Sharhi: Yana da fasaha amma ya fi kyau rubuce fiye da yawancin labaran bincike. Ya ba da labarin jaraba a matsayin yawan koyo, wanda ya maye gurbin jin daɗinmu da sha'awarmu.
Steven E. Hyman, MD Am J Psychiatry 162:1414-1422, Agusta 2005
Abstract
Idan neurobiology shine kyakkyawar taimakawa ga ci gaba da maganin cigaba da shan magani, masu bincike zasu gano hanyoyin kwayoyin da ake amfani da halayen maganin miyagun ƙwayoyi zuwa amfani da karfi, hanyoyin da ke haifar da jinkirin sake dawowa hadarin, da kuma hanyoyin da magungunan miyagun ƙwayoyi sun zo ne don sarrafa hali. Shaida a kwayoyin, salon salula, tsarin tsarin, tsarin halayen, da kuma lissafi na bincike yana canzawa don bayar da shawarar ra'ayi cewa jaraba yana wakiltar fasalin daji na ƙwarewa na ilmantarwa da ƙwaƙwalwar ƙwaƙwalwar ajiya cewa a ƙarƙashin al'amuran al'ada yana haifar da halin halayen rayuwa wanda ya shafi biyan bukatun sakamako da kuma alamun da suka hango su. Marubucin ya taƙaita bayanan mai juyawa a cikin wannan yanki kuma ya nuna muhimmancin tambayoyin da suka kasance
An bayyana jaraba a matsayin shan miyagun ƙwayoyi duk da mummunan sakamako. Manufofin mutumin da ya kamu da jaraba suna raguwa zuwa ga samun, amfani, da murmurewa daga miyagun ƙwayoyi, duk da gazawar rayuwarsa, rashin lafiya, haɗarin ɗaurin kurkuku, da sauran matsaloli. Muhimmin halayyar jaraba shine juriyarsa ta tauri (1 , 2) . Duk da cewa wasu mutane za su iya daina shan taba, barasa, ko miyagun ƙwayoyi ba bisa ƙa'ida ba da kansu, ga adadi mai yawa na mutane da ke fuskantar rauni ta hanyar abubuwan da suka shafi kwayoyin halitta da waɗanda ba na kwayoyin halitta ba ( 3-5 ) , jaraba ta zama yanayi mai jinkiri, na yau da kullun, da kuma sake dawowa (2) . Babbar matsalar da ke tattare da maganin jaraba ita ce ko da bayan dogon lokaci ba tare da shan miyagun ƙwayoyi ba, bayan da alamar janyewa ta ƙarshe ta ragu, haɗarin sake dawowa, wanda galibi ke haifarwa ta hanyar alamun da ke da alaƙa da miyagun ƙwayoyi, ya kasance mai girma sosai (6 , 7) . Idan ba haka lamarin yake ba, maganin zai iya haɗawa da kulle mutanen da suka kamu da jaraba a cikin yanayi mai kariya har sai alamun janyewa sun kasance a bayansu cikin kwanciyar hankali, suna ba da gargaɗi mai ƙarfi game da ɗabi'a ta gaba, da kuma gamawa da shi.
Sau da yawa ana ɗaukar matsalolin ƙwaƙwalwa a matsayin yanayi da suka shafi asarar ƙwaƙwalwa, amma idan kwakwalwa ta tuna da abubuwa da yawa ko kuma ta yi rikodin alaƙar cututtuka? A cikin shekaru goma da suka gabata, ci gaba a fahimtar rawar da dopamine ke takawa a cikin ilmantarwa mai alaƙa da lada (8) ya haifar da hujja mai ƙarfi ga tsarin jaraba na "koyo na cututtuka" wanda ya yi daidai da abubuwan da aka daɗe ana lura da su game da halayen mutanen da suka kamu da jaraba (6) . Wannan aikin, tare da sabbin nazarin lissafi na aikin dopamine (9 , 10) , ya ba da shawarar hanyoyin da magunguna da abubuwan da ke haifar da kwayoyi za su iya samun ƙarfin ƙarfafa su. A lokaci guda, binciken ƙwayoyin halitta da ƙwayoyin halitta sun bayyana kamanceceniya tsakanin ayyukan magungunan jaraba da nau'ikan koyo da ƙwaƙwalwa na yau da kullun ( 11-14 ) , tare da gargaɗin cewa iliminmu na yanzu game da yadda ake ɓoye ƙwaƙwalwa (15) da kuma yadda yake ci gaba (15 , 16) bai cika ba ga kowane tsarin ƙwaƙwalwar dabbobi masu shayarwa. A nan ina jayayya cewa jaraba tana wakiltar kwace hanyoyin jijiyoyi na koyo da ƙwaƙwalwa waɗanda a ƙarƙashin yanayi na al'ada ke taimakawa wajen tsara halayen rayuwa da suka shafi neman lada da alamun da ke annabta su (11 , 17-20 ).
Rayuwar mutum ɗaya da nau'in halittu tana buƙatar halittu su nemo kuma su sami albarkatun da ake buƙata (misali, abinci da matsuguni) da kuma damar saduwa duk da tsada da haɗari. Irin waɗannan manufofi na halitta masu dacewa da rayuwa suna aiki a matsayin "lada," watau, ana binsu da tsammanin cewa cin abincinsu (ko cikarsu) zai samar da sakamakon da ake so (watau, zai "inganta abubuwa"). Halaye masu manufofi masu lada suna ci gaba da dorewa har zuwa ƙarshe kuma suna ƙaruwa akan lokaci (watau, suna ƙarfafawa sosai) (21) . Yanayin motsa jiki na ciki, kamar yunwa, ƙishirwa, da sha'awar jima'i, suna ƙara ƙimar ƙarfafawa na alamun da suka shafi manufa da kuma abubuwan da burin ya ƙunsa da kansu kuma suna ƙara jin daɗin cin abinci (misali, abinci yana da ɗanɗano mafi kyau lokacin da mutum yake jin yunwa) (22) . Alamun waje da suka shafi lada (ƙwarin gwiwa), kamar ganin ko ƙanshin abinci ko ƙamshin mace mai ƙaiƙayi, na iya farawa ko ƙarfafa yanayin motsa jiki, yana ƙara yiwuwar cewa jerin halaye masu rikitarwa da sau da yawa masu wahala, kamar neman abinci ko farautar abinci, za a cimma nasara, koda kuwa a gaban cikas. Jerin halaye da ke tattare da samun lada da ake so (misali, jerin da ke tattare da farauta ko neman abinci) suna ƙara zama abin koyi. Sakamakon haka, ana iya yin jerin ayyuka masu rikitarwa cikin sauƙi da inganci, kamar yadda ɗan wasa ke koyon ayyuka har zuwa lokacin da suke aiki ta atomatik amma har yanzu suna da sassauƙa don amsa matsaloli da yawa. Irin waɗannan jerin halaye masu ƙarfi da atomatik kuma ana iya kunna su ta hanyar alamun da ke nuna lada (19 , 23).
Magungunan jaraba suna haifar da halaye kamar waɗanda lada ta halitta ke haifarwa, kodayake ana bambanta tsarin halayen da ke da alaƙa da ƙwayoyi ta hanyar ikonsu na maye gurbin kusan duk wasu manufofi. Kamar lada ta halitta, ana neman ƙwayoyi don tsammanin sakamako mai kyau (duk da gaskiyar cutarwa), amma yayin da mutane suka zurfafa cikin jaraba, neman ƙwayoyi yana ɗaukar iko wanda zai iya ƙarfafa iyaye su yi watsi da yara, mutanen da a da suke bin doka don aikata laifuka, da kuma mutanen da ke da cututtukan da suka shafi barasa ko taba don ci gaba da shan giya da shan taba (24) . Tare da shan miyagun ƙwayoyi akai-akai, ana samun daidaitawa na gida wanda ke haifar da dogaro, wanda a yanayin barasa da opioids na iya haifar da matsalolin janyewa tare da daina shan ƙwayoyi. Janyewa, musamman ɓangaren sha'awa, ana iya ɗaukarsa a matsayin yanayin motsa jiki (25) kuma don haka ana iya kwatanta shi da yunwa ko ƙishirwa. Kodayake gujewa ko dakatar da alamun janyewa yana ƙara ƙarfafawa don samun ƙwayoyi (26) , dogaro da janyewa ba sa bayyana jaraba (7 , 19) . A cikin samfuran dabbobi, dawo da shan miyagun ƙwayoyi da kansa bayan daina shan miyagun ƙwayoyi ya fi ƙarfin motsawa ta hanyar sake fallasa ga miyagun ƙwayoyi fiye da janyewa (27) . Wataƙila mafi mahimmanci, dogaro da janyewa ba za su iya bayyana halayen haɗarin sake dawowa ba bayan cire guba (6 , 7 , 19).
Rushewar bayan detoxification yana saukowa sau da yawa ta hanyar cues, irin su mutane, wurare, kayan aiki, ko cututtuka na jiki da suka shafi amfani da miyagun ƙwayoyi (6, 7) da kuma ta damuwa (28). Harkokin damuwa da damuwa irin su cortisol suna da tasirin ilimin lissafi a kan hanyoyi masu ladabi, amma yana da ban sha'awa a lura cewa danniya ya ba tare da magungunan ƙwayoyi abin da zai iya haifar da sakin dopamine (28) da kuma ƙara ƙarfin haɗin synapses a kan ƙwayoyin dopamine a cikin ƙananan ƙananan hanyoyi (29). Cues kunna amfani da miyagun ƙwayoyi (11, 30), neman magani (19, 31), da kuma amfani da miyagun ƙwayoyi. Hanyoyi masu binciken / maganin da ake amfani da su ta hanyar haɗin gwiwar miyagun ƙwayoyi dole ne su kasance masu sauƙi don su ci nasara a cikin duniyar duniyar, amma a lokaci guda, dole ne su kasance suna da muhimmancin gaske da kuma inganci na atomatik idan sun kasance masu inganci (19, 23, 31). Lalle ne kunnawa na karewa na yin amfani da miyagun ƙwayoyi masu amfani da na'ura na atomatik an tabbatar da su don taka muhimmiyar rawa a sake dawowa (18, 19, 23).
Sha'awar shan miyagun ƙwayoyi ta hanyar tunani shine wakilcin son shan miyagun ƙwayoyi; sha'awar mutum za a iya magance ta ne kawai ko kuma a sami ƙwarewa sosai idan magunguna ba su samuwa cikin sauƙi ko kuma idan mutumin da ke shan miyagun ƙwayoyi yana ƙoƙarin iyakance amfani da su (19 , 23 , 31) . Tambaya ce a buɗe ko sha'awar mutum ta hanyar tunani, sabanin hanyoyin da ke da alaƙa da motsa jiki, galibi ta atomatik, tana taka muhimmiyar rawa a cikin neman ƙwayoyi da shan miyagun ƙwayoyi (32) . Hakika, mutane na iya neman da kuma ba da magunguna da kansu ko da kuwa sun yanke shawara da gangan kada su sake yin hakan.
A wuraren gwaje-gwaje, an nuna cewa shan magunguna (33 , 34) da alamun da ke da alaƙa da magunguna ( 35-37 ) suna haifar da sha'awar magunguna da martanin jiki kamar kunna tsarin juyayi mai tausayi. Duk da cewa har yanzu ba a sami cikakken ra'ayi ba, nazarin aikin neuroimaging gabaɗaya sun ba da rahoton kunnawa don amsawa ga alamun magunguna a cikin amygdala, cingulate na gaba, cortex na orbital prefrontal da dorsolateral prefrontal, da kuma nucleus accumbens.
Harshen Dopamine
Wani babban aiki, wanda ya haɗa da nazarin magunguna, raunuka, transgenic, da microdialysis, ya tabbatar da cewa kyawawan halaye na magungunan jaraba sun dogara ne akan ikonsu na ƙara dopamine a cikin synapses da ƙwayoyin jijiyoyin ventral tegmental area ke yi akan ƙwayoyin nucleus (38-40 ) , wanda ke mamaye ventral striatum, musamman a cikin yankin harsashi na nucleus accumbens (41) . Hasashen dopamine na yankin ventral tegmental zuwa wasu sassan kwakwalwa na gaba kamar prefrontal cortex da amygdala suma suna taka muhimmiyar rawa wajen tsara halayen shan miyagun ƙwayoyi (42).
Magungunan jaraba suna wakiltar iyalai daban-daban na sinadarai, suna ƙarfafawa ko toshe manufofin ƙwayoyin halitta daban-daban na farko, kuma suna da ayyuka da yawa marasa alaƙa a waje da yankin ventral tegmental/nucleus accumbens da'irar, amma ta hanyar hanyoyi daban-daban (misali, duba nassoshi 43 , 44) , duk a ƙarshe suna ƙara synaptic dopamine a cikin ƙwayoyin halittar. Duk da babban rawar da yake takawa, dopamine ba shine cikakken labarin duk magungunan jaraba ba, musamman opioids. Baya ga haifar da sakin dopamine, opioids na iya aiki kai tsaye a cikin ƙwayoyin halittar ƙwayoyin halittar don samar da lada, kuma norepinephrine na iya taka rawa a cikin tasirin lada na opioids suma (45).
Ayyukan kwanan nan a halin kwaikwayo, tsarin ilimin lissafi, lissafi, da kwayoyin halitta sun fara samo hanyoyin da sakamakon aiwatar da kwayoyin halitta na kwayoyin halitta na kwayoyin halitta, wanda zai iya haifar da kwarewa ga miyagun kwayoyi har zuwa mahimmancin kula da shan magani an rasa. Abubuwa biyu masu mahimmanci a cikin nazarin wannan binciken shine cewa yaudara ne don mika abin da muka koya daga dabbobi masu labaran al'ada don yanayin haɗakar mutum irin su jaraba da cewa babu wani samfurin dabba na jaraba ya haifar da ciwo na mutum. Wannan ya ce, shekarun da suka gabata sun kawo matukar ci gaba a binciken da ake ciki na jaraba.
Ayyukan Dopamine: Ra'ayin Tsarin Dama-Kyauta
Hasashewar dopamine daga yankin ventral tegmental zuwa ga nucleus accumbens sune babban ɓangaren da ke cikin ladan kwakwalwa. Wannan da'irar tana ba da kuɗi gama gari don kimanta lada daban-daban ta kwakwalwa (21 , 46) . A cikin da'irar ventral tegmental/nucleus accumbens, ana buƙatar dopamine don abubuwan ƙarfafawa na halitta, kamar abinci da damar haɗuwa, don zama lada; haka nan, ana buƙatar dopamine don magungunan jaraba don samar da lada (22 , 39 , 40 , 47) . Bambanci mafi bayyananne tsakanin abubuwan da ake buƙata na halitta, kamar abinci, da magungunan jaraba shine cewa na ƙarshen ba su da ikon yin hidima ga buƙatar halitta. Duk da haka, saboda duka magungunan jaraba da lada na halitta suna fitar da dopamine a cikin ƙwayoyin halittar ƙwayoyin halittar da sauran tsarin kwakwalwa na gaba, magungunan jaraba suna kwaikwayon tasirin lada na halitta kuma don haka suna iya tsara hali (9 , 22 , 23) . Hakika, an yi hasashen cewa magungunan jaraba suna da fa'ida ta gasa akan yawancin abubuwan ƙarfafawa na halitta ta yadda za su iya samar da matakan sakin dopamine mafi girma da ƙarin motsa jiki mai tsawo.
Wane bayani ne aka rubuta ta hanyar sakin dopamine? Ra'ayi na farko game da aikin dopamine shine cewa yana aiki azaman siginar hedonic (jin daɗin sigina), amma wannan ra'ayi an yi tambaya ta hanyar toshewar magunguna, rauni (48) , da nazarin kwayoyin halitta (49) inda dabbobi suka ci gaba da fifita lada kamar sucrose duk da raguwar dopamine. Bugu da ƙari, ayyukan nicotine koyaushe sun kasance abin asiri a kan wannan dalili, saboda nicotine yana da jaraba sosai kuma yana haifar da sakin dopamine amma yana haifar da ƙarancin farin ciki.
Maimakon yin aiki a matsayin siginar hedonic, dopamine ya bayyana yana haɓaka ilmantarwa mai alaƙa da lada, yana ɗaure halayen hedonic na manufa zuwa ga sha'awa da aiki, don haka yana tsara ɗabi'ar da ta shafi lada ta gaba (48) . A cikin wani muhimmin jerin gwaje-gwaje da suka haɗa da rikodin daga birai masu faɗakarwa, Schultz da abokan aiki (8 , 50-52 ) sun binciki yanayin da ƙwayoyin dopamine na tsakiya ke yin wuta dangane da lada. Waɗannan gwaje-gwajen sun ba da mahimman bayanai game da shigarwar dopamine amma ba game da ayyukan daban-daban na dopamine akan ƙwayoyin nucleus, dorsal striatum, amygdala, da prefrontal cortex ba. Schultz et al. sun yi rikodin daga ƙwayoyin dopamine yayin da birai ke tsammanin ko cinye ruwan 'ya'yan itace mai daɗi, abin ƙarfafawa mai lada. An horar da birai don tsammanin ruwan 'ya'yan itace bayan wani lokaci mai tsawo bayan alamar gani ko ji. Abin da ya bayyana shine canjin yanayin harba ƙwayoyin dopamine yayin da birai suka koyi yanayin da lada ke faruwa. A cikin birai masu farkawa, ƙwayoyin dopamine suna nuna tsarin harba basal (tonic) mai daidaito; an ɗora su akan wannan tsarin basal gajerun fashewar ayyukan ƙara, wanda lokacinsa ya dogara ne akan ƙwarewar dabbar da ta gabata tare da lada. Musamman ma, lada da ba a zata ba (isar da ruwan 'ya'yan itace) yana haifar da ƙaruwar harbi na ɗan lokaci, amma yayin da biri ya fahimci cewa wasu sigina (sauti ko haske) suna annabta wannan lada, lokacin wannan aikin phasic yana canzawa. Jijiyoyin dopamine ba sa sake nuna fashewar phasic a martanin isar da ruwan 'ya'yan itace, amma suna yin hakan da wuri, don mayar da martani ga abin da ke haifar da hasashen. Idan aka gabatar da abin da ke haifar da sakamako wanda yawanci yana da alaƙa da lada amma an hana lada, akwai ɗan dakatawa a cikin harba ƙwayoyin dopamine masu ƙarfi a lokacin da za a yi tsammanin lada. Sabanin haka, idan lada ta zo a lokacin da ba a zata ba ko kuma ta wuce tsammanin, ana lura da fashewar phasic a cikin harbawa. An yi hasashen cewa waɗannan fashewar phasic da dakatawa suna ɓoye siginar kuskure-hasashe. Ayyukan tonic suna nuna babu karkacewa daga tsammani, amma fashewar phasic suna nuna kuskuren hasashen lada mai kyau (mafi kyau fiye da yadda ake tsammani), bisa ga taƙaitaccen tarihin isar da lada, kuma dakatarwa yana nuna kuskuren hasashen mara kyau (mafi muni fiye da yadda ake tsammani) (9 , 53) . Duk da cewa ya yi daidai da sauran abubuwan da aka lura da su, binciken waɗannan gwaje-gwajen masu wahala ba a sake yin su gaba ɗaya a wasu dakunan gwaje-gwaje ba kuma ba a yi su don ladan magani ba; saboda haka, amfani da su ga magungunan jaraba ya ci gaba da kasancewa mai zurfi. Yana da mahimmanci a lura cewa wannan aikin zai annabta ƙarin fa'ida ga magunguna fiye da ladan halitta. Saboda ayyukan su na magunguna kai tsaye, ikon su na ƙara matakan dopamine bayan shan su ba zai lalace akan lokaci ba. Don haka, kwakwalwa za ta sami siginar cewa magunguna sun "fi kyau fiye da yadda ake tsammani."
Berridge da Robinson (48) sun nuna cewa dopamine ba a buƙatarsa don abubuwan jin daɗi (hedonic) na sucrose ba, wanda, a cikin bincikensu, beraye da suka rasa dopamine suka ci gaba da "son" shi. Madadin haka, sun ba da shawarar cewa nucleus accumbens dopamine transmission yana daidaita sanya "ƙarfafawa" ga lada da alamun da suka shafi lada, ta yadda waɗannan alamun za su iya haifar da yanayin "son" ga abin da ake nufi kamar yadda ya bambanta da "son." A ra'ayinsu, dabba har yanzu tana iya "son" wani abu idan babu dopamine transmission, amma dabbar ba za ta iya amfani da wannan bayanin don ƙarfafa halayen da ake buƙata don samun sa ba. Gabaɗaya, za a iya kammala da cewa sakin dopamine ba wakilcin ciki na abubuwan hedonic na abu ba ne; gwaje-gwajen da Schultz et al. suka yi sun nuna a maimakon haka cewa dopamine yana aiki azaman siginar kuskure na hasashen da ke tsara hali don samun lada cikin inganci.
Wannan ra'ayi na aikin dopamine ya yi daidai da samfuran lissafi na koyon ƙarfafawa (9 , 53 , 54) . Tsarin koyo na ƙarfafawa ya dogara ne akan hasashen cewa manufar wani abu shine koyon yin aiki ta yadda zai haɓaka lada a nan gaba. Lokacin da aka yi amfani da irin waɗannan samfuran ga bayanan ilimin halittar jiki da aka bayyana a baya, ana iya ɗaukar dakatarwa da bugun ƙwayoyin dopamine a matsayin wakilcin ciki na kurakuran hasashen lada wanda ayyukan da aka tsara ko ainihin na biri ("wakili") ake "soki" ta hanyar siginar ƙarfafawa (watau, lada waɗanda suka zama mafi kyau, mafi muni, ko kamar yadda aka annabta). Sakamakon dopamine na iya tsara koyo na ƙarfafawa-lada don inganta hasashen yayin da kuma yana tsara koyo na ƙarfafawa-aiki, watau, martanin ɗabi'a ga abubuwan da suka shafi lada (8 , 9) . Ganin cewa akwai yiwuwar magungunan jaraba sun wuce abubuwan da suka faru na halitta a cikin aminci, yawa, da juriya na ƙaruwar matakan dopamine na synaptic, sakamakon da aka annabta na waɗannan hasashe zai zama zurfin koyo game da mahimmancin abubuwan da ke hasashen isar da magunguna. A lokaci guda, abubuwa da yawa ba su bayyana ba. Misali, a cikin birai da Schultz da abokan aikinsa suka yi nazari a kansu, ɗan gajeren fashewa da dakatawa a cikin harbin ƙwayoyin dopamine sun kasance siginar kuskure-hasashe. Duk da haka, magunguna kamar amphetamine na iya aiki na tsawon sa'o'i da yawa kuma don haka za su wargaza duk tsarin sakin dopamine na yau da kullun, duka tonic da phasic, don samar da siginar dopamine mara kyau. Tasirin kinetics na dopamine da ke da alaƙa da miyagun ƙwayoyi akan ɗabi'un da suka shafi lada an fara nazarin su ne kawai (55).
Matsayi don Tsarin Kasuwanci na Gabatarwa
A cikin yanayi na yau da kullun, halittu suna daraja manufofi da yawa, wanda hakan ya sa ya zama dole a zaɓi daga cikinsu. Wani muhimmin ɓangare na jaraba shine rage zaɓin manufa ga waɗanda ke da alaƙa da magunguna. Wakiltar manufofi, sanya musu ƙima, da zaɓin ayyuka bisa ga ƙimar da aka samu ya dogara ne akan prefrontal cortex ( 56-59 ) . Cikakken nasarar kammala ɗabi'ar da aka tsara bisa manufa, ko neman abinci (ko a zamanin yau, siyayya) ko neman heroin, yana buƙatar jerin ayyuka masu rikitarwa da tsawaita waɗanda dole ne a kiyaye duk da cikas da abubuwan da ke janye hankali. Ana tsammanin ikon fahimtar da ke ba da damar halaye da aka tsara bisa manufa su ci gaba zuwa ga ƙarshe mai nasara ya dogara ne akan kiyaye wakilcin manufa a cikin prefrontal cortex (56 , 59) . Bugu da ƙari, an yi hasashen cewa ikon sabunta bayanai a cikin prefrontal cortex ta yadda za a iya zaɓar sabbin manufofi kuma a guji juriya yana buɗewa ta hanyar sakin phasic dopamine (8 , 60).
Idan sakin dopamine na phasic ya samar da siginar gating a cikin prefrontal cortex, magungunan jaraba za su samar da siginar mai ƙarfi amma mai karkacewa sosai wanda ke wargaza koyo na yau da kullun da ke da alaƙa da dopamine a cikin prefrontal cortex, da kuma a cikin nucleus accumbens da dorsal striatum (9 , 19) . Bugu da ƙari, a cikin mutumin da ya kamu da jaraba, daidaitawar jijiyoyi ga maimaitawa, yawan bama-bamai na dopaminergic (61) na iya rage martani ga lada na halitta ko alamun da suka shafi lada waɗanda ke haifar da raunin ƙarfafa dopamine, idan aka kwatanta da magungunan da ke haifar da sakin dopamine kai tsaye; wato, abubuwan da ke haifar da halitta na iya kasa buɗe hanyar gating ta prefrontal a cikin mutumin da ya kamu da jaraba don haka ya kasa yin tasiri ga zaɓin manufa. Sakamakon irin wannan yanayin zai zama wakilcin son zuciya na duniya, wanda aka yi nauyi sosai ga alamun da suka shafi miyagun ƙwayoyi kuma nesa da wasu zaɓuɓɓuka, don haka yana ba da gudummawa ga asarar iko akan amfani da miyagun ƙwayoyi wanda ke nuna jaraba. Yana da ban sha'awa a lura cewa nazarin farko na neuroimaging ya ba da rahoton alamu marasa kyau na kunnawa a cikin cingulate cortex da orbital prefrontal cortex a cikin waɗanda suka kamu da jaraba ( 62-64 ).
Ko da yake ana buƙatar ƙarin bincike kan jijiyoyi don fahimtar tasirin tonic da phasic dopamine sigina, hanyoyin da magungunan jaraba ke wargaza su, da kuma sakamakon aikin wannan katsewar, fahimtar da ake da ita game da rawar da dopamine ke takawa a cikin ilmantarwa mai lada da kuma ilmantarwa mai lada yana da muhimman ma'anoni da dama ga ci gaban jarabar miyagun ƙwayoyi. Alamun da ke hasashen samuwar magunguna za su ɗauki babban tasiri na ƙarfafawa, ta hanyar ayyukan dopamine a cikin ƙwayoyin nucleus da prefrontal cortex, kuma za a haɗa ayyukan neman magani da ƙarfi ta hanyar ayyukan dopamine a cikin prefrontal cortex da dorsal striatum (9 , 18 , 19 , 23 , 65).
Koyon lada da motsa jiki yana haɗa takamaiman alamu, waɗanda ke faruwa a cikin takamaiman yanayi, tare da takamaiman tasirin kamar "son" lada, ɗaukar mataki don samun lada, da kuma amfani da lada. (Muhimmin al'amari na mahallin shine ko an isar da alamar kusa da lada [66] ; misali, fuskantar alamar da ke da alaƙa da miyagun ƙwayoyi a cikin dakin gwaje-gwaje yana da alaƙa daban-daban ga aiki fiye da fuskantar alamar iri ɗaya a kan titi.) Koyon mahimmancin alamar da haɗa wannan bayanin tare da amsa mai dacewa yana buƙatar adana takamaiman alamu na bayanai a cikin kwakwalwa. Wannan bayanin da aka adana dole ne ya samar da wakilci na ciki na abin ƙarfafawa da ya shafi lada, kimantawarsa, da jerin jerin ayyuka don alamar ta iya haifar da amsawar ɗabi'a mai inganci da inganci (19) . Dole ne ya zama haka ga alamun da ke nuna haɗari.
Idan hasashen kuskuren hasashen aikin dopamine daidai ne, ana buƙatar phasic dopamine don kwakwalwa ta sabunta mahimmancin hasashen alamun. Idan hasashen dopamine-gating na aikin prefrontal cortex daidai ne, ana buƙatar phasic dopamine don sabunta zaɓin manufa. Duk da haka, a kowane hali, dopamine yana ba da cikakken bayani game da yanayin motsa jiki na kwayoyin halitta; ƙwayoyin dopamine ba sa ƙayyade cikakkun bayanai game da ra'ayoyi, tsare-tsare, ko ayyuka masu alaƙa da lada. Tsarin tsarin dopamine - ƙaramin adadin jikin tantanin halitta da ke cikin kwakwalwa ta tsakiya wanda zai iya yin wuta tare kuma ya yi aiki sosai a cikin kwakwalwar gaba, tare da ƙwayoyin halitta guda ɗaya da ke shiga cikin maƙasudai da yawa - ba ya da amfani ga adana bayanai daidai (67) . Madadin haka, wannan tsarin "mai kama da feshi" ya dace don daidaita martani ga abubuwan da ke haifar da abubuwa masu mahimmanci a cikin da'irorin kwakwalwa da yawa waɗanda ke tallafawa wakilcin bayanai na ji ko na jerin ayyuka. Cikakken bayani game da abin da ke haifar da abubuwa masu motsawa da abin da yake annabta (misali, cewa wani yanki, wani al'ada, ko wani wari - amma ba ƙamshi mai alaƙa ba - yana annabta isar da magunguna) ya dogara ne akan tsarin ji da ƙwaƙwalwa waɗanda ke rikodin cikakkun bayanai na ƙwarewa tare da aminci mai yawa. Takamaiman bayanai game da alamun, kimanta mahimmancin su, da kuma amsoshin motsin da aka koya sun dogara ne akan da'irori waɗanda ke tallafawa daidaitaccen jigilar jijiyoyi na ma'ana-zuwa-maki kuma suna amfani da neurotransmitters masu motsa jiki kamar glutamate. Don haka, hulɗar haɗin gwiwa ce tsakanin glutamate da dopamine neurons a cikin irin waɗannan tsarin aiki daban-daban kamar nucleus accumbens, prefrontal cortex, amygdala, da dorsal striatum (68 , 69) wanda ke haɗa takamaiman bayanai na ji ko takamaiman jerin ayyuka tare da bayani game da yanayin motsa jiki na kwayoyin halitta da kuma ƙarfafawar alamun a cikin muhalli. Bukatun aiki don yin rikodin cikakkun bayanai game da abubuwan da suka shafi lada da martanin aiki wataƙila sun yi kama da waɗanda ke ƙarƙashin wasu nau'ikan ƙwaƙwalwar ajiya na dogon lokaci, wanda daga ciki kai tsaye ya biyo bayan hasashen cewa jaraba tana wakiltar satar tsarin ƙwaƙwalwa da ke da alaƙa da lada (11 , 19).
Robinson da Berridge (30 , 70) sun gabatar da wani ra'ayi daban - ra'ayin ƙarfafawa na jaraba. A cikin wannan ra'ayi, shan ƙwayoyi na yau da kullun yana haifar da haƙuri ga wasu tasirin magunguna amma haɓakawa mai ci gaba - ko faɗakarwa - na wasu (71) . Misali, a cikin beraye, allurar cocaine ko amphetamine kowace rana yana haifar da ƙaruwa mai ci gaba a cikin ayyukan motsa jiki. Jin hankali samfuri ne mai kyau don jaraba saboda jin hankali tsari ne na dogon lokaci kuma saboda wasu nau'ikan jin daɗi ana iya bayyana su ta hanyar da ta dogara da mahallin (72) . Don haka, misali, idan beraye suka sami allurar amphetamine kowace rana a cikin kejin gwaji maimakon kejin gidajensu, suna nuna halayen motsa jiki masu hankali lokacin da aka sake sanya su a cikin wannan kejin gwaji. Ka'idar jin daɗin ƙarfafawa ta nuna cewa kamar yadda ake iya jin daɗin halayen motsa jiki, shan magunguna akai-akai yana jin daɗin tsarin jijiyoyi wanda ke ba da jin daɗin ƙarfafawa (sabanin ƙimar hedonic ko "son") ga magunguna da alamun da suka shafi magunguna. Wannan jin daɗin ƙarfafawa zai haifar da tsananin "son" magunguna waɗanda za a iya kunna su ta hanyar alamun da ke da alaƙa da miyagun ƙwayoyi (30 , 70) . A takaice dai, ra'ayin ƙarfafawa ya yi daidai da ra'ayin cewa dopamine yana aiki a matsayin siginar hasashen sakamako-kuskuren kuskure (9) . Hakanan zai zama kamar ba a jayayya ba cewa ana ƙara ƙarfin ƙarfafawa na alamun da suka shafi magunguna a cikin mutanen da suka kamu da jaraba. Bugu da ƙari, babu rashin jituwa cewa ikon waɗannan alamun don kunna sha'awar miyagun ƙwayoyi ko neman ƙwayoyi ya dogara ne akan hanyoyin ilmantarwa na haɗin gwiwa. Babban abin da aka saba ji shi ne ko tsarin jijiyoyi na jijiyoyi na jijiyoyi, kamar yadda ake fahimta a yanzu daga samfuran dabbobi, yana taka muhimmiyar rawa a cikin jarabar ɗan adam. A cikin samfuran dabbobi, halayen motsa jiki masu jijiyoyi ana fara su a cikin yankin ventral tegmental sannan a bayyana su a cikin nucleus accumbens (73 , 74) , wataƙila ta hanyar haɓaka martanin dopamine. Ganin yadda aka daidaita hasashen yankin ventral tegmental zuwa nucleus accumbens ko zuwa prefrontal cortex da ikon waɗannan hasashen don yin hulɗa da neurons da yawa, yana da wuya a bayyana yadda irin wannan ingantaccen amsawar dopamine za a iya haɗa shi da takamaiman alamun da suka shafi magunguna ba tare da kiran hanyoyin ƙwaƙwalwar haɗin gwiwa ba. Duk da wallafe-wallafen gwaji da har yanzu ba a fahimta ba, shaidun da aka samu kwanan nan daga wani bincike da aka yi kan berayen da ke da ƙwayoyin halitta waɗanda ba su da masu karɓar glutamate na AMPA masu aiki sun gano rabuwar kai tsakanin fahimtar motsa jiki na motsa jiki da cocaine ke haifarwa (wanda aka riƙe a cikin berayen da ke da ƙwanƙwasa) da kuma ilmantarwa ta haɗin gwiwa; wato, berayen ba su sake nuna martanin motsa jiki mai tsari ba lokacin da aka sanya su a cikin mahallin da aka taɓa dangantawa da cocaine, kuma ba su nuna fifikon wuri mai tsari ba (75) . Aƙalla waɗannan gwaje-gwajen sun jaddada mahimmancin hanyoyin ilmantarwa na haɗin gwiwa don ɓoye takamaiman alamun magunguna da kuma haɗa waɗannan alamun tare da takamaiman martani (19 , 23) . Ko da za a nuna hankali a cikin mutane (wanda ba a yi shi da tabbaci ba), ba a san abin da rawar da zai taka ba face haɓaka hanyoyin ilmantarwa da ke dogara da dopamine ta hanyar ƙara sakin dopamine a cikin takamaiman mahallin. A ƙarshe waɗannan hanyoyin ilmantarwa ne ke da alhakin ɓoye wakilcin takamaiman alamun magunguna masu matuƙar ƙima, masu ƙarfi da kuma haɗa su da takamaiman halayen neman ƙwayoyi da martanin motsin rai.
A ƙarshe, bayanin jaraba yana buƙatar ka'idar juriyarsa. Tambayoyi da yawa sun rage game da hanyoyin da tunanin dogon lokaci ke ci gaba da wanzuwa tsawon shekaru da yawa ko ma tsawon rayuwa (15 , 16 , 76) . Daga wannan mahangar, martanin dopamine mai hankali ga magunguna da alamun magunguna na iya haifar da haɓaka tunanin haɗin gwiwa da suka shafi magani, amma dagewar jaraba zai zama kamar ya dogara ne akan sake fasalin synapses da da'irori waɗanda ake tsammanin suna da alaƙa da ƙwaƙwalwar haɗin gwiwa ta dogon lokaci (15 , 16).
Kamar yadda tattaunawar da aka yi a baya ta nuna, hanyoyin da ake amfani da su wajen jarabar kwayoyin halitta da tantanin halitta a matakin ɗabi'a da tsarin dole ne su bayyana 1) yadda maimaitawar sakin dopamine ke haɗa halayen shan miyagun ƙwayoyi zuwa amfani da su na tilas, 2) yadda haɗarin sake dawowa daga yanayin da ba shi da magani zai iya ci gaba na tsawon shekaru, da kuma 3) yadda alamun da suka shafi magani ke zuwa ga halayyar sarrafawa. Hanyoyin siginar cikin ƙwayoyin halitta waɗanda ke samar da yanayin synaptic hanyoyi ne masu kyau na jaraba saboda suna iya canza siginar da miyagun ƙwayoyi ke haifarwa, kamar sakin dopamine, zuwa canje-canje na dogon lokaci a cikin aikin jijiyoyi da kuma ƙarshe zuwa sake fasalin da'irorin neuronal. Tsarin synaptic yana da rikitarwa, amma ana iya raba shi ta hanyar heuristically zuwa hanyoyin da ke canza ƙarfi ko "nauyi" na haɗin da ke akwai da waɗanda za su iya haifar da samuwar synapse ko kawar da sake fasalin tsarin dendrites ko axons (15).
Kamar yadda aka bayyana, takamaiman alamun magunguna da alaƙarsu da takamaiman jerin halaye suna nuna cewa aƙalla wasu daga cikin hanyoyin da ke haifar da jaraba dole ne su kasance masu alaƙa da synapse. Mafi kyawun hanyoyin da aka fi siffanta don canza ƙarfin synaptic waɗanda ke da alaƙa da takamaiman synapse sune ƙarfin dogon lokaci da baƙin ciki na dogon lokaci. An yi hasashen waɗannan hanyoyin suna taka muhimmiyar rawa a cikin nau'ikan filastik da yawa da suka dogara da ƙwarewa, gami da nau'ikan koyo da ƙwaƙwalwa daban-daban (77 , 78) . Irin waɗannan hanyoyin filastik na synaptic na iya haifar da sake tsara kewayen jijiyoyi ta hanyar canza kwayar halitta da furotin a cikin ƙwayoyin jijiyoyi waɗanda ke karɓar sigina masu haɓakawa ko raguwa sakamakon ƙarfin dogon lokaci ko baƙin ciki na dogon lokaci. Ƙarfin dogon lokaci da baƙin ciki na dogon lokaci sun zama mahimman hanyoyin 'yan takara don canje-canjen da miyagun ƙwayoyi ke haifarwa na aikin kewayen jijiyoyi waɗanda ake tsammanin za su faru tare da jaraba (11) . Yanzu akwai kyakkyawan shaida cewa duka hanyoyin suna faruwa a cikin ƙwayoyin nucleus da sauran maƙasudin ƙwayoyin mesolimbic dopamine sakamakon shan magani, kuma ƙarin shaida yana nuna cewa suna iya taka muhimmiyar rawa wajen haɓaka jaraba. Cikakken bayani game da waɗannan binciken ya wuce iyakokin wannan bita (don sake dubawa, duba nassoshi 11 , 79-81 ) . Hanyoyin kwayoyin halitta da ke haifar da ƙarfin dogon lokaci da ɓacin rai na dogon lokaci sun haɗa da daidaita yanayin phosphorylation na manyan sunadarai, canje-canje a cikin samuwar masu karɓar glutamate a synapse, da kuma daidaita bayyanar kwayoyin halitta (78 , 82).
Tambayar yadda tunawa ke ci gaba (15 , 16 , 76) tana da matuƙar muhimmanci ga jaraba kuma ba a amsa ta da kyau ba tukuna, amma ana tsammanin juriya ta ƙunshi sake tsara synapses da da'irori. Sakamakon farko mai tayar da hankali ya nuna cewa amphetamine da cocaine na iya haifar da canje-canje a cikin ƙwayoyin halitta a cikin ƙwayoyin halitta da kuma prefrontal cortex (83 , 84).
Wani muhimmin tsari na gyaran jiki na dendrites, axons, da synapses shine canjin da miyagun ƙwayoyi ke haifarwa a cikin bayyanar kwayoyin halitta ko fassarar furotin. A cikin mawuyacin lokaci, nau'ikan tsarin kwayoyin halitta guda biyu na iya taimakawa ga ƙwaƙwalwar ajiya na dogon lokaci, gami da hanyoyin ƙwaƙwalwar da aka yi hasashensu a cikin jaraba: 1) tsawaita ko rage tsarin bayyanar kwayar halitta ko furotin na dogon lokaci da 2) fashewar bayyanar kwayar halitta (ko fassarar furotin) wanda ke haifar da sake fasalin synapses na zahiri (watau, canje-canje a cikin yanayin jiki wanda ke haifar da canje-canje a cikin ƙarfin synaptic, samar da sabbin synapses, ko yanke synapses da ke akwai) kuma, don haka, sake tsara da'irori. An lura da nau'ikan canje-canje guda biyu a cikin bayyanar kwayar halitta a martanin ƙarfafa dopamine da kuma magungunan jaraba kamar cocaine (85 , 86).
Canjin kwayoyin halitta mafi daɗewa da aka sani a halin yanzu yana faruwa ne sakamakon magungunan jaraba (da sauran abubuwan da ke haifar da su) a cikin ƙwayoyin halittar nucleus da dorsal striatum shine haɓaka tsarin daidaito, wanda aka gyara bayan fassara na factor ΔFosB (85) . A ɗayan ƙarshen bakan lokaci shine bayyanar wucin gadi (mintuna zuwa awanni) na adadi mai yawa na kwayoyin halitta waɗanda wataƙila sun dogara da kunna masu karɓar dopamine D1 da kuma factor transcription factor CREB, furotin mai ɗaurewa na AMP-response element cyclic (86) . CREB yana kunnawa ta hanyar kinases na furotin da yawa, gami da kinases na furotin mai dogara da AMP da kuma kinases na furotin da yawa da suka dogara da Ca2 + kamar calcium/calmodulin dependent protein kinase type IV (87 , 88) . Saboda CREB na iya amsawa ga hanyoyin AMP na cyclic da Ca2 + kuma saboda haka yana iya aiki azaman mai gano daidaituwa, an ga kunna shi a matsayin ɗan takara don shiga cikin ƙarfin dogon lokaci da kuma cikin ƙwaƙwalwar haɗin gwiwa. A gaskiya ma, babban binciken da aka gudanar a cikin marasa ƙashi da kuma a cikin beraye yana goyon bayan muhimmiyar rawa ga CREB a cikin ƙwaƙwalwar ajiya na dogon lokaci (don sake dubawa, duba nassoshi 87 da 88).
Bayar da ka'idar jaraba kamar yadda ake amfani dasu na ƙwaƙwalwar ajiyar ƙwaƙwalwar ajiyar lokaci, saboda ci gaba da ƙarfafawa ga CREB a wasu nau'i na ƙwaƙwalwar ajiyar lokaci (87, 88), kuma ya ba da damar hawan cocaine da amphetamine don kunna CREB (88-90), an yi amfani sosai da rawar da take takawa na CREB a cikin ƙarfafa tunanin da ya shafi sakamako (11, 19). Shaidu na kai tsaye ga irin wannan rawar har yanzu basu rasa. Amma, akwai wasu shaidu masu karfi da ke hada haɗin cocaine da amphetamine da ke motsawa na dopamine D1 mai karɓa-hanyar CREB don juriya da dogara. Mafi kyawun samfurin CREB-da aka tsara wanda ya dace da juriya da dogara shine fadin prodynorphin (91-93), wanda ke dauke da adioid dynorphin peptides wadanda suke abpa opioid receptor agonists. Cocaine ko amphetamine yana haifar da dopamin rinjayar D1 masu karɓa a kan ƙananan ƙwayoyin cuta a cikin ƙananan ƙwayoyi da kuma dorsal striatum, da dama zuwa ga CREB phosphorylation da kuma kunnawa na prodynorphin gene expression (93). Ana haifar da peptides na dynorphin zuwa magunguna masu sassauci na sarƙaƙƙiya, daga abin da suke hana izinin dopamine daga magunguna na tsakiya na kwayoyin dopamine, saboda haka rage yawan karbar tsarin tsarin kwayoyin halitta (91, 94). D1 Mai karɓar mai karɓa a karuwa a cikin dynorphin za'a iya fassara shi a matsayin abin da ya dace da matsakaicin matsanancin matsananciyar kwayoyin katakon kwayoyin halitta na kwayoyin halitta a cikin tsakiya da kuma dorsal striatum wanda ke ci gaba da dampen karamin bayanan dopamine (91). Dangane da wannan ra'ayin, ƙwaƙwalwar CREB a cikin ƙwayar da aka ƙaddamar da shi ta hanyar kyamarar hoto yana ƙara yawan ƙwayoyin prodynorphin kuma yana rage sakamakon lalacewar cocaine (95). Sakamakon sakamako na cocaine za a iya dawowa a cikin wannan samfurin ta hanyar kula da antagonist mai karba (95).
Daidaitawar homeostatic kamar haifar da dynorphin, wanda ke rage amsawar tsarin dopamine, zai bayyana yana taka rawa wajen dogaro da janyewa (26 , 96) . Ganin iyakancewar rawar da dogaro ke takawa a cikin cututtukan jaraba (6 , 11 , 19 , 27 , 40) , wasu nazarin sun mayar da hankali kan yuwuwar hanyoyin kwayoyin halitta waɗanda zasu iya taimakawa wajen haɓaka ladan magani (don sake dubawa, duba nassoshi 12 , 13) . Wanda aka fi nazari a kai zuwa yanzu shine factor transcription ΔFosB. Tsawon lokacin da ΔFosB ke wuce gona da iri a cikin samfurin linzamin kwamfuta mai canzawa ya ƙara tasirin cocaine mai lada, kuma yawan CREB da bayyanar ΔFosB na ɗan gajeren lokaci yana da akasin haka na rage ladan magani (97) . Bugu da ƙari, an samar da wani bayanin daban na bayyanar kwayoyin halitta a cikin kwakwalwar linzamin kwamfuta ta hanyar tsawaita lokacin bayyanar ΔFosB, idan aka kwatanta da CREB ko bayyanar ΔFosB na ɗan gajeren lokaci (97) . Ma'anar waɗannan binciken shine aƙalla wasu kwayoyin halitta da aka bayyana a ƙasan CREB, kamar kwayar halittar pro-dynorphin (93) , suna da hannu a cikin haƙuri da dogaro kuma kwayoyin halittar da aka bayyana a ƙasan ΔFosB na iya zama 'yan takara don haɓaka martani ga lada da alamun da suka shafi lada. Binciken yana da rikitarwa ta hanyar fasahar gwaji da ake da su saboda duk hanyoyin da za a iya amfani da su wajen bayyana CREB ta hanyar wucin gadi sun wuce lokacin da aka saba (minti) na phosphorylation na CREB da dephosphorylation a ƙarƙashin yanayi na al'ada. Don haka, bai kamata a yi watsi da rawar da CREB ke takawa wajen haɗa tunanin haɗin gwiwa da suka shafi lada bisa ga shaidar da ke akwai ba. Sabbin ƙoƙarin haɓaka samfuran jaraba na dabbobi (98 , 99) na iya zama da matuƙar amfani a ƙoƙarin danganta bayyanar kwayar halitta da ke haifar da magani da plasticity na synaptic, sake fasalin synaptic, da halaye masu dacewa.
Hasashe na dopamine game da tasirin miyagun ƙwayoyi ya karu ƙasa da shekaru ashirin da suka gabata (38-40 ) . A lokacin, an fi fahimtar dopamine a matsayin siginar hedonic, kuma an fahimci jaraba a cikin kalmomin hedonic, tare da dogaro da janyewa a matsayin manyan abubuwan da ke haifar da shan miyagun ƙwayoyi na tilas. Ƙoƙarin da aka yi kwanan nan a matakai daban-daban na bincike sun samar da hoto mai zurfi da rikitarwa game da aikin dopamine da kuma yadda zai iya haifar da jaraba, amma sabbin bayanai da sabbin gine-ginen ka'idoji sun tayar da tambayoyi da yawa kamar yadda suka amsa. A cikin wannan bita na yi jayayya cewa abin da muka sani game da jaraba zuwa yanzu ya fi dacewa da ra'ayin cewa yana wakiltar kwace hanyoyin ilmantarwa da ƙwaƙwalwa da suka shafi lada. Duk da haka, ya kamata kuma a bayyana cewa akwai wasu abubuwa da yawa na wasanin gwada ilimi, gami da wasu manyan, kamar yadda magunguna daban-daban ke wargaza siginar tonic da phasic dopamine a cikin da'irori daban-daban, sakamakon aikin wannan rushewa, da kuma hanyoyin ƙwayoyin halitta da kwayoyin halitta waɗanda magungunan jaraba ke sake fasalin synapses da da'irori. Duk da waɗannan ƙalubalen, ilimin kimiyyar jijiyoyi na asali da na asibiti sun samar da hoto mafi inganci da ƙarfi na jaraba fiye da yadda muka samu 'yan shekarun da suka gabata.
An karɓa a ranar 19 ga Agusta, 2004; an karɓi gyaran a ranar 15 ga Nuwamba, 2004; an karɓa a ranar 3 ga Disamba, 2004. Daga Sashen Ilimin Jijiyoyin Jijiyoyi, Makarantar Likitanci ta Harvard, Boston; da Ofishin Provost, Jami'ar Harvard. Aika wasiƙu da sake buga buƙatun zuwa ga Dr. Hyman, Ofishin Provost, Massachusetts Hall, Jami'ar Harvard, Cambridge, MA 02138; [email protected] (e-mail).
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]
[PubMed]
[CrossRef]