Rev. Neurosci Biobehav 2019 Yuni 24. maki: S0149-7634(19)30370-7. doi: 10.1016/j.neubiorev.2019.06.032.
Brand M 1 , Wegmann E 2 , Stark R 3 , Müller A 4 , Wölfling K 5 , Robbins TW 6 , Potenza MN 7.
labarai
- Haɗin halayen maye suna da alaƙa da sake aiki da sha'awar sha'awa
- Associateda'idodi masu haɗari suna da alaƙa da raguwar sarrafa inhibitory
- Ana haɓaka halaye masu ɗabi'a yayin aiwatar da halayen jaraba
- Rashin daidaituwa tsakanin da'irar saurin fuskoki yana taimakawa halayen jaraba
Abstract
Muna ba da sabon tsari na ofaukaka Tsarin Haɓaka-Tsarin-Kwarewar-Kashewar-I-PACE, wanda muke jayayya cewa yana da inganci don nau'ikan halayen jaraba, kamar caca, caca, sayayya, da kuma halayen jima'i na tilasta. cuta. Dangane da binciken da aka samo kwanan nan da kuma la'akari da zurfin tunani, muna jayayya cewa halayyar jaraba suna haɓaka sakamakon sakamakon hulɗar tsakanin masu canji, sahihancin martani da ƙwarewa ga takamaiman ƙuduri, da ayyukan zartarwa, kamar sarrafa inhibitory da yanke shawara. A yayin aiwatar da halayyar jaraba, ƙungiyar tsakanin cue-reactivity / sha'awar da rage ƙarancin sarrafawa yana ba da gudummawa ga haɓaka halayen al'ada. Rashin daidaituwa tsakanin ginin da'irori masu aiki da juna, musamman tsakanin bangarorin tashin iska, amygdala, da kuma bangarorin gabanin na farko, na iya zama da muhimmaci ga farkon matakan da kuma yanayin tashin-hankali zuwa matakai na jaraba. Tsarin I-PACE na iya samar da ka'idodin ka'idodin karatu na gaba game da halayen jaraba da kuma aikin asibiti. Nazarin nan gaba yakamata a bincika hanyoyin gama gari da na musamman waɗanda ke da hannu cikin jarabar jaraba, batsa-mai tilastawa, lalacewa, da rikice-rikicewar amfani da abubuwa.
KALMOMI MAI MUHIMMANCI: Sha'awar ɗabi'a; matsalar siyayya da siyayya; amsawar alama; matsalar caca; matsalar caca; ikon hanawa; amfani da batsa mai matsala
PMID: 31247240
1. Gabatarwa
Fiye da shekaru biyu da suka gabata ne aka buga alaƙar Mutun-Tasirin-Cognition-kisan (I-PACE) na takamaiman yanayin rikice-rikice na amfani da Intanet.Brand et al., 2016b). Aimaya daga cikin manufar ita ce bayyana hanyoyin tunani da ƙwaƙwalwar ƙwaƙwalwar ƙwaƙwalwa da ke tattare da haɓakawa da kuma ci gaba da amfani da jaraba game da takamaiman aikace-aikacen yanar gizo, kamar waɗanda aka yi amfani da su lokacin caca, caca, kallon batsa, siye-siye, da sadarwar zamantakewa. Tun lokacin da aka buga samfurin I-PACE, masu bincike sun ambaci shi gaba daya ba a duniya ba kawai don matsalar caca (misali, Deleuze et al., 2017; Dieter et al., 2017; Dong et al., 2019; Kaess et al., 2017; Lee et al., 2018a; Lee et al., 2018b; Li et al., 2018; Paulus et al., 2018; Sariyska et al., 2017), amma kuma don matsalar caca (misali, Ioannidis et al., 2019b; Starcke et al., 2018), rikicewar halayen jima'i na tilastawa gami da amfani da batsa na matsala (misali, Carnes & Loveauna, 2017; Strahler et al., 2018; Wéry et al., 2018), matsalar siyan siyayya (misali, Lam & Lam, 2017; Vogel et al., 2018), wuce gona da iri na aikace-aikacen sadarwa (misali, Dempsey et al., 2019; Elhai et al., 2018; Kircaburun & Griffiths, 2018; Montag et al., 2018; Rothen et al., 2018), matsalar rashin amfani da yanar gizo Carbonell et al., 2018; Emelin et al., 2017; Ioannidis et al., 2019a; Lachmann et al., 2018; Vargas et al., 2019; Zhou et al., 2018b), da sauran halayen jaraba waɗanda suka hada da rikice-rikice-masu amfani da kayan (Zhou et al., 2018a). Fasali na goma sha ɗaya na Kayan Kasuwanci na Duniya (ICD-11), yayin da aka sake shi kwanan nan (World-Health-Organization, 2019), yana mai da hankali kan rikicewar da kanta (misali matsalar caca) ba tare da yin magana da matsakaiciyar cuta ba, misali rikicewar wasan caca maimakon rikice-rikicen wasan-yanar gizo a bugu na biyar na Tsarin Bincike da kuma Statididdigar Lissafi (DSM-5) (APA, 2013). A cikin ICD-11, za a iya ƙayyade yanayin halayen a matsayin mafi yawan layi ko yawanci akan layi don rikice-rikicen caca da caca. Sakamakon haka, samfurin da ke bayanin hanyoyin da ke tattare da yanayin matsalar ya kamata ya zama ya dace ga duka layi da kuma layi da kuma haɗuran halayen layi da na kan layi. Muna ci gaba da ba da shawara cewa halayen da kanta shine babban abu don la'akari kuma yanayin (kan layi tare da layi) na iya zama na gaba da sakandare amma yana iya ba da gudummawa mai mahimmanci ga bayyana takamaiman halayen jaraba da bambancin gama gari a duk waɗannan halayen (Baggio et al., 2018). Muna ba da shawarar sabon samfurin I-PACE, wanda muke zaton zai zama mai inganci ba kawai don takaddama na amfani da yanar gizo ba, har ma da sauran nau'ikan halayen jaraba. Wannan samfurin I-PACE da aka sabunta shine ya mayar da hankali ga ƙayyadaddun hanyoyin tunani da ƙwaƙwalwar ƙwaƙwalwa na halayyar jaraba. Bayani mai mahimmanci na musamman na kafofin watsa labaru da sauran abubuwan da suka shafi muhalli waɗanda ke da alaƙa da halayyar da za su iya saurin haɓaka ko rage haɓakar halayen jaraba sannan za a iya bayyana su don takamaiman fasalin samfurin. Siffa 1 ta taƙaita bambance banbancen da aka gabatar tsakanin ɓangarorin matsakaici / muhalli, halayen mutane, da halayyar da abubuwan da ke tattare da yanayin jijiyoyi a cikin halayyar jaraba.
Hoto na 1. Bambance-bambancen fannoni na muhalli, halayen mutum ɗaya, da kuma sakamakon wasu halaye na musamman da aka maimaita a tsawon lokaci. Tsarin I-PACE da aka yi wa kwaskwarima ya mayar da hankali kan halayen mutum da sakamakon da ke tattare da haɓaka halaye masu jaraba.
Bugu da ƙari, muna da nufin bayyana yanayin tsarin samfurin a sarari ta hanyar bambance ƙananan samfura guda biyu, ɗaya don hanyoyin da ke cikin matakan farko da ɗaya don hanyoyin da ke cikin matakan ƙarshe na tsarin jaraba. Ba ma maimaita cikakken bayani game da duk abubuwan da aka haɗa a cikin samfurin I-PACE ba (cf. Brand et al., 2016b ). Madadin haka, galibi muna mai da hankali kan labaran da suka gabata, musamman nazarin meta da sake dubawa na tsari waɗanda suka ba da kwarin gwiwa ga sabunta I-PACE.
2. Sabuwar tsarin I-PACE na halayyar jaraba
Gyaran samfurin I-PACE ya ƙunshi manyan matakai guda uku. Na farko, mun mayar da hankali kan yin canje-canje masu canzawa, waɗanda aka yi la'akari da su a matsayin waɗanda ke da hannu a cikin nau'ikan halaye daban-daban na jaraba (matsalolin caca, matsalar caca, da sauransu) kuma mun bambanta su da ƙarin masu canzawa masu canzawa waɗanda ke da halaye daban-daban. Na biyu, mun fayyace daidai da da'irar ciki na tsarin jaraba a cikin samfurin I-PACE dangane da binciken da aka yi kwanan nan. Na uku, mun bambanta tsakanin matakai na farko da na ƙarshe na tsarin don nuna takamaiman rawar da za a iya takawa wajen daidaitawa da kuma daidaita masu canzawa dangane da matakin jaraba. An nuna samfurin I-PACE da aka sake fasalin na halayen jaraba a cikin Hoto na 2. Hoto na 2 A yana nuna hulɗa tsakanin masu canji waɗanda ake ɗauka da mahimmanci musamman a farkon matakan halayen jaraba. Hoto na 2 B yana kwatanta hulɗar masu canzawa a matakai na gaba na hanyoyin jaraba.
Hoto na 2. Tsarin I-PACE da aka gyara don halayen jaraba. Hoto na A yana nuna matakan farko na haɓaka halayen jaraba. Hoto na B yana nuna matakan ƙarshe na tsari da abubuwan da ke ba da gudummawa ga kula da halayen jaraba. Kibiyoyi masu ƙarfi suna nuna haɗin gwiwa/hanyoyi masu sauri.
2.1. P-bangaren samfurin I-PACE
P-bangaren wakiltar jigon mutum ne mai yiwuwa ya shiga aikin jaraba kamar yadda ake gabatar da masu canji (duba tattaunawa a Brand et al., 2016b). Gabaɗaya masu saurin canzawar abubuwa (gefen hagu a cikin babban akwatin samfurin) na iya ba da gudummawa cikin mahimmanci ga kowane nau'in halayen jaraba (alal misali, matsalar caca, rikicewar caca, siyayya-siyayya, lalata-kallon cuta / halin rashin hankali). Jerin waɗannan masu canji masu iya hango bambance-bambancen ra'ayi ba su cika ba. Tana taƙaita masu canji ne kawai waɗanda gaɗaɗan hujjoji zasu kasance, gami da daga nazarin-meta, kodayake shaidar tana iya bambanta ƙarfi don nau'ikan halayen jaraba. Bayanai suna ba da babbar gudummawa ta hanyar ƙwayar cuta ga cuta ta caca (Lobo, 2016; Potenza, 2017, 2018; Xuan et al., 2017) da rikicewar amfani da intanet wanda ba a bayyana ba (Hahn et al., 2017). Bugu da ƙari, abubuwan da ba su dace da ƙuruciya ba sun bayar da rahoton yadda abubuwan haɗari ke haifar da matsalar caca (Roberts et al., 2017) da rashin lafiyar caca (Schneider et al., 2017), Binciken yayi daidai da la'akari da ka'idojin ka'idojin kwanan nan game da rawar da aka makala a cikin halayen jaraba (Alvarez-Monjaras et al., 2018). An ba da rahoton cewa Psychopathological correlates, musamman bacin rai da damuwa na zamantakewa akai-akai don caca (Dowling et al., 2017), wasan kwaikwayo (Männikkö et al., 2017), amfani da yanar gizo wanda ba a bayyana ba (Ho et al., 2014), da siyan-cin kasuwa (Müller et al., 2019) rikice-rikice, da sauran jarabawar halayya (Starcevic & Khazaal, 2017). An kuma alakanta fasalin yanayin zafi, kamar babban son rai, da caca (Dowling et al., 2017), wasan kwaikwayo (Gervasi et al., 2017; Kuss et al., 2018; Ryu et al., 2018), kuma amfani da yanar gizo wanda ba a bayyana ba (Kayiş et al., 2016) rikice-rikice, kamar yadda yake da salon magance matsalar rashin aiki tare da rikicewar caca (Schneider et al., 2018). A cikin samfurin I-PACE, muna amfani da kalmomin gabaɗaya (alal misali, psychopathology, fasalulluka yanayin ciki har da, alal misali, ƙazantawa) wanda za'a iya ƙayyadaddun gaba game da halayyar ɗimbin jaraba. Dabarar-takamaiman tsinkayar masu canzawa (gefen dama na akwatin a sama a cikin samfurin, Siffa 2A da B) ana ɗaukar halayyar musamman halayen jaraba na daban. Misali, daidaikun mutane masu neman sabon abu suna iya samun ci gaban matsalar caca (Del Pino-Gutiérrez et al., 2017). Mutane da ke da babbar tsokanar zalunci da halaye masu inganci na iya zama mafi haɗari don haɓaka rikici na wasa (Gervasi et al., 2017). Mutane daya-daya da babban halin sha'awar jima'i na iya zama wataƙila za su iya haɓaka halayyar halayyar muhalli ko rashin amfani da hotunan batsa (Stark et al., 2017), da kuma daidaikun mutane masu darajar jari-hujja na iya zama sanadin bullowa kan siyayya ta siyayya (Claes et al., 2016; Müller et al., 2014).
2.2. Da'irar ciki: Tasirin (A-), fahimta (C-), da aiwatarwa (E-) aka haɗa nau'ikan samfurin I-PACE
Babban ra'ayi game da da'irar ciki na samfurin I-PACE shine cewa ci gaban ɗabi'a mai matsala da jaraba yana faruwa ne kawai a cikin hulɗa tsakanin masu canjin da ke haifar da mutane da wasu fannoni da takamaiman yanayi ke bayarwa. Hulɗar tana haifar da gogewa da diyya waɗanda ke da alaƙa da takamaiman halaye. A farkon matakai ( Hoto na 2 A), mutane na iya fahimtar waje (misali, fuskantar abubuwan da ke haifar da ɗabi'a) ko abubuwan da ke haifar da ciki (misali, mummunan yanayi ko yanayi mai kyau) a cikin takamaiman yanayi. Hasashen na iya haifar da martani mai tasiri da fahimta, kamar ƙara mai da hankali ga waɗannan abubuwan da ke haifar da ɗabi'a ta hanyoyi na musamman; misali sha'awar yin wasannin kan layi ko kallon batsa ( Starcke et al., 2018 ).
Amsoshin da suka shafi motsin rai da fahimta suna haifar da yanke shawara don yin aiki ta hanyoyi na musamman. Shawarar shiga cikin wani takamaiman hali na iya kasancewa ta hanyar tsarin hulɗa guda biyu: tsarin motsa jiki/mai amsawa, wanda galibi ya dogara ne akan koyo na haɗin gwiwa (na gargajiya da na aiki), da kuma tsarin tunani/mai tunani, wanda galibi yana da alaƙa da tunani da ayyukan zartarwa ( Kahneman, 2003 ; Schiebener & Brand, 2015 ; Strack & Deutsch, 2004 ). A cikin mutanen da ke da jaraba, ana ɗaukar hali ya dogara da tsarin jijiyoyi masu motsawa/mai amsawa, gami da tsarin limbic ( Noël et al., 2006 ). Kula da hana sha'awa da sha'awa da suka shafi prefrontal-cortex na iya raguwa yayin tsarin jaraba ( Bechara, 2005 ; Volkow & Morales, 2015 ). Idan muka haɗa waɗannan ra'ayoyin ka'idoji, muna ba da shawarar cewa alaƙar da ke tsakanin martanin motsin rai da fahimta ga abubuwan da ke haifar da abubuwan da ke haifar da waje ko na ciki da kuma yanke shawara don shiga cikin takamaiman halaye ana daidaita su ta hanyar matakin sarrafa hanawa gabaɗaya (sabanin ikon hana yanayi ko na musamman) da kuma daidaita kai/jagoranci kai ( Hahn et al., 2017 ), aƙalla a farkon matakan halayen jaraba. Nazarin meta na Meng, Deng, Wang, Guo, da Li (2015) ya nuna cewa rashin aikin prefrontal yana da alaƙa da matsalar caca, yana nuna yiwuwar rikici tsakanin tsammanin lada da tsarin sarrafa kai, gami da rikice-rikicen da ke tattare da jinkirin gamsuwa ( Volkow & Baler, 2015 ). Dangane da ikon hanawa gabaɗaya, Yao et al. (2017) sun ba da rahoton canje-canje na aiki da tsarin kwakwalwa a cikin matsalar caca waɗanda ke da alaƙa da raguwar aikin zartarwa. Halaye na musamman (misali yin wasan kan layi, caca a gidan caca, siyan abubuwa) na iya haifar da jin gamsuwa ko sauƙi daga mummunan yanayi ( Laier & Brand, 2017 ). Waɗannan abubuwan da suka faru daga baya suna canza tsammanin lada na mutum wanda ke da alaƙa da takamaiman halaye. Hakanan suna iya canza salon jurewa na mutum ɗaya. Misali, idan mutane suka fahimci cewa yin wasannin kan layi yana da tasiri wajen samar da kyawawan ji ko guje wa mummunan yanayin motsin rai, suna iya faɗaɗa tsammanin cewa yin wasannin kan layi yana da amfani don magance motsin rai a rayuwar yau da kullun ( Kuss et al., 2018 ; Laier et al., 2018 ). Canje-canje na tsammanin da salon jurewa na iya ƙara yiwuwar amsawa tare da jin sha'awa ko jin sha'awa a cikin yanayi masu zuwa lokacin da aka fuskanci abubuwan da ke haifar da waje ko na ciki. Wannan hulɗar abubuwan da ke haifar da sha'awa da tsammanin an nuna ta mutane masu tsananin alamun amfani da ayyukan sadarwa ta intanet ( Wegmann et al., 2018b ). Bayan lokaci, waɗannan alaƙar tsakanin martanin tausayi da fahimta, yanke shawara don yin aiki ta hanyoyi na musamman, gogewa na gamsuwa da diyya da tsammanin takamaiman hali na iya zama da ƙarfi. Saboda haka, iko kan halayen ta hanyar hanyoyin hana gabaɗaya na iya zama da wahala, kuma yanke shawara don yin aiki ta hanyoyi na musamman na iya zama jagora ta hanyar amsawar gaggawa/mai amsawa ga abubuwan da ke haifar da su. An taƙaita hanyoyin da aka gabatar don shiga cikin matakai na gaba na halayen jaraba a cikin Hoto na 2 B.
A matakai na baya na tsarin jaraba, kodayake matsawa na iya zama a hankali, ƙungiyoyin da aka ambata na iya ƙaruwa da ƙarfi, hakan yana haifar da ɗabi'a na al'ada waɗanda zasu iya jin kansu kai tsaye a wasu yanayi. Cake-reactivity da sha'awar na iya samo asali daga amsawa mai ma'ana da hankali akan lokaci saboda sakamakon hanyoyin kwantar da hankali (Starcke et al., 2018). Binciken da ya gabata ya nuna mahimmancin mahimmancin hankali game da motsawar da ke da sha'awar jaraba da kuma kunnawa cikin tsarin sakamako na jijiyoyin jiki wanda ya shafi ventral and therseratatatum da sauran tsarin ƙarancin jiki a cikin halayen jaraba (Fauth-Bühler & Mann, 2017; Fauth-Bühler et al., 2017; Luijten et al., 2017; Palaus et al., 2017). Abubuwan da ake tsammani na gaba zasu iya canzawa zuwa tasirin fahimta da fahimta, wanda zai iya haɗawa da nuna son kai ko kuma da alama ta atomatik ga abubuwan da suka danganci halayen da masu haifar da abubuwa (Jeromin et al., 2016). Mun ba da shawara cewa sakamako na biyan diyya ya zama mai ƙarfi akan sakamako mai gamsarwa a matakai na gaba na jarabar (jaraba) Brand et al., 2016b). Baya ga tasirin gyaran inhibitory na gaba daya kan alakar da ke tsakanin cue-reactivity / sha'awar da halayyar al'ada, muna ba da shawara cewa, takamaiman tsarin hana inhibitory na iya zama matsakanci a cikin matakan da suka biyo baya na ayyukan jaraba.Everitt & Robbins, 2016). Yawancin masu bincike sun jaddada kasawa a cikin inhibitory iko da ayyukan zartarwa a cikin matsalar caca (Ioannidis et al., 2019b; van Timmeren et al., 2018), rashin lafiyar caca (Argyriou et al., 2017; Kuss et al., 2018; Yao et al., 2017), da rikice-rikicen amfani da yanar gizoIoannidis et al., 2019a). Mun ba da shawara, duk da haka, cewa duk da cewa janar inhibitory gaba ɗaya na iya raguwa yayin tafiyar matakai na jaraba, haɓaka ƙayyadaddun takaddama mai hana ƙwari mai ƙarfi yana shiga halayyar ɗabi'a a ƙarshen matakan halayen jaraba. Muna ba da shawara cewa idan an inganta ma'amala da sha'awar azaba kamar yadda ake mayar da martani ga abubuwan na waje ko na ciki, wannan na iya haifar da raguwa a cikin sarrafa sha'awar yayin fuskantar haɗari game da jaraba, wanda hakan zai iya sa a sami damar nuna dabi'ar al'ada (Piazza & Deroche-Gamonet, 2013).
3. Hanyoyin sarrafa ƙwayoyin cuta
3.1. Ka'idodin kimiyyar jaraba ne wadanda aka haɗa su a cikin da'irar ciki ta samfurin I-PACE
Yawancin ka'idojin neuroscientific da samfuran da ke bayyana halayen jaraba suna haɗe cikin tsarin ka'idojin yanayin da'irar ciki-samfurin I-PACE (Brand et al., 2016b). Za a iya ganin hanyoyin kai tsaye zuwa ga Rashin Ingancin Amsar Canji da Salience Salihi (I-RISA) samfurin (Goldstein & Volkow, 2011), Centirƙira-Sensitization (Robinson & Berridge, 2008), Sakamakon Raunin Rauni (Blum et al., 1996) samfura da kuma ka'idoji, da kuma hanyoyin fuskantar jaraba (abubuwa biyu)Bechara, 2005; Everitt & Robbins, 2005, 2016) da ra'ayoyin rashin daidaituwa tsakanin halayyar da aka gabatar da manufa da halaye (Robbins et al., 2019). Hakanan muna koma zuwa ga mafi kyawun ƙayyadaddun samfuran ka'idoji waɗanda ke haɗawa da lafuzzan neurosificific na cuta na caca (Blaszczynski & Nower, 2002; Goudriaan et al., 2004) da rashin lafiyar caca (Dong & Potenza, 2014; Wei et al., 2017). Daidaita wadannan ka'idojin, zamuyi la'akari da ci gaban rashin daidaituwa tsakanin kararrakin neman jan hankali da sha'awowi a bangare guda da rage karfin takamaiman yanayin hana karfi kan wadannan sha'awoyi da sha'awowi a daya bangaren yana da mahimmanci ga ci gaba da kuma kiyaye halayen jaraba. Asingara ƙwaƙwalwar hankali, sakamakon aiwatar da hanyoyin (Berridge et al., 2009), na iya danganta shi da jan hankali da nuna ra'ayi a cikin ayyukan gaba na ayyukan jaraba. Mutanen da ke da ƙarancin lada na iya zama sannu a hankali don haɓaka abubuwan karfafa hankali (Blum et al., 2012). Centarfafawa da nutsuwa na iya haɓaka ma'amala da sha'awar abubuwa, wanda hakan na iya ba da gudummawa ga halayen mutane na jaraba.
Rage ayyukan zartarwa sun yi la'akari da duka a matsayin abubuwan rauni da sakamakon halayen jaraba, gami da matsalolin amfani da miyagun ƙwayoyi ( Volkow et al., 2012 ). A cikin jarabar halaye, kamar caca da matsalolin wasanni, mutum na iya jayayya cewa rage ayyukan zartarwa ya ƙunshi abubuwan rauni kuma ba ya haɓaka sakamakon halayen jaraba, saboda babu wani tasirin neurotoxic kai tsaye da ke da alaƙa da sinadarai a kwakwalwa da ke da hannu. Dangane da wannan ra'ayi, mun ba da shawarar cewa raguwar matakin sarrafa hana gabaɗaya abu ne mai rauni ga halayen jaraba kuma yana aiki azaman mai canzawa na alaƙar da ke tsakanin martanin motsin rai ga wasu abubuwan da ke haifar da damuwa (misali, damuwa ko yanayi mara kyau) da yanke shawara don shiga cikin takamaiman halaye (duba Hoto na 2 A). Bugu da ƙari, duk da haka, muna jayayya cewa bayan wannan tasirin matsakaici na ayyukan zartarwa azaman abin da ke haifar da rauni na jaraba, ikon hana hana takamaiman yanayi (lokacin da ake fuskantar abubuwan da ke haifar da jaraba) na iya raguwa akan lokaci sakamakon halayen jaraba, kodayake - sabanin matsalolin amfani da miyagun ƙwayoyi - babu wani tasirin neurotoxic kai tsaye akan kwakwalwa da ke da hannu a cikin jarabar halaye. Ragewar ikon hana motsa jiki na musamman na iya tasowa bisa ga amsawar da aka yi wa mutum da sha'awa kuma tare da canje-canje a cikin kwakwalwa mai aiki a cikin da'irorin da suka shafi jaraba ( Ersche et al., 2012 ; Koob & Volkow, 2010 ; Volkow & Morales, 2015 ; Volkow et al., 2012 ). Don haka, a cikin matakai na gaba na halayen jaraba ( Hoto na 2 B), hanyoyin sarrafa hana motsa jiki na musamman na iya shafar sha'awa da sha'awar da suka shafi fuskantar abubuwan da suka shafi jaraba, wanda hakan zai iya sa ya fi yiwuwa mutum ya yi aiki ta al'ada ko da alama ta atomatik ( Everitt & Robbins, 2005 , 2013, 2016).
3.2. Tsarin tushen daidaitattun abubuwa tsakanin cikin babban da'irar ciki-da samfurin I-PACE
An yi nazari game da rashin daidaituwa wanda aka ambata tsakanin tsaranin kwakwalwa / aikin-sakamako na kwakwalwa da kulawar farko a cikin jarabawar halayyar don kusan matsalar cuta ta caca (Clark et al., 2013; Goudriaan et al., 2014; Potenza, 2013; van Holst et al., 2010) da rashin lafiyar caca (Kuss et al., 2018; Weinstein, 2017; Weinstein et al., 2017), ciki har da nazar-nazarcen (Meng et al., 2015). Kodayake ƙasa da yawa, akwai kuma binciken ilimin halayyar halayen halayen jima'i, ciki har da amfani da batsa na matsala (misali, Brand et al., 2016a; Gola et al., 2017; Klucken et al., 2016; Schmidt et al., 2017; Voon et al., 2014), waɗanda aka bincika a cikin sake dubawar kwanan nan (Kraus et al., 2016; Stark et al., 2018). Nazarin ilimin kimiyya game da mahimmancin rikice-rikice na siye-siya yana da ɗan kaɗan. Akwai, duk da haka, wasu nazarin daga hangen nesa na ilimin masu amfani (misali, Raab et al., 2011) da kuma karatu ta amfani da matakan electrophysiological don bincika dabarun neurobiological na rashin sayayya na siyayya (Trotzke et al., 2014) waɗanda aka bita kwanan nan (Kyrios et al., 2018; Trotzke et al., 2017). Kodayake ba a yarda da shi a matsayin yanayin asibiti ba, akwai kuma wallafe-wallafe na kwanan nan akan abubuwan bincike da aiki na neuroimaging na rashin kulawa mai kyau da amfani da shafukan yanar gizo na yanar gizo da sauran aikace-aikacen sadarwa ta yanar gizo (misali, Dieter et al., 2017; Shi et al., 2017; Lemenager et al., 2016; Montag et al., 2017; Montag et al., 2018; Turel & Qahri-Saremi, 2016), waɗanda aka bita ta Wegmann et al. (2018a).
Akwai bambanci mai yawa a cikin nazarin hotunan jijiyoyi game da halayen jaraba game da nau'ikan jarabar ɗabi'a, dabarun da aka yi amfani da su (misali, hoton maganadisu na tsari/aikin aiki [s/fMRI], hoton positron emission tomography [PET]), tsarin tunani ko hanyoyin sha'awa, ayyukan gwaji da aka yi amfani da su don auna takamaiman ayyuka, samfuran da aka haɗa (samfura masu dacewa tare da mutane da ke nuna matakai daban-daban na alamun cutar idan aka kwatanta da mutanen da aka gano a asibiti ko marasa lafiya da ke neman magani), da kuma hanyoyin ganewar asali da aka yi amfani da su. Duk da haka, lokacin da aka zana ƙarshe daga nazarin, nazarin meta da sake dubawa (duba, misali, ambato a sama), akwai shaida ta farko don shigar da tsarin limbic mai ƙarfi, gami da amygdala da ventral striatum, da kuma da'irorin prefrontal-striatal hypoactive da ke da hannu a cikin sarrafa fahimta akan halayen. Duk da haka, akwai wasu gargaɗi, misali haɗakar lada mai ƙarfi a lokacin lokacin da ake jira na sarrafa kuɗi ( Balodis & Potenza, 2015 ), tare da wasu masu bincike suna ba da shawarwari kan bambance-bambancen da suka shafi sarrafa alamun jaraba (amsa lada mai ƙarfi) da alamun lada marasa jaraba (amsa lada mai ƙarfi) ( Limbrick-Oldfield et al., 2013 ). Insula na iya zama mai shiga tsakani tsakanin tsarin biyu (limbic da prefrontal-striatal), yana wakiltar yanayin somatic da ke da alaƙa da sha'awar da sha'awar yin aiki musamman (duba tattaunawa a cikin Namkung et al., 2017 ; Wei et al., 2017 ). An taƙaita manyan tsare-tsaren da aka gano a matsayin alaƙar kwakwalwa mai yuwuwar halayen jaraba a cikin Hoto na 3.
Hoto na 3. Da'irorin kwakwalwa na iya zama masu haifar da halayen jaraba. Kibiyoyi masu launin lemu suna wakiltar babban da'irar da aka gabatar don shiga cikin matakan farko na hanyoyin jaraba. Kibiyoyi masu launin shuɗi suna nuna ƙarin shiga na dorsal striatum da tsarin da ke da alaƙa a cikin matakan gaba na hanyoyin jaraba, lokacin da halaye suka zama al'ada. ACC = anterior cingulate cortex, AM = amygdala, DLPFC = dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, DS = dorsal striatum, GP = globus pallidus, Hipp = hippocampus, Ins = insula, Motor = motor cortex da yankuna masu alaƙa don aiwatar da halaye, OFC = orbitofrontal cortex, Rap = serotonergic raphé nuclei, SN = substantia nigra, Thal = thalamus, VMPFC = ventromedial prefrontal cortex, VS = ventral striatum, VTA = dopaminergic ventral tegmental area.
A cikin binciken da aka yi kwanan nan kan ayyukan kwakwalwa masu alaƙa da cue-reactivity a cikin nazarin fMRI tare da samfuran marasa lafiya da jarabar ɗabi'a idan aka kwatanta da waɗanda ke da iko ( Starcke et al., 2018 ), dorsal striatum (caudate nucleus) ya fi aiki a cikin mutanen da ke da jaraba idan aka kwatanta da waɗanda ba su da kuma a cikin mutanen da ke da jaraba lokacin da aka kwatanta yanayin da ke da alaƙa da jaraba da yanayin tsaka-tsaki a cikin ayyukan cue-reactivity. Abubuwan da aka gano na iya nuna canje-canje daga shiga cikin ventral striatum a farkon matakan jarabar ɗabi'a lokacin da aka fuskanci abubuwan da suka shafi jaraba zuwa shiga cikin dorsal striatum a cikin matakai na gaba na rashin lafiyar, lokacin da halayyar ta zama ta al'ada ( Everitt & Robbins, 2013 , 2016; Zhou et al., 2019 ). Tsarin kwakwalwa da da'irori waɗanda wataƙila ke haifar da halayen jaraba da canzawa daga farkon zuwa na ƙarshe na hanyoyin jaraba an kwatanta su da tsari a cikin Hoto na 3.
An bincika alaƙa mai faɗi tsakanin tsarin fronto-striatal ta amfani da binciken fMRI na yanayin hutawa tare da mutane masu lafiya kuma an nuna cewa suna da hannu a cikin sassaucin hali ( Morris et al., 2016 ). Waɗannan da'irori kuma sun yi daidai da hanyoyin sadarwa masu aiki waɗanda ke da hannu a cikin daidaita motsin rai ( Öner, 2018 ). Canje-canje a cikin haɗin kai tsakanin takamaiman tsarin da ke da hannu a cikin da'irori na fronto-striatal (misali, haɗin kai tsakanin amygdala da medial PFC) yana da mahimmanci wajen bayyana rashin daidaituwar motsin rai a cikin rikice-rikicen amfani da abu ( Koob, 2015 ; Wilcox et al., 2016 ). Haɗin hanyoyin sadarwa da ke da hannu a cikin sarrafa fahimta (da'irori na fronto-parietal da yankunan gaba na medial) da kuma a cikin sarrafa lada (gami da tsarin subcortical da limbic) an kuma nuna yana annabta kauracewa cikin matsalar amfani da cocaine bayan magani ( Yip et al., 2019 ). An gabatar da rabuwa mai ƙarfi na hanyoyin sadarwa guda biyu da ke da hannu a cikin sarrafa zartarwa da kuma fahimtar lada don haifar da sassaucin hali da raguwar tilastawa, wanda zai iya bayyana mafi kyawun sakamakon magani ( Yip et al., 2019 ).
A taƙaice, muna ba da shawarar cewa rashin daidaito a cikin da'irori masu sassaucin hali da kuma daidaita motsin rai/burin jiki suna da alaƙa da manyan fannoni na halayen jaraba. Hanyoyin sun haɗa da hasashen dopaminergic daga yankin ventral tegmental da substantia nigra zuwa yankunan prefrontal, ventral striatum, da anterior cingulate gyrus da kuma hasashen serotonergic daga raphé nuclei zuwa yankunan prefrontal (galibi yankunan orbitofrontal) ( Everitt & Robbins, 2005 ; Volkow et al., 2012 ; Volkow et al., 2013 ). Haɗin kai tsakanin tsarin striatal, thalamus, da yankunan prefrontal ya dogara ne da glutamate da gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) ( Naaijen et al., 2015 ), kuma tsarin neurochemical da ke cikin madaukai na fronto-striatal suna aiki a cikin salon haɗin gwiwa da na giciye ( Gleich et al., 2015 ). An yi tattaunawa sosai kan alaƙar jijiyoyi da jaraba a wasu wurare, kuma bincike da yawa sun jaddada muhimmancin rawar da dopamine ke takawa a cikin matsalolin amfani da miyagun ƙwayoyi ( Herman & Roberto, 2015 ; Pascoli et al., 2018 ; Volkow et al., 2016 ). Duk da haka, binciken da aka yi game da dopamine a cikin jarabar ɗabi'a ba shi da ƙarfi sosai ( Potenza, 2018 ).
Ko da yake an buga adadi mai yawa na bincike kan alaƙar jijiyoyi na jarabar ɗabi'a a cikin 'yan shekarun nan, akwai wasu iyakoki da ya kamata a ambata. Da farko, an buga yawancin nazarin kan matsalar caca da matsalar caca (duba sharhi a sama). Akwai ƙarancin shaida ga wasu jarabar ɗabi'a, gami da halayen jima'i na tilastawa, gami da amfani da batsa mai matsala, matsalar siyayya da siyayya, da sauran abubuwan da ba a san su ba tukuna a matsayin yanayin asibiti, kamar amfani da shafukan sada zumunta. Musamman ma, binciken da ke bincika alaƙar jijiyoyi na takamaiman ayyukan tunani (misali, sha'awa, sarrafa hanawa) a cikin takamaiman nau'ikan jarabar ɗabi'a ba su nan. Nazarin da ke bincika matakan hanyoyin jaraba ko tsananin alamun a matsayin masu hasashen ko daidaita canje-canje na ayyukan jijiyoyi da yuwuwar rashin daidaituwar tsarin kwakwalwa yana da mahimmanci don fahimtar hanyoyin da ke haifar da ci gaban halayen jaraba. Dangane da wannan, nazarin da ke kan kwakwalwa na alaƙar ɗabi'un jaraba waɗanda ke gwada takamaiman hasashe ba su nan. Binciken yuwuwar sauyawa daga aikin ventral zuwa dorsal striatum a matsayin martani ga alamun da suka shafi jaraba a cikin nau'ikan jarabar ɗabi'a da kuma a cikin matakai daban-daban na jaraba, ta amfani da ƙira-ɓangare da na tsayi, zai taimaka wajen fahimtar yanayin halayen jaraba. Irin waɗannan nazarin suna da mahimmanci don kawar da yiwuwar sauye-sauye daga sha'awa zuwa tilas da kuma tsammanin gamsuwa zuwa tsammanin sauƙi daga yanayi mara kyau lokacin da ake fuskantar abubuwan da suka shafi jaraba a matakai daban-daban na jarabar halaye, wanda hakan zai taimaka wajen inganta jiyya. Nazarin da ke kwatanta nau'ikan halaye daban-daban na jaraba da matakai daban-daban na hanyoyin jaraba, gami da nazarin da ake yi na tsawon lokaci, na iya bincika ra'ayin da aka yi na raguwar ikon hanawa a matsayin abin da ke haifar da rauni da/ko sakamakon halayen jaraba, da kuma wanda zai iya daidaita alaƙa tsakanin martanin sha'awa da halayen al'ada/tilastawa (duba tattaunawa a cikin Everitt & Robbins, 2016 ).
4. Kammalawa da kwatance masu zuwa
Tsarin I-PACE da aka sabunta hanya ce ta ka'ida don bayyana tsarin halayen jaraba ta hanyar haɗa ka'idodin ilimin halayyar ɗan adam da na kimiyyar jijiyoyi na cututtukan amfani da miyagun ƙwayoyi da jarabar ɗabi'a. Muna ɗaukar rikice-rikicen da ke faruwa sakamakon halayen jaraba sakamakon hulɗa tsakanin halayen mutum da wasu masu canzawa da masu daidaitawa da yawa, waɗanda na iya zama masu ƙarfi kuma suna haɓaka akan lokaci sakamakon shiga cikin takamaiman halaye. Muna ba da shawarar cewa samfurin I-PACE na halayen jaraba na iya zama da amfani ga binciken ilimin halayyar ɗan adam da na jijiyoyi saboda yana ba da damar ƙirƙirar da gwada hasashe bayyanannu game da tasirin hulɗa na takamaiman masu canzawa wajen bayyana bambancin a cikin tsananin alamun jarabar ɗabi'a. Tsarin kuma na iya ƙarfafa aikin asibiti (cf. King et al., 2017 ; Potenza, 2017 ) ta hanyar bayyana da bincika yiwuwar masu canzawa waɗanda za su iya wakiltar mahimman maƙasudai don magani (misali, tsammanin, martanin tausayi da fahimta ga abubuwan da ke haifar da hakan). Tsarin I-PACE da aka sabunta shi kuma yana ba da damar samar da hasashe akan matakan hanyoyin jaraba (duka yayin ci gaba da murmurewa), misali ta hanyar jayayya cewa rage takamaiman ikon hana-hana yana hanzarta a matakai na gaba a cikin ci gaban hanyoyin jaraba. Duk da haka, yana da muhimmanci a lura cewa muna ɗaukar samfuran ka'idoji a matsayin masu ƙarfi. Ya kamata a kimanta ingancin takamaiman hasashe, tare da haɗa su cikin tsarin ka'idoji, ta hanyar gwaji, kuma ya kamata a sabunta samfuran ka'idoji ta hanyar la'akari da binciken kimiyya na baya-bayan nan daga ra'ayoyi daban-daban.
Abin da ya kamata a tuna shi ne cewa samfurin ka'idar da aka gabatar ya dogara ne akan matakai daban-daban na shaidar kimiyya dangane da halayen jaraba. Kamar yadda aka ambata a cikin sassan da suka gabata, an yi nazari sosai kan shigar takamaiman hanyoyin tunani da hanyoyin jijiyoyi a cikin matsalar caca da matsalar caca kuma ba a yi bincike sosai ba a wasu nau'ikan halaye waɗanda ka iya zama jaraba, misali amfani da batsa, siyayya-siyayya da hanyar sadarwar zamantakewa. Bugu da ƙari, ga wasu fannoni da hanyoyin da aka gabatar a cikin samfurin I-PACE da aka sabunta, akwai matakai daban-daban na shaida. Don ayyukan zartarwa da ikon hanawa, adadi mai yawa na bincike sun yi amfani da misalai na gwaji kuma sun bincika takamaiman fannoni na aikin zartarwa a cikin nau'ikan halayen jaraba daban-daban. A gefe guda kuma, don amsawa-da-sha'awa da sha'awa a cikin takamaiman halayen jaraba, wasu nazarin sun yi amfani da ƙirar alaƙa, wanda ke sa fassarar dalili da lokacin haɓaka amsawa-da-sha'awa a cikin tsarin jaraba da wahalar bayyanawa ( Zilberman et al., 2019 ). Idan aka yi la'akari da waɗannan iyakoki, yana da mahimmanci a jaddada cewa samfurin da aka gabatar samfurin ka'ida ne wanda ke taƙaita yanayin binciken jarabar ɗabi'a na yanzu kuma yana da nufin ƙarfafa nazarin da ya dogara da ka'ida a nan gaba.
Wata matsala da ke da muhimmanci a yi la'akari da ita ita ce halayen mutum da halayensa ba su da tabbas game da takamaiman halaye na jaraba, ganin cewa waɗannan masu canji suna da hannu a cikin ilimin halayyar ɗan adam da yawa kuma galibi suna bayyana kawai wani yanki mai sauƙi zuwa matsakaici na alamun a cikin cututtuka daban-daban ( Zilberman et al., 2018 ).
Muna kuma son yin tsokaci kan muhawarar da ake yi a yanzu game da rarraba matsalar siyayya da batsa da kuma matsalar amfani da batsa a matsayin matsalolin sarrafa sha'awa ko kuma jarabar ɗabi'a. ICD-11 ya haɗa da amfani da batsa mai matsala a matsayin wani ɓangare na matsalar halayyar jima'i ta tilastawa a cikin nau'in matsalolin sarrafa sha'awa. An jera matsalar siyayya da siyayya a matsayin misali ga wasu takamaiman matsalolin sarrafa sha'awa a cikin kayan aikin lambar ICD-11 ( World-Health-Organization, 2019 ). Duk da haka, masu bincike da yawa suna jayayya cewa nau'ikan cututtuka biyu za a fi rarraba su a matsayin halayen jaraba ( Potenza et al., 2018 ).
Wani ƙalubale ga bincike da gina ka'ida a nan gaba ya haɗa da gano da kuma raba abubuwan da suka shafi juna da bambance-bambance tsakanin cututtuka saboda halayen jaraba da sauran matsalolin tunani, kamar cututtukan da suka shafi obsessive-compulsive da impulsive-control, waɗanda za su iya dangantawa da jarabar ɗabi'a akan matakan tunani da jijiyoyi ( Chamberlain et al., 2016 ; Fineberg et al., 2013 ; Fineberg et al., 2018 ; Robbins et al., 2019 ). Misali, an kuma gabatar da shawarar sarrafa hanawa da sarrafa lada don zama mahimmanci a cikin matsalolin da suka shafi obsessive-compulsive da impulsive-control, kamar yadda aka tattauna a cikin matsalar ɗaukar fata da trichotillomania, waɗanda kuma suna da alaƙa da aiki na da'irorin kwakwalwa na gaba ( Chamberlain et al., 2008 ). Duk da haka, rashin aikin madaukai na gaba-gaba na iya shiga cikin wasu matsalolin lafiyar kwakwalwa da yawa ( Mitelman, 2019 ). Duk da haka, gaskiyar cewa madaukai na fronto-striatal suna da hannu a cikin cututtukan kwakwalwa daban-daban ba lallai bane yana nufin cewa hanyoyin tunani da suka shafi yanayin cututtukan asibiti iri ɗaya ne. Na farko, madaukai na fronto-striatal an fayyace su daban-daban kuma an yi nazari a kansu a cikin nazarin. Nazarin gaba yakamata ya bincika takamaiman gudummawar tsarin da aka bayyana a halin yanzu a cikin madaukai na fronto-striatal zuwa wasu takamaiman hanyoyin tunani da ke ƙarƙashin takamaiman halayen matsala. Na biyu, shigar gabaɗaya na sarrafa hanawa da sarrafa lada ba yana nufin cewa hanyoyin tunani suna kama da juna a cikin cututtuka ba, kodayake akwai wasu haɗuwa na sha'awa/tilastawa da halayen jaraba (misali, Chamberlain et al., 2018 ). Yana da mahimmanci a fayyace ainihin abubuwan da ke haifar da ci gaban lokaci na kwarin gwiwa ga mutane su shiga cikin takamaiman halaye. Misali, a cikin halayen jaraba, yana iya zama cewa manyan dalilan shiga cikin caca ko caca, aƙalla a farkon matakai, sun haɗa da tsammanin lada. A cikin matakai na gaba, guje wa mummunan ji yana iya haɗawa. A cikin rikice-rikicen da ke da alaƙa da damuwa, yana iya zama cewa babban abin da ke motsa jiki a farkon matakai ya ƙunshi guje wa mummunan ji ko damuwa. Daga baya, wannan hali da kansa zai iya zama abin lada domin yana iya taimakawa wajen rage damuwa. A wata ma'anar, shigar da takamaiman ayyukan kwakwalwa ba lallai bane ya bayyana wata cuta gaba ɗaya. Wannan ra'ayi yana iya shafar hanyoyin jijiyoyi. Yana iya zama cewa a cikin rikice-rikice saboda halayen jaraba, ventral striatum yana ba da gudummawa sosai a farkon matakan cutar, dangane da amsawar cue-reactivity da sha'awa. A matakai na gaba, dorsal striatum na iya shiga cikin al'amuran yau da kullun da na tilastawa na cututtukan jaraba. Sabanin haka, dorsal striatum yana da alaƙa da rikice-rikice masu alaƙa da obsessive-compulsive da rikice-rikicen sarrafa motsin rai, kamar trichotillomania, tun daga farkon matakai ( Isobe et al., 2018 ; van den Heuvel et al., 2016 ).
A cikin karatun da za a yi nan gaba, da alama yana da muhimmanci a bincika matakai da cuɗanya da ayyukan neurocognitive daban-daban a cikin nau'ikan halayen jaraba don samun kyakkyawar fahimta game da halayen halayen mutane. Za'a iya amfani da samfurin I-PACE don ƙayyadewa da bayyana takamaiman laifofin da suke cikin binciken waɗannan abubuwan mamaki. Yana da muhimmanci a bincika hanyoyin rabe-rabe a cikin halayyar jaraba tare da kwatanta su da sauran raunin tunani, irin su rikice-rikice-rikice-rikice-rikice-rikice da rikice-rikice don fahimtar ko hanyoyin da ke tattare da yanayin sun bambanta ko kama. A wannan tsari, bayanan da aka samar ya kamata su taimaka wajen bayyana yadda ake iya amfani da wasu sharuddan daban-daban a halin yanzu don bayyana irin hanyoyin da ake amfani dasu a duk rikice-rikice. Ta wannan hanyar, samfurin da aka sabunta a cikin samfurin I-PACE yana ba da tsarin tunani wanda zai iya taimakawa magance manyan tambayoyi game da jaraba, damuwa, tilastawa da sauran rikice-rikice, gami da waɗanda suka shafi amfani da intanet, wanda zai iya zama dacewa fiye da lokaci da aka ba canje-canje a cikin yanayin fasaha na dijital.
Sanin sha'awa
Marubutan sun bayyana cewa ba su da wata takaddama ta sha'awa. Dr. Brand ya karɓi tallafin (ga Jami'ar Duisburg-Essen) daga Gidauniyar Bincike ta Jamus (DFG) , Ma'aikatar Bincike da Ilimi ta Tarayya ta Jamus , Ma'aikatar Lafiya ta Tarayya ta Jamus , da Tarayyar Turai . Dr. Brand ya yi bitar tallafin ga hukumomi da dama; ya gyara sassan mujallu da labarai; ya ba da laccoci na ilimi a wuraren asibiti ko na kimiyya; kuma ya samar da littattafai ko babi na littattafai ga masu buga rubutun lafiyar kwakwalwa. Dr. Potenza ta sami tallafi daga NIH ( R01 DA039136 , R01 DA042911 , R01 DA026437 , R03 DA045289 , R21 DA042911 , da P50 DA09241 ), Sashen Lafiyar Hankali da Ayyukan Jaraba na Connecticut , Majalisar Connecticut kan Caca ta Matsaloli da Cibiyar Wasannin da ke da Alhaki . Dr. Potenza ta tuntuɓi kuma ta ba da shawara ga Rivermend Health, Opiant/Lakelight Therapeutics da Jazz Pharmaceuticals; ya sami tallafin bincike (ga Yale) daga Mohegan Sun Casino da Cibiyar Kasa don Wasannin da ke da Alhaki; ya nemi shawara ko ya ba da shawara ga ƙungiyoyin shari'a da caca kan batutuwan da suka shafi sarrafa sha'awa da halayen jaraba; ya ba da kulawar asibiti da suka shafi sarrafa sha'awa da halayen jaraba; ya yi bita kan tallafin kuɗi; ya gyara mujallu/sassan mujallu; ya ba da laccoci na ilimi a manyan tarurruka, abubuwan da suka faru na CME da sauran wuraren asibiti/kimiyya; kuma ya samar da littattafai ko surori ga masu buga rubutun lafiyar kwakwalwa.
Godiya
Muna godiya da godiya da irin gudummuwar ilimi na Dr. Kimberly S. Young ga sigar farko ta samfurin I-PACE, wadanda suka kasance masu kwazo ga sabon samfurin. Dr. Young ya mutu a watan Fabrairu 2019. Domin tunawa da Dr. Kimberly S. Matashi, mun sadaukar da wannan labarin gare ta.
References
- Alvarez-Monjaras et al., 2018
-
M. Alvarez-Monjaras, LC Mayes, MN Potenza, HJV RutherfordTsarin haɓakawa na jaraba: Haɗa haɓakar ƙwaƙwalwar ƙwaƙwalwar ƙwaƙwalwa da haɓaka ta hanyar ruwan tabarauHaɗa & Ci gaban Dan Adam (2018), shafi na 1-22, 10.1080/14616734.2018.1498113
- APA, 2013
-
<br> <br>Bincike da kuma na ilimin kididdiga Manual da shafi tunanin mutum cuta(Tsarin 5th), APA, Washington DC (2013)
- Argyriou et al., 2017
-
E. Argyriou, CB Davison, TTC LeeInhibition na andaura da Rashin Tsarin Wasannin Yanar Gizo: metaididdige-kayan bincikeBeabi'a masu icara, 71 (2017), pp. 54-60, 10.1016 / j.addbeh.2017.02.026
Del Pino-Gutiérrez et al., 2017
Limbrick-Oldfield et al., 2013
Piazza da Deroche-Gamonet, 2013
World-Health-Organization, 2019