Critique ye "Zvinonyadzisira Chaizvoizvo nezve 'Kuvenga Vakadzi'? Zvinonyadzisira Vashandisi Vanobata Akawanda Gender Egalitarian Maonero Kupfuura Vasingasimudzi mune Mumiriri American Sample "(Kohut et al., 2016)

kohut 2016.JPG

Vanyori ve kudzidza uku rakagadzirwa egalitarianism se: (1) Tsigiro yekubvisa nhumbu, (2) Kuzivikanwa kwevakadzi, (3) Vakadzi vakabata zvinzvimbo zvemasimba, (4) Kutenda kuti hupenyu hwemhuri hunotambura kana mukadzi aine basa rakakwana, uye zvisinganzwisisike zvakakwana (5) Kubata zvimwe maitiro asiri iwo kumhuri yemadzitateguru. Kunyangwe zvipi zvaunotenda iwe pachako, zviri nyore kuona kuti vanhu vezvitendero vanosvika kure dzikisa pana Taylor Kohut's 5-chikamu "egalitarianism" kuongorora.

Heinoyiyiyi: vanhu vemunyika, avo vanowanzova vakasununguka, vane kure kumusoro matanho ekushandisa zvinonyadzisira kudarika vanhu vezvitendero. Nokusarudza mitemo ye 5 nekuregeredza zvimwe zvinoshandiswa zvisingaverengeki, Taylor Kohut aiziva kuti aizoguma nekushandiswa kwepabonde (mukuru mune zvenyika populations) achibatana nekudzidza kwake zvakanyatsosarudzwa kusarudzwa kwezvinoreva "egalitarianism"(Pasi muvanhu vanonamata). Ipapo Kohut akasarudza zita raakatsvaga.

Asi Kohut haana hanya nekutsvaga kukuru mupepa rake, iyo inopesana nerondedzero yake yakanyatsogadzirwa. MuTafura 2, zvimwe murume uye zvimwe chikadzi vanoshandisa zvinonyadzisira akapa "kwete, kwete mukadzi”Mhinduro - kana ichienzaniswa nevasiri-porn-vashandisi. Mune mamwe mazwi, chikamu chepamusoro chevasinga-porn-vashandisi vanozivikanwa se "mukadzi!" Cherekedza kuti tafura yaKohut yakavhiringidza sei nemaune. Inoverenga sekunge yakakwira muzana yevanoshandisa porn vanoona sevakadzi. Iwe unofanirwa kutarisa zvinyorwa zvemuzasi kuti udzidze kuti tsananguro yake yakachena spin.

Zvakare, zvakawanikwa naKohut zvinopesana neanenge mamwe ese akaburitswa kudzidza (ona urongwa urwu rwemashure e40 hunobatanidza zvinonyadzisira kunoshandiswa pakufunga zvepabonde, zvinoshandiswa uye zvishoma egalitarianism). Anobva pane iyi 2016 kudzokorora mabhuku acho: Mamiriyoni uye Zvepabonde: Hurongwa hweHupuriro Hwekutanga, 1995-2015.:

“Kuratidzwa kwevakadzi kuratidzwa pabonde kunowanzoitika munhepfenyuro huru, zvichimutsa mibvunzo pamusoro pekukanganisa kwekuratidzwa kwechinhu ichi pane zvinoonekwa nevamwe zvevakadzi uye nemaonero evakadzi ivo pachavo. Chinangwa chekuongorora uku chaive chekugadzira enjini yekuongorora mhedzisiro mhedzisiro yekuita zvepabonde. Iko kukoshesa kwaive kutsvagurudzo yakaburitswa mune vezera-vakaongorora, mamiririri eChirungu-mutauro pakati pe1995 na2015.Zvidzidzo zve 135 zvakaongororwa. Zvakawanikwa zvakapa uchapupu hunogara huripo hwokuti zvose mairabharoni anoonekwa uye nguva dzose, kusvibiswa kwezuva nezuva kwehuwandu hunoenderana zvakananga nemigumisiro yakawanda, kusanganisira kukwirira kwomuviri kusagutsikana, kuzviramba kukuru, rutsigiro rukuru rwezvitendero zvebonde uye nekutenda kunopesana pabonde, nekushivirira kukuru mhirizhonga pabonde kuvakadzi. Zvakare, kuyedza kuyedzwa kune ino content inotungamira vese vakadzi nevarume kuve neakadzikira kuona kwevakadzi kugona, hunhu, uye hunhu. "

Taylor Kohut ane nhoroondo yekuburitsa 'yekugadzira' zvidzidzo zvakagadzirirwa kuwana padiki kana pasina matambudziko anomuka kubva mukushandisa porn. In iyi 2017 chidzidzo, Kohut anoita kunge akanyengedza muyenzaniso kuti abudise zvaakange achitsvaga. Ipo zvidzidzo zvakawanda zvichiratidza kuti vashoma vashoma vevashandisi vevashandisi vevakadzi vanoshandisa porn, mune ino ongororo 95% yevakadzi vakashandisa porn vega (85% yevakadzi vakashandisa porn kubva kutanga kwehukama)! Chokwadi: Muchinjikwa-chikamu data kubva kuongororo hombe yeUS (General Social Survey) yakashuma kuti chete 2.6% yevakadzi vakashanyira "webhusaiti ye porno" mumwedzi wapfuura. Chimwe chinyorwa chinotsoropodza chidzidzo ichi:  Dzidzo itsva inotaura kuti vanoshandisa zvinonyadzisira vane 'mafungiro ehurumende' - saka chii? (2015) naJona Mix.

Kohut's Website itsva uye ake kuedza kubhadhara mari inoratidza kuti anogona kungova nerongwa. Kohut's bias inoratidzwa munguva pfupi yapfupi yakanyorerwa Komiti Yemazuva Ezvehutano Nezvekufungidzira M-47 (Canada). Muchikamu chechipiri Kohut uye mazano ake ane mhosva yekutora-kutora zvishoma zvidzidzo zvisiri izvo zvisiri izvo zvichitaura zvisiri izvo zvemazuva ano ekutsvakurudza pane zvinoitika zvekusangana. Tsanangudzo yavo yakatsauka uye inonyangadza yemapurogiramu epfungwa ekubudiswa kwemashoko evanhu vanoona zvinonyadzisira inosiya pasina mubvunzo pamusoro pezvavanoda.

Mu2019, Kohut akabatana vashoma vevanotsvaga-vezvekuona zvinonyadzisira uye murapi akaumba boka rekuba chiratidzo cheYBOP apo vachitsigira pachena indasitiri ye porn. Ona peji ino kuti uwane ruzivo: Chirwere Chimhosva Chine Mhosva Kupindira Kunotungamirirwa neHuman Addiction Deniers (www.realyourbrainonporn.com). Kohut akazvidzivirira pachena iyo RealYBOP twitter account. @BrainOnPorn chiitiko kurambidzwa kunetswa nekushungurudzwa.

Kwidziridzwa (2018): Mune mharidzo ye2018 Gary Wilson anotsanangura chokwadi chiri shure kweC5 isinganzwisisiki uye inotsausa zvidzidzo, kusanganisira ichi chidzidzo (Kohut et al., 2016): Ukutsvaga Zvinonyadzisira: Chokwadi kana Nhema?


J Sex Res. 2016;53(1):1-11. doi: 10.1080/00224499.2015.1023427.

Kohut T1, Baer JL1, Watts B2.

ngovepo

Zvinoenderana nedzidziso yakasimba yevakadzi, zvinonyadzisira zvinoshandisa kuwedzera kuzviisa pasi kwevakadzi nekudzidzisa vashandisi, vanhurume nevanhukadzi zvakafanana, kuti vaone vakadzi sezvinhu zvekubata pane izvo varume vanofanirwa kuve nehutongi hwakakwana. Misiyano yakasanganiswa kubva kuGeneral Social Survey yakashandiswa kuyedza fungidziro yekuti vashandisi vezvekuona zvinonyadzisira vaizobata hunhu hwaive hwakanyanya kutsigira gender kusaita hunhu pane vasinga zive zvinonyadzisira Mhedzisiro haina kutsigira fungidziro yakatorwa kubva mukunyanyisa kwevakadzi dzidziso. Vashandisi vezvepikicha vane hunhu hwakawanda - kuvakadzi muzvinzvimbo zvemasimba, kuvakadzi vanoshanda kunze kwemba, uye kubvisa nhumbu - pane vasingaregerere zvinonyadzisira. Kupfuurirazve, vashandisi vezvinonyadzisira uye vasina kuona zvinonyadzisira havana kusiyana zvakanyanya mumaonero avo kumhuri yechinyakare uye mukuzvizivisa kwavo sevakadzi. Mhedzisiro yechidzidzo ichi inoratidza kuti zvinonyadzisira zvinoshandiswa zvinogona kusabatana nehunhu husina hunhu nenzira inoenderana neyakaomarara dzidziso yevakadzi.

PMID: 26305435

DOI: 10.1080 / 00224499.2015.1023427