Steele et al., Mneneri wa 2013 Chithunzi cha Nicole adachita zoyankhulana zingapo za iye mu Julayi, Phunziro la 2013 EEG lokhudza anthu odandaula kuti akuvutika kuti ayesetse kugwiritsa ntchito zolaula. Kuyankha pansi pa Psychology Today kuyankhulana a Nicole Prause, katswiri wazama psychology pulofesa wotuluka a John A. Johnson Adati:
Mphuphu muzinthu zomveka bwino
{https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/542939#comment-542939}
umene John A. Johnson Ph.D. on July 19, 2013 - 2:35 pm
Mustanski akufunsa, "Cholinga cha phunziroli chinali chiani?" Ndipo Prause akuyankha, "Kuphunzira kwathu kunayesa ngati anthu omwe amafotokoza mavutowa [akuthetsa vuto lawo loyang'ana pa Intaneti] amaoneka ngati ena omwe amalephera kuchoka ku ubongo wawo ku zithunzi za kugonana."
Koma phunziroli silinagwirizane ndi zojambula za ubongo kuchokera kwa anthu omwe ali ndi mavuto otsogolera kuwona kwawo pa intaneti pa zochitika zapamwamba ku zojambula za ubongo kuchokera ku mankhwala osokoneza bongo ndi zojambula za ubongo kuchokera kwa osagwiritsa ntchito mankhwala osokoneza bongo, omwe akanakhala njira yowonekeratu kuti aone ngati ubongo umayankha kuchokera ku mavuto gulu likuwoneka ngati momwe ubongo umayankhira oledzera kapena osakhala oledzera.
M'malo mwake, Pemphero limanena kuti zojambula mwawo ndi njira yabwinoko, pamene maphunziro ofufuza amakhala ngati gulu lawo lolamulira. Pogwiritsa ntchito mapangidwe awa, iwo adapeza kuti mayankho a EEG a anthu awo (monga gulu) ku zithunzi zolaula zinali zamphamvu kuposa mayankho awo a EEG kwa mafano ena. Izi zikuwonetsedwa muzithunzi zoyendetsera (ngakhale pazifukwa zina graph imasiyanasiyana kwambiri kuchokera pa galasi lenileni mu nkhani yosindikizidwa).
Kotero gulu ili lomwe likunena kuti liri ndi vuto loyang'ana momwe iwo akuwonera pa machitidwe a pa intaneti ali ndi mayankho amphamvu a EEG kwa zithunzi zolaula kuposa mitundu ina ya zithunzi. Kodi anthu omwe amamwa mankhwalawa amasonyeza kuti ali ndi mphamvu zowonjezereka zowona ngati ali ndi mankhwala osankhidwa? Ife sitikudziwa. Kodi zachizoloŵezi, zomwe sizinayesedwe zimasonyeza yankho lolimba ngati gulu lovutitsidwa kuti lisamapite? Apanso, sitikudziwa. Sitikudziwa ngati chitsanzo ichi cha EEG n'chofanana kwambiri ndi njira za ubongo zomwe sizingatheke.
Gulu lofufuzira la Prause limanena kuti litha kuwonetsa ngati mayankho okwera a EEG a omvera awo kuti athetse vuto lawo ndimankhwala osokoneza bongo kapena yankho lapamwamba kwambiri la ubongo mwa kulumikizana ndi mafunso angapo omwe amafunsidwa ndi kusiyana kwa mayankho a EEG. Koma kufotokoza kusiyana kwa mayankho a EEG ndi funso losiyana pakuwunika ngati yankho la gulu lonse likuwoneka ngati losokoneza kapena ayi. Gulu la a Prause linanena kuti mgwirizano wokhawo wowerengeka ndi yankho la EEG unali mgwirizano wolakwika (r = -. 33) wokhala ndi chikhumbo chogonana ndi mnzake. Mwa kuyankhula kwina, panali chizoloŵezi chochepa cha maphunziro omwe ali ndi mayankho amphamvu a EEG kuti asakhale ndi chilakolako chochepa chogonana ndi mnzanu. Kodi izi zikunena bwanji ngati ubongo umayankha anthu omwe ali ndi vuto lowongolera momwe amaonera erotica ali ofanana ndi omwe amamwa mankhwala osokoneza bongo kapena osakhala osokoneza bongo omwe ali ndi libido yayikulu?
Patatha miyezi iwiri Johnson adasindikiza izi Psychology Today blog yomwe adalemba pazoyankhulana za Prause.
Mwinanso malingaliro a Prause adatsogolera kumapeto motsutsana ndi zotsatira {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/556448#comment-556448}
umene John A. Johnson Ph.D. on September 22, 2013 - 9:00 pm
Maganizo anga akupitilizabe kunena za a Prause kuti maubongo a omwe anali nawo sanayankhe pazithunzi zachiwerewere monga bongo la omwe amagwiritsa ntchito mankhwala osokoneza bongo amayankha mankhwala awo, atanena kuti amawerengedwa kwambiri P300 pazithunzi zogonana. Monga oledzera omwe amawonetsa ma P300 spikes akaperekedwa ndi mankhwala omwe amasankha.
Kodi angapeze bwanji lingaliro lomwe lili losiyana ndi zotsatira zake zenizeni? Ndikuganiza kuti zitha kukhala zogwirizana ndi zomwe amaganiza - zomwe amayembekeza kuti apeze. Ndinalemba izi kwina.
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/cui-bono/201308/preconceptions-may-color-conclusions-about-sex-addiction
Johnson a Psychology Today positi: Malingaliro Amaganizo Amatha Kusankha Maganizo Ponena za Kugonana. Chotsitsa chofunika: M'ndandanda yake Johnson amafotokoza za Prause kumbuyo kwa zochitika, monga kuwopseza mwalamulo (monga adachitira ndi Wilson) ndikumenya Psychology Today olemba ndi kuwawopseza, kuwakakamiza kuti achotse mabulogu awiri omwe amatsutsa zomwe a Prause sanachite (1 - Kudzudzula kwa Gary Wilson kwa "Steele ndi al., 2013 ″, 2 - kutsutsidwa ndi Robert Weiss, LCSW & Stefanie Carnes PhD). Amalongosolanso kulandira maimelo osokoneza ndi owopseza maulamuliro:
Pamene ndinayamba kulandira chilolezo cha blog ndikuyamba kulembera mwezi umodzi wapitawo, cholinga changa choyambirira chinali kufotokozera momveka bwino njira zomwe ndinawonera otsutsa omwe ali mbali zosiyana siyana za mkanganowo akukweza kapena kutsindika mfundo zawo kuposa deta lenileni mu phunziroli. Kenaka ndinasintha maganizo anga pamene ndinawona chiwonongeko chokwiya pakati pa ophunzirawo. Osati kutsutsana pa zomwe deta imatanthauza, koma ziopsezo za ad hominem, kuphatikizapo kuopsezedwa ndi malamulo. Ndinawona chiphaso cha blog cha PT chimawoneka, mwinamwake chifukwa chimodzi cha maphwando chinkafuna kuti chichotsedwe. Ndinalandira ma email angapo okwiya chifukwa mmodzi wa maphwando adamva kuti ndayankha mafunso okhudza kutanthauzira molondola za kafukufuku omwe akukambidwa mu gawo la sayansi.
Kotero, ine ndasankha kuti ndisiye mwakachetechete ndikukankhira kunja kwa chipindacho. Ndasankha kuti ndipitirize ndikulemba pano zomwe ndakhala ndikulemba mwezi watha, to ndikupereka chitsanzo cha zonena zanga kuti sayansi si ntchito yeniyeni yokha, komanso kuti asayansi enieni angathe kugwira nawo ntchito yawo ndiyomwe. Mtsutso womwe uli mufunsowu ndi chitsanzo chabwino kwambiri kachitidwe kaŵirikaŵiri pakati pa ofufuza a ku United States kuti afotokoze zotsatira za sayansi yosavuta.
Izi zinakwiyitsa Prause yemwe anatsutsa (kugwiritsa ntchito mayina abodza) ndi Johnson mu gawo la ndemanga zake Psychology Today Cholemba pa blog chokhudza Phunziro la 2013 EEG la Prause (zindikirani kuti Johnson alibe malingaliro okhudzana ndi chizolowezi chogonana). Ndizowona kuti "osadziwika" ndi Nicole Prause; mwina Jen H alinso.
PRAUSE & JOHNSON "Kutsutsana"
SEKANI {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/556243#comment-556243}
Yofotokozedwa ndi Jen September 21, 2013 - 5:44 pm
Zikomo Dr. Johnson,
Inenso ndakhala ndikudandaula ndikuzungulira, awa, ambiri, okonda kugonana.
Zabwino zonse mukasankha kudziponyera nokha m dzenje. Ndikuyembekeza ntchito yabwino yamaphunziro pankhaniyi posachedwa.
Nkhani
Jen H., CSW
Chidwi ndilo mawu ake! {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/556450#comment-556450}
umene John A. Johnson Ph.D. on September 22, 2013 - 9:10 pm
Zikomo chifukwa cha ndemanga yanu, Jen.
Zikuwoneka kwa ine kuti chilakolako ndi lupanga lakuthwa konsekonse. Pa mbali yabwino, chilakolako cha phunziro chimatanthauza kuti munthuyo akufunitsitsa kugwiritsa ntchito nthawi yambiri ndi mphamvu pa phunziroli. Chifukwa chiyani wina angaphunzire chinachake pokhapokha atakhala nacho chilakolako?
Koma, ngati munthu wokonda kale ali ndi malingaliro ake, mphamvu zonse zokhumba zidzakonzedwanso ku chinthu chimodzi, chabwino kapena cholakwika. Ndipo pamene cholakwika, chilakolako chimatsogolera ku khungu ku choonadi.
Ndikutheka kuti sindingathe kumangokhalira kutsutsana ndikutsutsana ndi ochita kafukufukuwo.
Webusaiti yachinyengo? {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/565636#comment-565636}
Yovomerezedwa ndi Anonymous pa November 2, 2013 - 6:26 pm
Monga mukunenera, kutsutsana uku kwadzaza ndi ma ajenda. Komabe, kulumikiza kutsutsana kwa sayansi ndi munthu wina wosavuta kuyesera kugulitsa mabuku? Kodi uku ndikusintha bwanji? Ndikuganiza kuti mwaphonya tanthauzo la phunziroli… anthu onse akuwonetsa. Gulu ili (1) limawoneka chimodzimodzi monga wina aliyense, ndipo (2) motsimikiza, muyeso wamaubongo sunali wokhudzana ndi chiwerewere chilichonse (ngakhale chinali kufuna kuchita zogonana ndi wokondedwa). Sindikudziwa chifukwa chake sizinali zokhudzana ndi chikhumbo chodziseweretsa maliseche, ngakhale olemba adapereka lonse lonse ndikukambirana chifukwa chake zingakhale choncho.
Mwinamwake ine ndinasowa mfundoyi {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/565666#comment-565666}
umene John A. Johnson Ph.D. on November 2, 2013 - 9:39 pm
Ngati cholinga cha phunziroli chinali kuwonetsa kuti "anthu onse" (osati omwe amangoti ndiwozolowera kugonana) amawonetsa kukwera kwa matalikidwe a P300 mukamawona zithunzi zakugonana, mukunena zowona - sindikumvetsetsa, chifukwa kafukufukuyu amangogwiritsa ntchito zongogonana osokoneza. Ngati phunziroli * likadagwiritsa ntchito gulu lofanizira osagwiritsa ntchito mankhwala osokoneza bongo ndikupeza kuti nawonso adawonetsa kukwapula kwa P300, ndiye kuti ofufuzawo akanakhala ndi mlandu podzinenera kuti ubongo wa omwe amatchedwa omwe amakonda kugwiritsa ntchito mankhwala osokoneza bongo amachitanso chimodzimodzi ndi omwe samakonda kumwa , ndiye mwina palibe kusiyana pakati pa omwe amati ndi osokoneza bongo komanso omwe siomwerekera. M'malo mwake, kafukufukuyu adawonetsa kuti omwe adziwonetsa okhawo adawonetsa kukwapula kwa P300 poyankha zomwe amadzinenera kuti ndi "mankhwala" (zithunzi zakugonana), monganso omwe amakonda kugwiritsa ntchito mankhwala osokoneza bongo a cocaine amawonetsa kukwapula kwa P300 atapatsidwa mankhwala osokoneza bongo a cocaine, zidakwa zimawonetsa P300 woperekedwa ndi mowa, ndi zina.
Ponena za kulumikizana pakati pa matalikidwe a P300 ndi zina zambiri, chiwonetsero chofunikira kwambiri chinali cholumikizira * cholakwika * ndi chikhumbo chogonana ndi mnzanu. Mwanjira ina, mphamvu ya ubongo ikamayang'ana chithunzi cha kugonana, * zochepa * zimafuna kuti munthuyo agonane ndi munthu weniweni. Izi zikumveka kwa ine ngati mbiri ya munthu yemwe amakonda kwambiri zithunzi zomwe amavutika kulumikizana ndi anthu m'moyo weniweni. Ndinganene kuti munthuyu ali ndi vuto. Kaya tikufuna kunena kuti vutoli ndi "chizolowezi" tikukambiranabe. Koma sindikuwona momwe izi zikuwonetsera kusowa kwa chizolowezi muchitsanzo ichi.
Kwa kudziwa kwanga, positi yanga sinali ndi maulumikizi othandizira kuti azigulitsa mabuku. Webusaiti Yophunzira Zophunzira Zophunzira ili ndi zopereka za anthu angapo omwe akufuna chidwi, ndipo ndinapempha owerenga kuti adziweruzire okha zomwe zifukwa zingakhale zoyenera. Sindinayang'ane malonda aliwonse a bukhu pa sitetiyi.
Chabwino, ndidzakhala {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/565897#comment-565897}
Yovomerezedwa ndi Anonymous pa Novembala 3, 2013 - 8: 37pm
Chabwino, ndikhala ndi chiyembekezo ndipo sindiganiza kuti wolemba nkhani iyi ya PT kapena olemba nkhaniyo sanasankhe dala. Kumbali imodzi, kusintha kumeneku (zithunzi zachiwerewere zomwe zasintha kwambiri) ndikuganiza kuti zasinthidwa ndi ma laboratories osachepera 100 pakuwongolera. Ndi khola kwambiri. Komanso, zowongolera ndi anthu omwe ali kumapeto kwenikweni kapena kwina kwa chidwi. Zowonongeka (osati zolumikizana) zomwe zachitika, zitha kutsutsidwa chifukwa chosakhala ndi mathero otsika oimiridwa bwino, koma mawonekedwe amomwe akuwonekera akuyimiridwa. Pomaliza, sitikudziwa kuti kuwongolera sikunasonkhanitsidwe. Sayansi ndiyosachedwa. Zitha kubwera musanaponyedwe wasayansiyo ndi biohazard (ha!)
Izi zikuti, pali mafunso ambiri phunziro ili likukwera:
1. Kodi munthu amene ali ndi vuto linalake angayankhe bwanji?
2. Kodi chimasintha ndi mafano osiyanasiyana?
3. Nanga bwanji mafilimu?Funso lalikulu, komabe, ndi… chifukwa chiyani zidatenga nthawi yayitali kuti maphunziro ngati awa achitike poyambirira? Zowonadi, onse omwe akuchita bwino komanso ochita manyazi akuyenera kuchititsidwa manyazi ndi kuchuluka kwa sayansi m'derali.
Pali asayansi enieni omwe amalemba pamutuwu ngati mungafune kulumikizana bwino. Uyu ndi blogger yemwe amawoneka kuti alibe zizindikilo ndipo adalakwitsa zambiri mu "kuwunika" kwawo. Ndikupatsanso maulalo a sayansi yaukadaulo. PT sayenera kudalira ndemanga zopanda pake monga choncho. Mwinanso amatanthauza kuti azikhala ndemanga pazokondera zomwe wolemba PT adangosankha ulalo wokonda kugwiritsa ntchito mankhwala osokoneza bongo kuchokera kwa wolemba mabulogu yemwe si wasayansi?
Chiyembekezo chanu pa ine chiyenera {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/556243#comment-556243}
umene John A. Johnson Ph.D. on November 3, 2013 - 9:50 pm
Ndingakhale ndizinyoza pa mutu uwu, koma ngati ndichita, sindikudziŵa, ndipo ndithudi sindikuyesera kuti ndikutsutsane. Kotero ndibwino kuti muganize kuti zosangalatsa zilizonse zomwe ndikulemba sizongoganiza. Kaya olemba a phunziroli ali okonzeka mwadala, sindingathe kunena. Ndikuganiza kuti iwo akufuna kuti phunziro lawo liwonetsetse kuti mayankho omwe amavomereza kuti akugonjetsedwa ndi amuna omwe akugonana akudziwika bwino ndi mayankho omwe sali ovomerezeka kuti asokoneze lingaliro la chizolowezi chogonana. Iwo ndithudi anali okonzeka kufotokozera nkhani zofalitsidwa ndi anthu otchuka kuti phunziro lawo limapangitsa kukayikira kwakukulu ponena za kugonana kwachiwerewere. Koma ndithudi popanda gulu lolamulira la osakondera kuti asonyeze kuti mayankho a neural pakati pa magulu awiriwa ndi osadziwika, chidziwitso chotsutsa lingaliro la chizolowezi chogonana chiri msanga.
Mukuti sitikudziwa ngati gulu lolamulira lidayendetsedwa. Poyankha funsoli pagulu la asayansi, ofufuzawo adati alibe gulu lowongolera chifukwa palibe lomwe likufunika, kuti omwe amawatumikira azikhala olamulira awo pakapangidwe kazomwe amaphunzira. Ndidapeza kuyankha kosamveka chifukwa zofanizira zokhazokha zopangidwa ndi zomwe zidapangidwa mkati mwa maphunziro anali mayankho a P300 pamitundu yosiyanasiyana yazokopa. Izi zikuwonetsa kuti kukwapula kwa P300 kunali kwakukulu pazithunzi zolaula zinali zazikulu kuposa zifanizo zina. Koma kaya kukula kwake kuli kofanana kapena kosiyana ndi komwe sikunadziwone ngati omwe ali osokoneza bongo, sitikudziwa. Ngati pali zomwe zapezeka m'ma laboratories mazana pa iyi, olembawo akanatha kufananizira izi. Koma sanatero.
Ngati ochita kafukufukuwa adakhalapo omwe adalongosola kuti sanali oledzera mu phunziro lawo, chiwerengero chosagwirizana pakati pa P300 ndi chilakolako chogonana ndi mnzawo chikanakhala champhamvu kuposa chiwerengero chomwe anachiwonetsera. Mgwirizano umene iwo adapeza mwina unachepetsedwa chifukwa choletsedwa ku P300 matalikidwe. Kotero iwo adadzipangira okha osasunga zitsanzo zosiyana zomwe zikuphatikizapo anthu omwe sanafotokoze mavuto omwe akuwonetsa maonekedwe awo pa Intaneti.
Ndimagwiritsa ntchito kugwiritsanso ntchito mawu mosiyanasiyana. Kaya wina amachita zovuta zowerengera kapena imodzi mwanjira zingapo zobwereza, zonsezo ndizofanana ndi mtundu wanthawi zonse. Timafupikitsa mgwirizano wolumikizana wa Pearson ndi chilembo chaching'ono r, chomwe chimayimira kukonzanso. Tiyeni tisayang'ane mbali pazosafunikira.
Chifukwa ndilibe nawo gawo pazokambirana zakugonana, sindikufuna kungotenga nawo kafukufukuyu wotsutsana ndi zosokoneza bongo osati omwe amatsutsa phunziroli. Bulogu yomwe ndidalumikizayo ili ndi ndemanga zomwe ndizosankha mwanjira yawo, ngakhale sindikufuna kulingalira ngati kusankhaku kukuchitika mwadala kapena ayi. Ndidapemphedwa ndi wolemba chimodzi mwazowunika patsamba lino kuti ndiyang'ane pamalingaliro ake asanatulutsidwe, ndidatero, ndipo ndinafotokozera zomwe ndimaganiza kuti zinali zolondola komanso zosalondola pakudzudzula. Adatsatira ena, koma osati onse, a malingaliro anga pobwereza zomwe adadzudzula. Chifukwa chake, inde, pali zolakwika pakuwunikanso chifukwa si malingaliro anga onse omwe adatsatiridwa. Ndaloza ku blog iyi kungokhala poyambira pazinthu zomwe zikukambirana. Ngati mungapereke maulalo ku ndemanga zapamwamba kwambiri (mwina zakumwa zoledzeretsa kapena zosokoneza bongo), imeneyo ingakhale ntchito yabwino kwa omvera omwe ali ndi chidwi ndi lingaliro lakugonana.
Monga ndidanenera, chidwi changa chachikulu ndichazinthu zamaganizidwe zomwe zimakhudza machitidwe ndi kumasulira kwa kafukufuku wasayansi, koposa lingaliro lakugonana nthawi zonse. Mwinanso zinali zophweka kwa ine kuloza tsamba la wokhulupirira woona pamalingaliro okhudzana ndi chiwerewere kuti afotokozere zomwe zingachitike pamaganizidwe omwe amakhudza kutanthauzira kwa kafukufuku kuposa malo okhazikika, osalowerera ndale osungidwa ndi akatswiri ofufuza zakugonana. Ngati pali malo omwe amati alibe tsankho (pro- kapena anti-bongo), ndingakonde kupeza ulalowo kuti ndiziwonere ndekha ngati ulidi wosakondera. Kupeza zokambirana zopanda tsankho kungakhale koyamba kwa ine.
Craptastic {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566091#comment-566091}
Yofotokozedwa ndi Jen November 4, 2013 - 4:02 pm
Poyeneradi. Zikumveka kwa ine monga wolemba mwina ayenera kuti anapereka mowonjezereka kumvetsera kwanu, asanayambe kusindikiza.
Kudana kunena zomwe zikuwonekeratu mopweteka apa, buuuut, titha kunena kuti ngati kutsutsana kwakukulu kotsutsana ndi zomwe zikuchitika ndikowona, m'malo mokhutira, pali vuto lina.
Vuto la psychology lonse {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566277#comment-566277}
umene John A. Johnson Ph.D. on November 5, 2013 - 11:14 m'mawa
Inde, ngati vuto silikuwonekera, liyenera kukhala. Vutoli silili lapadera, komabe, ku mutuwu. Imafala kwambiri m'maganizo a maphunziro.
Akatswiri a zamaganizidwe amapeza maphunziro ochulukirapo pamaganizidwe ozama, momwe ndimatanthawuza kufunafuna zolakwika m'maphunziro ofufuza ndikupanga matanthauzidwe ena azotsatira, kuti ambiri aife tapanga hypertrophy ya ntchito yathu yovuta komanso kuwonongeka kwa ntchito yathu yolimbikitsa, yolenga. Akatswiri azamaganizidwe amangosankha zolakwika mu njira zamaphunziro zomwe sizigwirizana ndi zomwe amakhulupirira kale. Izi zikuwonetsa vuto pamavuto amisala yonse. Palibe kafukufuku amene ali wangwiro mwamakhalidwe, ngakhale atafalitsidwa omwe awunikidwanso mozama. Ndi chinthu chimodzi kuti mupeze zolakwika m'maphunziro omwe amapeza mfundo zomwe simukuzikonda; Ndi china kupanga ndikupanga kafukufuku komwe kumathandizira mosagwirizana ndi malingaliro ena.
Eya, kuti musasokonezedwe {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566638#comment-566638}
Yovomerezedwa ndi Anonymous pa November 6, 2013 - 6:58 pm
Eh, kuti tisasokonezedwe koma "Timafupikitsa cholumikizira cha Pearson ndi chilembo chaching'ono r, chomwe chimayimira kukonzanso" sichoncho ayi. Kuponderezedwa kumapeza cholakwikacho mosiyana ndi kulumikizana. Mutha kudziwa kuti ndi ndani amene adawerenga phunziroli likuwunikidwanso… ngati anganene kuti "kulumikizana" samadziwa zomwe zidachitika powerengera (munthu wolumikizana naye adalakwitsanso). Musakhale munthu ameneyo!
Komabe, sindinapeze olemba mabulogu asayansi omwe amalankhula za nkhaniyi, koma panali ndemanga zabwino kwambiri, zomwe mungatchule:
Wina wa Blogger wa PT ndi aphunzitsi oledzera:
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/addiction-in-society/201307/the-apocryphal-debate-about-sex-addictionKuchokera kwa mtsogoleri wamkulu akuyesera kutenga chiwerewere mu DSM:
https://web.archive.org/web/20160313043414/http://rory.net/pages/prausecritque.htmlMnyamata yemwe amafalitsa zauchidakwa, ngakhale osati za phunziro ili:
https://web.archive.org/web/20150128192512/http://www.sexologytoday.org/2012/03/steve-mcqueens-shame-valid-portrayal-of.htmlZachidziwikire amamenya wothandizira kutikita minofu ku Oregon chifukwa chotha kudzudzula mofanana. Sindikugwirizana ndi zonsezi ngakhale, koma ndiye mfundoyi. Izi zikuwonetsa zabwino ndi zoyipa, pomwe zomwe zidanenedwa ndizabodza (mwachitsanzo, olemba SNP adasonkhanitsa ndikuwonetsa lonse SDI). Nthawi zonse zimakhala bwino kuti musalimbikitse zonena zabodza!
Kuchokera pa phunziro {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566673#comment-566673}
umene John A. Johnson Ph.D. on November 6, 2013 - 10:29 pm
Ndiroleni ine ndibwereze kuchokera ku phunziro, limene ine ndaliwerenga kale ine ndisanalembere positi yanga. Kuchokera pa http://www.socioaffectiveneuroscipsychol.net/index.php/snp/article/view/20770/28995:
"Malumikizidwe a Pearson adawerengedwa pakati pa matalikidwe otanthawuza omwe amayesedwa pawindo la P300 ndi zomwe adzifunsa okha. Cholumikizira chokha chomwe chidakwaniritsidwa chinali kusiyana pakati pa kusaloŵerera m'ndime ndi zosangalatsa-zenera mu P300 zenera lokhumba kugonana ndi mnzake, r (52) = - 0.332, p = 0.016. "
Inde, ochita kafukufuku adachitanso kafukufuku wambiri, komabe mungathe kuona kuchokera pamwambamwamba omwe adalemba Pearson coefficients.
Kuphatikiza apo, ndimawona kuti kusintha ndi kulumikizana sizinthu ziwiri zosiyana. Ndikudziwa kuti anthu ena amati cholumikizira coefficient, r, ndi "chabe" cholozera chokwanira cha ubale wolumikizana pakati pa x ndi y, pomwe kuponderezedwa kumatanthauza kuyerekezera x kapena y malinga ndi mzere woyenera kwambiri mwina y '= bx + a kapena x' = wolemba + a. Koma ngati tibwerera m'mbuyo pa x, mtengo wokwanira wotsetsereka, b, ndi r * Sy / Sx. Sankhani buku lililonse lamanenedwe azamaganizidwe (mwachitsanzo, Quinn McNemar) ndipo werengani zokambirana zake zakuphatikiza ndi kubwerera m'mbuyo.
Zikomo chifukwa chowonjezera zowonjezera. Ndinkadziwa bwino lomwe Peele (Stanton Peele ndiwotsimikizika pankhaniyi), ndipo ndinali nditawerenga chidutswa cha Rory Reid, koma osati zomwe James Cantor adalemba (ngakhale ndimadziwa ndikulemekeza malingaliro ake). Zolemba zina izi ndizothandiza kwa iwo omwe akufuna zambiri.
Kusanthula kunanenedwa molakwika {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566683#comment-566683}
Yovomerezedwa ndi Anonymous pa November 6, 2013 - 11:15 pm
"Pofuna kuwunika mwachindunji ubale womwe ulipo pakati pa kusiyanasiyana kwa matalikidwe a P300, njira ziwiri zotsatila zinawerengedwa."
Ndimakhala mlangizi wamawerengero pafupipafupi, ndipo mumadzichititsa manyazi. Nthawi yolakwitsa ndiyosiyana pakati pa kubwereza ndi kulumikizana… iwo ali, makamaka "zinthu ziwiri zosiyana". Kodi mumagwiritsidwa ntchito bwanji padziko lapansi? Osachepera khalani kutali ndi ophunzira anga!
Sindikudziwa chifukwa chake inu {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566750#comment-566750}
umene John A. Johnson Ph.D. on November 7, 2013 - 9:32 m'mawa
Sindikutsimikiza chifukwa chomwe mudaperekera mawuwo kuchokera mu kafukufukuyu, "magawo awiri amachitidwe amawerengedwa adawerengedwa," pomwe ndimavomereza kale kuti kuwunika kwa ofufuzawo kunaphatikizanso kuwongolera kambiri komanso kuwerengera kwa malumikizano a Pearson.
Monga ndidanenera, "Inde, ofufuzawo adawunikanso zingapo, koma mutha kuwona pazomwe tafotokozazi kuti adalemba mgwirizano wa Pearson."
Chifukwa chomwe ndidatulutsira mawuwo, "Malumikizidwe a Pearson adawerengedwa. . . ”Chinali chifukwa mudanenanso kuti ine ndi wotsutsayo sitidawerenge phunziroli. Mudati, "Mutha kudziwa kuti ndi ndani amene adawerenga phunziroli adawunikiranso… ngati ati 'malumikizidwe' samadziwa zomwe zidachitika powerengera (munthu amene mumalumikizana naye adalakwitsanso zomwezo)"
Ngati mukufuna kusunga kuti kugwirizanitsa ndi kulumikizana ndi zinthu ziwiri zosiyana, khalani mlendo wanga. Sindikudziwa kuti ophunzira anu ndi ndani chifukwa inu simukudziwika. Ngakhale nditatero, sindikanawavutitsa. Sindichita manyazi ndi ntchito yanga monga katswiri wa zamaganizo; Ndikukhulupirira kuti mumapeza ntchito yanu yokhutiritsa.
;