Idan kana bin filin "matsalar amfani da batsa" (PPU), za ka iya sanin wani kamfen da ƙawayen masana'antar batsa ke yi don shawo kan jama'a cewa "PPU kunya ce kawai ta addini da aka yi ado da ita kamar damuwa game da jaraba." Marigayi Gary Wilson ya rubuta game da wannan "ja herring" mai ƙwarewa.
Da farko wannan kamfen ya sami wasu nasarori (ba a cancanta ba), wanda ya samu taimako daga masana'antar batsa da kuma hazakar da abokan karatunta suka nuna. A hankali, duk da haka, masu bincike sun fara yin tambayoyi mafi kyau. Haka kuma, masu sharhi sun ba da damar wasu bincike da ba su goyi bayan ra'ayin su wuce bitar su. (Gabaɗaya, duk da haka, lokacin da masu sharhi suka gyara binciken da suka goyi bayan "rashin daidaiton ɗabi'a," yana kama da ra'ayin yana raye kuma yana lafiya, ba tare da la'akari da binciken masu binciken ba, kamar yadda yake a cikin wannan misali na baya-bayan nan .)
Don haka, yana iya zama da wahala a fahimci halin da ake ciki a yanzu game da muhawarar "rashin daidaiton ɗabi'a". Domin taimakawa baƙi wajen amsa tambayoyi, ga wani sabon bincike da wani mai bincike a fannin ya yi:
Masana da yawa a fannin ilimin jima'i sun nuna cewa kallon batsa yawanci al'ada ce mai kyau. Suna jayayya cewa lokacin da mutane ke fama da amfani da batsa, ba halin/abin da ke ciki ba ne matsalar. Madadin haka, suna nuna "kunyar jima'i," laifin addini, ko kuma jin cewa ɗabi'ar ba daidai ba ce. Duk da cewa gaskiya ne cewa mutane masu addini sun fi bayyana kansu a matsayin "masu jaraba," yana ƙara wahala a yi jayayya cewa kunya ita ce kawai dalilin da ya sa mutane ke jin suna da matsala.
A cikin da'irorin bincike, wannan muhawara ana kiranta da Rashin Daidaito a Ɗabi'a (MI). Wannan yana faruwa ne lokacin da wani ya yi imanin cewa batsa ba daidai ba ne amma yana kallonta ko ta yaya, yana haifar da rikici na ciki. Lokacin da wannan ra'ayi ya shahara a kusa da 2015, an ɗauke shi a matsayin "abokin gaba" ga tsarin jaraba. Mutane da yawa sun ɗauka cewa idan kun ji kun kamu da batsa (wanda aka auna a matsayin Amfani da Batsa Mai Matsala, ko PPU), ba a zahiri kuke fama da halin ba; kawai kuna jin laifi ne. Duk da haka, yanzu mun san cewa wannan ra'ayi babban sauƙaƙawa ne.
Sake Tunani Game da Muhawarar "Laifi da Jaraba"
Kimanin shekaru biyar da suka gabata, masana sun fara jayayya cewa PPU da MI ba kawai ɓangarorin tsabar kuɗi guda biyu ba ne, amma a zahiri waƙoƙi ne guda biyu daban-daban waɗanda za su iya wanzuwa a lokaci guda ko kuma gaba ɗaya su kaɗai. Muhimman takardu na ka'idoji guda uku daga 2019 sun fara ƙalubalantar tsarin "PPU vs MI": Kraus & Sweeney (2019; https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-018-1301-9), Brand et al. (2019; https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-018-1293-5), da Vaillancourt-Morel & Bergeron, 2019; https://doi.org/10.1007/s10508-018-1292-6). Waɗannan masu binciken sun lura da manyan kurakurai guda biyu a cikin tsoffin bincike: 1) zato cewa mutane sun fuskanci jaraba da laifi ta hanya ɗaya, da kuma 2) cewa ana ɗaukar MI a matsayin kawai abin kunya na addini.
A takaice, an fahimci waɗannan abubuwan:
– Mutane daban-daban ne: Mutum zai iya fama da ɗabi'un tilastawa, kamar jaraba ba tare da wata mummunar fahimtar "dabi'a" ba.
– Laifi ba addini kawai ba ne: Rikicin ɗabi'a ba wai kawai yana zuwa daga imani ba; yana iya samo asali ne daga ɗabi'un mutum ko na zamantakewa.
– Mai amfani da Rikicin Ɗabi'a "Tsarkakakke": A gefe guda kuma, wasu mutane suna jin babban laifi kan ƙaramin amfani da shi, duk da cewa ba su nuna alamun gwagwarmayar ɗabi'a ba.Ci gaba daga tsofaffin samfura
Binciken da aka yi daga dubban mutane ya wargaza ra'ayin cewa jin "sha'awar" batsa koyaushe sakamako ne kawai na laifin addini.
Ga taƙaitaccen bayani game da abin da sabuwar kimiyya ta gaya mana game da bambanci tsakanin ainihin amfani da matsala da rikicin ɗabi'a.1. Yawancin Damuwa Game da Ɗabi'a Ba Addini Ba Ne
Tatsuniya ce da aka saba gani cewa mutane suna jin bacin rai game da batsa ne kawai saboda imaninsu. Duk da haka, wani bincike da aka yi kan Amurkawa sama da 1,000 waɗanda ba su yarda da batsa ba ya nuna cewa dalilansu sun bambanta sosai (Hoagland et al., 2023; https://doi.org/10.1080/0092623X.2023.2186992). Yayin da kusan kashi 30% suka ambaci addini, wasu da yawa sun damu da:
Ɗabi'a: Kashi 27% sun damu da cin zarafi ko cin zarafin masu wasan kwaikwayo.
Dabi'un Jama'a: Kashi 20% sun kalli hakan ta hanyar nazarin mata, kuma kashi 19% sun damu da tasirin da zai yi wa iyalansu da aurensu.
Ci gaban Kai: Kashi 16% kawai sun ji cewa "ɓatar lokaci ne."2. PPU Ba tare da Rashin Da'a ba
Bayanai daga wani babban bincike na duniya kan mutane 66,000 (Bőthe et al., 2025; doi: 10.1556/2006.2024.00054) sun gano cewa kusan kashi 20% na masu amfani sun fada cikin rukunin PPU kawai. Waɗannan mutane sun nuna alamun rashin amfani da su amma suna da ƙarancin rikici na ɗabi'a.
An samu goyon bayan wannan ta hanyar bincike a China (Jiang et al., 2022, https://doi.
org/10.1556/2006.2022.00065; Chen et al., 2022, https://doi.org/10.1037/adb0000714), wanda ya gano cewa ko a cikin dandalin murmurewa ta yanar gizo, mambobi da yawa suna da ƙin amincewa da ɗabi'a "tsakiyar hanya" kawai ga batsa. Idan gwagwarmayarsu kawai kunya ce, za ku yi tsammanin ƙimar rashin amincewa da ɗabi'arsu ta fi girma.3. Alamomin da ke kama da jaraba na iya haifar da damuwa fiye da laifi
Wani bincike da aka yi kan maza 2,300 (Ince et al., 2025; doi: 10.1556/2006.2025.00022) ya gano "bayanan martaba" daban-daban na masu amfani. Wasu sun ji babban laifi na ɗabi'a amma ba su da alamun jaraba, yayin da wasu kuma suna da alamun jaraba mai yawa amma rashin daidaiton ɗabi'a.
A gaskiya ma, ƙungiyar "mai MI kawai" (tare da ƙarancin PPU) a zahiri tana da lafiyar kwakwalwa mafi kyau fiye da ƙungiyoyin da ke nuna alamun PPU. Wannan yana nuna cewa ainihin ɗabi'ar - ba kunya ba - ita ce ke haifar da damuwa ta tunani da kuma buƙatar taimakon ƙwararru.Kwayar
Ba za mu iya cewa amfani da batsa mai matsala "abin kunya ne kawai na addini ba," kodayake babu shakka yana da mahimmanci ga wasu mutane. Madadin haka, bayanan sun nuna cewa:
– Amfani da matsala da kuma laifin ɗabi'a/addini abubuwa biyu ne daban-daban.
– Za ka iya jin kamar ka kamu da batsa ba tare da ka fuskanci kunya ta ɗabi'a ko addini ba.
– Rashin amincewa da ɗabi'a sau da yawa yana zuwa ne daga damuwa ta duniya, ta ɗabi'a, ko ta dangantaka maimakon kawai addini.
SABUNTARWA Nuwamba, 2026
Grubbs, tare da zaɓaɓɓun abokan aikinsa, ya ci gaba da haɓaka ra'ayinsa na "rashin daidaiton ɗabi'a" wanda ba shi da ma'ana - wanda ya sami iskar oxygen daga masu bincike fiye da yadda ya cancanta. Duba misali, Tsarin Haɗakar Dabi'u Biyu: Nazarin Matakai da yawa na Amfani da Batsa Mai Matsala. Duk da dabarun marubutan da aka yi da kyau don sanya "rashin daidaiton ɗabi'a" ya yi kama da muhimmin ra'ayi mai amfani, ainihin magana abu ne mai sauƙi kuma ba abin mamaki ba:
- Mutane (a duk faɗin jama'a) waɗanda ke tunanin amfani da batsa ba shi da kyau ƙarancin yiwuwar haɓaka amfani da batsa mai matsala.
- Lokacin da waɗanda ba su yarda da amfani da batsa ba do suna amfani da batsa, kuma suna ganin kansu suna amfani da su akai-akai fiye da yadda suke so, suna iya damuwa cewa suna "jaraba." Wannan haka ne, koda kuwa amfaninsu bai cika (har yanzu) da yanke shawara na ƙwararru masu siffanta kansu ba.
Musamman:
Waɗannan binciken sun nuna cewa yayin da rashin amincewa da ɗabi'a na iya zama shinge ga matakin jama'a ga amfani da batsa, yana aiki a matsayin wani abu mai haɗari ga jin daɗin jaraba tsakanin mutanen da ke amfani da batsa, musamman a lokutan da suka fuskanci matakan amfani mafi girma.