hais txog kuv phau ntawv, qhov tseeb tias kuv tau txais los ntawm phau ntawv mus rau The Reward Foundation, thiab qhov tseeb tias kuv qhov kev koom tes yog ib qho chaw tsis muaj nqis. Ua rau kuv pheej tsis lees paub tias kuv tau txais ntau txhiab phaus los ntawm kev siab hlub. Cov ntaub ntawv pov thawj tias nws tau yuam kev yog muab teev rau lwm qhov ntawm nplooj ntawv no.

Pre-MDPI keeb kwm: Lub Yale Phau Ntawv Teev Xov Xwm Txog Tshuaj & Tshuaj, thiab "Janey Wilson"

Zaj dab neeg txog Prause txoj kev siv dag zog ntsig txog daim ntawv uas tau luam tawm thaum kawg Park et al. yeej pib ua ntej kev koom tes ntawm MDPI thiab Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam. Ib qho dhau los, ntau luv luv ntawm daim ntawv, nrog tib tus sau phau ntawv thiab sau kev koom tes raws li nws tau muaj thaum tom qab xa mus Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam, thawj zaug xa mus rau Yale Journal of Biology thiab Medicine (YJBM). Nws tsim nyog saib xyuas cov kev coj ua muaj feem xyuam nrog daim ntawv no thaum nws raug saib xyuas los ntawm YJBM.

Ib qho ntawm 2 cov neeg soj xyuas ntawm daim ntawv tau muab nws cov lus soj ntsuam nrog 70 + kev thuam, thiab nws tau raug tsis lees paub. Nyob ib ncig ntawm lub sijhawm ntawd YJBM tso tseg daim ntawv, "Janey Wilson"Pib thuam kuv phau ntawv tshaj tawm, Lub Tebchaws Sau Dawb, thiab lub chaw pabcuam uas kuv tau txais kuv cov lus qhia hauv cov ntawv. (Kuv yog tus sau ntawm Koj lub paj hlwb ntawm Porn: Kev saib duab hauv Internet thiab Kev Tshaj Tawm Txog Kev Yeeb Tshuaj.) Ib qho tseem ceeb ntawm "Janey's" muaj kev tsim txom, tsis muaj kev txwv tsis tu ncua nyob hauv qab ntawm nplooj ntawv no.

Lus Cim: Xa mus rau YJBM yog qhov chaw tsuas yog kuv qhov kev koom nrog nrog kev siab hlub, Lub Rooj Sab Laj (TRF), yuav tau pom, raws li nws twb tsis pom qhov chaw pej xeem. Hauv lwm lo lus, apart from Board of TRF thiab kuv tus kheej, tsuas yog tus YJBM editor thiab nws ob tug neeg xyuas tau paub txog qhov kev koom tes ntawm no. Thiab tseem, "Janey" thov kom muaj pov thawj ntawm qhov kev sib koom tes no, thiab siv kuv kev koom tes los tsim ntau cov lus iab liam ntawm TRF thiab kuv. Nws txawm sau tsab ntawv ceeb toom nrog lub Scottish Charity Regulator, kom tsis muaj avail.

Tom qab, Dr. Prause xa nws qhov kev sib tw YJBM xyuas nrog 70 + kev thuam rau lub npav saib xyuas (ua ib feem ntawm kev sib tw kom luam tawm daim ntawv luam tawm), yog li lees tias nws tau muab qhov tseeb YJBM nrog rau qhov tsis zoo ntawm daim ntawv. (Ntxiv pov thawj tias nws yog ib tug YJBM kev ntsuam xyuas muab lub sijhawm thaum Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam kev xa tawm, raws li tau hais tseg hauv qab no.) Qhov xwm txheej tsis raug cai, Prause kev ua txhaum yog kev ua txhaum cai COPE cov cai rau cov phooj ywg tshuaj xyuas (Tshooj 5 ntawm "Cov Txheej Txheem ntawm Cov Ntawv Qhia Zoo"), Uas yuav tsum tau saib xyuas kom ceev txhua yam uas lawv kawm tau los ntawm kev txheeb xyuas cov txheej txheem.

YJBM (1) tus cwj pwm ua phem (cwj pwm) los ntawm "Janey," (2) "Janey's" qhov tseeb ntawm tus kheej, thiab (3) qhov tseeb tias "Janey" muaj peev xwm ua txhaum COPE cov cai rau cov neeg saib xyuas kev sib xyuas los ntawm kev tsim cov ntaub ntawv pej xeem paub txog kuv.

Daim ntawv tau raug lees txais los ntawm YJBM... thiab tom qab ntawd tsis tau luam tawm nyob rau hauv phau ntawv journal tom qab tag nrho, vim los ntawm phau ntawv xov xwm qhov kev txiav txim siab tias nws yog lig dhau los ua qhov kev thov tau kho thiab tseem ua tau raws li hnub kawg sau rau YJBM's tshwj xeeb "tiv thaiv" qhov teeb meem.

***Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam* version ntawm *Park et al.***

Daim ntawv kho dua tshiab thiab kho tshiab ntawm daim ntawv ntawd tau xa mus rau phau ntawv sau tseg Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam. Tom qab ob peb qho kev txheeb xyuas thiab rov ua dua tshiab nws tau txais kev pom zoo ntawm cov ntaub ntawv, nrog rau kev tshawb fawb. Nws daim ntawv kawg yog txawv ntawm qhov qub YJBM xa tawm.

Thaum lub sijhawm no, daim ntawv tau muab rov los xyuas dua los tsis muaj tsawg dua 6 cov neeg soj xyuas. Tsib dhau nws, qee qhov muaj qee qhov kev hloov kho, thiab ib qho kev tsis txaus siab nws tsis lees paub (kwv yees leej twg?).

Kauj ruam ib qho ntawm cov txheej txheem no nthuav tawm raws li hauv qab no: Daim ntawv raug xa rov qab ob zaug, ib qho ntawm lawv qhov kev tsis txaus siab, ib qho txiaj ntsim. Puzzled los ntawm lub hnyav rejection, Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam xa daim ntawv tawm los saib xyuas 2 lwm cov neeg tawm tswv yim. Cov kev rov qab xyuas no dhau los ntawm daim ntawv. Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam cautiously tsis txais daim ntawv, tab sis pub tus sau phau ntawv "kho thiab rov ua dua." Ua ib feem ntawm txoj haujlwm no, cov kws sau ntawv tau muab tag nrho cov lus los ntawm cov saib xyuas (tab sis tsis yog lawv tus kheej). Cov kev soj ntsuam cov kev txhawj xeeb tau raug muab hais kom zoo, taw tes rau ntawm qhov point (muaj raws li qhov kev thov).

Los ntawm cov lus sau, nws tau tshwm sim hais tias "hnyav saib xyuas" ntawm Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam daim ntawv tseem tau nyeem daim ntawv ntawm YJBM. Txog ib feem peb ntawm 77 cov ntsiab lus tau tshwm sim tsis txheeb rau Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam xa tawm ntawm tag nrho cov. Lawv xa mus rau cov ntaub ntawv uas yog tsuas tam sim no nyob rau hauv dhau los version ntawm daim ntawv, qhov ib uas tau xa mus rau YJBM.

Ua lwm yam lus, tus neeg siab phem tau txiav thiab tsiv dozens ntawm kev thuam ntawm kev ntsuam xyuas ua tiav lwm phau ntawv journal (YJBM), uas tsis muaj qhov cuam tshuam rau ntawv xa tuaj rau Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam. Qhov no yog qhov tsis ncaj ncees. Ntxiv mus, Prause xaus rau nws tus kheej ua tus sau ntawm cov kev thuam ntawm nws cov lus tsis txaus siab mus rau kev cai lij choj (saib saum toj), uas nws qhia nws YJBM rov xyuas dua ntawm cov ntawv tsis muaj tseeb ntawm daim ntawv.

Incidentally, thaum Prause tau nug kom rov saib daim ntawv ntawm Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam nws thaj tsis tau qhia tias nws twb tau nyeem daim ntawv ntawm lwm phau ntawv journal. Nws yuav yog tus neeg saib xyuas kev coj ua kom pom cov kev rov ntsuam xyuas dua.

Cia kuv saib lub sijhawm ua ntej ntau qhov kev tawm tsam rau peb cov ntawv. Ntxiv dua thiab, 25 los yog lawv tsis muaj ib yam dab tsi los ua nrog rau Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam ntawv Prause tau nug los ntawm Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam los saib xyuas. Lawv xa mus rau nws thawj xa tawm ntawm YJBM. Qhov no yuav tsum tsis pom zoo rau tag nrho cov kev ntsuam xyuas los ntawm kev xav ntxiv.

Tsis tas li ntawd, peb ua tib zoo sib txuas los ntawm txhua lub ncauj lus nrhiav kev pabcuam, thiab sau cov lus teb rau tag nrho cov lus rau Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam thiab nws cov neeg kho. Yuav luag tag nrho cov seem 50 cov lus tseem ceeb heev txawm yog scientific tsis raug, tsis txawj, los yog tau cias cov lus. Qee leej tau rov qab ua dua. Muaj ntau qhov tsis txaus siab hais txog cov lus hais los ntawm 3 cov neeg mob, txawm tias daim ntawv xa tuaj raws li "kev ntsuam xyuas cov ntaub ntawv qhia." Qee qhov tau hais rau qee qhov ntawm cov ntaub ntawv peb tau hais, tab sis cov ntaub ntawv tsis txaus siab cov ntaub ntawv lawv tus kheej. Ntau tshaj 10 cov lus hais tias cov kws kho mob tsis muaj peev xwm tshuaj xyuas lawv cov neeg mob rau cov ntaub ntawv tshawb fawb (!).

Nyob rau hauv luv luv, thaum cov neeg tawm tswv yim cov lus yeej ib txwm zoo dua tej daim ntawv rau qee qhov kev kawm, muaj tiag tiag tsis yog qhov yuav tsum tau "kho" ntau ntawm daim ntawv nws tus kheej hauv lub teeb ntawm Prause cov lus. Yam peb tau ua yog ntxiv zog rau daim ntawv nrog 50 ntau cov ntawv, kom lwm cov neeg nyeem ua ib qho uas tsis sib thooj.

Daim ntawv tau muab sau tseg thiab kho dua tshiab. Tom ntej no, ob tug neeg xyuas dua thiab tus thawj saib xyuas kev saib xyuas tau rov xyuas dua thiab tau muab tso nrog ntau lub tswv yim, nrog rau cov lus taw qhia kom rov ua zoo li "saib cov ntaub ntawv tshawb fawb." Tsis txaus siab tias txhua yam kev txhawj xeeb muaj tau hais lawm, Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam luam tawm daim ntawv.

Retraction dag zog

Tam sim ntawd Ua ntej pib xav tias daim ntawv yuav muab rho tawm. Ntawm lwm cov dag zog, nws tau xa cov ntaub ntawv tsis zoo no email rau MDPI nrog cov xovxwm tsis zoo yog tias lawv tsis kam xa daim ntawv:

“Qhov no raug foob thaum Lub Yim Hli 24, 2016. Tam sim no Lub Kaum Ib Hlis 12, 2016… Yog tias kuv tsis hnov dab tsi li ntawm ob lub lim tiam tom ntej, peb yuav pib sau cov thawj tswj hwm ntawm phau ntawv xov xwm ntawd nrog cov lus tseeb ntawm rooj plaub. Muaj ntau lub zeem muag tawm dhau los twb paub txog thiab tos kom hnov tias yuav muaj kev tawm zuj zus, tab sis yuav tshaj tawm txog qhov tsis ua yuav tau tawm yog tias tsim nyog. "

Nov yog lwm ntawm nws qhov kev tsim kev kub ntxhov rau MDPI ntawm Mon, Nov 14, 2016:

"Kev Coj Tus Cwj Pwm yog cov lus txhais ntawm phau ntawv xov xwm xav tau thiab raug lees paub rau Beall cov ntawv xov xwm xav tau ua ntej txog thaum koj hem nws kom tshem nws. Thawj tshaj tawm xov xwm ntawm qhov no yuav tsum tshwm sim lig rau lub lim tiam no hauv kev tshaj tawm thoob tebchaws. Peb tau muab txoj hauv kev rau koj rov qab rho tawm cov ntawv cuav no. "

MDPI tsis pom zoo nrog Prause qhov kev txhawj xeeb lossis kev txheeb xyuas ntawm daim ntawv, thiab tsis kam muab nws, tab sis xav paub ntxiv txog nws cov lus pom zoo. Cov dabneeg tseem yuav txuas ntxiv mus, thiab qhov xaus ntawm nws tshwm thaum kawg ntawm nplooj ntawv no.

Nyob rau txhua qhov kev tshwm sim, tom qab nws cov lus txiav txim siab xav tau, Ua ntej pib defaming MDPI (thiab nws cov phau ntawv journal Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam) raws li "predatory" ntawm kev tshaj xov xwm.

**Prause siv kev tshaj tawm txog kev tsim txom MDPI, cov neeg tshawb xyuas uas luam tawm hauv MDPI phau ntawv, thiab leej twg xam Park et al., 2016**

Tawm hauv qhov tseeb Tshaj tawm tsam MDPI thaum lub Kaum Ib Hlis, 2017, tweeting ib tsab xov xwm uas tsis muaj dab tsi ua nrog MDPI:

MDPI teb:

Qhov no ua rau Prause mus rau ntawm kev sib tw Twitter (ob peb tus tweets hauv qab no):

MDPI teb rau qhov ua ntej:

Tus thawj coj ntawm MDPI Franck Vazquez, Ph.D, kuj tau txais kev pab, raws li kev tsis pom zoo:

Ua ntej yuav mus (MDPI ignores nws Twitter tagging):

Tau Kev Thaj Tsam tau sim ua kom MDPI muab pov tawm ntawm PubMed thiab lwm yam kev taw qhia raws li nws qhov kev ua txhaum? Peb tawm ntawm lub Yim Hli, 2016 - ob peb lub lim tiam tom qab Park et al., 2016 tau luam tawm:

Ob qho tweet:

Peb lub tweet:

Lwm tweet los ntawm lub Kaum Ib Hlis, 2017 tawm tswv yim Ua tseem yog kev ua phem rau cov koom haum tswj hwm txog MDPI (https://twitter.com/NicoleRPrause/status/935983476775387136):

Los ntawm ib lub voj voog uas muaj ntau yam lus dag los ntawm Prause: http://www.patheos.com/blogs/mormontherapist/2016/12/op-ed.htmlCov. Ib tsab xov xwm raug xa mus rau yog kev tshuaj xyuas los ntawm 7 Navy cov kws kho mob thiab kuv, lwm qhov muaj kev sib koom tes los ntawm lwm tus kws tshaj lij, suav nrog Todd Hlub PsyD - leej twg Prause tau kuj ua phem. Dua, MDPI raug thaij tawm thiab raug tshem tawm ua ntej ntawm Beall coj nws cov npe cia.

Qee zaum tseem tau sim cuam tshuam nrog lwm yam MDPI phau ntawv teeb meem los ntawm defaming MDPI:

----

Ntawm no yog cov piv txwv ntawm Kev Ua Tsis Ncaj Ncees Txaus lwm leej lwm tus vim kev koom tes / luam tawm nrog / tau txais khoom plig los ntawm MDPI:

-

----

---

Ntawm no Prause ua si nws nyiam daim npav - liam lwm tus ntawm kev tsis nkag siab - yam tsis muaj pov thawj (ib yam li nws tau ua nrog kuv thiab lwm tus ntau dua).

Tsis muaj ntau yam kev tsis txaus siab ntawm qhov tsis txaus siab:

Prause cuav claims tus Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam daim ntawv nws tawm tsam tau rho tawm. Qhov no yog ob qho tib si defamatory thiab unprofessional.

Lub sib tham Twitter tseem:

"Pornaddiction rov qab" tweets ob YBOP npe, uas ua rau Prause kom tweet ib daim ntawv los ntawm Gary Wilson thiab Navy cov kws kho mob. Tham tsis ncaj ncees hais tias nws thaib COPE txhawm rau tawm tswv yim kom thim tawm. Nws yog txhua tus bullshit.

Tom qab lub sijhawm ntev, kev tshawb nrhiav, kev siv sijhawm ntev, MDPI txiav txim siab tsis pub rho tawm ntawm daim ntawv, thiab tau sau ib daim qauv tsim kho kev thuam ntawm Pred's unprofessional cwj pwm. Sai li sai tau qhia tias, nws pib ua haujlwm uas tsis muaj kev sib raug zoo, tsis muaj kev txhawj xeeb email nrog MDPI, luam ntau yam bloggers nws vam tias nws yuav siv nws cov lus rau tej yam thiab luam tawm cov khoom tsis zoo. retraction Watch twb tau ua tiav nrog nws xav tau.

Nws yog 2019 thiab Prause tseem tshawb nrhiav twitter rau cov ntaub ntawv tsis cuam tshuam yog li nws muaj kev zam txim rau tweet nws qhov tsis tseeb thiab bogus Retraction Saib tsab xov xwm:

Tweet teb rau ob lub npe ntawm kev tshawb fawb los ntawm YBOP. Tsis muaj daim ntawv teev npe Park et al., 2016.

Lub ib hlis ntuj 29, 2019:

Nyob rau lub Ob Hlis 16, 2019, tus kws kho mob tshwj xeeb tau qhia txog kev sib tham ntawm tus 21st Congress ntawm cov European Society rau Kev Sib Deev rau hauv Internet kev cuam tshuam rau kev sib deev. Ob peb swb piav txog teeb meem ntawm kev sib daj sib deev, ntxias Park et al., 2016, tau tweeted. Cov tweets ua rau Nicole Prause, David Ley, Yauxej Pab Pawg thiab lawv cov phooj ywg rau Twitter-npau taws rau Park et al., 2016.

Muaj ntau zaug ntawm Prause's tweets thuam mus rau qhov chaw nyob los ntawm Gary Wilson tau teem rau lub rooj sib tham 2018 ISSM. Suddenly thiab tsis piav qhia kuv tham yog mysteriously tso tseg. Nws pom tau tias Dr. Prause yog tom qab qhov kev tshem tawm vim nws yog tib txog kev qhia (khav theeb txog?) Qhov kev tshem tawm (pheej) ntawm kev tshaj tawm. Nws muaj keeb kwm ntev ntev ntawm kev qhia cuav rau cov koom haum thiab cov thawj coj hauv lub cev.

Nws yuav pom tias Prause pub khoom ntawm ISSM cov rooj sib tham nws li ib txwm sau ntawm falsehoodsCov. Piv txwv li, Kuv xav tias nws tau taw qhia tias kuv tau tshaj tawm qhia rau Oregon Pawg Neeg ntawm Kev Puas Siab Puas Ntsws (tsis muaj laj thawj) rau "kev xyaum kev siab ntsws uas tsis muaj daim ntawv tso cai." Kuv hais qhov no vim tias, tsis ntev tom qab sablaj, Kuv tau txais ib tsab ntawv los ntawm Pawg Neeg Tswj exonerating kuv ua li ntawd (lawv tsis tuaj yeem qhia tias leej twg tau ua ntawv tsis txaus siab).

Prause kuj tseem hais txog cov neeg, xws li cov rooj sib tham txog kev sib tham, tias kuv tuav kuv tus kheej ua xibfwb. Qhov no kuj yog qhov tseeb. (Mus saib qhov txuas ntxiv no: Kev Sij Hawm - Ua cem dag hais tias Wilson tau tsis lees paub nws daim ntawv pov thawj.) Tej zaum nws tseem yuav hais rau cov tuav xam tias nws dag ntau zaus tias kuv tau txwv tsis pub tawm tsam kuv kom nws muaj kev nyab xeeb, thiab hais tias kuv tau tshaj qhia rau FBI. Tsis muaj qhov kev sib tham “tsis tiv tauj”, thiab kuv twb tau tshaj tawm pej xeem a tsab ntawv ceeb toom los ntawm FBI tshem kuv thiab kev lees paub Ua zoo li dagCov. Hauv qab no yog cov piv txwv ntawm Prause lub Ob Hlis 16, 2019 Twitter-npau taws ntsig txog Park et al., 2016:

Josh Grubbs feem ntau txhawb kev phooj ywg Ua ntej hauv nws qhov kev sib tawm tsam thiab kev ua tsis ncaj ntawm kev tshawb fawb (los yog nws cov kev kawm):

Tib hnub ntawd, NatureReviewsUrology (NRU) hais los ntawm kev hais lus, tsis yog los ntawm peb daim ntawv. Qhov xov xwm NRU no yog ib qho uas tau ua rau Twitter npau taws feem ntau los ntawm Pause thiab nws cov neeg tawm tsam peb cov ntawv, txawm tias peb daim ntawv tsis hais cov lus hauv qab no, thiab yeej tsis hais dab tsi txog kev quav yeeb quav tshuaj porn. Raws li qhov cia tseg, Prause cov lus foob hais txog "cov ntaub ntawv tsis raug" yog qhov tsis muaj tseeb thiab tsis muaj kev txhawb nqa.

Tsis muaj ntaub ntawv sau cia ntawm ib yam dab tsi, dua li ntawm Prause tus tsis muaj qhov kawg ntawm txoj kev tsis txhawb nqa, kev hais lus tawm suab, tsis txaus siab rau cov nplooj ntawv no:

Qhov tseeb yog, Kuv yog feem ntau yuav tsis muaj npe ua tus hais lus tseem ceeb los ntawm ISSM vim muaj kev cuam tshuam tom qab ntawm Prause thiab nws lub suab nrov thiab tus kws sau Jim Pfaus (ISSM tus tswv cuab), uas siv nws lub sijhawm ntev los tso Lub screws rau ISSM pawg neeg. Raws li kuv tau koom nrog ib qho kev iab liam tsis raug, Prause kom meej meej tsim ib co kev dag dag kom hem hem ISSM (ua raws nrog nws tus qauv ntawm tus cwj pwm sau rau ntawm nplooj ntawv no). Lub vijtsam me me ntawm Gary Wilson cov lus sib tham ntawm 2018 ISSM lub rooj sib tham tau tuav hauv Portugal:

Pawg neeg nug kuv kom kuv hais lus vim hais tias: (1) Kuv nyob rau Park et al., 2016, thiab, (2) Kuv tau muab ib nrov TEDx tham nrov heev, uas tau tshoov siab rau porn-vim ED. Ib qho screenshot ntawm kev caw tuaj koom:

Ntawm social media, Prause tau hais tias nws tau txais kuv cov lus tham tag lawm vim tias kuv tau hais tawm "daim ntawv pov thawj cuav." Piv txwv li, Prause's tweet tawm tsam ESSM tham, thiab nws tus neeg thov tias Gary Wilson tsis muaj npe vim nws "muab cov ntawv pov thawj cuav":

Cov ntaub ntawv pov thawj hais tias muaj kev dag ntxias: nyob rau sab nrauv tawm los, kuv nco txog pawg neeg ISSM uas kuv tsis muaj PhD lossis MD (saib hauv qab). Txawm li cas los xij, pawg neeg tuaj koom kuv tam sim no thiab them rau kuv lub davhlau rau Portugal txawm tias qhov kev tshem tawm (uas tsis txwm tas).

Thaum nws yuav xav tsis thoob tias Prause yuav ua rau cov skulduggery, peb yuav tsum nco ntsoov tias qhov no yog tib tus neeg uas qhia txog 7 cov kws kho mob ntawm Park et al. rau lawv lub xeev cov chaw kho mob (cov laug tsis quav ntsej Prause li tsim kev kub ntxhov). Nws yog tib tug neeg uas muaj dag hais txog 6 xyoo uas nws tau qhia Gary Wilson rau FBI. Tib tug neeg uas pheej twv twv hais tias Ntaus Cov Tshuaj Tshiab tau hais rau nws cov thwjtim tias “Dr. Kev ua txhaum yuav tsum tau tsoob ”Cov. Tibtus neeg uas tawm tsam thiab kev ntxub ntxaug yav dhau los UCLA tus neeg koom tes Rory C. Reid PhDCov. Tib tug neeg uas tshaj tawm cov lus tshaj tawm hauv lub vev xaib porn, dag hais tias Gary Wilson tau raug rho tawm los ntawm University of Oregon Oregon. Thiab nyob rau hauv thiab nws mus.

Ntxiv tweets zom cov 2019 ESSM tham thiab Park et al., 2016:

Tsis yog, COPE tsis tau hais tawm txog kev tawm, tab txawm Prause ua phem rau lawv rau 3 ncaj xyoo. Sai li sai tau COPE nkag siab tias txhua txoj kev cai Navy tso cai tau ua tiav nrog, txhua tus tham ntawm qhov kev txiav tawm tas.

Diagnostic manuals xws li DSM thiab ICD tsis siv lo lus "kev quav tshuaj" los piav txhua yam kev tiv thaiv: lawv siv "teeb meem." Nyob hauv qhov tseeb, qhov tseeb version ntawm lub koom haum World Health Organization kev ntsuam xyuas mob phau ntawv, Lub International Classification of Disease (ICD-11), muaj tus mob tshiab tsim nyog rau kev kuaj mob dab tsi uas feem ntau hu ua 'porn abuse' lossis 'kev sib daj sib deev.' Nws hu ua "Teebmeem Kev Sib Haum Ua Poj Ntxuam"(CSBD).

Thawj seem ntawm qhov kev ntaus nqi nws kim heev Nws pib qhov cov lus dag uas nyob ib puag ncig ICD-11: Debunking "Vim Li Cas Ho Peb Tos Tamsim No Uas Saib Xyuas Porn? ", Los ntawm Marty Klein, Taylor Kohut, thiab Nicole Prause (2018). Rau qhov tseeb ntawm ICD-11 qhov kev kuaj mob tshiab, saib tsab xov xwm nyuam qhuav los ntawm Lub Koom Haum rau Kev Txhawm rau Kev Sib Deev (SASH): "Kev Cwj Pwm ntawm Kev Sib deev" tau raug txwv los ntawm World Health Organization li Kev Puas Siab Puas Ntsws.

Ntxiv trolling ntawm 2019ESSM tham:

Ua ntej thiab Ley - raws li ib txwm, nrov nrov tiv thaiv porn thiab porn kev lag luam.

Tsis muaj laj thawj dab tsi, Prause tweets bogus RetractionWatch tshooj rov hais txog Park et al (3-1-19):

Ua ntej tseem muaj, defaming phau ntawv Journal Behavioral Sciences:

Cyber-harassment.

Tawm ntawm xiav, Prause tweets tus nres ntawm MDPI: Cov nram qab no khees me ntsis los ntawm Norwegian Register yog ib qho txhaum cai clerical, uas tom qab kho. Saib qhov kev piav qhia ntawm MDPI Wikipedia nplooj: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:MDPI#Reply_1-APR-2019

Prause paub qhov tseeb raws li ob peb tus neeg fake aliases tau kho cov MDPI Wikipedia nplooj ntawv, inserting nws txheej txheem ntawm cov lus dag.

Ib qhov txuas rau tus kho version qhia tias MDPI tsis tau txo qis qis. Tias yog vim li cas Prause tsis txuas rau nplooj ntawv hauv nws qhov tweet. Screenshot hauv qab no:

Ob hnub tom qab Prause trolls ib tug qub twitter xov tau Gary Wilson twb kho Josh Grubbs tig. Nws tweets tib lub vijtsam debunked:

Qhov cim tias 4 xyoo obsessive cyber-harassment thiab defamation.

Lub Plaub Hlis, 2019, David Ley koom Nickky hauv disparaging Park thiab al., 2016:

Ley yeej tsis teb nrog cov khoom kom rov qab tau nws cov lus dag.

Plaub Hlis Ntuj 27, 2019. Trolling ib cov lus xov rau ib qho kev zam txim rau kev sib kis li niaj zaus falsehoods:

Raws li tau teev muaj tsuas yog ib tus 'kws tshawb fawb ", Prause. Thiab tsis yog, tsis muaj 8 tsis lees paub tias cov kev tshawb fawb.

----

Lub Xya hli ntuj, 2019 - Nws tunes tuaj dua tweeting, raws li ib tug Wikipedia yuav Prock sockpuppet inserts cov ntaub ntawv no tib yam rau hauv MDPI Wikipedia.

Ib qhov txuas rau tus kho version uas qhia tias MDPI tsis downgraded hauv 2019 (nws yog kev ua txhaum yuam kev uas nws thiaj li kho). Thaum lub 2020 kev ntsuam xyuas kuj tseem yog ib qho yuam kev, Norwegian register tsis qhia tias "0" - tab sis nws yog "tsis dua". Daim ntawv ceeb toom tias Prause yog sim ntxias pej xeem los ntawm tweeting 2 screenshots ntawm qhov kev sib tw; ib tug nrog 2020 nkaus xwb, thiab ib qho screenshot ntawm 2019 yuam kev uas tom qab kho. Preview tus screenshots:

Thawj qhia tawm 2020 xwb

Qhov thib ob uas qhia qhov yuam kev tsis tiav:

Ua ntej yog dag txog MDPI tus 2019 kev ntsuam xyuas, raws li tau pom nyob rau hauv ib lub screenshot ntawm qhov tsis ntev los no:

Concurrently nrog Prause tus tweet tweet ib "Tshiab" Wikipedia cai inserts qhov 2020 ntsuam xyuas hauv phab Wikipedia.

Franck Vazquez, Ph.D. (Thawj Coj ntawm MDPI) hu ua ntej tawm rau dag:

Nws pom tias 2020 kev ntaus nqi yuav raug kho thaum pib ntawm lub xyoo.

Nyob rau hauv cov lus teb, Prause trolls ib tug 3-hli qub Frank Vasquez tweet:

Thov mus ntes hauv lwm cov lus dag hais txog cov kev ntsuas ntawm Norwegian. Qhov tseeb txuas rau nplooj ntawv rau txhua phau ntawv journal: https://dbh.nsd.uib.no/publiseringskanaler/VedtakNiva1Cov. Nrhiav MDPI thiab koj yuav pom tias tag nrho nws cov phau ntawv tshaj tawm muaj qhov ntsuas "1", suav nrog Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam, qhov twg Park et al., 2016 tau tshaj tawm.

--------

Lub Yim Hli, 2019: Prause thiab David Ley pab pawg los dag txog Park et al., 2016. Daim ntawv tau tshaj tawm hauv xov yog Ley tsis qhia qhov tseeb ntawm kev tshawb fawb hauv xeev, hais tias kev quav yeeb yaj kiab tsis muaj nyob. Tam sim ntawd Ley teb nrog kev sib cem - thov kom cov kws sau ntawv them nyiaj rau kom muaj Park et al., 2016 luam tawm:

Gary Wilson kho Ley lub falsehoods:

Nicole Prause tweets nws falsehoods , thov lub 8 tus kws sau ntawv tau raug them "hu rau nws kev quav".

Ntawm no nws mus dua, nyob rau hauv tib tweet:

Raws li cov Tus Thawj Coj ntawm MDPI tau piav qhia, qhov kev ntaus nqi tiag tiag tshwm sim hauv 2020.

HLOOV TSHIAB (2020): raws li koj tuaj yeem pom, MDPI ib txwm tau ntsuas raws li # 1 - (thiab Prause ib txwm tau dag txog MDPI kev ntsuas):

————————————————————————————————

Prause thiab Ley tawm lus pom nyob rau lub Yim Hli, 2016 Psychology Niaj hnub no blog sau los ntawm Mark Castleman. Castleman tus ncej yog nra hnav nrog tsis tseeb hais txog Park et al., 2016 thiab Grubbs thiab Gola, 2016. Castleman dag txog kojbrainonporn.com, thov kom peb tsis txhob qhia txog qhov kev tshawb fawb lossis sau cov ntawv tshawb fawb tsis zoo li txhua lwm tus nayasayer tab sis nws tsis muab ib qho piv txwv ntawm qhov tsis zoo. Nws tseem dag nyob rau hauv nws cov lus qhia txog qhov uas YBOP hais txog kev siv porn los ntawm ED. Txhua yam nws foob txog Park et al. yog cov lus dag: cov ntsiab lus, nws cov neeg pab leg ntaubntawv, nws lub hom phiaj, cov kev tshawb fawb, cov kev tshawb fawb, koj lub npe nws. Qhov no yuav tsum tsis txhob muaj kev xav tsis thoob li Castleman tau tshaj tawm ntau cov ntawv xov xwm hauv kev txhawb nqa kev lag luam porn (txhua qhov kev ntxub ntxaug thiab kev tshawb fawb tsis muaj tseeb). Nws tsis yog cov kws tshawb nrhiav lossis therapist, tsuas yog cov neeg sau xov xwm nrog cov txheej txheem. Castleman cov lus kuj tau txhawb nqa realyourbrainonporn.com raws li qhov tseeb ntawm kev xav txog porn cov teebmeem. Muaj me ntsis tsis ntseeg ntawm Prause thiab Ley txoj kev koom tes hauv nws cov khoom ntaus tam sim no.

Thawj zaug saib los ntawm Ley:

Ob peb cov lus ntawm Ley cov lus dag thiab kiv.

LEY - Tshaj tawm hauv phau ntawv xov xwm tsis zoo uas muaj xwm txheej ceev.

Kev Coj Tus Cwj Pwm yog PubMed qhov ntsuas, tsis zoo li cov ntawv xov xwm uas tau txais Ley 2 daim ntawv xav (piv txwv li Porn Studies Journal, Xov Xwm Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv Tam Sim No).

Quaj - Tsis muaj leej twg ntawm cov kws sau ntawv pom tias muaj kev qhia txog kev noj qab haus huv, lossis kev kho mob nrog txiv neej pw thiab ntau tus kws kho qhov muag?

Raug Ley. Ntawm yim tus kws sau ntawv yog xya tus kws kho mob uas muaj kev txawj ntse hauv qab no: ob tus kws ntsuas mob hlwb, tus kws kho neuroologist, thiab ob tug kws kho mob hlwb, thiab ib tug kws kho mob. " Raws li lub ntsej muag kws kho mob, Dr. Doan yog ob qho tib si MD thiab PhD (Neuroscience - Johns Hopkins), yog yav dhau los ntawm Lub Taub Hau ntawm "Kev Tshawb Nrhiav thiab Kev Rov Qab Ua Haujlwm" hauv Lub Chaw Haujlwm Saib Xyuas Kev Puas Hlwb ntawm Naval Medical Center. Ntxiv rau cov ntaub ntawv hais txog internet pornography, Doan tau sau ntau daim ntawv ntawm kev coj tus cwjpwm / kev txheeb tus kabmob uas cuam tshuam nrog thev naus laus zis, (nws luam tawm cov kev tshawb fawb phooj ywg ua ntej nws tawm los ntawm tsev kawm theem siab).

LEY - Cov kev ntsuam xyuas piav qhia txog kev kho mob thiab kev kho mob hauv cov tshooj lus Park yog qhov nyuaj heev. Hauv thawj qhov xwm txheej tshawb fawb, cov kws sau ntawv piav qhia tias lawv tau qhia tus neeg mob tias "kev siv cov khoom ua si sib deev tau ua rau nws txoj hlab ntsha hauv qhov chaw mos," cov lus tshaj tawm thiab tsis tau txhawb nqa los tshaj tawm, yam tsis muaj kev soj ntsuam urological.

Ley xav tias nws yog qhov tseem ceeb rau cov kws kho mob tawm tswv yim kom muab cov khoom ua si pw ua ke thiab porn siv (txawm tias tus neeg caij nkoj hnyav hnyav txog nws cov khoom ua si / porn tsim kev sib deev sib deev). Ib qho lus piav los ntawm rooj plaub-hais tawm qhia Ley cov lus qhia ua tsis raug:

Ib tug 20 xyoo laus uas tseem ua haujlwm tau ua npe rau Caucasian serviceman tau qhia txog kev nyuaj los ntawm kev ua tiav thaum lub sijhawm ua ke rau lub sijhawm dhau los rau lub hlis. Nws tau tshwm sim thaum nws tau ua haujlwm sab nraud. Nws yog masturbating txog ib teev tsis muaj ib qho orgasm, thiab nws tus qau mus flaccid. Nws qhov teeb meem tswj kev erection thiab ua tiav orgasm txuas ntxiv mus thoob nws qhov kev xa mus. Txij li thaum nws rov qab, nws tsis tau muaj peev xwm ejaculate thaum lub sij hawm com nrog nws fiancée. Nws muaj peev xwm ua tau ib qho erection, tiam sis tsis tau orgasm, thiab tom qab 10-15 min nws yuav plam nws erection, uas tsis yog qhov teeb meem ua ntej nws muaj ED teeb meem. Qhov no ua rau muaj teeb meem hauv nws txoj kev sib raug zoo nrog nws tus fiancée.
Tus neeg mob pom zoo kev zoo siab ntau zaus rau “xyoo”, thiab ib lossis ob zaug yuav luag txhua hnub rau ob peb lub xyoo dhau los. Nws pom zoo rau saib Internet duab liab qab rau kev sim. Txij li thaum nws txais kev nkag mus siv Is Taws Nem ceev, nws cia siab rau Internet saib duab liab qab. Thaum pib, "porn muag", qhov twg cov ntsiab lus tsis tas cuam tshuam txog kev sib deev, "ua qhov yuam kev". Txawm li cas los xij, maj mam nws xav tau ntau dua cov duab lossis cov khoom fetish kom orgasm. Nws tau tshaj tawm qhib ntau cov yeeb yaj kiab ib txhij thiab saib cov feem txhawb nqa feem ntau. Thaum npaj rau kev xa tawm ib xyoos dhau los, nws tau txhawj xeeb txog kev txav deb ntawm kev sib deev sib deev. Yog li, nws tau yuav ib qho khoom ua si sib deev, uas nws tau qhia tias yog "chaw mos cuav". Cov cuab yeej no tau pib ua kom nws thiaj li mus txog orgasm nyob rau hauv feeb.
Kev kho mob, nws tsis muaj keeb kwm muaj mob loj, kev phais, los yog mob hlwb. Nws tsis noj tshuaj los yog tshuaj noj. Nws tsis pom zoo siv cov khoom luam yeeb tab sis haus ob peb haus ntawm ob tog ib zaug lossis ob zaug hauv ib lub hlis. Nws yeej tsis blacked tawm cawv toxication. Nws qhia txog ntau tus neeg koom nrog kev sib deev yav dhau los, tab sis txij li thaum nws kev sib koom tes ib xyoo dhau los nws tus fiancée tau nws ib tus txiv neej kev sib deev. Nws tsis pom zoo txog keeb kwm kev sib deev kis kabmob. Rau sab cev nqaij daim tawv, nws cov cim tseem ceeb tau ua txhua yam, thiab nws txoj kev kuaj mob hauv plab yog qhov tshwm sim tsis muaj mob los yog masses.
Thaum xaus ntawm kev mus xyuas, nws tau piav qhia rau nws tias kev siv cov khoom ua si sib deev tau muaj peev xwm ua rau nws txoj hlab ntsha hauv qhov chaw mos thiab saib cov duab liab qab hauv Internet tau hloov kho nws txoj haujlwm ntawm kev sib deev. Nws raug qhia kom tsis txhob siv cov khoom ua si thiab saib hardcore Internet pornography. Nws raug xa mus rau urology rau kev txheeb xyuas ntxiv.
Los ntawm lub sijhawm nws tau pom los ntawm urologist ob peb lub lis piam tom qab, nws tau txiav tawm hauv Is Taws Nem siv cov duab liab qab siv tau ntau, txawm hais tias nws hais tias nws tsis tuaj yeem nres. Nws tsis tau siv cov khoom ua si ntawd. Nws rov qab muaj orgasms dua los ntawm kev sib deev nrog nws tus fiancée, thiab lawv txoj kev sib raug zoo tau zoo tuaj.

Cov ntaub ntawv pov thawj ntxiv tias Ley yuav tsum tau muab cov lus qhia kev sib deev.

Cov lus hais los ntawm Prause alias (nws tsis qhia txog nws tus kheej tias nws tau koom nrog 2 kev foob raws li Lub Yim Hli, 2016):

Cov lus hais tsis tseeb zoo li Park et al., 2016 tsis yog kev kawm, tab sis kev tshuaj xyuas. Raws li nthuav tawm ntawm nplooj ntawv tam sim no, Prause raug dag txog teeb meem kev coj ua thiab cov ntaub ntawv hais plaub. Tab sis dab tsi koj cia siab tias los ntawm MDPI tus cyberstalker?

Lwm saib los ntawm lub npe hu ua Prause:

Raws li saum toj no, Chaw Ua Si yog qhov tshuaj xyuas, yog li nws tsis nthuav tawm cov ntaub ntawv sim. Txawm li cas los xij, nws muaj cov ntaub ntawv loj thoob plaws thiab 200 cov ntawv xa mus.

------

Lub Tsib Hlis 24-27, 2018 - Kev Tshaj Lij ua rau ntau cov thom khwm-cov menyuam roj hmab los kho cov nplooj ntawv MDPI Wikipedia (thiab raug txwv rau cov thom khwm

Nyob rau hauv ib tug tshooj ua ntej peb tau piav txog Prause ua kev ua phem ntawm MDPI thiab nws phau ntawv ceev xwm txheej Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam TshuamCov. Peb tseem ua ntev dhau los ntawm Prause cov keeb kwm ntev ntawm kev ua haujlwm ntau lub npe siv dag siv ntawm Wikipedia (uas nws ua txhaum nws cov cai) ua phem rau ntau tus tib neeg lossis cov koom haum muaj npe ntawm nplooj ntawv no. Piv txwv li:

Prause qhov tseeb ntawm barrage Wikipedia tau tshwm sim txij lub Tsib Hlis 24 txog rau 27th thiab koom nrog tsawg kawg 6 lub npe cuav (hu ua "sock-puppets" hauv Wikipedia jargon). Cov ntawv txuas hauv qab no coj koj mus rau txhua qhov kev hloov kho los ntawm cov usernames tshwj xeeb ("cov neeg siv pab txhawb"):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Suuperon
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/NeuroSex
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Defender1984
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/23.243.51.114
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/185.51.228.243
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/209.194.90.6

Thawj plaub usernames edited ntawm MDPI Wikipedia nplooj, thaum 3 ntawm 6 edited tus Nofap Wikipedia nplooj ntawv, lub Kev sib deev quav yees duab thiab cov Pornography Addiction page. Tag nrho cov nplooj ntawv 3 yog obsessions ntawm Prause. Txawm Wikipedia tau lees paub cov usernames li ntawm tib tug neeg vim tias tag nrho cov npe raug txwv rau "kev tso dag-puppetry." Peb tuaj yeem paub meej tias nws tau kho ua Ntej MDPI vim tias:

1) Lub sijhawm tshaj tawm ntawm emails ntawm MDPI thiab Nicole Prause pib rau May 22, nrog MDPI ceeb toom txhua tus koom tes hais tias ib qho kev kho me me thiab kev sau ntaub ntawv xov xwm yuav tawm los. Qhov no ua rau muaj kev cuam tshuam cov neeg uas tau ntsib nrog txoj kev xav thiab kev hem, thiab ua raws li kev hais lus tsis zoo thiab kev tawm tsam.

2) Tus edits pib nrog neeg NeuroSex uas nws tsuas hloov ua ntej May 24th yog ib qho tsis sib haum kom muaj lwm cov nplooj ntawv Wikipedia txuas rau Nicole Ua Ntej Wikipedia (Lub Ob Hlis, 2018). Ntawm qhov NeuroSex tham sab:

Txais tos rau Wikipedia. Txawm hais tias txhua tus neeg tuaj yeem txais kev pabcuam rau hauv phau ntawv qhia txog ntau ntau, koj qhov ntxiv los ntawm ib lossis ntau dua sab nraud mus rau nplooj ntawv Nicole Prause tau raug thim rov qab.

3) Cov ntsiab lus Wikipedia tig rau ib puag ncig ntawm Prause txoj kev xav tsis tu ncua: cuam tshuam thiab sim thim rov qab ntawm cov ntawv sau los ntawm Gary Wilson thiab US Navy cov kws kho mob: Puas yog cov duab liab qab hauv Internet Ua kom muaj kev sib deev? Kev Ntsuam Xyuas Nrog Kev Tshaj Qhia Cov Kuaj Mob (Park et al., 2016)

4) Tag nrho Wikipedia edits daim iav thwj sim Tweets thiab nws emails rau MDPI (ntau ntawm Wilson tau pom).

5) Cov thuam-puppets thov nqa ntiag tug MDPI emails - uas lawv xav xa mus rau MDPI Wikipedia nplooj ntawvCov. Nov yog qhov NeuroSex tau hais hauv nws cov lus tshaj tawm. (Nco tseg: Hauv nws tsab email txuas mus rau MDPI, Prause cc'd RetractionWatch, thaj rau HLA MDPI nrog pej xeem ua pauj.):

Kuv muaj cov duab uas tshawb xyuas txhua tus neeg pab leg ntaubntawv (xws li, email los ntawm publisher, email los ntawm cov ntawv sau, thiab lwm yam). RetractionWatch thiab lwm cov kev tshaj tawm xaiv qhov kev txheeb xyuas ntawm nws zoo li, tab sis kuv tsis tuaj yeem paub hais tias cov neeg yuav ua. Qhov zoo tshaj plaws los muab cov pov thawj uas muaj pov thawj rau cov lus pom zoo? Ua duab kos? Sau lwm qhov nrog cov duab thiab txuas?

Cia peb muab qee qhov piv txwv ntawm "NeuroSex" kho (lus dag) ntsig txog Gary Wilson thiab Park et al., 2016 - ua raws li Wilson cov lus:

NeuroSex hloov #1: Gary Wilson tau los ntawm {{pab tswv yim web | npe = them tshaj 9000 phaus | url =https://www.oscr.org.uk/downloadfile.aspx?id=160223&type=5&charityid=SC044948&arid=236451}} Lub Reward Foundation yuav tuaj tos txais nyob hauv Asmeskas sawv cev rau kev tshaj tawm hauv lub xeev lossis kev saib duab liab qab.

Wilson saib: NeuroSex txuas nrog rau cov ntawv sau cia, thov tias Gary Wilson tau them 9,000 phaus los ntawm Scotish kev siab hlub The Reward Foundation. Ob hnub ua ntej dhau los Prause ua tsis ncaj ncees rau tus neeg sau xov xwm MDPI (thiab lwm tus) tias, raws li cov chaw pab nyiaj (tsoomfwv sau npe), nrog rau kev them nyiaj rov qab rau tus neeg khiav dej num pab nyiaj tau yog qhov tseeb them rau Wilson. Prause tsis tau soj ntsuam nws qhov tseeb, thiab nws yuam kev (dua). Wilson yeej tsis tau txais ib qho nyiaj los ntawm Lub Reward Foundation. Gary Wilson xa tawm thov Prause rau Darryl Mead, Tus Thawj Coj ntawm Lub Reward Foundation. Nws teb tau saum toj no:

Los ntawm: Kev Ntshaw Nqi Zog[email tiv thaiv]>
Xa: Hnub Thursday, Tsib Hlis 24, 2018 8:17 AM
Mus rau: gary wilson
Subject: Re: txhawj xeeb txog tsa COPE los ntawm Nicole Prause. Cov ntawv luam tawm ID behavsci-133116

Nyob zoo Gary:

Kuv tau saib mus rau qhov no. Prause hais tias:

On 22/05/2018 20:48, Nicole Prause sau hais tias:
> Nws zoo nkaus li Wilson tau txais nyiaj los ntawm Lub Reward Foundation. Rhais nrog Yog Cov Khoom Qhia Tshaj Plaws Lub Xyoo Txhua Xyoo. Ib qhov C6 hais txog kev taug kev uas piav qhia Gary Wilson qhov kev mus ncig tag nrho 9,027 phaus.
>
> Kuv thov kom txhua txoj kev kho kom haum suav nrog COI nyiaj txiag no, lossis sijhawm muab tso los qhia tias qhov no tsis yog kev pheej hmoo nyiaj txiag ntawm qhov muaj txiaj ntsig.
>
> Nicole Prause, Ph.D. Liberoshttp://www.liberoscenter.com>

Nov yog qhia rau peb cov Nyiaj Xyoo 2016-17. Ib qho version ntawm cov as khauj nrog kev lees paub tus kheej tau luam tawm los ntawm Lub Chaw Haujlwm ntawm Scottish Charity Regulator thiab tuaj yeem rub tawm ntawm https://www.oscr.org.uk/search/charity-details?number=SC044948#results, daim ntawv txuas nrog. Qhov txheej txheem liab no tau ua los ntawm OSCR tsis muaj kev tawm tswv yim los ntawm lub npe sib hlub sib txhawb.

Cov ntu uas cuam tshuam nrog nyeem ntxiv raws li qhov tshuaj ntsuam no.

Tus neeg xa mus rau hauv C6 yog Darryl Mead, tus Thawj Coj ntawm Lub Reward Foundation. Kuv yog tus neeg ntawd thiab kuv tau ua thov cov nyiaj them rov qab ntawm kev mus ncig thiab lwm yam nqi.

Tus thawj ntawv nyeem raws li nram no:

Tsis muaj peev xwm hais txog Gary Wilson hauv ib qho twg ntawm kev siv nyiaj rau Cov Nyiaj Pab Rov Ntsuas vim tias tsis muaj kev them nyiaj rau nws.

Nrog kev xav tau zoo tshaj plaws,

Darryl Mead

Hauv cov ntsiab lus, Prause ua txhaum Wilson tau txais nyiaj los ntawm Lub Reward Foundation. Tom qab ntawv nws tshaj tawm nws cov lus dag rau MDPI, COPE, RetractionWatch, thiab lwm tus, siv cov ntawv pov thawj uas nws xa (tsuas yog li NeuroSex dag rau Wikipedia hauv nws qhov kev sim ua kom nws muaj feem cuam tshuam nrog kev hloov).

Hloov kho, 6-7-18: Tsis muaj laj thawj dab tsi tshwj xeeb tshaj yog tias kuv tsis tau tshaj tawm thiab tsis muaj leej twg suav kuv cov haujlwm lossis hais txog kuv, Prause muab lo rau ICD-11 txog Gary Wilson (yuav tsum tsim tus username los saib cov lus). Hauv tsab ntawv no Prause rov ua cov lus dag saum toj no nws tau hais hauv kev sib pauv email nrog MDPI, RetractionWatch, thiab COPE (thiab ntawm Wikipedia):

Ob peb hnub tom ntej no Nicole Prause tau tshaj tawm 4 lo lus phem ntxiv rau ICD-11 tawm tsam Gary Wilson thiab txuas yam tsis tseeb tias nws yog tus neeg ua haujlwm tau nyiaj ntawm Lub Reward Foundation. Darryl Mead, tus Thawj Coj ntawm Lub Reward Foundation, thaum kawg teb:

Raws li tau npaj tseg, Prause tau teb nrog ntau cov lus dag thiab kev tawm tsam.

Hloov kho, 6-18-18: Siv sijhawm tsim lwm tus Wikipedia npe los kho cov MDPI wikipedia nplooj ntawv - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/185.51.228.245 - thiab ntxiv cov hauv qab no:

Xyoo 2016, lwm qhov MDPI phau ntawv sau, Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam, luam tawm tsab ntawv soj ntsuam ntawv lees tias cov duab liab qab tshwm sim erectile kawgCov. Rau cov kws tshawb fawb txog nws tus kheej MDPI txhawj xeeb txog kev dag thiab lwm yam teeb meem hauv tsab xov xwm, pib ua ib qho kev ywj pheej rov los saib xyuas los ntawm Pawg Neeg Saib Xyuas Kev Tshaj Tawm (COPE). COPE pom zoo kom rov qab sau kab lus.^[31] Cov ntawv xov xwm uas sau cia, Scott Lane, raug tsis pom zoo ua tus editor. Yog li, daim ntawv zoo nkaus li tsis muaj kev tshawb xyuas tus phooj ywg rov qab los-tshuaj xyuas. Ntxiv mus, ob tus kws sau ntawv tau sau cov kev tsis sib haum xeeb ntawm cov paj. Gary Wilson lub koom haum nrog Lub Reward Foundation tsis tau txheeb xyuas nws tus kheej ua haujlwm, tiv thaiv kev saib duab liab qab.
Wilson tseem tau tshaj tawm txog kev sib tham hauv social media tias qhov kev tshawb fawb yog "los ntawm US Navy", txawm hais tias thawj daim ntawv tau hais tias nws tsis cuam tshuam cov kev xav ntawm US Navy. Lwm tus kws sau ntawv, Dr. Andrew Doan, nws yog ib tus kws kho qhov muag uas tau ua haujlwm tiv thaiv kev saib duab liab qab tiag tiag Chaw Tuav Haujlwm Sib Tw, thov kev pab nyiaj pub dawb rau lawv cov lus.^[32] Ntxiv mus, Pawg Neeg Saib Xyuas Kev tshaj tawm Xov Xwm tau txiav txim tias cov teeb meem tsis raug, kev pom zoo ua rau suav tsis txheeb. MDPI muab kev kho rau qee cov teeb meem no,^[33] tab sis tau tsis kam tshaj tawm kev txhim kho rau lwm tus kom txog hnub uas tau piav qhia los ntawm Retraction Watch.^[31]

Ob peb ntawm cov saum toj no dag debunked:

Tsis tau muaj 6 tus kws tshawb fawb - tsuas yog Prause hu rau MDPI.
Kuv lub koom haum nrog Lub Reward Foundation tau qhia tawm txij thaum pib los. Raws li tau piav qhia ua ntej, kuv cov kev sib koom nrog Lub Reward Foundation (TRF) ib txwm tau hais meej meej, ob qho tib si hauv qhov pib Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam tsab xov xwm thiab kev kho lus tsis ntev los no (tus thawj PubMed version). Lub hom phiaj ntawm cov tshiab kho lus kho yog yuav tiv thaiv Dr. Prause lub incessant defamatory claims tias kuv tau txais nyiaj los ntawm TRF, thiab tias kuv tau nyiaj los ntawm kuv phau ntawv (kuv cov nyiaj rau qhov uas, qhov tseeb, mus rau hauv kev siab hlub)
Kuv tau tshaj tawm tias daim ntawv no muaj feem txog 7 tus kws kho mob hauv Navy Asmeskas. Navy twb tsis muaj teeb meem nrog kuv cov lus.
Dr Andrew Doan yog ob qho tib si MD thiab PhD (Neuroscience - Johns Hopkins), yog yav dhau los ntawm Lub Taub Hau ntawm "Kev Tshawb Xyuas thiab Kev Tshawb Nrhiav Kev Nyab Xeeb" nyob hauv Lub Tsev Haujlwm Saib Xyuas Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv ntawm Naval Medical Center. (Nws tau raug hloov mus ua haujlwm thiab nce qib, thiab muaj lub luag haujlwm sib txawv.) Doan tau sau ntau daim ntawv hais txog kev coj tus cwjpwm / kev hais tawm txog cov thev naus laus zis (hauv qee kis nrog tus sau ntawv ntawm cov ntawv koj tau sau txog ntawm no). Hauv ntej, nws yog tus kws tshaj lij kev txawj sau ntawv. Lwm cov ntawv no tuaj yeem pom nyob ntawm no: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=doan+klamCov. Nws cov neeg tsis muaj txiaj ntsig, Cov Thawj Saib Xyuas Kev Tshawb Fawb (R.M.) tsis tau tham txog duab liab qab ua ntej luam tawm cov ntawv. Txawm hais tias RBM tau hais txog kev saib duab liab qab nws yuav tsis muaj kev tsis sib haum xeeb.
Raws li tau piav qhia saum toj no, COPE qhov kev txiav txim siab yog lub ntsej muag thiab tsis siv rau peb daim ntawv raws li US Navy cov kws kho mob ntau dua li ua tiav nrog lawv Naval Medical Center - San Diego's IRB txoj cai tso cai. Naval Medical Center hauv San Diego's IRB txoj cai tsis xav txog cov ntaub ntawv ntawm tsawg dua plaub tus neeg mob hauv ib tsab xov xwm los ua tib neeg kev tshawb fawb thiab tsis tas yuav kom cov neeg mob tso cai rau kev tso tawm hauv ib tsab xov xwmCov. Txawm hais tias cov kws tshawb nrhiav tsis tas yuav tsum tau txais kev pom zoo, rau ob kis, kev pom zoo ntawm ncauj thiab sau ntawv tau txais. Hauv rooj plaub thib plaub uas tsis qhia npe tsis zoo yuav tsis muaj kev cuam tshuam, tsis muaj ntaub ntawv pom zoo tau txais. Qhov tshwm sim tsis txaus siab, ntawm Dr. Prause qhov kev thov tsis txaus siab, tom qab sau daim ntawv, cov kev ua ntawm Navy cov kws sau ntawv sib xyaw nrog cov ntawv no tau muab tshuaj xyuas zoo nyob rau hauv qhov kev tshawb nrhiav Navy ywj siab. Tshwm sim? Kuv muaj ib daim ntawv tshaj tawm los ntawm ib tus kws lij choj nrog Navy paub tseeb tias cov kws sau ntawv sau ua ke nrog tag nrho cov kev cai IRB.

Hauv daim ntawv foob uas tau teev tseg rau hauv Tsev Hais Plaub Tsoom Fwv Teb Chaws, Gary Wilson tau hais tias Prause (1) siv qhov tsis tseeb (Janey Wilson) txhawm rau rhuav tshem thiab tsim txom Wilson, nws tus tshaj tawm, thiab Lub Reward Foundation, (2) dag hauv email, ntawm Wikipedia, thiab hauv cov lus tshaj tawm pej xeem thaum hais tias Gary Wilson tau txais nyiaj them los ntawm Lub Reward Foundation

Prause cov lus dag thiab kev ua phem thaum kawg tau ntes nrog nws.

Raws li tau piav qhia txhua yam nyob hauv ntu lus dhau los Gary Wilson donates cov nyaij ntawm nws phau ntawv rau Qhov Tsim Txiaj. Wilson lees txais tsis muaj nyiaj, thiab tsis tau txais ib lub dime rau txhua qhov ntawm nws lub zog. YBOP lees txais tsis muaj kev tshaj tawm thiab Wilson tau lees txais tsis muaj nqi rau kev hais lus. Raws li sau tseg rau ntawm ntu no, Prause tau tsim tsa ib tus dab neeg sau dab neeg uas Wilson raug them los ntawm tib qho kev siab hlub nws pub nws phau ntawv rau:

Qhov tseeb, qhov no tsis yog qhov tseeb. Cov ob ntu lus saum toj saud tau hais tseg hauv Gary Wilson cov lus cog tseg, uas yog ib feem ntawm Dr. Hilton qhov kev foob foob foob rau Dr. Prause.

Hauv kev cog lus lees paub nyob hauv Tsoomfwv Tsev Hais Plaub, Gary Wilson tau hais (raws li raug nplua lub txim txhaum) tias (1) Nicole Prause siv qhov tsis tseeb (Janey Wilson) txhawm rau rhuav tshem thiab ua phem rau Wilson, nws tus tshaj tawm, thiab Lub Reward Foundation, (2) uas Siv cov lus dag hauv email, Wikipedia thiab hauv tsoomfwv cov lus qhia thaum Gary Wilson tau txais nyiaj txiag los ntawm Lub Reward Foundation.

Saib tag nrho cov lus qhia: Lub Xya Hli, 2019: Gary Wilson daim ntawv cog lus: Donald Hilton foob kev foob tawm tsam Nicole R Prause & Liberos LLCCov. Cov lus ntxiv los ntawm Gary Wilson cov lus cog tseg, uas yog ib feem ntawm Dr. Hilton qhov kev foob foob foob Dr. Prause.

Hais qhov yooj yim, Nicole Prause tau koom nrog hauv kev ua txhaum kev txhaum rau Wilson thiab Dr. Hilton. Ntxiv rau Wilson, 8 lwm tus neeg raug tsim txom ntawm Prause tau foob daim ntawv lees cov lus foob nrog lub tsev hais plaub piav qhia qhov kev thuam, kev ua phem, thiab kev hais tawm phem rau cov neeg tswj hwm lub cev thiab cov chaw haujlwm (tsuas yog qhov kawg ntawm xwb lub Prause iceberg).

**Kev dag ntxias txog Gary Wilson hauv email rau MDPI, David Ley, Neuro Skeptic, Adam Marcus ntawm Retraction Saib, thiab COPE (Tsib Hlis, 2018)**

Thaum lub Tsib Hlis, 2018 email sib pauv nrog MDPI & COPE, Prause theej cov bloggers uas tau tso rau qhov puas tsuaj ntawm lub koob npe ntawm MDPI hauv kev tshaj xov xwm, yog tias lawv xaiv. Ley blogs nyob Psychology Niaj hnub no thiab feem ntau tau txais kev pabcuam raws li Lub Ncauj Ncaj ntawm Kev Ntseeg. Neuro Skeptic muaj ib qhov nrov blog uas tsis pom zoo raws cai (thiab qee zaum dubious) kev tshawb fawb. Adas Marcus sau rau Retraction Watch. Prause kuj theej Iratxe Puebla, uas ua haujlwm rau COPE, ib lub koomhaum uas hais txog kev coj ua zoo. Tamsis no, Adam Marcus ntawm retraction Watch coj tus kab nuv ntses tsis muaj kev tshawb nrhiav txaus.

Nyob rau hauv nws cov lus phem, tweets, thiab Quora cov lus tshaj tawm Prause tau paub thiab tsis tseeb hais tias kuv (Gary Wilson) tau lees tias "xibfwb hauv kev kawm keeb kwm" "kws kho mob" lossis "kws kho mob hlwb." Kuv yog tus qhia ntxiv rau ntawm Oregon University Yav Qab Teb thiab qhia tib neeg tej cev, nqaij tawv thiab kab ke ntawm lwm qhov chaw. Txawm hais tias cov neeg sau xov xwm tsis zoo thiab lub vev xaib tau muab kuv cov npe ntawm qhov ua yuam kev ntau xyoo dhau los (suav nrog ib nplooj ntawv tam sim no tsis muaj dab tsi nyob rau hauv lub vev xaib uas muaj ntau tus TEDx hais lus thiab piav qhia cov neeg hais lus tsis saib xyuas yam tsis tau tiv tauj lawv) Kuv ib txwm hais tias kuv qhia kev ua haujlwm & muaj sia. Kuv tsis tau hais dua Kuv muaj PhD lossis yog xibfwb. Kev thov dag tib neeg dag rau cov neeg txais email:

KEV KAWM TXUJ EMAIL # 1 (5-1-2018)

Hnub Tue, Tsib Hlis 1, 2018 ntawm 10:11 PM, Nicole Prause >
Tsis tas li ntawd, Mr. Wilson tam sim no siv phau ntawv tshaj tawm no los thov ua tus kws kho mob online rau cov neeg mob tsis nco qab (txuas nrog).
NP
Nicole Prause, Ph.D. Liberos LLC: koj puas xav tau ntau tus thwjtim? www.liberoscenter.com

Hauv qab no yog qhov siv lub ntsej muag (Prause) siv "los ua pov thawj" tias kuv tau hais qhia qhov tsis tseeb txog kuv daim ntawv pov thawj (dua, nplooj ntawv Gary Wilson no tsis muaj ntxiv lawm). Nco tseg: Txog thaum Prause tsim nws “pov thawj,” Kuv tsis tau pom dua lub vev xaib no thiab tsis tau sib txuas lus nrog cov tswv, tsis thau nplooj ntawv hauv kab lus nug thiab tsis tshem nws. Yog lintawd Kuv yeej tsis muab qhov xyoob ntoo, lossis kev tshaj lij ntawm “kev tshajtawm txoj haujlwm.”

Kuv qhia ntawm Southern Oregon University ob zaug. Kuv kuj tau qhia txog kev ua kom lub cev, physiology thiab pathology ntawm ntau lub tsev kawm nyob rau ob xyoo dhau los, thiab tau raug lees paub los qhia cov kev kawm no los ntawm cov chaw qhia ntawv hauv Oregon thiab California. Kuv tsis nrhiav kev hais lus thiab tsis tau txais tus nqi hais lus. Ntxiv mus, YBOP lees txais tsis muaj kev tshaj tawm, thiab cov tau txais txiaj ntsig los ntawm kuv phau ntawv mus rau ib qho chaw pabcuam siab.

On phab “txog” nplooj ntawv qhov website ntawm Keynotes.org tau hais tias nws tsis yog ib qho chaw khiav dej num thiab hais tias txhua tus neeg tuaj yeem muab tus yees duab thiab hais lus bio: Keynotes.org tsis yog koom haum, tab sis, theej, yog qhov chaw tshaj xov xwm…. Keynotes.org yog qhov muaj neeg coob thiab siv los ntawm TrendHunter.com, uas yog lub vas sab ntau tshaj plaws nyob rau hauv lub ntiaj tebCov. Ib zaug ntxiv, Kuv tsis tau tshaj tawm ib yam dabtsi rau lub xaib, thiab kuv tsis muaj lub tswv yim uas muab upload nplooj ntawv no (lossis txiav kom nws muab tshem tawm).

Yog li, nws yog txawm tau hais tias Prause tau muab nplooj ntawv no, nrog kuv cov TEDx tham thiab lub hom phiaj tsis muaj tseeb, thiaj li ua kom nws xav tau "cov ntawv pov thawj" ntawm qhov tsis tseeb - thiab tom qab ntawd tshem nws. Tom qab 5 xyoo ntawm kev ua phem nruam ntxiv thiab cyber-stalking, cov ntaub ntawv tsis zoo, libelous assertions, pua pua tweets, Thiab kaum ob ntawm usernames nrog pua pua lus, tsis muaj dab tsi xav surprise peb.

Qhov screen saum toj-txhaj tshuaj yog ib feem ntawm a cov ntawv loj dua los ntawm Prause qhov uas nws dag hais tias kuv raug rho tawm haujlwm los ntawm Southern Oregon University: Lub Peb Hlis, 2018 - Tsis Txaus Ntseeg tias Gary Wilson Raug Rho TawmCov. Hauv nws tsab xov xwm, uas tau tshaj tawm nyob rau hauv lub chaw saib duab liab qab thiab Quora, Prause tau tshaj tawm cov ntawv pov thawj hais txog kuv cov ntaub ntawv qhia txog kev ua haujlwm yav qab teb Oregon University, hais qhia tsis tseeb Kuv tau raug rho tawm haujlwm thiab tsis tau qhia dua ib zaug hauv SOU. Raws li nrog nws cov lus thov ib puag ncig Lub Reward Foundation, Prause dag txog cov ntsiab lus tseeb ntawm dab tsi hauv cov ntawv sau cia. Los ntawm txoj kev, David Ley kuj tau tshaj tawm Cov Lus Qhia Pov Tseg hauv ob peb zaug, hais tias kuv raug rho tawm haujlwm los ntawm SOU (screenshots ntawm nplooj ntawv).

Thaum kawg, Kev thov raug txwv tsis pub dhau Quora rau kev ua phem rau kuv thiab cov porn-blog site tshem tawm Prause cov lus dag.

------

Hauv email rau MDPI, COPE, Ley, Neuroskeptic, Adam Marcus ntawm retraction Watch thiab lwm tus Ua Tsis Txaus Siab lav lav tias Kuv tau txais nyiaj los ntawm Lub Khoom plig Rov Los.

KEV KAWM TXUJ EMAIL # 2 (5-22-2018)

Liberoshttp://www.liberoscenter.com> Hnub tim 22/05/2018 20:48, Nicole Prause sau tias:
Nws zoo nkaus li Wilson tau txais nyiaj los ntawm Lub Reward Foundation. Rhais nrog Yog Cov Khoom Qhia Tshaj Plaws Lub Xyoo Txhua Xyoo. Ib qhov C6 hais txog kev taug kev uas piav qhia Gary Wilson qhov kev mus ncig tag nrho 9,027 phaus.
Kuv thov kom txhua txoj kev kho kom yog suav nrog COI nyiaj txiag no, lossis sijhawm muab tso los qhia tias qhov no tsis yog kev pheej hmoo nyiaj txiag.
Nicole Prause, Ph.D. Liberos

Prause tsis tau soj ntsuam nws cov lus, thiab nws yog qhov yuam kev. Kuv ib txwm tsis tau txais nyiaj los ntawm Lub Khoom plig Rov Los. Kuv xa Daim Ntawv Thov Prause rau Darryl Mead, Tus Thawj Coj ntawm Lub Reward Foundation, uas tau ua txhaum Prause cov lus thov: Saib Saud Rau Sau Ntaub Ntawv.

------

KEV KAWM TXUJ EMAIL # 3 (5-22-2018)

Hauv ntau tsab ntawv nws xa rau MDPI (thiab lwm tus), Prause hais txog "77 tus thuam" thiab hais tsis tseeb hais tias lawv tsis tau hais daws. Qhov no yog nyuam qhuav tseeb:

Hnub Tue, Tsib Hlis 22, 2018 thaum 9:36 AM, Nicole Prause>
Kuv tau muab 77 lub ntsiab lus thuam ua ntej tshaj tawm tias qhov tseeb, qhov tseeb ntawm phau ntawv xov xwm xav tau MDPI tau tshwm sim, tsis quav ntsej.
Nicole Prause, Ph.D. Liberos LLC: koj puas xav tau ntau tus thwjtim? www.liberoscenter.com

Qhov no txhais tau tias Prause yog ib tug ntawm ob tug rov xyuas dua ntawm Yale Journal of Biology thiab Medicine xa tawm - thiab yog li “Janey Wilson.” Raws li tau piav qhia, ntau ntawm 77 qhov teeb meem thiaj li hu ua luam tawm tsis zoo thiab dhau los ntawm Prause kev tshuaj xyuas ntawm tus YJBM xa tawm; 25 ntawm lawv tsis muaj ib yam dabtsi ua nrog rau Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam xa tawm. Hauv lwm lo lus, tsuas yog tus tshuaj xyuas cov ntawv rau txim rau daim ntawv tau txiav thiab dhau ntau thuam ntawm kev thuam los ntawm kev tshuaj xyuas tas lwm phau ntawv journal (YJBM), uas tsis muaj qhov cuam tshuam rau ntawv xa tuaj rau Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam. Qhov no yog qhov tsis ncaj ncees.

Txawm tias sib nrauj los ntawm qhov tsis zoo, qhov teeb meem 77 tsawg tsawg kuj raug xam tias yog qhov tseeb. Tsis tas li ntawd xwb, peb tau ua tib zoo sib txuas los ntawm txhua qhov tawm tswv yim rau cov tswv yim zoo, thiab tau sau cov lus teb rau tag nrho cov lus rau Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam thiab nws cov neeg kho. Yuav luag tag nrho cov seem ntawm 50 cov lus tseem ceeb tau tshawb pom qhov tseeb, tsis muaj tseeb, lossis cov lus tsis muaj tseeb. Qee qhov rov ua dua. Cov kws sau ntawv muab MDPI nrog cov ntsiab lus taw tes teb rau txhua qhov teeb meem.

Qhov kev siv ntawm "Janey Wilson" (thov txim)

Saib cov ntawv luam ntawm email tiag nyob hauv qab cov ntsiab lus no.

Tsis ntev tom qab kuv phau ntawv tau luam tawm nyob rau xyoo 2015, Prause sau ntawv rau kuv tus tshaj xo txog xov xwm, siv lub npe ("Janey Wilson"). Presuming "Janey" yog qhov raug cai, Dan Hind ntawm Tsoom Fwv Tebchaws Tshaj Tawm tshaj tawm nws qhia nws tias kuv feem ntawm cov phau ntawv tau nyiaj mus rau Lub Reward Foundation, ib qho kev sau npe hauv Scottish kev siab hlub (PDF ntawm Nicole Prause aliases nws tau siv los ua phem & hais phem).

“Janey Wilson” tau ceeb toom tam sim ntawd rau kev siab hlub tias Wilson tau “dag nws tus kheej tsis pub leej twg paub ua koom nrog Lub Reward Foundation,” thiab hais tias nws muaj ntawv pov thawj. Tib txoj kev uas nws tuaj yeem muaj “cov ntawv pov thawj” ntawm qhov tsis tau-tab-pej xeem cuam tshuam yog tias nws tau pom cov ntawv kawm uas kuv tau sib koom ua ke. Nws yog kev ua txhaum ntawm kev tshaj tawm cov cai coj ua zoo tshaj plaws los qhia tawm lossis siv cov ntaub ntawv tau kawm los ntawm kev tshuaj xyuas.

Cov ntaub ntawv "Janey" ua tsis tiav qhov ua rau cov kev npau taws xav tau los ntawm Lub Reward Foundation (raws li qhov tseeb kuv tau koom nrog Lub Tsev Haujlwm, ua haujlwm nyob rau hauv txoj haujlwm tsis txaus siab ua "Tus Thawj Tswj Haujlwm Science"). Tsis muaj qhov tsis txaus siab, "Janey" tom qab ntawd tau tshaj tawm Lub Reward Foundation mus rau Scottish Charity Regulator rau kev xav txog nyiaj txiag thiab lwm yam kev iab liam.

Txoj kev sib hlub yog qhov tshiab heev uas tsis tas yuav tsum muaj ntaub ntawv thov nyiaj, yog li nws tsis muaj peev xwm ua tau los ntawm Reward Foundation tau ua txhaum cov kev tshaj tawm nyiaj txiag uas "Janey" tau liam.

Nyob ib ncig ntawm lub sijhawm uas "Janey" (1) tau sau Lub Reward Foundation los qhia nws txog kuv qhov "cuav" thov kev koom nrog, thiab (2) qhia txog kev siab hlub nws tus kheej mus rau Scottish Charity Regulator, "Janey" kuj tau sau Edinburgh lub koom haum qhov twg kev siab hlub yog domiciled nrog cov lus tsis tseeb hais txog kuv thiab Lub Reward Foundation (saib hauv qab). Lub chaw Edinburgh hu ua “The Melting Pot.” Nws yog ib lub kaus lub koom haum uas tsim ntau yam lag luam me. "Janey" thaj ib txhij tso tawm txog qhov no ntawm redddit / pornfree porn rov qab rooj sab laj - Gary Wilson yog profiting los ntawm YBOP:

Qhov saum toj no tsis yog xav tsis thoob li Prause tau ua haujlwm ntau cov plhuaj roj hmab ntawm tus kheej los tshaj tawm, feem ntau ntawm kev sib tham porn, rov hais txog Wilson Rau exmaple pua pua ntawm cov lus los ntawm Prause cov pom meej avatars tuaj yeem pom ntawm cov kev sib txuas hauv qab no. Thiab, lawv tab sis yog qhov sau tsis tiav:

Lwm daim ntawv tshaj tawm / saib duab liab qab uas tau tshwm sim tib lub sijhawm (Prause tau muab nws lub thom khwm npe zais cia, raws li nws tau ua tas tom qab tshaj tawm):

Janey / Prause ua qhov tsis lees paub tias kuv raug "them" Lub Reward Foundation rau TEDx tham kev sib tham uas tau tshwm sim ntau xyoo dhau los, xyoo 2012. Nws tau npaj rau xyoo 2011, ntau xyoo ua ntej kev siab hlub tau xeeb los sis teeb tsa. Pom tseeb, tsis muaj qhov subterfuge xav tau. Kuv muaj txoj cai los muab kuv phau ntawv sau rau ib tus neeg ntawm ib lub sijhawm twg, lossis muab cia rau hauv kuv lub hnab ris. Kuv tau xaiv Qhov Kev Tsim Txiaj (Reward Foundation) vim tias kuv fwm nws txoj haujlwm zoo, lub hom phiaj kawm ntawv.

Lub koom haum tsis yog (Scottish Charity Regulator thiab Melting Pot) tsis teb rau “Janey,” vim nws tsis muaj pov thawj, thiab yuav tsis qhia nws tus kheej, thov tus kheej tsis pub lwm tus paub (txawm tias, nws tsis yog neeg ua haujlwm , thiab tsis muaj kev hem thawj). Muaj kev siab hlub tsis muaj kev sib raug zoo, kev sib raug zoo nrog Melting Lauj kaub, thiab tau nws twb tau ua tiav cov ntaub ntawv nyiaj txiag nrog Scottish Scottish Charity Regulator, "Janey's" cov lus foob uas tsis zoo yuav ua rau ntau qhov kev puas tsuaj rau kev siab hlub lub koob npe thiab pib ua siv sijhawm ua haujlwm, tshawb xyuas tus nqi zoo, thiab lwm yam.

Nyob rau hauv 2016 lig, Nws pib tawm nws tus kheej li "Janey Wilson" thaum nws xav tau (pheej yig thiab tsis tau) tias Dan Hind ntawm Commonwealth Publishing paub tseeb hais tias Kuv kev txuas nrog Scottish kev siab hlub hu ua The Reward Foundation los ua ntej sau ntawv. Luam daim ntawv MDPI (tus tshaj tawm ntawm cov ntawv uas tau hais tseg dhau los) thiab lub koom haum kev koom tes ntawm lub koom haum (COPE), Nres tshaj tawm hais tias Commonwealth tus Hind hais tias nws twb tau sau nws mus rau cov nyhuv no.

Txawm li cas los xij, tib tsab ntawv xov xwm Hind tau nrog leej twg ntawm Wilson thiab The Reward Foundation tau nrog "Janey," thiab nws tau hais txog qhov no hauv kev sau ntawv (hauv qab). Yog li, Prause tau tam sim no tawm nws tus kheej ua tus qub "Janey." Thaum Hind tsis teb rau Prause cov lus thov dua, nws tom qab ntawd tau thov cov ntaub ntawv los ntawm Commonwealth's web designer - nrog, raws li ib txwm muaj, los ntawm kev dag thiab kev hem:

Koj tuaj yeem xav txhawb tus tswv ntawv lub vev xaib uas koj tsim los qhia meej tias nws tus neeg sau tau ntes thov kom "pub" tau nyiaj los ntawm phau ntawv uas tau nkag mus rau hauv nws lub hnab tshos. Yawg Hind ua tsis tiav los teb cov lus nug nrog Pab Pawg ntawm Kev Tshaj Tawm. Kuv xav tias koj yuav tsis xav tau koj lub npe entangled hauv kev dag li qhov no hauv txhua txoj kev.

Prause zoo li ntseeg tias qhov tseeb tias qhov kuv faib ntawm phau ntawv tau mus rau Scottish kev sau npe kawm kev siab hlub, uas kuv tau teev raws li kuv kev sib koom ua ke rau ob lub hom phiaj ntawm kev kawm ob daim ntawv luam tawm xyoo 2016, txhais tau hais tias kuv tau qee hnab ris (ntawm kuv tus kheej phau ntawv) - thiab yog li muaj kev tsis sib haum xeeb, uas yog qhov laj thawj, hauv nws lub siab, rau kuv daim ntawv yuav thim rov qab. Puas tej ntawm qhov no ua rau muaj kev nkag siab nyob rau hauv lub teeb ntawm qhov tseeb?

Qhov tseeb, kuv tsis nyob hauv Pawg Thawj Coj los ntawm kev siab hlub, thiab yeej tsis tau hais dua hauv phau ntawv tau txais nws raws li qhov tau txais txiaj ntsim ntawm kuv qhov kev pab dawb. Incidentally, kuv affiliation yog tam sim no pej xeem, raws li nws yog hais nyob rau hauv ob qho tag nrho cov ntaub ntawv kuv luam tawm nyob rau hauv 2016. Hauv ntej, tsis muaj dab tsi zais los yog tsis ua mus, thiab tsis muaj teeb meem ntawm kev nyiam - txawm Prause tus neeg pab leg ntaubntawv tom qab lub scenes thiab laj mej pej xeem.

Hauv ob peb hnub ntawm Nicole Prause (xws li nws tus kheej) xa email rau MDPI thov kom lawv rov qab tawm Park et al., 2016, Twitter tus account “pornhelps” tawm tsam Mary Sharpe ntawm Lub Khoom Phaj Tsa. Nyob rau hauv lub tweet @pornhelps txhua yam tab sis lees nws yog Prause:

Prause, Kinsey qhov kev kawm tiav thiab qub kev kawm, hu nws tus kheej tus kws kho mob hlwb, thiab zoo li tau pib kawm ntawv qib siab txog 15 xyoo ua ntej. Tsis ntev tom qab qhov kev tshaj tawm tweet no “pornhelps” tau tshem tawm nws ob qho Twitter account thiab lub vev xaib (pornhelps.com) - vim nws tau pom meej rau lwm tus hais tias Prause feem ntau tweeted nrog tus lej no thiab pab nrog lub vev xaib.

Cov seem hauv qab no ntawm Lus thov nplooj muab cov piv txwv ntawm Prause thiab "pornhelps" tib lub sijhawm tawm tsam thiab ua phem rau qee tus Prause nyiam cov hom phiaj (cov txiv neej uas khiav porn rov qab cov tswv yim, cov neeg tshawb xyuas kev quav yeeb yaj kiab, SIJHAWM tus kws sau ntawv Belinda Luscombe, uas sau lub ncauj lus npog Prause tsis pom zoo):

hloov tshiab: Thaum lub Tsib Hlis, 2018 Prause dag hais qhia rau cov neeg sau xov xwm MDPI (thiab lwm tus) tias, raws li cov chaw pab kho mob pej xeem tsis ntev los no (nrog rau lub npe sau tsis raug, raws li tus qauv), cov nyiaj them rov qab tau them rau tus tub ceev xwm kev siab hlub tau qhov tseeb tau them rau kuv. Kuv xa Daim Ntawv Thov Prause rau Darryl Mead, Tus Thawj Coj ntawm Lub Reward Foundation, uas tau ua txhaum Prause cov lus thov: Saib Saud Rau Sau Ntaub Ntawv.

----

Ob peb ntawm lwm cov emails xa hauv "Janey" zaj dab neeg:

2015

[“Janey's” pauv nrog kuv tus tshaj tawm]

Los ntawm: Daniel Hind
Hnub tim: Thu, Lub Peb Hlis 26, 2015 thaum 10:15 AM
Subject: RE: Cov kev txhawj xeeb txog kev twv txiaj ntsig yam tsis yog txiaj ntsig ntawm Melting Pot

Kuv tau ntsib tus neeg hu ua Janey Wilson hnub Saturday. Kev sib pauv tag nrho ntawm peb yog txiav thiab ntxiv rau hauv qab. Raws li koj tuaj yeem pom kuv tau hais rau nws tias tus kws sau ntawv cov nyiaj tau them rau Lub Reward Foundation.
Kuv yuav tsum tau soj ntsuam nrog koj, kuv twv. Kuv thov txim yog tias kuv tau tsim cov teeb meem tsis tsim nyog rau leej twg.
Dan

-----------

Hnub Tim: Thu, 26 Mar 2015 16:59:12 +0000
Subject: Fwd: Wilson cov ntawv nyeem
от : xxxxxxxxx
To: xxxx

---- Xa cov lus hais
From: Dan Hind
Hnub: Tue, Mar 24, 2015 thaum 9:33 AM
Subject: Re: Wilson cov lus
Mus rau: Janey Wilson[email tiv thaiv]>
Lub chaw pab Charity Commission yog kev tso npe ntawm cov chaw siab dej ntsws hauv Askiv thiab Wales. Lub Reward Foundation tau cuv npe hauv Scotland.

Ntawm no yog nws cov npe ntawm Cov Scottish Ntseg Sau npe -
https://www.oscr.org.uk//charities/search-scottish-charity-register/charity-details?charitynumber=sc044948
Nyob rau hauv UK ntau lub luag haujlwm yog devolved rau Scottish Parliament, suav nrog kev tso npe ntawm cov koom siab, nws zoo li.
Kuv vam tias qhov no tshem tawm qhov tsis meej pem,
Koj ua tsaug,
Dan Hind

-

Hnub Tue, Mar 24, 2015 thaum 7:15 AM, Janey Wilson[email tiv thaiv]> sau tau:

Nyob zoo Dan Hind,
Ua tsaug rau koj cov lus qhia. Kuv yuav tsis nquag soj ntsuam, tab sis kuv zoo siab kuv tau ua. Lub koom haum ntawd yeej tsis rau npe hauv UK:
http://apps.charitycommission.gov.uk/Showcharity/RegisterOfCharities/registerhomepage.aspx
Ntawm no yog tsoom fwv lub npe, yog li kuv tsis paub tseeb tias lwm tus yuav nyob qhov twg. Tej zaum koj yuav xav ceeb toom koj cov kws sau ntawv tias lawv yuav tuaj yeem pab nrog kev dag. Kuv tsis tuaj yeem yuav raws qhov no, thiab kuv tsis xav tias lwm tus yuav tsum yog.
J

---

On Mon, Mar 23, 2015 ntawm 4:42 AM, Dan Hind sau:

Nyob zoo Ms Wilson,
Tus sau cov nyiaj tau los pab txhawb Lub Reward Foundation, kev sau npe kev siab hlub hauv UK.
http://www.rewardfoundation.org/
Koj ua tsaug,
Dan Hind

-

Hnub Vas Xaum, Lub Ib Hlis 21, 2015 thaum 6:17 AM, Janey Wilson[email tiv thaiv]> sau:

Kuv tuaj los,
Kuv pom cov nyiaj tau los hauv phau ntawv no yog mus tshawb fawb. Lub koom haum twg tau txais txiaj ntsig? Kuv xav pom yog tias kuv tuaj yeem sau nws rau ntawm kuv cov se ua kev txiav tawm.

---

[“Janey's” Sib Pauv Nrog Lub Melting Lauj kaub]

Txog 25 Lub Peb Hlis 2015 thaum 12:08 Mohammad Abushaaban[email tiv thaiv]> sau:
Mary - vam tias koj ua kom muaj zog.
Kuv tau txais qhov no txawv tawm ntawm cov email xiav los ntawm Janey Wilson…
Koj puas paub tus neeg no?
Muab nws nyeem thiab qhia rau kuv paub koj txoj kev xav.
tsaug
Mo.

---- Xa cov lus hais
Los ntawm: Janey Wilson[email tiv thaiv]>
Hnub tim: 25 Lub Peb Hlis 2015 thaum 04:09
Subject: Txhawj xeeb txog cov nyiaj khwv tau los tsis ua haujlwm ntawm Melting Pot
Rau: [email tiv thaiv]
Nyob zoo Mohammad Abushaaban,
Kuv sau tawm ntawm qhov kev txhawj xeeb rau Lub Reward Foundation nyob ntawm Melting Pot, uas tau hais tias tsis yog txiaj ntsig. Xyoo 2012, Mary Sharpe ua lub luag haujlwm rau xaiv TEDX cov neeg hais lus hauv Glasgow. Nws ua qhov kev txiav txim siab tsis tshua muaj txiaj ntsig los ua ib tug kws kho zaws zaws tsis muaj qhov paub txog keeb kwm yav dhau los, Gary Wilson, hais txog lub hlwb ntawm qhov "quav yees". Cov lus hais yog li ntawd tsis zoo nws yog tam sim no nyob rau hauv kev tshawb nrhiav rau nws pseudoscience los ntawm TEDX. Tam sim no, Mr. Wilson zoo li tab tom them nyiaj Mary Sharpe rau lub sijhawm no.
Tshwj xeeb, nws muag phau ntawv thiab tag nrho cov nyiaj tau los ntawm phau ntawv tau hais tias nws yuav mus rau Lub Reward Foundation rau "kev tshawb fawb":
www.therewardfoundation.org
Tsis tau, Mary Sharpe tsis yog ib tug kws tshawb fawb, tsis muaj keeb kwm txog lub hlwb yav dhau los, thiab cov chaw sib hlub sib txhawb tsis muaj txoj hauv kev rau cov kws tshawb fawb tiag tiag los thov cov nyiaj no. Cov nyiaj pom tau ncaj qha mus rau hauv nws lub hnab tshos, zoo li pauv rau nws ua ntej TEDX nyiam. Txoj kev siab hlub ntxiv tau xaiv tsis qhib qhib kev sib txuas rau lawv cov nyiaj txiag.
Kuv tau sau daim ntawv tsis txaus siab no rau Scottish Charity Register thiab. Kuv xav kom koj xav tshawb xyuas ntxiv li cas Ms. Sharpe tej zaum yuav siv pseudo-science kom paub cov neeg muaj kev txhawj xeeb ntau. Qhov ntawd tsis yog nyob rau hauv txoj kab nrog ib qho ntawm qhov xav tau lub hom phiaj uas tau teev tseg hauv Melting Pot lub vev xaib.
J

-

Mohammad Abushaaban, Tus Tuav Haujlwm Kev Lag Luam
Cov chaw muab kev pab zoo rau kev hloov pauv
5 Rose Street, Edinburgh, EH2 2PR
Tel: +44 (0) 131 243 2626/3
www.TheMeltingPotEdinburgh.org.uk
Lub Tuam Txhab Tsis Yog: SC291663

Los ntawm: Janey Wilson[email tiv thaiv]>
Hnub tim: 22 Lub Plaub Hlis 2015 thaum 17:21
Subject: Re: Txhawj Xeeb txog kev tawm tsam-ua rau tsis raug txiaj ntsig ntawm Melting Pot
Txog rau: Mohammad Abushaaban[email tiv thaiv]>
Kuv tam sim no muaj ntaub ntawv qhia tias Gary Wilson nws tus kheej tab tom thov los ua tus tswv cuab ntawm Lub Reward Foundation. Thaum nws tsis muaj npe nyob ntawm nplooj ntawv lub vev xaib tshiab (http://www.rewardfoundation.org/who-we-are.html), qhov no sawv cev rau kev ua txhaum ntau dua. Nws thov kom "pub" cov nyiaj tau los ntawm nws phau ntawv rau kev tshawb fawb, uas tam sim no mus rau kev siab hlub uas tsis muaj cov phiaj xwm kev tshawb fawb thiab uas nws yog ib feem. Mary Sharpe tej zaum yuav tsis paub tias nws tau hais cov lus thov no, Kuv tsis paub tseeb, tab sis tam sim no nws tau ua rau lawv pom.

---

Raws li tau piav qhia saum toj saud, daim ntawv sau ua ntej thiab ntau yam sib txawv ntawm daim ntawv Kuv tau koom tes nrog 7 US Navy cov kws kho mob, Chaw ua si, li al., tau muab xa ua ntej thaum Lub Peb Hlis, 2015 rau Yale Journal of Biology thiab Medicine raws li ib feem ntawm nws "Kev quav" qhov teeb meem. Daim ntawv no yog tib qho chaw kuv koom nrog Lub Tuam Txhab Muab Khoom Plig Rov Los Pom ntawm lub sijhawm ntawm “Janey's” kev sib pauv, vim nws tsis nyob qhov twg. Yog li “Janey” yuav tsum pom daim ntawv xa mus YJBM rau tshuaj xyuas.

---

2016

Thov hu rau kuv tus tshaj tawm, Dan Hind, nws thiaj li outing nws tus kheej li “Janey Wilson”

Ntawm: Nikky [email tiv thaiv]
Xa: 03 Kaum Ib Hlis 2016 21:27
Rau: Dan Hind;
Cc: Dr Franck Vazquez | CEO | MDPI; Iratxe Puebla; [email tiv thaiv]; Martyn Rittman; Dr. Shu-Kun Lin; Yawg Jim Pfaus
Subject: Re: Kev Pab Nyiaj Rau Tib Neeg
Yawg Hind,
Peb twb muaj email dhau los ntawm koj tshawb xyuas tias Gary Wilson tau xa tag nrho cov nyiaj ntawm nws phau ntawv rau lub koom haum uas nws tau ua haujlwm los ntawm, Lub Reward FoundationCov. Koj tuaj yeem xaiv tsis kuaj xyuas cov ntaub ntawv no rau Pawg Neeg ntawm kev tshaj tawm Cov Neeg Coj Zoo, tab sis email yav dhau los tuaj yeem muab rau lawv tib yam nkaus.
Koj tus kws sau ntawv tsis qhia txog nws qhov teeb meem tsis txaus siab nyiaj txiag hauv cov ntawv nthuav tawm tam sim no kom tau txais txiaj ntsig nws tus kheej thaum thov kom "pub" cov nyiaj tau los rau pej xeem (thiab rau koj). Qhov no twb yog qhov kev paub ntawm tsoomfwv hais tias koj ib leeg tuaj yeem sau cia kom pab nthuav tawm lossis tus kws paub zoo, raws li koj thov.
NP
Nicole Prause, Ph.D.
Kev Tshawb Fawb: www.span-lab.com
Liberos LLC: koj puas xav tau ntau tus thwjtim? www.liberoscenter.com
323.919.0783

--------

Email rau Dan Hind tus tsim qauv web:

Ntawm: Jamie Kendall[email tiv thaiv]>
Xa: 04 Kaum Ib Hlis 2016 11:32
Rau: Daniel Hind
Subject: Fwd: Nyiaj phau ntawv muaj txiaj ntsig zoo
Nyob zoo Dan,
Qhia rau lawv tias kuv yuav xa txhua yam no mus rau koj.
Jamie
Jamie Kendall MA (RCA)
www.jamiekendall.com
Pib xa lus:
Ntawm: Nikky[email tiv thaiv]>
Hais txog: Fwd: Phau ntawv kev pabcuam nyiaj txiag
Hnub: 3 Kaum Ib Hlis 2016 thaum 21:31:24 GMT
Rau: [email tiv thaiv]
Nyob zoo Mr. Kendall,
Koj tuaj yeem xav txhawb tus tswv ntawv lub vev xaib uas koj tsim los qhia meej tias nws tus neeg sau tau ntes thov kom "pub" tau nyiaj los ntawm phau ntawv uas tau nkag mus rau hauv nws lub hnab tshos. Yawg Hind ua tsis tiav los teb cov lus nug nrog Pab Pawg ntawm Kev Tshaj Tawm. Kuv xav tias koj yuav tsis xav tau koj lub npe rau hauv kev dag ntxias zoo li qhov no hauv txhua txoj kev.
NP
Nicole Prause, Ph.D.
Kev Tshawb Fawb: www.span-lab.com
Liberos LLC: koj puas xav tau ntau tus thwjtim? www.liberoscenter.com
323.919.0783

Ntsiab lus:

Lub peb hlis ntuj, 2015 ib tug nyuam qhuav pib version ntawm Park et alCov. tau xa mus rau Yale Journal of Biology thiab MedicineCov. Kev mloog lus rau YJBM yog tib qho chaw kuv koom nrog kev siab hlub Lub Reward Foundation (TRF), tuaj yeem nrhiav pom, zoo li nws tsis pom qhov twg rau pej xeem.
Nruab nrab ntawm Lub Peb Hlis 21^stthiab lub Plaub Hlis 22^nd ntawm 2015, "Janey Wilson" tau xa ob peb tsab ntawv mus rau Dan Hind ntawm Cov Poj Niam Tebchaws Tshaj Tawm, Mohammad Abushaaban ntawm Melting lauj kaub Edinburgh (uas cov tsev Lub Reward Foundation), thiab Scottish Ntseg Tswj Kev Lom ZemCov. Txhua tus muaj cov lus thov tsis raug txhawb ntawm qhov ua txhaum. Nws zoo nkaus li yuav tshwm sim los ntawm cov ntsiab lus thiab qhov sib txawv hais tias "Janey" yog qhov tseeb Nicole Prause - uas tom qab tau lees paub.
cov YJBM tau ceeb toom txog tus cwj pwm thab plaub (koom nrog los ntawm ib ntawm lawv ob qhov kev soj ntsuam dhau los ntawm "Janey Wilson"). Thaum nws tau hais tias Dr. Prause tej zaum yuav nyob tom qab cov email tsis zoo no thiab cov ntawv tsis txaus siab thaum pib, daim ntawv tau lees txais tam sim ntawd… thiab tom qab ntawv tsis muab luam tawm tom qab tag nrho, raws li qhov kev lees tias nws lig dhau lawm kom tau ua tiav tsab ntawv tshaj tawm rau hnub YJBM's "Tiv thaiv" qhov teeb meem.
Qhov hloov tshiab ntawm daim ntawv no tau muab xa mus rau phau ntawv ceev xwm txheej Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam. Plaub tus neeg tau tshuaj xyuas daim ntawv nrog 3 lees txais thiab Prause (raws li peb pom tom qab) tsis lees nws nrog nws daim ntawv teev npe ntawm "77 teeb meem".
Ntau ntawm nws tus 77 qhov teeb meem thiaj li tsis raug suav nrog thiab luam tawm ntawm Prause kev tshuaj xyuas ntawm tus YJBM kev mloog lus, raws li 25 ntawm lawv tsis muaj dab tsi ua nrog qhov Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam ntawv.
Tsawg ntawm 77 lub teeb meem yuav suav tau tias yog qhov tseeb. Cov kws sau ntawv muab MDPI nrog cov ntsiab lus taw tes teb rau txhua qhov teeb meem.
Park et al. tau rov kho dua thiab rov tshawb xyuas los ntawm ob tug ntxiv tshuaj xyuas.
Sai li sai tau raws li Park et al., 2016 tau tshaj tawm, Prause pib nws txoj kev sib tw kom muaj daim ntawv thim rov qab, xa ntau cov lus rau MDPI, COPE, Tub Rog, cov kws kho mob, thiab kuv tus tshaj tawm (thiab tej zaum PubMed, FTC thiab leej twg paub lwm qhov) Cov.
MDPI muab cov sijhawm los mus tshaj tawm Kev tshaj tawm lus tshaj tawm Park et al, nyob rau hauv Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam TshuamCov. Kev thov tsis yeem. Yog tias daim ntawv tsis muaj qhov tseeb txaus, nws yuav yog qhov yooj yim lees paub nws nrog kev tawm tswv yim.
Thaum xyoo 2016, Prause ua rau nws tus kheej yog "Janey Wilson" thaum nws xav (rov ua dua thiab ua tsis tiav) tias kuv tus tshaj tawm paub tseeb hais tias kuv kev sib txuas nrog Scottish kev siab hlub hu ua Lub Reward Foundation mus rau Kev Sau Ntawv. Luam tawm ob qho MDPI (tus tshaj plaws luam tawm ntawm daim ntawv uas tau hais saum toj no) thiab lub koom haum tshaj tawm txog kev ncaj ncees, Prause qhia rau Tebchaws Asmeskas Dan Hind tias twb sau nws rau hauv cov nyhuv no. Tseem nws tau tsuas yog sau txog kev sib txuas nrog "Janey."
Thaum muaj kev ua phem rau nws cov kev tawm tsam, thiab feem ntau dag txog kuv thiab cov ntawv ntawm cov ntawv, Prause thaum kawg tuaj nrog tsuas yog 2 qhov teeb meem uas COPE yuav xav txog (1) Gary Wilson txoj haujlwm tsis txaus ntseeg nrog Lub Reward Foundation, (2) Kev pom zoo los ntawm peb tus tib neeg tshwj xeeb. cov ntaub ntawv tshawb fawb.
Txawm hais tias kuv muaj ntau heev nrog COPE, thiab tuaj yeem yooj yim pom lub roj teeb lawv Pawg Neeg yuav tsum tau ua siab ntev, hauv kuv qhov kev pom, tsis yog qhov laj thawj rau kev thim rov qab los yog txawm rau kev kho (txawm hais tias qhov kev kho tsis muaj teebmeem no tsis muaj qhov loj)
1. Kuv qhov kev tsis txaus siab sib txuas nrog Lub Reward Foundation tau pom tseeb tsis yog qhov kev tsis sib haum xeeb thiab kuv cov kev koom ua ke twb tau qhia tawm hauv cov ntawv qub, thiab
2. Lub Navy ua raws li nws cov lus qhia rau kev tso cai (uas yeej tsis xav tau tej sau ntawv pom zoo rau cov ntaub ntawv tshawb fawb nrog tsawg dua 4 tus neeg mob). Txawm li ntawd los, hauv kev nplua nuj ntawm kws kho mob-ly ceev faj, tag nrho cov lus pom zoo ua ntej tau txais rau ob tus neeg. Rau qhov thib peb, cov ntsiab lus tsis txaus yuav tsum muaj kev pom zoo tau pom tias tau muab rau hauv daim ntawv. Kev Tshawb Fawb Meskas Kev Tshawb Fawb tau lees paub tias cov kws kho mob tau ua raws li IRB cov cai txhua tus.

Txawm hais tias qee tus neeg yuav tsis pom zoo nrog kuv, nws pom tseeb tias tsis ntawm cov ntsiab lus no cuam tshuam nrog "kev dag" lossis ua txhaum, raws li Prause tseem hais ntxiv.

Muaj dab tsi hauv no?

Tau ntau xyoo dhau los ntawm Prause thiab Ley tau koom ua ke rau kev rhuav tshem, ua phem thiab cyber-stalk cov tib neeg thiab cov koom haum uas tau ceeb toom txog porn muaj kev puas tsuaj lossis tshaj tawm cov kev tshawb fawb qhia txog porn kev ua phem. Tsis ntev los no, Prause thiab Ley nce lawv cov kev ua tsis raug cai thiab feem ntau txhaum cai hauv kev txhawb nqa cov txheej txheem kev lag luam porn. Piv txwv, 0n Lub Ib Hlis 29, 2019, Prause foob a trademark daim ntawv thov kom tau txais KOJ KOJ TUS KHEEJ thiab KOJBRAINONPORN.COM. Lub Plaub Hlis 2019, ib pab pawg coj los ntawm Prause thiab Ley koom nrog tsis raug cai trademark infringement of YourBrainOnPorn.com los ntawm tsim "RealYourBrainOnPorn.com.

Tshaj tawm lawv qhov chaw tsis raug cai, tus kheej tshaj tawm "cov kws tshaj lij" tau tsim Twitter tus account (https://twitter.com/BrainOnPorn), YouTube channel, Facebook page, thiab luam tawm a xovxwm tso tawmCov. Hauv kev sim ua kom cov pej xeem ua rau cov neeg tsis ncaj ncees, tsab ntawv tshaj tawm tsis muaj tseeb los ntawm Gary Wilson lub tsev nyob hauv nroog - Ashland, Oregon (tsis muaj "cov kws tshaj lij" nyob hauv Oregon, cia nyob Ashland). Txiav txim rau koj tus kheej seb "cov kws tshaj lij" ntxiv rau kev txaus siab ntawm kev lag luam porn lossis qhov tseeb tshawb nrhiav kev tshawb fawb los ntawm kev paub tseeb qhov sau los ntawm RealYBOP tweets. Piav hauv Dr. Prause's txawv lwm tus qauv, tweets extol cov kev pab ntawm porn, misrepresent tam sim no lub xeev ntawm txoj kev tshawb fawb, thiab troll cov neeg thiab cov koom haum Ua ntej tau ua phem.

Ib qho ntxiv, "cov kws tshaj lij" tau tsim ib Reddit account (tus neeg siv / science) mus rau spam porn rov qab rooj sab laj reddit / pornfree thiab reddit / NoFap nrog kev txhawb nqa kev lag luam, thov kev siv porn siv yog harmless thiab disparaging YourBrainOnPorn.com thiab Gary WilsonCov. Nws tseem ceeb kom nco ntsoov tias Prause, ib txoj kev kawm yav dhau los, muaj ib tug ntev sau tseg keeb kwm ntawm kev ua haujlwm ntau aliases los tshaj tawm ntawm cov porn rov qab. (YBOP tam sim no koom nrog kev cai lij choj nrog Prause thiab nws tus phooj ywg cov porn).

Thaum Lub Xya Hli 2019, David Ley thiab ob tus kws paub zoo tias RealYBOP "cov kws tshaj lij" (Justin Lehmiller thiab Chris Donaghue) tau pib sib koom tes nrog kev lag luam porn. 3 txhua tus nyob hauv advisory board ntawm lub fledgling Poj Niam Deev Hluas Kev Sib Nrauj (SHA). Thaum hais tsis sib haum txog nyiaj txiag, David Ley thiab SHA yog raug nplua nyiaj los ntawm kev lag luam porn loj heev XHamster los txhawb nws cov vev xaib (piv txwv li StripChat) thiab ntxias cov neeg siv tias kev quav yeeb quav tshuaj nees thiab kev quav yeeb quav tshuaj yog kev ntseeg!

Ntxiv rau ntawm Nicole Prause

Hauv 2013 tus kws tshawb fawb UCLA Nicole Prause pib ua siab phem, luag nyaum thiab cyberstalking Gary Wilson. Tsis ntev tas los no, nws kuj pib targeting rau lwm tus, xws li cov kws tshawb fawb, kws kho mob, kws kho mob, kws kho mob, ib tug neeg ua haujlwm hauv UCLA, ib tus neeg ua haujlwm hauv UK, txiv neej rov qab los, SIJHAWM magazine editor, ob peb tug xibfwb, IITAP, KEEB KWM, Sib Ceeb Tus Tshiab Tshuaj, Khiav Qav, NoFap.com, RebootNation, YourBrainRebalanced, cov phau ntawv kawm txoj kev kawm Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam, nws lub koom haum niam txiv MDPI, US Navy cov kws kho mob, tus thawj coj ntawm cov ntawv sau tseg CUREUS, thiab phau ntawv sau tseg Kev sib deev sib deev & Kev xav sib ua.

Thaum siv nws cov sijhawm ua quab yuam lwm tus, Ua rau thaj ntsej muag ua ntsej muag - nrog cov pov thawj ntawm cov pov thawj tseeb - nws yog "tus neeg raug tsim txom" ntawm feem ntau txhua tus neeg uas tsis txaus siab tsis pom zoo nrog nws tsis lees paub kev ncaj ncees puag ncig porn cov teebmeem lossis tam sim no lub xeev ntawm kev tshawb nrhiav porn. Txhawm rau tiv thaiv qhov ua kev tsim txom thiab tsis muaj tseeb, YBOP raug yuam kom sau qee yam ntawm Prause cov haujlwm. Xav txog cov nplooj ntawv txuas mus ntxiv no. (Cov xwm txheej ntxiv tau tshwm sim hais tias peb tsis muaj kev ywj pheej ntawm kev faib tawm - raws li Prause cov neeg raug tsim txom ntshai tsam raug nplua ntxiv.)

Nyob rau hauv thawj Ua ntej ntiav cov neeg ua haujlwm fake usernames los xa tawm porn rov qab rooj sab laj, Quora, Wikipedia, thiab hauv saib seem raws li cov khoom. Ua ntej nws tsis siv nws lub npe tiag tiag lossis nws tus kheej cov nyiaj hauv kev tshaj xov xwm. Tias tag nrho hloov tom qab UCLA tau xaiv los ua kom tsis txhob rov ua daim ntawv cog lus (ze lub Ib Hlis, 2015).

Tso tawm ntawm kev saib xyuas thiab tam sim no tus kheej-ua lag luam, Ua ntej ntxiv ob tus thawj tswj hwm xov xwm / txhawb nqa ntawm Media 2 × 3 rau nws lub tuam txhab me me ruaj khov ntawm "Cov Neeg Sib Koom Tes." (erstwhile) Media 2 × 3 tus thawj tswj hwm Jess Ponce piav txog nws tus kheej li ib Hollywood media coach thiab tus kws pab tswv yim tus kheej.) Lawv txoj haujlwm yog li chaw khoom hauv xovxwm featuring Prause, thiab nrhiav nws hais lus engagements hauv pro-porn thiab cov chaw dav dav. Khib tactics rau ib tus kws tshawb fawb muaj kev ncaj ncees.

Ua ntej pib muab nws lub npe rau cov lus dag, qhov kev sib tham nrog ntau tus neeg thiab cov koom haum ntawm kev tshaj tawm thiab lwm qhov. Txij thaum Prause lub hom phiaj yog Gary Wilson (pua pua ntawm kev tawm tswv yim nrog rau qab qhov kev ua yeeb yam hauv email), nws ua qhov tseem ceeb los soj ntsuam thiab sau daim ntawv twvtes thiab cov ntawv. Qhov no tau ua tiav rau nws cov neeg raug tsim txom, thiab tseem ceeb rau txhua yam kev cai lij choj yav tom ntej.

Nws tau tshwm sim sai sai tias Prause tus tweets thiab lus tsis tshua txog kev tshawb fawb txog kev sib daj sib deev, neuroscience, lossis lwm yam kev kawm txog nws tus kheej kev txawj ntse. Qhov tseeb, feem coob ntawm Prause cov posts yuav muab faib ua ob pawg overlapping:

Kev them nyiaj yug ncaj qha ntawm kev lag luam porn: Defamatory & koj hominem cov lus hais txog cov tib neeg thiab cov koom haum uas nws sau tias "tus neeg tawm tsam porn" (feem ntau lees tias nws yog tus raug tsim txom los ntawm cov neeg no thiab cov koom haum). Cov ntaub ntawv ntawm no: phab 1, phab 2, phab 3, Thiab phab 4.
Kev pab ncaj qha ntawm kev lag luam porn:
- tshwj xeeb tshaj yog cov FSC (Dawb Hais lus Coalition), AVN (Adult Video Xov xwm), cov kws tsim tawm suab, cov kws ua yeeb yam, thiab lawv cov txheej txheem
- countless misrepresentations ntawm lub xeev ntawm kev tshawb fawb kev tshawb fawb thiab tawm tsam nyob rau hauv kev tshawb fawb liab los yog cov neeg tshawb fawb porn.

Cov nplooj ntawv txuas ntxiv no muaj cov piv txwv ntawm tweets thiab cov lus pom muaj feem cuam tshuam rau #2 - nws txoj kev txhawb nqa kev lag luam porn thiab nws txoj haujlwm raug xaiv. YBOP yog qhov pom tias Prause qhov kev nkag ua tsis sib xws tau nce mus rau qhov kev tawm tsam tsis xws luag (tsis raug iab liam nws cov neeg raug ntau ntawm "kev cem nws," "tsis zoo," "txhawb lwm tus kom txhom nws," thiab "yog neo-Nazis") , hais tias peb raug yuam kom kuaj xyuas nws cov kev xav ua tau. Cov khoom no tau muab faib ua 4 qhov tseem ceeb:

Thaum tsis muaj pov thawj ntawm ib qho ntawm Prause cov neeg raug tsim txom hais tias Prause tau txais nyiaj los ntawm kev lag luam porn, txhua tus yuav raug zam txim rau kev xav paub yog tias nws is tseeb cuam tshuam los ntawm porn kev lag luam. Lub Ua ntej nplooj nyob rau lub vev xaib no tsuas yog qhov ntxeev ntawm qhov loj heev Prause Iceberg. Nws tau tshaj tawm ntau txhiab zaus, tawm tsam txhua tus thiab txhua tus uas qhia txog porn tuaj yeem tsim teeb meem. (Prause tsis ntev los no tau ntxuav nws tus account twitter ntawm 3,000 lossis ntau dua kev tsim txom cov tweets.) Nws tau tiv thaiv kev lag luam txhua lub sijhawm, ntau npaum li qhov kev lag luam uas tau them nyiaj-tus thawj coj tuaj yeem xav ua. Pom meej Pom Zoo, uas nyob hauv LA, txaus siab rau kev sib raug zoo nrog kev lag luam duab liab qab. Saib qhov no tus duab ntawm nws (far right) saib npaum li cas rau cov ntaub pua plag liab ntawm X-Rated Critics Organization (XRCO) khoom plig ceremony. raws li Wiki tshuaj txiv,

"Lub XRCO Txeeb raug muab los ntawm Amelikas X-Rated Critics Organization txhua xyoo rau cov neeg ua haujlwm laus kev lom zem thiab nws yog qhov kev ua lag luam rau cov neeg laus uas tsuas qhia tau tshwj tseg rau cov neeg koom hauv kev lag luam.^[1]"

Cov duab thaij ntawm 2016 XRCO khoom plig (Prause & nrog cov koob meej porn lub hnub qub Melissa Hill nyob hauv qab-sab laug). Thov nco ntsoov: Muaj cov lus pov thawj tsis sib xws uas pom tias kev lag luam porn tau pab nyiaj txiag txoj haujlwm sexology rau xyoo lawm. Sexology cov txheej txheem tseem tseem ua haujlwm pabcuam kev lag luam porn. Yog li, cov ntawv pov thawj ntawm nplooj ntawv no yuav tsum raug saib hauv cov ntsiab lus loj. Saib Hugh Hefner, International Academy ntawm Kev Sib deev, thiab nws cov Thawj Coj Lub Hauv Paus kom nkag siab txog kev sib deev kev lag luam tus phooj ywg zoo li cas los cuam tshuam txog Kinsey Institute. Qee zaum yog Kinsey.

Ntxiv rau David Ley

David Ley nyiaj txiag tsis sib haum xeeb ntawm kev txaus siab (COJ) zoo li muaj pov thawj.

COI #1: Hauv qhov hais tsis tau nyiaj txiag tsis txaus siab, David Ley yog raug nplua nyiaj los ntawm kev lag luam porn loj heev X-hamster txhawm rau txhawb lawv lub vev xaib thiab ntxias cov neeg siv tias kev quav yeeb quav cawv thiab kev quav yeeb quav tshuaj yog kev ntseeg! Tshwj xeeb, David Ley thiab cov nyuam qhuav tsim Poj Niam Deev Hluas Kev Sib Nrauj (SHA) muaj koom tes nrog X-Hamster lub vev xaib (Sawb-Sib Tham). Saib “Stripchat sib txig nrog Kev Pabcuam Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv txhawm rau txhawm rau txhawm rau ua rau koj lub ntsej muag ntsig txog kev porn":

Txoj Kev Pabcuam Txoj Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv Kev Sib Koom Tes (SHA) advisory board suav nrog David Ley thiab ob tug lwm tus RealYourBrainOnPorn.com "cov kws tshaj lij" (Justin Lehmiller & Chris Donahue). RealYBOP yog ib pab pawg ntawm openly pro-porn, tus kheej tshaj tawm “cov kws tshaj lij” tau coj los ntawm Nicole PrauseCov. Qhov no tseem yog cov pab pawg tau koom nrog hauv txhaum cai trademark infringement thiab squatting qhia rau YBOP raug cai. Muab yooj yim, cov neeg sim ntsiag to YBOP tseem tau them nyiaj los ntawm kev lag luam porn txhawm rau txhawb nws / lawv cov lag luam, thiab paub tseeb tias cov neeg siv porn thiab cam tso tawm kom tsis muaj teeb meem (ceeb toom: Nicole Prause muaj ze, cov pej xeem muaj feem cuam tshuam nrog kev lag luam porn li teev rau ntawm nplooj ntawv no).

In no tsab xov xwm, Ley tso nws txoj kev them nyiaj yug los ntawm kev lag luam porn:

Tso cai, cov kws kho mob kev sib deev koom tes ncaj qha nrog kev lag luam porn platform ntsib qee qhov kev poob qis, tshwj xeeb rau cov neeg uas xav nthuav tawm lawv tus kheej uas tsis muaj kev ncaj ncees. Ley hais, "Kuv xav pom txhua [tus neeg tawm tsam porn] tawm rau txhua lub suab qw, 'Au, saib, saib, David Ley ua haujlwm rau porn,'" lub npe yog li ib txwm tau hais nrog kev saib tsis taus hauv cov zej zog tawm tsam kev zoo siab zoo li NoFap.

Tab sis txawm hais tias nws ua haujlwm nrog Stripchat yuav tseeg yuav muab fodder rau leej twg xav sau nws li kev ntxub ntxaug lossis hauv hnab tshos ntawm qhov chaw tos porn, rau Ley, tias kev lag luam tawm los yog qhov tsim nyog. Nws hais tias "Yog peb xav pab [txhawj xeeb txog cov neeg siv porn], peb yuav tsum mus rau lawv," nws hais. "Thiab qhov no yog li cas peb ua li ntawd."

Biased? Ley ua rau peb nco txog cov kws kho mob luam yeeb, thiab Pab pawg neeg kev noj qab haus huv Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv ua rau peb nco txog Lub Tuam Txhab Ua Luam Yeeb.

COI #2 David Ley yog raug them txhawm rau porn thiab quav tshuaj sib deev. Qhov kawg ntawm no Psychology Niaj hnub no blog ncej Ley hais tias:

"Kev nthuav tawm: David Ley tau ua pov thawj hauv cov teeb meem kev cai lij choj uas muaj feem ntsig txog kev lees kev sib deev."

Hauv 2019 David Ley lub vev xaib tshiab tau muab nws kev pab zoo “kev them nuj nqi” cov kev pab:

David J. Ley, Ph.D., yog ib tus kws saib xyuas mob hlwb thiab AASECT-tus thawj saib xyuas kev pom zoo ntawm kev sib deev, raws li hauv Albuquerque, NM. Nws tau muab cov kws tshaj lij thiab cov lus pov thawj ntau yam nyob hauv Tebchaws Meskas. Dr. Ley tau raug suav tias yog tus kws tshaj lij hauv cov lus tsis txaus siab ntawm kev hais txog kev sib deev, thiab tau raug pom zoo ua cov neeg pov thawj paub txog cov ncauj lus no. Nws tau ua pov thawj hauv xeev thiab tsoomfwv cov tsev hais plaub.
Hu rau nws mus teem sijhawm them nqi thiab teem sijhawm tuaj sab laj txog qhov koj nyiam.

COI #3: Ley khwv tau nyiaj muag ob phau ntawv uas tsis pub sib deev thiab yees kev sib deev ("Lub tswvyim hais txog kev sib deev, ”2012 thiab“Ethical Porn rau Dicks,”2016). Pornhub (uas yog los ntawm porn giant MindGeek) yog ib qho ntawm tsib daim ntawv tshaj tawm pom zoo uas tau teev rau Ley phau ntawv 2016 hais txog porn:

Nco tseg: PornHub yog qhov thib ob Twitter account kom retweet RealYBOP thawj zaug tweet tshaj tawm nws “tus kws tshaj lij” lub vev xaib, tawm tswv yim kev sib koom tes ntawm PornHub thiab lub Cov kws paub ntawm RealYBOP. Wow!

COI #4: Thaum kawg, David Ley khwv nyiaj tau los ntawm Kev kawm seminars, qhov uas nws txhawb nqa kev quav-deniers 'lub tswvyim kev ntseeg tau teeb tsa hauv nws ob phau ntawv (uas recklessly (?) tsis quav ntsej kaum ob ntawm cov kev tshawb fawb thiab qhov tseem ceeb ntawm cov tshiab Compulsive Sexual Behavior Kev paub tsis meej hauv phau ntawv qhia Kev Noj Qab Haus Huv (World Health Organization). Ley raug them nyiaj rau nws ntau cov lus hais tawm uas nws saib kev saib tsis taus ntawm porn. Hauv 2019 nthuav qhia Ley zoo li txhawb thiab txhawb nqa cov hluas porn siv: Kev Txhim Kho Cov Lus Qhia Kev Coj Zoo thiab Saib Duab Liab Qab Siv hauv Cov Hluas.

Lub Rau Hli, 2019: MDPI (niam txiv lub tuam txhab ntawm phau ntawv xov xwm Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam) tshaj tawm ib editorial txog Nicole Prause tus cwj pwm tsis zoo nyob ib puag ncig nws ua tsis tiav cov kev sim muaj Park et al., 2016 tshem tawm

MDPI tawm tswv yim txog Prause tus cwj pwm (uas tau muab teev cia saum no):

21 Lub rau hli ntuj 2019
Tawm tswv yim rau ntawm Chaw Ua Si, B., li al. Puas Yog Kev Phem Duab Internet Ua Rau Ua Rau Kev Sib deev Rho Npe? Saib Xyuas nrog Cov Ntawv Tshaj Lij Xyuas Behav. Sci. 2016, 6, 17
Thaum lub Yim Hli 2017, Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam luam tawm tsab xov xwm [1], uas suav nrog cov ntaub ntawv tshawb fawb ntawm peb tus neeg hauv US Navy. Daim ntawv dhau los ua peb cov txheej txheem kho xov xwm li niaj zaus, suav nrog kev tshuaj xyuas neeg sab nraud, thiab raug lees txais rau kev tshaj tawm Txij li thaum ntawd, peb tau txais ntau cov lus tsis txaus siab los ntawm ib tus neeg thov tias daim ntawv yog muaj qhov tsis txaus ntseeg thiab hu kom thim tawm ntawm tsab xov xwm. Hauv cov lus tshaj tawm no peb xav rov hais dua tias cov txheej txheem raug raug ua raws li kev tuav cov ntawv sau thiab los tawm tsam qee qhov kev lees paub. Pawg Neeg Saib Xyuas Kev tshaj tawm (COPE) tau txiav txim siab qee qhov teeb meem thiab peb zoo siab rau lawv cov lus qhia thiab kev koom tes. Peb kuj xav ua tsaug rau cov kws sau ntawv rau lawv txoj kev koom tes.
Ib qhov kev hais plaub loj dhau los ntawm daim ntawv yog tias qhov kev pom zoo uas xav tau tsis tau nrhiav los ntawm peb tus tib neeg tshwj xeeb hauv cov ntaub ntawv tshawb fawb. Raws li cov lus qhia rau cov sau phau ntawv tshaj tawm nyob rau hauv Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam lub vev xaib, kev pom zoo yuav tsum tau txais rau kev kawm tshawb fawb qhov twg muaj kev pheej hmoo uas yuav qhia tau cov tib neeg. Thaum nug kom paub meej txog cov ntsiab lus no, cov sau phau ntawv tshawb xyuas qhov tseeb tias tau txais kev pom zoo rau ob tus neeg thiab tias rau tus neeg thib peb tsis muaj cov ntsiab lus tsis txaus siab tau muab sau rau hauv ntawv kom xav tau kev pom zoo. Lub chaw haujlwm kho chaw tau pom tias daim ntawv pom zoo raug pom zoo raug pom zoo thiab muaj kev txaus siab ntawm cov neeg sau cov lus piav qhia.
Lwm qhov teeb meem yog tias tus kws tshaj lij kev kawm ntawm tsab xov xwm tsis paub tias nws tau txiav txim siab zaum kawg los txais tsab xov [1] rau kev tshaj tawm. Cov Cwj Pwm Cuam Tshuam siv tus qauv zoo rau kev caw cov neeg kho kom txiav txim siab zaum kawg los txais cov ntawv luam tawm, uas tau ua tseem nyob hauv qhov no. Txij li cov lus tsis txaus siab, tus kws tshaj lij kev kawm txuj qub tau qhia rau peb tias nws tsis paub tias qhov no yog nws lub luag haujlwm rau daim ntawv. Peb rov ntsuam xyuas cov txheej txheem kev soj ntsuam nrog tus phooj ywg nrog ((tam sim no qub) Tus Thawj Saib Xyuas Haujlwm Thawj Tswj Hwm John Coverdale thiab tau ua kev txiav txim siab tias cov ntawv sau tsis raug muab tshem tawm vim li no. Hauv cov Ntawv Tshaj Tawm [2] luam tawm, cov ntaub ntawv kho cov lus qhia txog kev kawm tau raug hloov kho.
Ntau qhov kev tawm tsam hais txog kev tsis sib haum xeeb ntawm kev txaus siab ntawm tus sau tau ua nyob rau hauv kev sib raug zoo rau [1]. Tsuas yog ib qho kev tsis sib haum xeeb ntawm kev txaus siab tau pom tias muaj ntau thiab daim ntawv tau hloov kho [2].
Yog li ntawd, MDPI tau hloov kho nws cov lus qhia rau cov kws sau ntawv kom paub meej ntxiv txog cov teeb meem pom zoo thiab qhia cov kws sau ntawv hauv thaj chaw no zoo dua. Peb cov kev xav tau thiab cov cai tsis tau hloov thiab peb tseem ua raws cov lus qhia los ntawm COPE.
Peb ntseeg hais tias qhov kev tsis sib haum nyob ib puag ncig ntawm daim ntawv no tau tshwm sim los ntawm qhov sib txawv ntawm kev xav hauv txoj kev kho mob ntawm cov tib neeg uas siv cov duab liab qab siab, thiab tsis tau mob siab los ntawm kev txhawj xeeb tiag tiag txog kev ua hauj lwm kho ib ncig ntawm daim ntawv [3]. Peb txoj kev xav yog qhov tseeb uas tsim nyog los daws qhov kev tsis sib haum xeeb no yog los ntawm kev piav qhia thiab kev sib cav nyob rau hauv cov neeg sib txheeb xyuas, keeb kwm kev tshawb fawb qhov twg txhua qhov kev tsis sib haum xeeb los ntawm ob tog raug muab qhia tawm kom raug. Kev thuam tus kheej tsis muaj qhov chaw hauv cov ntsiab lus no thiab npaj siab yuav kaw cov neeg uas muaj qhov kev tawm tsam los ntawm kev tshem tawm lawv txoj haujlwm ntawm cov ntawv nyeem tsis yog qhov tseeb. Peb paub tias feem ntau ntawm cov kws sau ntawv thiab cov neeg nyeem nyeem txoj hauv kev tshawb fawb hauv qhov zoo thiab kev koom nrog thiab peb xav txhawb txoj kev ua no kom zoo rau cov txiaj ntsig ntawm kev tshawb fawb hauv zej zog.
References
[1] Chaw Ua Si, BY; Wilson, G .; Berger, J .; Christman, M .; Reina, B .; Npis, F .; Klam, WP; Doan, AP Puas Yog Is Taws Nem Internet Ua rau Ua plees Ua yi? Saib Xyuas nrog Cov Ntawv Tshaj Lij Xyuas. Sci. 2016, 6, 17.
[2] Chaw Ua Si, BY li al .; Kev kho: Chaw ua si, BY, li al. Puas Yog Kev Phem Duab Is Taws Nem Ua Puas Tsuaj Ua Dab Tsi? Txheeb xyuas nrog Cov Ntawv Ceeb Toom Chaw Soj Ntsuam Sci. 2016, 6, 17. Behav. Sci. 2018, 8, 55.
[3] Marcus, A. “Cov ntawv sau xov xwm kho kom yog, tab sis yuav tsis thim rov qab, cov ntawv muaj teeb meem hauv internet porn”. retraction WatchCov. Muaj online: https://retractionwatch.com/2018/06/13/journal-corrects-but-will-not-retract-controversial-paper-on-internet-porn/ (nkag mus rau 13 Lub Rau Hli 2018) thiab https://web.archive.org/web/20180913124808/https://retractionwatch.com/2018/06/13/journal-corrects-but-will-not-retract-controversial-paper-on-internet-porn/ (khaws cia rau 13 lub Cuaj hli 2018).

Gary Wilson cov lus ntawm kab lus nram no:

Tsuas yog ib qho kev tsis sib haum xeeb ntawm kev txaus siab tau pom tias muaj ntau thiab daim ntawv tau hloov kho [2].

Raws li kuv tau piav nyob rau hauv kuv rov Los Saib Saib (uas yog ib nrab censored los ntawm Retraction Watch!), kuv lub koom haum nrog Lub Reward Foundation tau nyob ntawm thawj daim ntawv, thiab daim ntawv tso tawm ua ntej xa mus rau Yale Phau Ntawv Teev Xov Xwm Biology & Tshuaj thaum ntxov xyoo 2015Cov. Kuv saib:

Dab tsi tsis meej hauv tsab xov xwm no yog tias kuv (Wilson) txoj kev koom nrog Lub Reward Foundation tau nthuav tawm los ntawm qhov pib (saib daim qauv PubMed qub, luam tawm thaum Lub Yim Hli, 2016 - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5039517/)). Qhov kev kho no raug tshaj tawm rau kev tiv thaiv kuv, hauv kev sim txwv tsis pub Dr. Prause los ntawm kev thov ntxiv tias kuv tau nyiaj los ntawm The Reward Foundation los ua qhov chaw tos txais, lossis nyuam qhuav raug "them tawm." (Nws tau nthuav tawm ntau qhov kev xav txog qhov tsis muaj kuv txog kev xav txog kev noj nyiaj txiag.) Hauv phau ntawv sau xov xwm txoj kev kho, tsuas yog lub npe ntawm kuv phau ntawv (“Koj Lub Hlwb Ntawm Porn: Internet Pornography thiab Kev Tshawb Fawb ntawm Kev Tshawb Fawb”) thiab qhia meej txog kuv lub luag haujlwm tsis paub zoo ntawm Lub Reward Foundation tau ntxiv. Ib zaug ntxiv, qhov no yog los tiv thaiv cov lus hais ntxiv ntawm ib qho teeb meem nyiaj txiag tsis txaus siab ntawm kev txaus siab. Kho version: http://www.mdpi.com/2076-328X/8/6/55/htm

Hais qhov yooj yim, qhov kev txhim kho no tau pab tiv thaiv kuv ntawm Prause thiab nws txoj kev dag ntawm qhov tsis tseeb nyob ib puag ncig ntawm daim ntawv no.

Lub Rau Hli, 2019: MDPI cov lus teb mus rau lub MDPI nplooj ntawv Wikipedia (uas tau muab kho los ntawm ob peb Nicole Prause thom khwm)

Tsis ntev tom qab Park et al., 2016 tau luam tawm Prause mus ntawm kev tawm tsam tawm tsam MDPI, Kev Coj Tus Cwj Pwm, thiab tus sau ntawm Park et al., Ua haujlwm ntau txoj hauv kev hla thiab npog kev tawm tsam (sau rau ntawm nplooj ntawv nthuav dav no - Ua ntej lub sijhawm muaj kev tshuaj ntsuam xyuas tus cwjpwm (Park et al., 2016) retracted )). Ib txoj hauv kev ntawm kev tawm tsam yog los kho MDPI nplooj ntawv Wikipedia siv ntau lub npe (phua ntiag), uas ua txhaum Wikipedia cov cai. Txog rau hnub tim peb tau txheeb pom tsawg kawg 30 qhov yuav ua rau hnab looj tes Pov Hwm Pov (Prause).

Cia peb pib nrog Wikipedia tus neeg siv NeuroSex, uas muaj tsawg kawg 8 lwm aliases - txhua tus ntawm no raug txwv tsis pub muaj Wikipedia sockpuppets ntawm NeuroSexCov. Neurosex, nws cov thom khwm pov thawj, thiab lwm yam Sock so khawm tau muab kho Wikipedia, tso cov lus qhia tsis tseeb txog Gary Wilson, Park et al. thiab MDPI (PDF ntawm Nicole Prause aliases nws tau siv los ua phem & hais phem).

Piv txwv li, NeuroSex tso cov ntaub ntawv mirroring Prause tweets thiab noj cov ntsiab lus ncaj qha los ntawm Prause's email sib pauv nrog MDPI (ntau yam uas Wilson tau pom). NeuroSex tau thov rau nqa ntiag tug MDPI emails - uas lawv xav xa mus rau MDPI Wikipedia nplooj ntawvCov. Nov yog qhov NeuroSex tau hais hauv nws cov lus tshaj tawm. (Nco tseg: Hauv nws tsab email txuas mus rau MDPI, Prause cc'd RetractionWatch, thaj rau HLA MDPI nrog pej xeem ua pauj.):

Kuv muaj cov duab uas tshawb xyuas txhua tus neeg pab leg ntaubntawv (xws li, email los ntawm publisher, email los ntawm cov ntawv sau, thiab lwm yam). RetractionWatch thiab lwm cov kev tshaj tawm xaiv qhov kev txheeb xyuas ntawm nws zoo li, tab sis kuv tsis tuaj yeem paub hais tias cov neeg yuav ua. Qhov zoo tshaj plaws los muab cov pov thawj uas muaj pov thawj rau cov lus pom zoo? Ua duab kos? Sau lwm qhov nrog cov duab thiab txuas?

Cia peb muab qee qhov piv txwv ntawm "NeuroSex" kho (lus dag) ntsig txog Gary Wilson thiab Park et al., 2016 - ua raws li Wilson cov lus:

NeuroSex hloov # 1: Gary Wilson tau los ntawm {{pab tswv yim web | npe = them tshaj 9000 phaus | url =https://www.oscr.org.uk/downloadfile.aspx?id=160223&type=5&charityid=SC044948&arid=236451}} Lub Reward Foundation yuav tuaj tos txais nyob hauv Asmeskas sawv cev rau kev tshaj tawm hauv lub xeev lossis kev saib duab liab qab.

Gary Wilson tawm lus: NeuroSex txuas nrog rau cov ntawv sau cia, thov tias Gary Wilson tau them 9,000 phaus los ntawm Scottish kev siab hlub The Reward Foundation. Ob hnub ua ntej dhau los Prause ua tsis ncaj ncees rau tus neeg sau xov xwm MDPI (thiab lwm tus) tias, raws li cov chaw pab nyiaj (tsoomfwv uas sau npe tshiab), uas tau them tus nqi them rov qab rau tus tub ceev xwm yog qhov tseeb them rau Wilson. Prause tsis tau soj ntsuam nws qhov tseeb, thiab nws yog yuam kev (dua). Wilson yeej tsis tau txais ib qho nyiaj los ntawm Lub Reward Foundation. Kev thov rov ua dua qhov dag no nyob rau lwm qhov.

Peb lub hnab thom khwm ntawm NeuroSex uas tau kho MDPI tus nplooj ntawv Wikpedia (cov ntawv sib tw qhia cov npe kho rau txhua daim thom khwm):

Lwm yam yuav yog thom khwm ntawm NeuroSex (Prause) uas tau kuj tau kho MDPI (muaj ntau zaum):

Ntau lwm cov thom khwm muaj npe nyob tom kawg ntawm ntu no: Lub Plaub Hlis Ntuj-Tsib Hlis, 2019: Ob lub hnab “NeuroSex” (thom khwm ob

Txog rau MDPI cov lus tshaj tawm:

Tshaj tawm ntawm MDPI 19 Lub Rau Hli 2019
Teb rau MDPI Wikipedia Tshooj
Wikipedia yog qhov tseem ceeb ntawm cov neeg zej zog kev paub thiab MDPI txhawb qhov kev ua kom pom kev nthuav tawm kev paub, uas sib luag lub hom phiaj ntawm MDPI. Hmoov tsis zoo, qee cov neeg kho ntawm nplooj ntawv Wikipedia txog MDPI tsis muaj cov hom phiaj. Qhov no tawm tsab xov xwm hnyav nyom thiab tsis lees paub txog feem ntau ntawm MDPI cov haujlwm. Ib qho kev txhim kho uas muaj peev xwm ntxiv rau nplooj ntawv tau nrawm tshem tawm. Peb tau ua ntau qhov kev txiav txim siab los tham nrog Wikipedia cov neeg kho kom hloov kho tau cov ncauj lus zoo, tab sis tsis muaj kev vam meej. Yog li, rau lub sijhawm tam sim no, peb tsis pom zoo kom Wikipedia yog qhov muaj txiaj ntsig ntawm cov ntaub ntawv hais txog MDPI.
Txog keeb kwm zoo ntawm MDPI, saib https://www.mdpi.com/about/historyCov. Tsis tas li ntawd, nws muaj cov thib peb cov ntaub ntawv ntawm MDPI cov ntawv txhua hnub xws li http://qoam.eu/journals, thiab Luam tawm (https://publons.com/journal/?order_by=num_reviews_last_one_year).
Yuav luag peb lub hlis ntawm Wikipedia tsab xov xwm npog cov ncauj lus tsis sib haum, hais txog 4 ntawm 200,000 cov ntawv luam tawm, ib qho piv txwv uas 10 tus neeg sau ntawv tawm rooj (nyob rau xyoo 2018 peb muaj tshaj 43,000 Tus Thawj Saib Xyuas Cov Rooj Sab Laj thiab Cov Neeg Qhua), thiab suav nrog Jeffrey Beall cov npe, paub tias muaj qhov cuam tshuam nrog qhib kev nkag thiab los ntawm MDPI raug tshem tawm (saib peb cov lus teb no)). Thaum peb tsis pom zoo rau cov ncauj lus uas tau hais no, txoj hauv kev uas lawv tau hais tawm yog qhov yuam kev.
Cov lus teb rau qee cov ncauj lus uas them tuaj yeem nrhiav tau ntawm:
Australian Paradox (Cov Khoom Noj Muaj Zog): https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/4/4/258/htm.
Andrulis ntawv (Lub neej): https://www.mdpi.com/2075-1729/2/1/213/htm.
Cov lus txiav txim tawm ntawm pawg thawj coj saib xyuas (Cov khoom noj): https://www.mdpi.com/about/announcements/1389.
Tawm tswv yim rau ntawm Chaw Ua Si, B., li al. Puas Yog Kev Phem Duab Internet Ua Rau Ua Rau Kev Sib deev Rho Npe? Saib Xyuas nrog Cov Ntawv Tshaj Lij Xyuas Behav. Sci. 2016, 6, 17: https://www.mdpi.com/about/announcements/1616.

Lub tuam txhab niam txiv loj tshaj tawm ob daim ntawv tshaj tawm uas cuam tshuam txog kev coj tsis ncaj los ntawm tus neeg siab tawv PhD yuav tsis muaj qhov ua ntej.