Tambayoyin Mata Masu Ilimin Halayyar Dan Adam . Maris 2018; 42(1): 9–28.
An buga a yanar gizo 2017 Disamba 15. doi: 10.1177/0361684317743019
PMCID: PMC5833025
Kathrin Karsay , 1 Johannes Knoll , 1 da Jörg Mattes 1
Abstract
Masu nazarin ka'idojin Objectification sun nuna cewa fallasa ga kafofin watsa labarai masu lalata yana ƙara nuna son kai tsakanin mutane. Binciken hulɗa da gwaji da ke bincika wannan alaƙar ya sami ƙarin kulawa. Manufar wannan nazarin meta shine bincika tasirin amfani da kafofin watsa labarai masu lalata akan son kai tsakanin mata da maza. Don wannan dalili, mun bincika takardu 54 waɗanda suka samar da bincike 50 masu zaman kansu da girman tasirin 261. Bayanan sun nuna sakamako mai kyau, matsakaici na yin jima'i akan son kai ( r = .19). Tasirin ya kasance mai mahimmanci kuma mai ƙarfi, 95% CI [.15, .23], p < .0001. Mun gano tasirin yanayi na nau'in kafofin watsa labarai, yana nuna cewa amfani da wasannin bidiyo da/ko kafofin watsa labarai na kan layi ya haifar da tasirin son kai idan aka kwatanta da amfani da talabijin. Sauran halaye na samfuri ko halayen bincike ba su daidaita tasirin gaba ɗaya ba. Don haka, bincikenmu ya nuna mahimmancin fallasa kafofin watsa labarai masu lalata akan ra'ayin mata da maza na son kai. Muna tattauna jagororin bincike na gaba da abubuwan da za a yi a aikace. Muna fatan wannan labarin zai ƙarfafa masu bincike a aikinsu na gaba don magance gibin bincike da aka bayyana a nan. Bugu da ƙari, muna fatan cewa binciken zai ƙarfafa masu aiki da iyaye su yi tunani game da rawar da amfani da kafofin watsa labarai masu lalata ke takawa wajen haɓaka son kai na mutane. Ana samun ƙarin kayan aiki na kan layi don wannan labarin a gidan yanar gizon PWQ a http://journals.sagepub.com/doi/suppl10.1177/0361684317743019
Manyan kafofin watsa labarai na yau (misali, talabijin, kayan bugawa, wasannin bidiyo, shafukan sada zumunta) ana nuna su da fifiko kan bayyanar jima'i, kyawun jiki, da kuma sha'awar jima'i ga wasu ( Ƙungiyar Masana Ilimin Halayyar Dan Adam ta Amurka [APA], 2007 ). Wannan nau'in gabatarwa ana yi masa lakabi da lalata ( Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997 ; Ward, 2016 ; Zurbriggen, 2013 ). An soki abubuwan da ke haifar da lalata a kafofin watsa labarai saboda dalilai da yawa. Misali, fallasa ga kafofin watsa labarai masu lalata yana da alaƙa da ƙa'idodin jinsi da aka ƙarfafa (misali, Galdi, Maass, & Cadinu, 2014 ), karuwar karɓar tatsuniyoyi na fyade (misali, Fox, Ralston, Cooper, & Jones, 2015 ), da kuma ƙaruwar rashin gamsuwa a jiki (misali, Halliwell, Malson, & Tischner, 2011 ). A cikin sauran wannan labarin, muna amfani da kalmar "lalata jima'i" lokacin da muke magana game da gabatar da mutane da haruffa a kafofin watsa labarai. Muna magana ne game da abubuwan da ke "yin jima'i" yayin da muke magana game da tasirin kafofin watsa labarai da haruffa a kan mai kallo.
Ta hanyar amfani da ka'idar nuna fifiko ( Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997 ), babban burinmu a cikin wannan binciken shine mu binciki girman, da kuma a cikin wane yanayi, kafofin watsa labarai masu nuna fifikon ...
Masu bincike da yawa sun yi bincike kan alaƙar amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i da kuma nuna son kai ta hanyar gwaji (misali, Andrew, Tiggemann, & Clark, 2016 ; Aubrey, 2006a ; de Vries & Peter, 2013 ; Grabe & Hyde, 2009 ; Grey, Horgan, Long, Herzog, & Lindemulder, 2016 ; Karsay & Matthes, 2015 ; Manago, Ward, Lemm, Reed, & Seabrook, 2015 ; Vandenbosch & Eggermont, 2012 ). Duk da haka, wallafe-wallafen da ke ƙaruwa, gami da binciken sassa daban-daban, binciken kwamitoci, da binciken gwaji, sun haifar da sakamako iri-iri. Saboda haka, masana ba su kai ga cimma matsaya ko yanke hukunci mai gamsarwa ba game da rawar da amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i ke takawa wajen haɓaka nuna son kai. Mun yi niyya ga bincikenmu na meta-analytic don magance wannan buƙata.
Matsalar Zuciya
Ka'idar Objectification ( Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997 ) da tattaunawa game da sanin jiki mai manufa ( McKinley & Hyde, 1996 ) sun yi amfani da ƙa'idodin mata don bayyana abubuwan da mata ke fuskanta na jima'i da kuma mummunan tasirinsa ga lafiyar mata. Masana ka'idoji sun yi nuni da cewa tun suna ƙanana, ana kallon jikin mata, ana yin sharhi a kai, kuma wasu suna kimanta su. 'Yan mata da mata suna koyo daga gogewa da lura da rashin jituwa ta jima'i cewa (sha'awa) sha'awa ita ce babban ɓangare na rawar jinsi na mata, don haka burin da dole ne su yi ƙoƙari a kai ( Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997 ). An ci gaba da faɗaɗa ka'idar objectification zuwa ga al'ummomi daban-daban, ciki har da maza, tsirarun jinsi, da tsirarun kabilu ( Fredrickson, Hendler, Nilsen, & O'Barr, 2011 ).
An bayyana manufar jima'i a matsayin aikin kallon, amfani, da/ko kimanta mutum a matsayin abu (watau, abu) wanda darajarsa ta dogara ne kawai da kyawun jikinsa da na jima'i ( Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997 ). Abubuwan da suka shafi nuna wariya ga jima'i ba wai kawai jima'i ba ne, har ma sun haɗa da matsin lamba na al'umma don ƙirƙirar, gabatar, kiyayewa, da kuma inganta kyawun fuska (watau, sirara ga mata; mafi kyawun tsoka ga maza; Moradi, 2010 , 2011 ; Zurbriggen, 2013 ). Don haka, nuna wariya ga jima'i na iya faruwa ta hanyoyi da yawa kuma ya kama daga nuna nau'in jiki mai kyau, zuwa kimantawa (marasa so) na jikin mutum (misali, kallo, busa, maganganun jima'i), ko cin zarafin jima'i ( Kozee, Tylka, Augustus-Horvath, & Denchik, 2007 ; Moradi, 2011 ).
Fredrickson da Roberts (1997) sun ɗauki nuna son kai ga jima'i da kuma nuna son kai ga jima'i a matsayin kalmomin da za a iya musanyawa. Dangane da Ƙungiyar Aiki kan Nuna Son Kai ga 'Yan Mata, mun fi son kalmar nuna son kai ga jima'i saboda ta haɗa da nuna son kai ga jima'i ( APA, 2007 ). A cewar APA, nuna son kai yana faruwa duk lokacin da (a) aka ƙayyade ƙimar mutum musamman ko kuma kawai daga sha'awar jima'i ko halayensa, maimakon ware wasu halaye; (b) an riƙe mutum bisa ga mizani wanda ya daidaita kyawun jiki da kuma nuna son kai ga jima'i; (c) an nuna son kai ga jima'i; ko (d) an sanya wa mutum jima'i ba daidai ba. Duk wani daga cikin waɗannan sharuɗɗan yana aiki a matsayin alamar nuna son kai ga jima'i.
Kafofin watsa labarai suna taka muhimmiyar rawa wajen fallasa hotuna, rubutu, sautuka, da gogewa masu lalata ( Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997 ). Sakamako daga nazarin abubuwan da ke ciki da yawa ya nuna cewa jima'i yana ko'ina a cikin nau'ikan kafofin watsa labarai iri-iri, kamar talabijin na kiɗa ( Aubrey & Frisby, 2011 ; Vandenbosch, Vervloessem, & Eggermont, 2013 ), mujallu na bugawa ( Stankiewicz & Rosselli, 2008 ), wasannin bidiyo ( Burgess, Stermer, & Burgess, 2007 ), da shafukan sada zumunta ( Hall, West, & McIntyre, 2012 ; Kapidzic & Herring, 2015 ).
Ƙaddamar da Kai
Moradi (2011) ya yi hasashen cewa abubuwan da suka shafi jima'i suna haifar da fahimtar juna game da muhimmancin yadda mutum ke "bayyana" da kuma kyawawan halaye, wanda hakan ke haifar da nuna son kai. A cewar ka'idar nuna son kai ( Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997 ), nuna son kai yana da alaƙa da tsarin tunani wanda ke fassara abubuwan da suka shafi jima'i a matakin al'adu zuwa halayen tunani da halaye na lafiyar kwakwalwa da walwala a matakin mutum ɗaya ( Calogero, Tantleff-Dunn, & Thompson, 2011 ; Moradi, 2010 , 2011 ; Moradi & Huang, 2008 ). Misali, nazarin gwaji ya nuna cewa nuna son kai yana annabta girman kunyar jiki da kuma yawan damuwa a bayyanar jiki ( Moradi & Huang, 2008 ).
An gina gine-ginen kayan aikin kai tsaye a matsayin mai koya fasalin (Calogero, 2011). Duk da haka, ana iya ɗaukar shi ta ɗan lokaci, kamar ta hanyar yin amfani da labaru, kuma zai iya haifar da wani jihar na son objectification (Calogero, 2011, Moradi & Huang, 2008). Akwai hanyoyi daban-daban don aiwatar da rahoton kai kwarewar kai-kai saboda masu bincike sun fahimci shi a matsayin wata manufa mai yawa (Calogero, 2011; Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997; Vandenbosch & Eggermont, 2012, 2013). Kayan aiki na mutum ya ƙunshi abubuwa masu hankali, irin su darajar bayyanar da kwarewa (kamar yadda ma'auni na Tambaya (Self-Objectification Questionnaire) [SOQ] ya auna; Noll & Fredrickson, 1998), da kuma halayen halayya, kamar su shiga cikin kulawar jiki na yau da kullum (kamar yadda aka auna ta hanyar Sanya ido na Siffar Ƙididdiga na Jirgin Ƙirƙirar [OBCS]; McKinley & Hyde, 1996). Sakamakon SOQ da Sashen OBCS sun nuna rashin daidaituwa tsakanin juna tsakanin juna (misali, Aubrey, 2006a; Calogero, Herbozo, & Thompson, 2009; Vandenbosch & Eggermont, 2015a). Sakamakon kula da jiki, duk da haka, ya kasance da alaƙa da alaka da mummunar sakamako, irin su mummunan yanayin jiki da matsalar kiwon lafiya, idan aka kwatanta da kwarewar mutum (Moradi & Huang, 2008). Ko da yake duka SOQ da OBCS suna da matakan amincewa da inganci a cikin samfurori daban-daban, kuma waɗannan ra'ayoyin biyu na kayan kai-kai sun yi mahimmanci, ba su dace ba (Calogero, 2011; Moradi & Huang, 2008).
Yawanci, a cikin binciken gwaji, an auna yanayin da aka haifar da ƙira ta hanyar amfani da gwajin Bayanan Ashirin na Fredrickson, Roberts, Noll, Quinn, da Twenge (1998) (TST). Bayan magudin gwaji, masu amsa sun cika jimloli har zuwa 20 waɗanda suka fara da "Ni ne." Bayan haka, an tsara maganganun da suka shafi bayyanar kuma an ayyana su a matsayin yanayin da aka saba amfani da shi. Kodayake TST ya kasance ma'auni da aka saba amfani da shi a cikin binciken gwaji, ya kasance matsala saboda ƙarancin matakan bambance-bambance (misali, Aubrey, 2010 ; Aubrey, Henson, Hopper, & Smith, 2009 ; Karsay & Matthes, 2016 ). Masu bincike sun kuma yi amfani da sigar da aka gyara na SOQ ko ƙaramin sikelin OBCS a cikin binciken gwaji don auna yanayin da aka ƙara girman son kai ( Calogero, 2011 ). Kamar yadda aka ambata a baya, nazarin da ke kan alaƙar da ke tsakanin kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i da son kai sun haifar da sakamako iri ɗaya. A cikin sassan da ke gaba, za mu bayyana abubuwan da aka gano a yanzu game da alaƙar da ke tsakanin amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i da kuma kin amincewa da kai daga hulɗa (bangarori da na dogon lokaci) da kuma binciken gwaji. Sai dai idan an lura akasin haka, muna amfani da kalmar kin amincewa da kai idan an yi amfani da ɗayan matakan da aka ambata a sama.
Binciken hulda
Yawancin nazarin alaƙar da ke tsakanin ɓangarorin biyu sun nuna cewa amfani da shirye-shiryen talabijin da mujallu da kuma amfani da shafukan sada zumunta, kamar Facebook ko Pinterest, suna da alaƙa mai kyau da nuna son kai tsakanin mata da maza, da kuma tsakanin 'yan mata da samari ( Aubrey, 2007 ; Fardouly, Diedrichs, Vartanian, & Halliwell, 2015 ; Fox & Rooney, 2015 ; Kim, Seo, & Baek, 2015 ; Manago et al., 2015 ; Nowatzki & Morry, 2009 ; Tiggemann & Slater, 2014 , 2015 ; Vandenbosch & Eggermont, 2015a ). Duk da haka, akwai keɓancewa. Misali, a cikin wani bincike da Morry da Staska (2001) suka yi , amfani da mujallun kyau ko motsa jiki ba su da alaƙa da nuna son kai tsakanin maza. An kuma sami sakamako iri-iri don amfani da bidiyon talabijin da kiɗa na kiɗa; Fardouly, Diedrichs, Vartanian, da Halliwell (2015) ba su sami wata alaƙa da nuna son kai da bidiyon kiɗa a tsakanin mata ba, amma wasu masu bincike ( Grabe & Hyde, 2009 ; Vandenbosch & Eggermont, 2015a ) sun yi wa 'yan mata da maza duka. Meier da Gray (2014) sun nuna cewa amfani da Facebook kawai dangane da kamanni, amma ba na gabaɗaya ba, yana da alaƙa mai kyau da nuna son kai a tsakanin 'yan mata.
Masu bincike kaɗan ne kawai suka yi amfani da wani tsari na bincike na kwamitin (watau, na tsawon lokaci). Aubrey (2006a ) sun gano cewa fallasa ga talabijin mai lalata yana nuna halayen son kai ga mata da maza na jami'a, amma fallasa ga mata na kafofin watsa labarai yana nuna sa ido ga jiki ga maza kawai. Doornwaard et al. (2014) sun kuma gano bambance-bambancen jinsi tsakanin matasa. Amfani da kayan intanet masu bayyana jima'i sun annabta sa ido ga jikin maza ne kawai. Sabanin haka, amfani da shafukan sada zumunta sun annabta sa ido ga jiki ne kawai tsakanin 'yan mata. Vandenbosch da Eggermont (2015a ) sun gano bambance-bambance tsakanin nau'ikan kafofin watsa labarai amma ba tsakanin 'yan mata da maza ba. Amfani da kafofin watsa labarai masu lalata (misali, mujallu da talabijin na kiɗa) sun annabta sa ido ga kai ta hanyar shigar da manufofin bayyanar ciki. Duk da haka, amfani da shafukan sada zumunta bai annabta sa ido ga kai tsakanin matasa ba. Ma'aunin kafofin watsa labarai na iya zama bayani mai yiwuwa game da dalilin da ya sa binciken da aka samu daga nazarin alaƙa ya bambanta sosai. Yayin da wasu bincike suka haɗa da ma'aunin amfani da kafofin watsa labarai marasa bambanci, wasu sun binciki ƙananan nau'ikan kafofin watsa labarai ko abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai.
Idan aka kwatanta da binciken gwaji, fa'idar bayanan bincike ita ce mahalarta ba a tilasta musu kallon ko karanta abubuwan da ke lalata da kafofin watsa labarai ba, sai dai su bayar da rahoton yadda suke fallasa a kafofin watsa labarai. Duk da haka, rashin ingantattun ma'auni masu inganci na fallasa a kafofin watsa labarai yana wakiltar babban ƙalubale a binciken tasirin kafofin watsa labarai wanda zai iya haifar da ƙananan sakamako ko rashin daidaituwa ( de Vreese & Neijens, 2016 ; Valkenburg & Peter, 2013 ). Bayanan da aka bayar da rahoton kansu na iya zama marasa tushe saboda fahimi (misali, ƙwaƙwalwar da ba ta dace ba) ko dalilai masu motsa rai (misali, sha'awar zamantakewa; Valkenburg & Peter, 2013 ).
Binciken gwaji
Nazarin gwaje-gwajen zai iya haifar da ƙaddara game da sakamakon tasirin watsa labaru a kan ƙwarewar mutum ta hanyar ƙaddamar da binciken bincike da kuma magudi mai sauƙi na tayin mai zaman kanta. A gefen ƙananan, ban da ƙalubalantar kalubale na gabatar da mahalarta a cikin abun ciki na jima'i, wani dakin gwaje-gwaje a koyaushe yana kunshe da yanayi na artificial don amfani da kafofin watsa labarai. Bugu da ƙari, ɗaukar hotuna da jima'i a cikin gwajin gwaji na wakiltar kashi ne kawai na yawan masu halartar mahalarta cikin rayuwarsu ta yau da kullum.
Nazarce-nazarce da yawa na gwaji sun gano ƙaruwar nuna son kai tsakanin mata bayan ɗan lokaci da suka fallasa abubuwan da ke haifar da jima'i a kafofin watsa labarai. Bayyana hotunan mata masu haifar da jima'i ( Aubrey et al., 2009 ; de Vries & Peter, 2013 ; Grey et al., 2016 ; Hopper & Aubrey, 2016 ), bidiyon kiɗa masu haifar da jima'i ( Aubrey & Gerding, 2015 ; Karsay & Matthes, 2015 ), da kuma avatars na wasan bidiyo masu haifar da jima'i ( Fox, Bailenson, & Tricase, 2013 ; Fox et al., 2015 ) sun ƙara nuna son kai tsakanin mata matasa. Ƙananan binciken gwaji da suka binciki maza sun nuna cewa fallasa maza ga hotunan maza masu haifar da jima'i bai ƙara nuna son kai ba ( Kalodner, 1997 ; Michaels, Parent, & Moradi, 2013 ).
Ƙananan binciken gwaji da aka gudanar da matasa sun haifar da sakamako daban-daban. MA Miller (2007) bai sami wani tasiri ba bayan fallasa 'yan mata ga hotunan jima'i, amma Daniels (2009) ya nuna tasirin hulɗa na shekaru da yanayin gwaji, yana nuna cewa 'yan mata sun fi kamuwa da mummunan tasirin hotunan jima'i, idan aka kwatanta da mata. Mun gano wani bincike na gwaji guda ɗaya kawai da samari da 'yan mata matasa a matsayin mahalarta. Vandenbosch, Driesmans, Trekels, da Eggermont (2015) sun nuna cewa yin wasan bidiyo tare da hoton jima'i yana haɓaka ƙara son kai tsakanin matasa. Wannan tasirin ba ya dogara da jinsi na matasa.
Nazarin Yau
Meta-bincike na iya ƙaddamar da haske a kan sakamako masu rarrabe ta hanyar ƙididdige girman sakamako (O'Keefe, 2017). Bugu da ƙari, ma'anar sakamako mai haɗaka za a iya fahimta ta ƙara masu dacewa masu dacewa zuwa bincike. Kodayake yawan nazarin nazarin maganganun da ake amfani da su na maganganun da ake amfani da su, da kuma siffar jikin mutum (misali, Barlett, Wasula, & Saucier, 2008; Grabe, Ward, & Hyde, 2008; Groesz, Levine, & Murnen, 2002; Hausenblas et al., 2013; Holmstrom, 2004; Ka so, 2009), babu wani zane-zane mai mahimmanci wanda yayi nazari a fili game da tasiri na yin amfani da jarida ta hanyar jima'i akan yin amfani da kai. Har zuwa yau, ƙididdiga guda uku kawai kawai (Grabe et al., 2008) da kuma bayanai na biyu (López-Guimerà, Levine, Sánchez-carracedo, da Fauquet, 2010; Ward, 2016) sun gabatar da kayan kai-da-dai-dai a matsayin wani ɓangare na rashin jin daɗin jiki-zuwa bincike. Mun nemi taimaka wa littattafai kamar haka: Na farko, wannan shine farkon zane-zane wanda yayi bincike a fili cewa yin amfani da kafofin watsa labaran jima'i zai kara karuwa. Ward (2016) da ake kira na bincike-bincike-bincike wanda yayi nazarin wannan dangantaka. Na biyu, mun hada da dukkanin zane-zane na bincike a bincikenmu, gwada yiwuwar bambance-bambance tsakanin su-cross-sectional, panel, da kuma gwaji. Na uku, mun haɗa duk binciken da ake samuwa - ko da kuwa yanayin asalin su - a cikin nazarin, idan sun kasance a Turanci. Saboda haka, ba mu ƙuntata samfurinmu ga ƙasashen Ingilishi ba, kamar yadda yake a cikin wasu ƙididdigar wasu (misali, Grabe et al., 2008). Hudu, mun yi amfani da tsarin ingantacciyar hanya. Mun ƙididdige samfurin ƙirar harshe don ɗaukar dukkanin tasiri mai tasiri a cikin lissafi ba tare da tarawa da asarar bayanin (Cheung, 2014; Field, 2015). Wannan hanya ta hanya ta ƙyale mu mu gwada gwagwarmayar tasiri da kuma matsayin wasu masu dacewa masu dacewa da dama. A ƙarshe, mun gano matakan binciken bincike dacewa ta hanyar bincike-bincike na yanzu. Bisa ga bincikenmu, mun bayar da shawarar da za a gudanar da bincike na gaba don kara da tasirin tashar watsa labarun da kuma bincike game da jikin mutum.1
Hanyar
Bincike
Siffa ta 1 ta nuna dabarun bincikenmu da kuma tsarin cire takardu. Mun tattara takardun binciken da ake yi a yanzu daga manyan rumbunan bayanai guda biyu a fannin ilimin halayyar dan adam (PsycINFO) da sadarwa (Communication and Mass Media Complete). Bugu da ƙari, mun duba shirye-shiryen taron shekara-shekara na Ƙungiyar Ilimi a Aikin Jarida da Sadarwa da Ƙungiyar Sadarwa ta Duniya. Mun takaita bincikenmu ga bincike da aka rubuta da Turanci kuma ana samunsa har zuwa watan Yunin 2016. Mun bincika rumbunan bayanai ta hanyar amfani da kalmar objectification* ba tare da kuma tare da kafofin watsa labarai* a cikin kowane filin bincike da ake da shi ba. Haka kuma, mun yi amfani da kalmomin kula da jiki, kula da kai, objectifi*, da objectify* tare da kalmar media*, bi da bi. Alamar ta ba da damar kalmomin su sami duk ƙarshen da zai yiwu. Don gano ƙarin littattafai, mun bincika mujallu uku (watau, Hoton Jiki , Matsayin Jima'i , da Ilimin Halayyar Mata na Kwata ), waɗanda muka ɗauka suna da matukar dacewa da nazarinmu. Mun kuma yi amfani da tsarin ƙwallon dusar ƙanƙara ta hanyar bincika jerin abubuwan da aka yi nazari a kansu da dama, musamman jerin abubuwan da aka yi nazari a kansu (misali, Grabe et al., 2008 ; Ward, 2016 ). Mun yi la'akari da takardu da aka buga da waɗanda ba a buga ba (misali, takardun taro, rubuce-rubucen digiri), kuma wannan binciken ya haifar da samfurin farko na takardu 622.
Zaɓin Takardun
Mun yi amfani da matakai uku don biyan jerin abubuwan da muka dace don maganin nan. Na farko, marubucin farko ya cire dukkan bincike-bincike, bincike-bincike, nazarin bayanai, binciken bincike, bincike-binciken, dubawa, sharhi, da kuma bincike ba tare da alaƙa da batun ba (misali, anthropology, ilimin lissafi, fasaha) ta hanyar yin la'akari da lakabi da ɗan littafin kowane takarda. A wannan mataki na farko, mun cire takardun 309.
A mataki na biyu, mun yi amfani da ka'idoji guda uku na haɗawa, waɗanda suka dace da ma'aunin amfani da kafofin watsa labarai, ma'aunin nuna son kai, da abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai. An yi cikakken bayani game da dukkan masu canji guda uku a ƙasa a matsayin wani ɓangare na nazarin masu gudanarwa: (1) A cikin binciken da suka gabata, an tambayi mahalarta game da, ba kawai yadda kafofin watsa labarai suka ba da rahoton kansu ba, har ma da fahimtarsu game da matsin lamba daga kafofin watsa labarai don su bi ƙa'idodin kyau da ake da su (misali, Ra'ayoyin Al'adu Game da Bayyanar Siffa ta 3; Thompson, van den Berg, Roehrig, Guarda, & Heinberg, 2004 ). Duk da haka, muna sha'awar kawai hanyar haɗin kai tsaye ta amfani da kafofin watsa labarai da kuma nuna son kai; don haka, mun haɗa da waɗannan nazarin ne kawai waɗanda suka tattara bayanai kan adadin lokaci da mita na mahalarta ta amfani da matsakaici. Mun haɗa da nazarin gwaji kawai waɗanda suka gabatar da ƙarfafa kafofin watsa labarai a cikin yanayin gwaji da yanayin sarrafawa. (2) Dole ne nuna son kai ya zama mai dogaro a cikin nazarin gwaji. A cikin nazarin alaƙa, dole ne a tantance nuna son kai a matsayin ɗaya daga cikin masu canji da aka bincika. (3) Nazarin gwaji dole ne ya ƙunshi ƙungiyoyin da aka fallasa ga abubuwan da ke haifar da jima'i ko abubuwan da ke mayar da hankali kan bayyanar kafofin watsa labarai. Lokacin da aka fallasa ƙungiyar gwajin ga abubuwan da ke haifar da gabaɗaya na kafofin watsa labarai kawai, ba a rubuta girman tasirin da ya dace ba kuma ba a haɗa shi cikin binciken ba. Yanayin sarrafawa na iya haɗawa da ko dai hotuna marasa alaƙa da jima'i (watau, babu ko kaɗan daga cikin nassoshi masu alaƙa da jima'i) ko babu mutane kwata-kwata. Da wannan mataki na biyu, mun cire takardu 240.
A mataki na uku da na ƙarshe, mun cire duk takardun da suka bayyana wani shiga tsakani (misali, Choma et al., 2010 ; Harrison & Hefner, 2014 ; Veldhuis, Konijn, & Seidell, 2014 ). Wannan ya maye gurbin duk wani bincike da ke da nufin magance tasirin da kafofin watsa labarai ke haifarwa na son kai (misali, gabatar da kayan karatu na kafofin watsa labarai kafin fallasa kafofin watsa labarai). Wasu nazarin shiga tsakani suna tattara bayanai na asali (misali, kafin shiga tsakani) kan amfani da kafofin watsa labarai da ma'aunin halaye (misali, son kai) don bayyana samfurin su sosai ko kuma la'akari da masu daidaitawa a cikin nazarin tasirin shiga tsakani. Waɗannan bayanai za su dace da bincikenmu. Duk da haka, yawancin nazarin shiga tsakani a cikin samfurinmu ba su yi amfani da ƙirar kafin shiga ba amma sun yi amfani da hanyar bayan shiga kawai. Sauran nazarin shiga tsakani ba su auna amfani da kafofin watsa labarai a Lokaci na 1 ba ( t 1) kuma wasu nazarin ba su bayar da rahoto kan yiwuwar alaƙar ba. Don haka, babu wata alaƙa da ta shafi nazarin meta kuma mun cire duk ƙirar nazarin shiga tsakani daga samfurinmu.
Ba mu haɗa da takardu waɗanda ba a iya samu ba (ba a samun su a yanar gizo ba) ko kuma waɗanda ba su bayar da bayanan kididdiga da ake buƙata don ƙididdige girman tasirin ba. Mun tuntuɓi marubuta takwas don samun kwafin rubutunsu da marubuta biyu don samun ƙarin bayanan ƙididdiga; marubuta biyar ba su amsa ba kuma dole ne mu cire takardu biyar saboda rashin bayanai. Mun kuma cire duk kwafi. Wato, wasu takardu suna samuwa a matsayin rubutun digiri da kuma takardu da aka buga ko kuma takardun taro da kuma takardu da aka buga. A cikin waɗannan sharuɗɗan ban da ɗaya, mun sanya lambar takaddun da aka buga. Banda ita ce takardar da Aubrey da Taylor suka rubuta; mun yanke shawarar sanya lambar takardar taron ( Aubrey & Taylor, 2005 ) maimakon takardar da aka buga ( Aubrey & Taylor, 2009 ) saboda ta samar da ƙarin girman tasirin don nazarin meta-analysis. Mataki na uku kuma na ƙarshe ya haifar da cire takardu 19.
Sample na Samun Nazarin
Samfurin ƙarshe ya ƙunshi takardu 54. Waɗannan takardu sun samar da bincike mai zaman kansa guda 50 (watau, samfurori masu zaman kansu) tare da jimillar mahalarta 15,100. Samfurinmu ya ƙunshi labarai daga mujallu 27, takardu 4 na taro, da kuma rubuce-rubuce 2. Tebur na 1 ya ba da taƙaitaccen bayani game da nazarin da aka haɗa da kuma masu canji a cikin nazarin meta-analysis. Adadin nazarin ya yi ƙasa da adadin takardu tunda akwai takardu da yawa waɗanda suka dogara da samfurin iri ɗaya. 2 Mun yi la'akari da sakamakon irin waɗannan takardu kamar yadda aka samo daga wannan binciken; wato, mun ƙididdige girman tasirinsu kuma daga baya muka ɗauke su a matsayin waɗanda suka samo asali daga wani bincike guda ɗaya ( Guo, 2016 ). Girman samfurinmu da jimlar adadin mahalarta sun dace don gudanar da nazarin meta-analysis (duba Pigott, 2012 ).
Bayanan Mai Bayani
Mun yi sha'awar ko halayen ƙira na samfuri ko nazari za su daidaita alaƙar da aka tsara tsakanin amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i da kuma nuna son kai. Bincikenmu na masu yin sulhu ya takaita ga waɗanda (a) suka dace da ka'ida, (b) sun samar da isasshen adadin girman sakamako, kuma (c) sun nuna isasshen bambanci don gwada daidaiton. Misali, mun haɗa da jinsi a matsayin mai gudanarwa saboda ka'idar nuna son kai ( Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997 ) ya bayyana dalilin da yasa mata ke fuskantar ƙarin gogewa na nuna son kai a rayuwarsu ta yau da kullun fiye da maza. Don haka, ana iya tsammanin girman tasirin da ya fi girma don nuna son kai ga mata idan aka kwatanta da maza. Higgins da Green (2011) sun ba da shawarar yin la'akari da nazarin mai gudanarwa kawai idan akwai bincike 10 ko fiye da suka haɗa da masu gudanarwa. Ga masu yin sulhu na rukuni (misali, nau'in kafofin watsa labarai), waɗannan nau'ikan masu gudanarwa ne kawai ke cikin aƙalla bincike biyu daban-daban aka haɗa. Mun bambanta tsakanin masu yin sulhu dangane da halayen samfuri da halayen ƙirar bincike.
Ayyukan Samfurori
Mun bincika ko shekarun mahalarta sunyi jagorantar sakamakon ta hanyar ƙayyade shekarun da suka wuce. Kuma mun hada da jinsi da aka rarraba a cikin kowane samfurin, wanda aka sanya shi a matsayin namiji (0), haɗe (1), ko mace (2), a matsayin mai gudanarwa. An kirkiro kabilanci, yawan nau'o'i na White ko Caucasian, don yin nazari a Amurka. Har ila yau, mun haɗa da matakan dichotomous wanda ya nuna ko mahalarta yawanci dalibai ne (1) ko a'a (0).
Ayyukan Harkokin Nazarin
Mun hada da masu biyowa guda shida masu bambanta don halaye na zane-zane:
Sakamakon yin amfani da kai
Dangane da tunani mai zurfi ( Calogero, 2011 ; Moradi & Huang, 2008 ) da kuma nazarin meta na Grabe et al. (2008) , mun haɗa da ma'aunin da aka fi sani na son kai. Mun rubuta lambar TST (1) kuma mun gyara nau'ikan TST waɗanda suka bi ƙa'idar ɗaya ta lissafa bayanin kai da ya shafi kamanni (sabanin wanda ba ya da alaƙa da bayyanar). Mun kuma rubuta lambar SOQ (2), ƙaramin sikelin OBCS na Kulawa (3), ƙaramin sikelin Kulawa na Objectified Body Consciousness Scale-Youth (4; OBCS-Y; Lindberg, Hyde, & McKinley, 2006 ), ƙaramin sikelin Kulawar Jiki na Jama'a na Tambayar Kulawar Jiki (5; BSC; LC Miller, Murphy, & Buss, 1981 ), da sauran (= kula da fuska; 6). Mun haɗa da BSC saboda sikelin yana tantance jin daɗin sanin kai a cikin aikace-aikacen jiki kuma don haka yana nuna ƙarfin son kai ( McKinley & Hyde, 1996 ). Mun yi amfani da wani bincike wanda ya yi amfani da sikelin sa ido kan fuska ( Kim et al., 2015 ) saboda yana wakiltar wani nau'in son kai na musamman ga al'ada.
Nau'in tsari
Mun sanya nau'in ƙirar binciken a matsayin ƙirar gwaji (0), binciken sassa (1), ko binciken bangarori (2). Mun sanya girman tasirin daga nazarin gwaji a matsayin ƙirar gwaji; girman tasirin da ke nuna bayanan bincike daga lokaci 1 (misali, amfani da kafofin watsa labarai masu lalata t 1 da kuma amfani da kai t 1) an sanya shi a matsayin binciken sassa; girman tasirin da ke nuna bayanan bincike daga lokaci 2, wato, bayanan da ba su da jinkiri (misali, amfani da kafofin watsa labarai masu lalata t 1 da kuma amfani da kai Time 2 [ t 2]), an sanya shi a matsayin binciken bangarori.
Media type
Muna so mu san ko ma'anar matsakaici na matsakaici yadda tasirin ya yi amfani da shi don yin amfani da kai. Mun ƙayyade cikakken amfani da talabijin, yin amfani da shirye-shiryen talabijin na musamman ko nuna (misali, sitcoms, bidiyo bidiyo), da kuma gabatar da kayan audiovisual a cikin gwaji (misali, shirye-shiryen bidiyo, tallace-tallace na talabijin) a cikin talabijin (0). Lokacin da aka yi amfani da jaridun bugawa ko lokacin da masu halartar ke nunawa hotunan ko tallace-tallace bugawa a cikin gwaje-gwajen (ko da an gudanar da binciken a yanar-gizon), mun ƙaddamar da matsakaici kamar yadda aka buga (1). Amfani da Intanet ko hanyoyin yanar sadarwar zamantakewa an tsara su ne a yanar gizo (2). Mun ƙayyade kallon kallon wasan kwaikwayo kamar wasan bidiyo (3). Sauraron kiɗa an tsara shi ne a matsayin kiɗa (4).
Abubuwan jarida
Mun tantance abubuwan da ke cikin jarida kamar yadda jima'i da bayyanar ido (0) suke, mayar da hankali (ba jima'i ba; 1), ko kuma general (2). Don kaucewa rikicewa, zamu koma cikin ragowar rubutun zuwa jigon farko kamar "jima'i." Mun gano abun da ke cikin jarida a matsayin jima'i lokacin da ya dace da APA (2007) definition of sexualization. Don ƙididdige nazarin gwaje-gwajen, muna karanta labaran abin da ya dace, kuma, idan aka ba da shi, dubi hotuna na abin da ya dace. Don nazarin hulda, mun bayyana matakan da ake bi a matsayin jima'i: batsa, abin da ake kira "jarida matasa" (watau kafofin watsa labaru da aka tsara musamman a mazaunan sauraren maza irin su Maxim or FHM), bidiyo na kiɗa, talabijin na talabijin, talabijin na gaskiya, da launi, kyau, da kuma mujallu na matasa (APA, 2007; Klaassen & Bitrus, 2015; Stankiewicz & Rosselli, 2008; Vandenbosch et al., 2013). A wasu nazarin hulda (misali, Aubrey, 2006a, 2006b; Vandenbosch & Eggermont, 2013), mawallafa sunyi amfani da hanya domin su sanya nauyin da ya fi dacewa ga kafofin watsa labarun da ake ganin karin jima'i. Masu amsawa sun nuna amfani da su da dama da kuma nau'in watsa labarai. Bayan karbar bayanai, wani juriya mai zaman kanta ya ba da labarin kafofin watsa labaru game da mita da kuma ƙarfin jima'i. Bisa la'akari da jimlar juri, an kirkiro jimillar jima'i don kowane matsakaici da kuma amfani da nauyin hanyoyin watsa labaru (don ƙarin bayani game da hanya, gani Zurbriggen, Ramsey, & Jaworski, 2011). Mun bi da matakan da aka auna nauyin watsa labarun yada labarai game da jima'i. Wasu masu bincike sun haɗa da su a cikin littattafan da suka yi nazari kan su wanda bai dace ba ko jima'i (misali, Aubrey, 2010; Harrison & Fredrickson, 2003; Meier & Grey, 2014) amma har yanzu yana da alaka da binciken. Mun lissafa wannan ƙungiyar watsa labarun ba tare da nuna bambanci ta hanyar fassara shi ba kamar yadda aka mayar da hankali (Moradi, 2010; Vandenbosch & Eggermont, 2015a). Alal misali, kallon ko aika hotuna akan Facebook (Meier & Grey, 2014) an rarraba shi a matsayin abin da aka mayar da hankali. Harkokin gwaji da ke nuna masu halartar su zuwa shafuka tare da siffar bayyanar, kamar yadda ya bambanta daga tsarin kiwon lafiya, an tsara shi azaman abin da aka mayar da hankali (bayyanar da ido)Aubrey, 2010). A ƙarshe, mun ƙayyade cikakken amfani da Intanet, shafukan sadarwar zamantakewa, ko talabijin, kazalika da yin amfani da labaru da kafofin watsa labaru, kamar yadda tasirin watsa labarai ke gudana.
Sashen nazarin da shekarar da aka buga
Mun ƙayyade wurin binciken da aka dogara kan nahiyar da aka gudanar da binciken: Arewacin Amirka (1), Turai (2), Asia (3), da Australia da Oceania (4). Idan ba a ba da labarin a nahiyar ko ƙasar ba, haɗin mawallafin sun kasance mai nuna alama. Kuma mun hada da shekara ta bugawa a matsayin mai dacewa a cikin binciken.
Yin amfani da shi cikin aiki
Domin tantance amincin masu coder tsakanin lambobi, masu coder guda biyu (marubuci na farko da na biyu) sun rubuta ƙaramin samfurin girman tasirin 36. Krippendorff (2004) α ya kasance cikakke (α = 1.0) ga duk masu canzawa, sai dai ma'aunin mai daidaitawa na son kai (α = .92). An warware bambance-bambancen ta hanyar tattaunawa bayan sake duba binciken da aka yi. Bayan haka, masu coder guda biyu sun rubuta duk masu canzawa bisa ga bayanan da ke cikin rubuce-rubucen.
Ƙididdigar Ƙididdiga da Ƙimar Girma Ƙididdiga
Misalin lissafi
Nazarce-nazarce da dama sun bayar da rahoton sakamako da ya ba mu damar ƙididdige girman tasirin fiye da ɗaya a kowane bincike. Yin nazarin meta akan waɗannan nazarin zai karya zato na 'yancin kai na girman tasirin kuma ya sanya ƙarin nauyi ga binciken da ke samar da girman tasirin fiye da ɗaya. Masu bincike kwanan nan sun ba da shawarar ɗaukar meta-analysis a matsayin samfurin matakai da yawa don magance waɗannan batutuwa (misali, Cheung, 2014 ; Field, 2015 ; Konstantopoulos, 2011 ). Asalin ra'ayin yana da girman tasirin (matakin farko) a cikin binciken (mataki na biyu; Konstantopoulos, 2011 ; don ƙarin bayani dalla-dalla, duba Field, 2015 ). Girman tasirin da ya samo asali daga wannan binciken yana samun irin wannan tasirin bazuwar, yayin da girman tasirin da ya samo asali daga bincike daban-daban suna samun tasirin bazuwar daban-daban. Saboda haka, dogaro ko 'yancin kai na girman sakamako an tsara shi a sarari ta hanyar sanya madaidaicin tasirin bazuwar ( Konstantopoulos, 2011 ; Viechtbauer, 2015 ). Saboda haka, ana iya la'akari da duk girman tasirin ba tare da tattarawa da asarar bayanai ba. Wannan tsari yana da matuƙar amfani idan ana maganar nazarin mai gudanarwa saboda girman tasirin da yawa a cikin nazarin yawanci suna da alaƙa da matakai daban-daban na canjin mai gudanarwa. Sakamakon ya kasance iri ɗaya lokacin da ake ƙididdigewa cikin sauƙi maimakon samfuran komawa baya da yawa.
Mun rubuta waɗannan bayanai ga kowane takarda: (a) duk girman tasirin, gami da bambance-bambancen rukuni, ma'ana, karkacewar daidaito, da kurakurai na yau da kullun a cikin binciken gwaji. Idan yanayi da yawa sun dace da buƙatun ƙungiyar sarrafawa, mun haɗa da girman tasirin ga kowane rukunin sarrafawa. A cikin nazarin alaƙa, mun rubuta Pearson's r ; idan nazarin alaƙar bincike ne na kwamitin, mun rubuta duk girman tasirin da ake da shi, matuƙar ba a yi amfani da kafofin watsa labarai ba (watau, amfani da kafofin watsa labarai t 1 da fifikon kai t 1, amfani da kafofin watsa labarai t 1 da fifikon kai t 2, da amfani da kafofin watsa labarai t 2 da fifikon kai t 2). Kuma mun rubuta (b) duk masu gudanarwa.
Girman lissafi
Mun yi amfani da r na Pearson a matsayin kimanta girman tasirin saboda ana iya fassara shi cikin sauƙi dangane da mahimmancinsa na aiki. Girmansa yana da iyaka daga 0 zuwa 1 ( Rosenthal & DiMatteo, 2001 ). R mai kyau yana nuna cewa yayin da amfani da kafofin watsa labarai ke ƙaruwa, ƙimar kai tana ƙaruwa. A cikin nazarin alaƙa, mun ɗauki r kai tsaye daga labaran. A wani yanayi ( Doornwaard et al., 2014 ), mun sanya ma'aunin daidaitawa na daidaito maimakon haka, kuma mun canza shi zuwa r bisa ga dabarar da Peterson da Brown suka bayar (2005) . A cikin nazarin gwaji, mun ƙididdige r bisa ga dabarun da Lipsey da Wilson (2001) suka bayar . Kafin yin haɗakar, mun canza ma'aunin haɗin gwiwa ( r ) zuwa sikelin z na Fisher ( Zr ; Borenstein, Hedges, Higgins, & Rothstein, 2009 ; Lipsey & Wilson, 2001 ). A jimilla, mun sami girman sakamako 261.
Mun gudanar da nazarin meta ta hanyar amfani da fakitin metafor na R ( Viechtbauer, 2010 ). Mun dogara da kimantawa akan samfuran tasirin bazuwar. Samfuran tasirin bazuwar suna ɗaukar bambancin girman tasirin gaske, misali, saboda mahalarta ko jiyya daban-daban. Bugu da ƙari, sakamakon tasirin bazuwar na iya zama gabaɗaya fiye da nazarin da aka haɗa a cikin binciken saboda ana ɗaukar nazarin da aka bincika a matsayin wani ɓangare na babban yawan jama'ar bincike ( Hedges & Vevea, 1998 ). An gudanar da nazarin mai gudanarwa ta amfani da aikin rma.mv() na fakitin metafor na R, wanda ya ba da damar kimanta samfuran tasirin gauraye masu matakai da yawa ( Viechtbauer, 2010 ). Mun gudanar da nazarin tasirin gaba ɗaya da bita tare da girman sakamako da aka tattara a cikin nazarin ta amfani da aikin rma(). Wannan hanyar ta ba da damar kimanta samfuran tasirin bazuwar mataki ɗaya ( Viechtbauer, 2010 ; duba Pearce & Field, 2016 , don irin wannan hanyar). Mun yi amfani da kimantawa mafi girman yuwuwar.
Kamar yadda bincike ya nuna bambanci mai yawa a girman samfurin, kuma wasu sun samar da kimantawa da yawa na girman tasirin, mun auna girman tasirin ta hanyar girman samfurin da adadin girman tasirin a kowane bincike. Manyan bincike don haka sun sami nauyi mafi girma. Kuma nazarin da ke bayar da rahoton girman tasirin da yawa bai sami nauyi fiye da nazarin da ke bayar da rahoton girman tasirin guda ɗaya kawai ba. Saboda haka, mun auna girman tasirin ta hanyar ƙididdige rabon girman samfurin binciken zuwa adadin girman tasirin da aka rubuta daga binciken ( Hunter & Schmidt, 2004 ). Misali, idan Nazarin 1 yana da mahalarta 200 kuma ya samar da girman tasiri guda ɗaya, an sanya wannan girman tasirin nauyin 200/1 = 200. Idan Nazarin 2 yana da mahalarta 200 kuma ya samar da girman sakamako guda huɗu, an sanya kowane girman tasirin nauyin 200/4 = 50. A lissafin matsakaicin girman tasirin, Nazarin 1 ya sami nauyi na 200, yayin da Nazarin 2 ya sami nauyi na 4 × 50, wanda ya haifar da nauyin gaba ɗaya iri ɗaya.
results
Overall Effect Analysis
Tebur 1 ya gabatar da dukkan girman tasirin mutum ɗaya. Binciken tasirin gabaɗaya ya nuna sakamako mai kyau, ƙarami zuwa matsakaici na amfani da kafofin watsa labarai akan son kai ( r = .19, Zr = .19). Tasirin ya kasance mai mahimmanci, 95% CI [.15, .23], p < .0001. Bayan Rosenthal (1979) , mun ƙididdige abin da ake kira nazarin aljihun fayil, wanda ya magance damuwar cewa akwai ƙarin nazarin da ba a haɗa su a cikin binciken ba wanda ya kasa bugawa saboda girman tasirin su sifili ne, ko aƙalla ƙarami sosai. Haɗa su a cikin binciken na iya haifar da sakamako mara mahimmanci gabaɗaya ( Borenstein et al., 2009 ). Don magance wannan damuwa, Rosenthal (1979) ya ba da shawarar hanyar ƙididdige adadin nazarin tasirin sifili da ake buƙata don soke sakamakon da aka samu ( Borenstein et al., 2009 ). Binciken ya nuna N mai aminci na gazawa na 7,816. Don haka, tasirin da aka lura yana da ƙarfi sosai.
Bugu da ƙari, mun sami babban bambancin da ke tsakanin girman tasirin, Q (49) = 213.72, p < .0001. Wannan yana nuna cewa girman tasirin ya bambanta sosai saboda bambance-bambancen tsakanin binciken. Ƙididdigar I 2 —adadin jimlar bambancin (bambancin samfur + bambancin) wanda za a iya dangantawa da bambancin tsakanin tasirin gaske ( Higgins & Thompson, 2002 )—ya samar da ƙarin fahimta. Kimanin kashi 75% na jimlar bambancin za a iya dangantawa da bambance-bambancen tsakanin binciken ( I 2 = 75.03). Da alama masu daidaitawa za su iya bayyana wasu daga cikin waɗannan bambance-bambancen ( Huedo-Medina, Sánchez-Meca, Marín-Martínez, & Botella, 2006 ).
Bincike na sharudda
Mun gwada tasirin da aka daidaita ta hanyar ƙididdige meta-regressions (samfurin sakamako masu gauraye-matakai da yawa). Ga kowane mai gudanarwa, mun ƙididdige meta-regression daban. An yi wa masu gudanarwa nau'i-nau'i (misali, jinsi, ma'auni, nau'in ƙira, nau'in kafofin watsa labarai, abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai, da wurin karatu) lambar sirri. Mun ɗauki nau'ikan da aka fi sani da lambar sirri a matsayin nau'ikan tunani. Ma'aunin komawa baya yana wakiltar canje-canje a girman sakamako bisa ga canje-canje a matakan mai gudanarwa. Ƙididdigar gwajin χ 2 ta nuna ko mai gudanarwa, wanda aka ɗauka gaba ɗaya, ya shafi girman tasiri sosai ( gwajin Q ; Borenstein et al., 2009 ). Sabanin haka, ƙididdigar gwajin z ta nuna ko wani matakin mai gudanarwa na rukuni ya bambanta sosai da rukunin tunani na wannan mai gudanarwa ( gwajin Z ; Borenstein et al., 2009 ). Tebur 2 da 3 suna nuna duk sakamako.
Idan aka duba Jadawali na 2 (samfurin halaye), babu wani muhimmin tasiri na daidaitawa. Wato, tasirin amfani da kafofin watsa labarai kan kin amincewa da kai ya bayyana ba tare da la'akari da shekarun mahalarta, jinsi, da ƙabilarsu ba, haka kuma ba tare da la'akari da ko mahalarta ɗalibai ne ko a'a ba.
Idan aka duba Tebur na 3 (halayen ƙirar nazari), nau'in kafofin watsa labarai ya daidaita girman tasirin sosai, χ 2 (3) = 7.65, p = .05. Girman tasirin Zr shine .11 ( z = 2.13, p < .05), yana nuna tasirin da ya fi ƙarfi lokacin da mahalarta suka yi amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na kan layi maimakon talabijin. Bugu da ƙari, girman tasirin ya kasance .18, ya fi ƙarfi lokacin da mahalarta suka yi amfani da wasannin bidiyo maimakon talabijin ( z = 2.24, p < .05). Amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na bugawa bai haifar da wani bambanci ba, ko idan aka kwatanta da talabijin ko lokacin da aka kwatanta da kafofin watsa labarai na kan layi ko wasannin bidiyo. Sauran halayen ƙirar binciken ba su shafi girman tasirin ba. Wato, tasirin amfani da kafofin watsa labarai akan son kai ya bayyana ba tare da la'akari da nau'in auna son kai ba, ƙirar binciken, da abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai. Akwai wani yanayi da ke nuna cewa wurin binciken ya daidaita girman tasirin, χ 2 (3) = 6.60, p = .09. Musamman ma, girman tasirin Zr na nazarin Turai ya fi girma da .12 idan aka kwatanta da nazarin da aka yi daga Arewacin Amurka ( z = 2.53, p < .05). Sabanin haka, binciken Asiya ko na Ostiraliya bai bambanta sosai da na Arewacin Amurka ba, kuma ba su bambanta da na Turai ba. Shekarar da aka buga ba ta daidaita girman tasirin gaba ɗaya ba.
Mun kuma duba tasirin hulɗa tsakanin masu gudanarwa. Musamman, mun ɗauka cewa maza da mata (jinsi), matasa da manya mahalarta (shekaru), ko ɗalibai da waɗanda ba ɗalibai ba (samfurin ɗalibi) za su mayar da martani daban-daban ga sha'awar jima'i, mai mai da hankali kan bayyanar, da kuma abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai gabaɗaya (abun ciki). Duk da haka, babu wata muhimmiyar hulɗa tsakanin nau'in abun ciki da ɗaya daga cikin masu gudanarwa uku: Jinsi × Abun ciki: χ 2 (2) = .12, p = .94; Shekaru × Abun ciki: χ 2 (2) = .30, p = .86; Samfurin Ɗalibi × Abun ciki: χ 2 (2) = 1.02, p = .60. A ƙarshe, tasirin amfani da kafofin watsa labarai akan sha'awar kai ya bayyana yana da ƙarfi sosai. Baya ga tasirin wurin karatu da nau'in kafofin watsa labarai, sha'awar kai ba ta shafi yanayin iyaka da aka bincika ba.
Bias Analysis Buga
A ƙarshe, mun duba ko akwai son zuciya a cikin wallafe-wallafe. Mun gwada ko an kasa buga nazarin da ke da ƙananan samfura da ƙananan girman sakamako. Mun yi amfani da shirin funnel da gwajin komawa baya na Egger don rashin daidaiton zane na funnel ( Egger, Smith, Schneider, & Minder, 1997 ). Kamar yadda aka ba da shawarar a cikin wallafe-wallafen, mun yi amfani da kuskuren da aka saba a matsayin alamar girman samfurin ( Borenstein et al., 2009 ). Idan muka kalli shirin funnel ( Hoto na 2 ), akwai ƙaramin shaida na son zuciya a cikin ƙananan bincike tare da ƙananan girman sakamako da suka ɓace a kusurwar hagu ta ƙasa. Duk da haka, an juya wannan tsarin lokacin da aka kalli tsakiyar ɓangaren adadi (nazarin da manyan girman sakamako suka ɓace), suna jayayya game da son zuciya a cikin wallafe-wallafe. Bugu da ƙari, gwajin komawa baya na Egger mara mahimmanci, t (48) = −1.00, p = .33, ya nuna cewa ba a tabbatar da son zuciya a cikin wallafe-wallafe ba.
tattaunawa
Nuna son kai ra'ayi ne mai matuƙar muhimmanci a binciken tasirin kafofin watsa labarai. An ƙarfafa shi ta hanyar aikin masu ra'ayin nuna son kai (misali, Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997 ; McKinley & Hyde, 1996 ), a cikin bincike da yawa na gwaji, masana sun binciki tasirin sanya kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i akan nuna son kai. Dangane da wani bincike na meta wanda ya haɗa da bincike 50 (girman sakamako 261), wanda ya ƙunshi nau'ikan ƙira uku na bincike, mun sami damar nuna a cikin binciken na yanzu cewa, a cikin nau'ikan kafofin watsa labarai daban-daban da ke gabatar da matakai daban-daban na abubuwan da ke haifar da jima'i, akwai kyakkyawan tasiri na amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i akan nuna son kai ( r = .19). Kamar yadda aka yi hasashe, amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na jama'a ya ƙara nuna son kai tsakanin mata da maza. Tasirin ya kasance mai ƙarfi sosai kuma ƙarami zuwa matsakaici dangane da girma ( Lipsey & Wilson, 2001 ).
Ayyukan Samfurori
Babu ɗaya daga cikin halayen samfurin (shekaru, jinsi, ƙabila, da samfurin ɗalibai) da ya daidaita babban tasirin. Fredrickson da Roberts (1997) sun nuna cewa mata na kowane rukuni na shekaru ana iya musanta su. Duk da haka, ana iya jayayya cewa matasa sun fi saurin kamuwa da abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i ( Fortenberry, 2013 ). Duk da haka, nazarinmu na meta-bincike bai nuna wani tasiri na matsakaici na matsakaicin shekaru ba kuma bai goyi bayan wannan zato ba. Duk da haka, dole ne a lura cewa an rage shekarun samfuranmu sosai, wanda ya ƙunshi kusan gaba ɗaya na matasa da manya masu tasowa. Za mu ci gaba da tattauna wannan batu a cikin sashin Iyakoki.
Bugu da ƙari, ba mu sami wani matsakaicin jinsi a kan tasirin amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i akan nuna son kai ba. Wani bayani mai yiwuwa shine cewa yanayin kafofin watsa labarai ya canza. Sakamakon binciken abubuwan da suka gabata ya nuna cewa maza suna fuskantar ƙaruwar yuwuwar fuskantar hotunan maza masu nuna son kai ( Gill, 2009 ; Hatton & Trautner, 2011 ; Ricciardelli, Clow, & White, 2010 ; Rohlinger, 2002 ). Duk da cewa nuna son kai ga maza da mata yana da ma'anoni daban-daban na zamantakewa, a ƙarshe, jikin da aka yi wa jima'i ya zama abin da wasu ke ladabtarwa, sarrafa shi, kuma wasu ke bincika shi ( Rohlinger, 2002 ), wanda ke haifar da nuna son kai tsakanin mata da maza. Wannan na iya bayyana dalilin da yasa maza, idan aka kwatanta da mata, suka nuna irin wannan tasirin amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i akan nuna son kai. Sakamakonmu ya tabbatar da binciken da ya gabata wanda ya gano kamanceceniya tsakanin jinsi a cikin alaƙar da ke tsakanin nuna son kai da darajar jiki ko kunya ta jiki ( Moradi & Huang, 2008 ). Duk da haka, dole ne mu yi la'akari da tasirin ƙa'idodi daban-daban na al'adu da aka yi amfani da su ga mata da maza. Manufar al'adu don jan hankalin maza ta haɗa da ƙarfi, ƙarfin tsoka, da rinjaye, yayin da manufar al'ada don jan hankalin mata ta ta'allaka ne akan siriri da rauni ( Moradi, 2010 ). Don haka, bincikenmu bai kamata ya ɓoye gaskiyar cewa dangantakar iko da wariya da ke akwai suna ci gaba da wanzuwa ba ( Moradi, 2010 ). Bugu da ƙari, mata suna da sha'awar, a cikin ci gaba a tsawon rayuwa, karɓar ƙarin bayanai, sharhi, ko ayyuka na jima'i fiye da maza (misali, Swim, Hyers, Cohen, & Ferguson, 2001 ).
Ba mu sami wani tasiri na matsakaicin ƙabilar mahalarta ba. Nazarin da muka haɗa ya ba mu damar bambance tsakanin Fari/Caucasian da duk wata ƙabila da ba Fari/wasu ba. Haɗa ƙabilu daban-daban tare na iya haifar da watsi da bambance-bambancen da ka iya wanzuwa saboda wata ƙungiya na iya soke tasirin wata. Misali, wani bincike na tsawon lokaci ya nuna cewa 'yan matan Baƙar fata Amurkawa sun ba da rahoton ƙarancin rashin gamsuwar jiki a cikin shekarun makarantar sakandare idan aka kwatanta da sauran 'yan mata. Duk da haka, 'yan matan Asiya sun ba da rahoton ƙaruwar rashin gamsuwar jiki idan aka kwatanta da 'yan matan Baƙar fata Amurkawa, 'yan matan Latina, da 'yan mata masu ƙabila da yawa ( de Guzman & Nishina, 2014 ). Duk da haka, wani bincike kan ƙabila da rashin gamsuwar jiki wanda ya haɗa da matan Asiyawa, Amurkawa, Baƙar fata, Hispanic, da Fari ya gano ƙaramin bambanci ne kawai a cikin rashin gamsuwar jiki ga matan Fari idan aka kwatanta da matan Baƙar fata ( Grabe & Hyde, 2006 ). Ana iya samun wani bayani a cikin abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai. Masu bincike na baya sun lura cewa mata baƙaƙe sun fi son sifofi masu wakiltar jiki mai lanƙwasa maimakon sirara da ake nunawa a kafofin watsa labarai ( Capodilupo & Kim, 2015 ; Overstreet, Quinn, & Agocha, 2010 ). Rashin wakiltar mata marasa rinjaye a kafofin watsa labarai na iya haifar da irin wannan sakamako ga mata masu launin fata da fararen fata, domin babu wata ƙungiya da ke fuskantar hotuna da ke wakiltar su daidai. An ƙara tattauna wannan batu a cikin sashe kan bincike na gaba.
Bayanan Nazarin
Mun gano cewa amfani da wasannin bidiyo da/ko kafofin watsa labarai na kan layi ya haifar da ƙarin tasirin son kai idan aka kwatanta da amfani da talabijin. Ana iya la'akari da bayanai da yawa game da wannan tasirin. Duk nau'ikan kafofin watsa labarai guda biyu suna da alaƙa da manyan matakan hulɗa da iko ( Eveland, 2003 ). A wata ma'anar, yayin da mutum zai iya kallon talabijin cikin sauƙi kuma ya yi wani abu da ba shi da alaƙa a lokaci guda, wannan ya fi wahala da wasannin bidiyo kuma, zuwa wani mataki, ya fi wahala da kafofin watsa labarai na kan layi. Wasannin bidiyo na iya haifar da babban matakin ƙwarewar tunani na kasancewa, wato, jin kasancewar kasancewa a cikin yanayin kafofin watsa labarai ( Weibel, Wissmath, & Mast, 2011 ; Wirth et al., 2007 ). Bugu da ƙari, wasannin bidiyo an san su da nuna halayen wasan mata da maza masu jima'i (misali, Burgess et al., 2007 ; Lynch, Tompkins, van Driel, & Fritz, 2016 ), kuma wasanni da yawa suna ba wa mutane damar yin wasa da wani hali mai jiki daban, wataƙila nau'in jiki mafi kyau fiye da nau'in jikin ɗan wasan. Shafukan sada zumunta kafofin watsa labarai ne na kan layi waɗanda aka siffanta su da abubuwan da suka dace, na gani da ke kewaye da kai. Bidiyo da hotunan da aka tsara na kai, takwarorinka, da sauran mutane na iya haɓaka kwatancen zamantakewa da kuma haɗa manufofin bayyanar ciki, kuma, bi da bi, na iya ƙara nuna son kai tsakanin mutane ( Perloff, 2014 ).
Ba mu sami wani tasiri mai mahimmanci na matsakaici ga nau'in ma'aunin son kai ba. A gefe guda, wannan sakamakon ya nuna cewa duk matakan da aka haɗa a cikin binciken na yanzu sun yi tasiri daidai gwargwado wajen kama tasirin kafofin watsa labarai akan son kai. A gefe guda kuma, ana iya hasashen cewa tasirin son kai ga kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i yana da ƙarfi daidai gwargwado ga ɓangarorin fahimi da ɗabi'a na son kai, tunda an haɗa matakan fahimi (misali, SOQ) da matakan ɗabi'a (misali, ƙaramin sikelin OBCS) a cikin binciken. Duk da haka, masu bincike sun nuna cewa son kai da sa ido kan jiki suna da alaƙa da juna amma ba daidai ba ne ( Calogero, 2011 ; Moradi & Huang, 2008 ). Ana buƙatar ƙarin bincike don yanke hukunci na ƙarshe game da tasirin son kai ga kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i akan da bambance-bambance tsakanin matakan son kai da ake da su.
Ba mu gano wani muhimmin tasiri ga nau'in ƙira ba: nazarin bincike na ɓangarori daban-daban, nazarin binciken kwamitoci, da nazarin gwaji sun ba da sakamako iri ɗaya; wato, ba mu gano wani bambanci mai mahimmanci a kididdiga a cikin girman tasirin ba. Abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai kuma ba su da wani tasiri mai daidaitawa. Yawancin nazarin da aka haɗa a nan sun binciki fallasa ga abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i. Don haka, za mu iya ɗauka cewa wannan takamaiman nau'in abun ciki na iya haifar da tunani ko hali na son kai. Duk da haka, abubuwan da ke mai da hankali kan bayyanar (ba na jima'i ba) da abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai gabaɗaya suma sun annabta son kai a cikin bincikenmu. Wannan matsakaici mara mahimmanci za a iya bayyana shi ta hanyar ka'idar noma (misali, Gerbner, 1998 ). Kasancewar abubuwan da ke cikin jima'i a cikin kowane nau'in kafofin watsa labarai (misali, Aubrey & Frisby, 2011 ; Burgess et al., 2007 ; Lynch et al., 2016 ; Stankiewicz & Rosselli, 2008 ; Vandenbosch et al., 2013 ) na iya samun tasiri mai tarawa da ƙarfafa juna akan son kai tsakanin mutane. Duk da haka, an soki zato na tasirin kafofin watsa labarai iri ɗaya (misali, Bilandzic & Rössler, 2004 ). Sakamakon binciken tasirin kafofin watsa labarai masu alaƙa ya nuna cewa amfani da takamaiman abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai ya annabta rashin gamsuwa ga jiki, yayin da jimillar amfani da kafofin watsa labarai bai yi ba ( Levine & Murnen, 2009 ; Meier & Gray, 2014 ). Dangane da wannan dalili, Andrew, Tiggemann, da Clark (2016) sun nuna kwanan nan cewa amfani da kafofin watsa labarai marasa bayyana, kamar nunin bayanai, shirye-shiryen shirye-shirye, da labarai, yana da alaƙa da rashin amincewa da kai. Don haka, ba mu yi imani da cewa duk wani abun ciki na kafofin watsa labarai zai haifar da rashin amincewa da kai ta atomatik ba ( Levine & Murnen, 2009 ). Maimakon haka, kafofin watsa labarai waɗanda suka mayar da hankali - har zuwa wani mataki - kan bayyanar waje ya kamata su yi tasiri. Bugu da ƙari, mun yi imanin cewa rashin daidaito ta hanyar abun ciki na kafofin watsa labarai na iya nuna iyakoki a cikin hanyoyin da aka yi amfani da su da nau'ikan bayanai da aka tattara a cikin binciken da aka yi nazari. Mun tattauna wannan batu sosai a cikin sashin Iyakoki.
Mun sami ɗan ƙaramin yanayin zuwa wurin karatu a matsayin mai gudanarwa: Tasirin nazarin Turai ya fi girma idan aka kwatanta da nazarin da aka yi daga Arewacin Amurka. Duk da haka, yana yiwuwa wannan tasirin ya samo asali ne daga binciken da Doornwaard et al. (2014) suka yi . Binciken Doornwaard et al. (2014) yana cikin kaɗan daga cikin waɗanda suka binciki tasirin abubuwan da ke haifar da jima'i a bayyane, wato batsa. Bugu da ƙari, babban samfurin ( N = 1132) na matasa waɗanda Doornwaard et al. (2014) suka yi amfani da su a bincikensu ya ba da ƙarin nauyi ga girman tasirinsu a cikin bincikenmu. Lokacin gudanar da nazarin mai gudanarwa ba tare da binciken ba, tasirin matsakaici na wurin karatu bai kasance mai mahimmanci ba, wanda ke goyan bayan bayaninmu.
A takaice dai, bincikenmu yana nuna cewa tasirin masu amfani da jima'i da yin amfani da su a kan kwarewar mutum yana da karfi sosai. Yana da mahimmanci a jaddada cewa mun samu kusan babu wani tasiri daga waɗannan ƙananan canji, ko da yake yawan karatun da samfurin samfurori sun kasance cikakke sosai don gudanar da nazarin sharudda.
Ƙididdiga da Tsarin Gabatarwa don Binciken Bincike
A cikin sassan da ke gaba, mun magance iyakokin wannan binciken da gibin bincike a fannin binciken hoton jiki da binciken tasirin kafofin watsa labarai kuma mun samar da ajanda don bincike na gaba. A cikin wannan binciken, mun haɗa da takardu kawai waɗanda ke akwai a Turanci. Duk da haka, nazarin aljihun fayil ya nuna babban tasiri. Bugu da ƙari, mun san cewa rubuta wurin binciken ta hanyar nahiyar ba zai iya ɗaukar duk bambance-bambancen da ke cikin rashin yarda da kai ba wanda zai iya samo asali daga asalin al'adun mutane; ƙasashe a cikin kowace nahiya za su iya bambanta a cikin nau'ikan hotunan jima'i da aka nuna a cikin kafofin watsa labarai (misali, Collins, 2011 ). A ƙarshe, kodayake mun gudanar da cikakken bincike na wallafe-wallafe don nazarin meta-analysis, ba za mu iya kawar da cewa an rasa nazarin guda ɗaya ba, musamman waɗanda ba a buga su ba ko kuma ba a samu a Intanet ba. Duk da haka, mun yi imanin cewa wannan iyakancewa ba ya rage bincikenmu yayin da muka yi amfani da samfurin tasirin bazuwar don nazarin meta-analysis. Don haka, a cikin bincikenmu, an ɗauki binciken da aka bincika a matsayin wani ɓangare na babban yawan masu bincike ( Hedges & Vevea, 1998 ). Hakanan ba mu sami wata shaida ba don nuna son kai na wallafe-wallafe.
Cibiyar bincike da muka bincika ma yana da iyaka. Wadannan sun haɗa da gajerun hanyoyi game da samfurori da aka bincika, da rashin nazarin lokaci, da kuma rashin bincike da yawa.
Ƙananan samfurori da aka bincika
Bincikenmu ya nuna cewa bincike kan kafofin watsa labarai da kuma nuna rashin amincewa da aka gudanar a wajen ƙasashen Yamma ko Yammacin duniya ba shi da yawa. Duk da cewa an nuna wannan son zuciya a fili a baya ( Moradi & Huang, 2008 ), abin mamaki ne. Kashi casa'in da shida cikin ɗari ( n = 48) na binciken da muka gano sun samo asali ne daga Arewacin Amurka, Turai, ko Ostiraliya da Oceania. Nazari biyu kacal suka fito daga Asiya ( Barzoki, Mohtasham, Shahidi, & Tavakol, 2016 ; Kim et al., 2015 ), kuma babu ɗaya daga Latin Amurka ko Afirka.
Bugu da ƙari, yawancin bincike kan nuna son kai sun mayar da hankali kan mata. A cikin nazarinmu na meta-analysis, kashi biyu bisa uku ( n = 33) na binciken sun binciki mata ne kawai. Mata suna fuskantar ƙarin gogewa ta hanyar jima'i tsakanin mutane idan aka kwatanta da maza ( Swim et al., 2001 ), kuma mata sun fi fuskantar yiwuwar yin jima'i a cikin nau'ikan kafofin watsa labarai daban-daban ( Aubrey & Frisby, 2011 ; Burgess et al., 2007 ; Stankiewicz & Rosselli, 2008 ; Vandenbosch et al., 2013 ). Kuma mata galibi suna ba da rahoton matakan nuna son kai fiye da maza (misali, Aubrey, 2006a ; Lindberg et al., 2006 ; Vandenbosch & Eggermont, 2015b ; Ward, Seabrook, Manago, & Reed, 2015 ). Duk da haka, sakamakonmu ya nuna cewa tasirin kafofin watsa labarai kan nuna son kai iri ɗaya ne ga duka jinsi. Saboda haka, yana da mahimmanci a haɗa mata da maza a cikin binciken da ya shafi son kai.
Idan aka yi la'akari da cewa matsakaicin shekarun mahalarta da aka bincika shine shekaru 19.67, ana buƙatar bincike tsakanin matasa da tsofaffi. Tunda abubuwan da suka shafi jima'i da kuma son kai sun fara ne tun suna ƙanana, masu bincike sun yi bincike kwanan nan game da son kai tsakanin yara (misali, E. Holland & Haslam, 2016 ; Jongenelis, Byrne, & Pettigrew, 2014 ; Slater & Tiggemann, 2016 ). Yana da mahimmanci a haɗa da tsofaffi saboda son kai na iya canzawa akan lokaci ( Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997 ).
A ƙarshe, bincike kan ƙabilu daban-daban ya ɓace. Misali, gwargwadon iliminmu, bincike ɗaya kawai na gwaji ya binciki tasirin fallasa kafofin watsa labarai kan nuna son kai tsakanin 'yan mata da 'yan mata fararen fata ( Harrison & Fredrickson, 2003 ). Bayan haka, bincike na gaba ya kamata ya haɗa da mata da maza a matakai daban-daban na rayuwa a wajen "kumfa ta Yamma" domin gwada amfani da tsarin ka'idoji tsakanin al'adu daban-daban, kamar ka'idar nuna fifiko ( Moradi & Huang, 2008 ).
Muna bayar da shawarar cewa a nan gaba, masu bincike su bincika yadda yara, matasa, da / ko masu tsufa da ke da bambancin kabilu daban-daban suna nunawa ga abubuwa masu yawa na jima'i. Bugu da ƙari kuma, muna bada shawara cewa masu bincike a kasashe da dama, irin su Ingila, Jamus, da Ostiraliya, ya kamata su kasance masu hankali da hankali game da tattara bayanai game da kabilanci.
Rashin karatu na tsawon lokaci
Mun gano adadin zane-zanen gwaji da zane-zanen bincike na sassan jiki da aka rarraba daidai gwargwado a cikin binciken da muka haɗa. Duk da haka, akwai ƙananan nazarin bincike na tsawon lokaci; mun gano samfura uku masu zaman kansu kawai waɗanda suka yi amfani da wannan hanyar ( Aubrey, 2006a , 2006b ; Aubrey & Taylor, 2005 ; Doornwaard et al., 2014 ; Vandenbosch & Eggermont, 2014 , 2015a , 2015b ). Ana buƙatar ƙarin bincike na tsawon lokaci don ƙarin tantance tasirin da ake iya samu, kuma mai yiwuwa sakamakon, ta hanyar kimanta alaƙar da ke tsakanin juna da canjin mutum ɗaya a cikin saitunan da suka dace na waje (G. Holland & Tiggemann, 2016 ; Valkenburg & Peter, 2013 ).
An kasa bincikar masu canji
Tsarin ra'ayoyin bayyanar ciki muhimmin abu ne wanda ba a haɗa shi cikin bincikenmu ba. Mun yi imanin cewa zai zama da amfani a duba wannan ra'ayi sosai. Fredrickson da Roberts (1997) sun yi nuni da tsarin ra'ayoyin bayyanar ciki a matsayin wata hanya ta bayyanawa da ke haifar da ra'ayin kai. Su da wasu sun yi hasashen cewa ra'ayin jima'i da aka fuskanta ko aka yi tsammani yana haifar da ra'ayoyin bayyanar ciki, wanda hakan ke haifar da tunani ko hali na son kai ( Fredrickson & Roberts, 1997 ; Moradi, 2010 ; Moradi & Huang, 2008 ). Masu bincike sun nuna sau da yawa cewa ra'ayin ciki yana aiki a matsayin mai shiga tsakani tsakanin amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i da kuma ra'ayin kai ( Tiggemann & Slater, 2014 ; Vandenbosch & Eggermont, 2012 , 2013 , 2014 ). Duk da haka, wasu masu bincike ba su sami goyon baya ga tasirin shiga tsakani na shiga cikin gida akan son kai ba ( Aubrey, 2006b ; Karsay & Matthes, 2015 ). Ana buƙatar bincike kan yadda ake haɗa ra'ayoyin bayyanar cikin gida domin a fayyace waɗannan binciken da suka saɓa wa juna.
Bugu da ƙari, ya kamata a binciki waɗannan masu canji guda biyu da ba a yi nazari a kansu ba a nan gaba: matsayin zamantakewa da tattalin arziki da fahimtar rawar da jinsi ke takawa. Duk da haka, waɗannan masu canji guda biyu ba sa wakiltar cikakken jerin masu canji da ba a yi nazari a kansu ba. Binciken da aka yi a baya kan rashin gamsuwa da jiki ya nuna cewa babban matsayin zamantakewa da tattalin arziki yana da alaƙa da rashin gamsuwa da jiki da kuma sha'awar yin siriri a tsakanin mata ( Swami et al., 2010 ). Don haka, da alama matsayin zamantakewa da tattalin arziki yana taka rawa wajen nuna son kai. Bugu da ƙari, ya kamata a ƙara bincika bambance-bambancen tsakanin jinsi, kamar fahimtar rawar da jinsi ke takawa, saboda yanayin yawan jinsi yana da alaƙa da amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na jima'i, nuna son kai, da kuma halayen jima'i ( Nowatzki & Morry, 2009 ; van Oosten, Peter, & Boot, 2015 ).
Mun kuma gano wasu canje-canje da ba a yi nazari sosai ba dangane da amfani da kafofin watsa labarai. Musamman ma, an auna amfani da kafofin watsa labarai da aka bayar da rahoton kansu ba daidai ba a cikin binciken alaƙa. Yayin da wasu nazarin suka tantance amfani da kafofin watsa labarai tare da ma'auni daban-daban na suna (misali, Andrew et al., 2016 ; Fardouly et al., 2015 ), wasu nazarin sun haɗa da ma'aunin ma'auni ta hanyar tambayar mahalarta game da takamaiman lokacin da suka yi amfani da wani nau'in kafofin watsa labarai (misali, Barzoki et al., 2016 ).
Binciken da aka gudanar bisa tsarin gabatarwar kafofin watsa labarai ya nuna cewa ƙarfin babban kafofin watsa labarai yana tasiri ga ƙarfin tasirin kafofin watsa labarai (misali, Arendt, 2013 ). Saboda haka, don nazarin gwaji, da farko mun ƙididdige yawan lokacin da mahalarta ke bayyana ga kafofin watsa labarai. Duk da haka, bincike da yawa sun kasa bayar da rahoton waɗannan bayanai kuma bambancin bayanan da aka rubuta ya yi ƙasa sosai. Don haka, ba za mu iya haɗa mita da tsawon lokacin fallasa kafofin watsa labarai a matsayin mai gudanarwa ba a cikin binciken ƙarshe. Bugu da ƙari, bincike kaɗan ne kawai suka binciki alaƙar abubuwan da ke bayyana jima'i a kafofin watsa labarai da kuma nuna son kai (misali, Tylka, 2015 ; Doornwaard et al., 2014 ), kodayake an nuna cewa abubuwan batsa sun ƙunshi zane-zane da yawa masu nuna son kai ( Klaassen & Peter, 2015 ). Waɗannan ma'auni daban-daban (da waɗanda ba sa nan) na amfani da kafofin watsa labarai na iya lissafa (a) sakamakon da ba shi da ma'ana da gauraye a fagen da kuma (b) babban bambancin bambance-bambancen tsakanin bincike da muka samu a cikin nazarinmu na meta. Muna ba da shawarar masu bincike su yi nazari sosai kan abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai, nau'ikan, da taken da ake magana a kai yayin da suke binciken alaƙar amfani da kafofin watsa labarai da kuma nuna son kai. Bugu da ƙari, masu bincike ya kamata su ba da rahoton takamaiman nau'in abun ciki, nau'ikan, ko taken da suke nazari a kai (duba kuma Valkenburg & Peter, 2013 ). Wannan zai taimaka wajen fahimtar wane abun ciki ke tasiri ga son kai da kuma wane abun ciki ba ya tasiri. Masu bincike na gaba kuma za su iya bincika yiwuwar tasirin hulɗa tsakanin nau'in kafofin watsa labarai da abubuwan da ke cikin kafofin watsa labarai. Misali, wasannin bidiyo an san su da abubuwan da ke haifar da jima'i (misali, Burgess et al., 2007 ) kuma, a lokaci guda, wasannin bidiyo na iya haifar da babban matakin kasancewa, wanda zai iya haifar da manyan matakan nuna son kai.
A ƙarshe, kamar yadda Moradi da Huang (2008) suka riga suka jaddada, yana da mahimmanci a bambanta tsakanin kalmomin hali da na yanayi lokacin da ake tattaunawa kan batun son kai. Nazarin 16 ne kawai daga cikin 50 suka nuna bambanci tsakanin hali da batun son kai. Dangane da batun aunawa, ya kamata a yi la'akari da wasu ra'ayoyi da ke da alaƙa da son kai a cikin bincike na gaba, kamar ginin Piran (2015 , 2016 ) na rashin daidaituwa ko dangantakar Tolman da Porche (2000) da jikin mutum.
Yi Ayyukan Ɗaukaka
Sakamakon sakamakon bincike na yanzu yana iya sanar da rigakafi da kuma kokarin shiga tsakani a cikin ɗakunan lissafi da kuma ilimi. Alal misali, masu warkarwa da masu ba da shawara za su iya ƙarfafa abokan su don yin tunaninsu game da yin amfani da labarun masu yin jima'i da kuma hangen nesa. Cibiyoyin koyarwa za su iya karɓar tasirin wasan kwaikwayon wasanni na bidiyo da kuma labarun intanet don inganta wayar da kan jama'a a cikin 'yan daliban, tun da dukkanin nau'o'in kafofin watsa labarun suna da kyau a cikin yara da matasa. Malami da malamai zasu iya koya wa dalibai yadda za su gane abubuwan da ke tattare da jima'i da kuma bayyanar da suka fito da bayyanar da kuma bayyana irin mummunar tasiri game da kayan kai da sauran abubuwan da suka shafi lafiyar jiki, irin su kunyatar jiki, rashin jin daɗin jiki, da kuma cin abinci. Dukansu malaman da kuma masu aiki zasuyi aiki a kan hanyoyin dabarun don magancewa ko rage tasirin hanyoyin watsa labarun kan abubuwan da suka dace. Binciken, masu aiki da malaman da suke cikin batutuwa na al'amuran jikin mutum da lafiyar mata zasu iya amfana daga nazari na wallafe-wallafe da kuma bayanan da aka tsara don bincike na gaba.
karshe
Mun yi ƙoƙari don ƙididdige tasirin yin amfani da kafofin watsa labaru ta hanyar jima'i ta hanyar amfani da kayan aiki na mutum ta hanyar amfani da matakan kwakwalwa. Sakamakon ya nuna karami zuwa matsakaicin sakamako. Mun sami sakamako na ƙayyadadden nau'in mai jarida, yana ba da shawara cewa an ƙaddamar da sakamako ga masu halartar yin amfani da wasan bidiyo ko kuma labarun intanet. Bugu da ƙari, binciken da aka bayar ya nuna cewa tasirin masu amfani da labaru na amfani da kayan kai-tsaye ya shafi maza da mata, tsofaffi da matasa masu halartar, da kuma mahalarta kabilanci. Muna kira don bincike na gaba da za a haɗa da maza da mata a duk matakan rayuwa da kuma daga sassa daban-daban na duniya, don aiwatar da kayayyaki na tsawon lokaci, don kara bincikar yadda ake yin kwaskwarima, da kuma bayar da rahoto game da yadda ake amfani dasu. Muna fatan cewa binciken bincikenmu zai taimaka wa masu bincike su magance labarun bincike a binciken su a nan gaba. Bugu da ƙari kuma, muna fatan wannan labarin zai karfafa masu aiki da iyaye suyi tunani game da muhimmancin yin amfani da jarida ta hanyar yin amfani da jima'i a cikin ci gaba da haɓakar 'yancin mutum.
Notes
1. Ana iya samun bayanai daga marubucin farko idan an buƙata.
2. Aubrey (2006a ), Aubrey (2006b ), da Aubrey da Taylor (2005) an gina su ne akan samfurin iri ɗaya. Haka nan, Tiggemann da Slater (2013) da Slater da Tiggemann (2015) an gina su ne akan samfurin iri ɗaya. A ƙarshe, Vandenbosch da Eggermont (2012) , Vandenbosch da Eggermont (2013) , Vandenbosch da Eggermont (2014) , Vandenbosch da Eggermont (2015a ), da Vandenbosch da Eggermont (2015b ) suma an gina su ne akan samfurin iri ɗaya.
Bayanan kalmomi
Sanarwa Kan Abubuwan Da Suka Saɓa wa Juna: Marubucin(marubutan) ya bayyana cewa babu wani rikici na sha'awa dangane da bincike, marubuci, da/ko buga wannan labarin.
Kuɗi: Marubucin(marubutan) bai sami tallafin kuɗi ba don bincike, marubuta, da/ko buga wannan labarin.
References

