John A. Johnson a kan Steele et al., 2013 (da kuma Johnson suna yin muhawwara da Nicole Prause a cikin sharhin sashe a karkashin PT labarin)

Steele et al., mai magana da yawun Nicole Prause ta shekarar 2013 ta gudanar da tambayoyi da dama game da bincikenta na EEG a watan Yuli, 2013 kan mutanen da ke korafin cewa suna da matsala wajen sarrafa amfani da batsa. Da take tsokaci a ƙarƙashin hirar Psychology Today da Nicole Prause, babban farfesa a fannin ilimin halayyar ɗan adam, Emeritus John A. Johnson, ta ce:

Raguwa a cikin mahimmanci

{https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/542939#comment-542939}

An gabatar da shi ta John A. Johnson Ph.D. a ranar 19 ga Yuli, 2013 - 2:35 na yamma

Mustanski yayi tambaya, "Menene manufar binciken?" Kuma Fuskoshin amsa ya ce, "Nazarinmu ya gwada ko mutanen da ke bayar da rahoton irin wadannan matsalolin [matsalolin da suke kallon kallon su na yanar-gizon erotica] suna kama da sauran masu siyaya daga kwakwalwar su ta hanyar zinawa."

Amma bincike bai kwatanta rikodin kwakwalwa daga mutanen da ke da matsalolin da suke kulawa da ra'ayinsu game da labarun yanar gizo ba zuwa ga rikodin kwakwalwa daga magungunan miyagun ƙwayoyi da kuma rikodin kwakwalwa daga wani rukuni na marasa rinjaye, wanda zai zama hanya mai mahimmanci don ganin idan amsawar kwakwalwa daga damuwar rukuni suna kama da kwakwalwar kwakwalwa game da masu siya ko wadanda ba'ayi ba.

Maimakon haka, Magana ya yi iƙirarin cewa zane-zane a ciki shine hanya mafi kyau, inda zancen bincike ya zama jagoran ƙungiyar su. Tare da wannan zane, sun gano cewa amsawar EEG a kan batutuwa (a matsayin ƙungiyoyi) don hotunan hotuna ya fi karfi fiye da yadda EEG ke amsawa ga wasu nau'o'in hotuna. Ana nuna wannan a cikin zane-zane na zane-zane (ko da yake saboda wasu dalilai hoton ya bambanta da yawa daga ainihin zane a cikin labarin da aka buga).

Don haka wannan rukuni wanda ke yin rahoton rashin matsala akan daidaita yadda suke kallon yanar-gizon erotica yana da karfin EEG mai karfi ga hotuna masu ban sha'awa fiye da sauran hotunan. Shin addicts nuna irin wannan karfi EEG kamar yadda aka gabatar tare da miyagun ƙwayoyi na zabi? Ba mu sani ba. Shin al'ada, wadanda ba safiɗa ba su nuna amsar da karfi kamar rukuni na rudani zuwa erotica? Bugu da ƙari, ba mu sani ba. Ba mu san ko wannan tsari na EEG ya fi kama da yanayin kwakwalwa na addicts ko wadanda ba'a yi ba.

Prauseungiyar bincike na Fassara sun yi iƙirarin cewa za su iya nunawa ko haɓakar EEG da aka ɗauka game da batutuwan su zuwa erotica ita ce amsawar ƙwaƙwalwar ƙwaƙwalwa ko kawai amsawar ƙwaƙwalwar libido ta hanyar daidaita jerin tambayoyin tambayoyi tare da bambancin mutum a cikin amsa EEG. Amma bayyana bambance-bambance a cikin amsawar EEG tambaya ce daban daga bincika ko amsar ƙungiyar baki ɗaya tana da jaraba ko a'a. Prauseungiyar Prauseungiyar ta ba da rahoton cewa kawai ƙididdigar ƙididdigar lissafi tare da amsa EEG shi ne daidaituwa mara kyau (r = -. 33) tare da sha'awar yin jima'i tare da abokin tarayya. A takaice dai, akwai ɗan yanayi ga batutuwan da ke da karfin amsawar EEG ga erotica don samun ƙananan sha'awar yin jima'i da abokin tarayya. Ta yaya wannan ke faɗi wani abu game da ko amsar kwakwalwa ga mutanen da ke da matsala game da tsara yadda suke kallon erotica sun yi kama da masu shan tabar ko waɗanda ba sa shan ƙwaya tare da babban libido?

Bayan watanni biyu Johnson ya wallafa wannan Psychology yau blog post wanda ya sanya labarinsa a ƙarƙashin hira da Prause.

{https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/556448#comment-556448}

An gabatar da shi ta John A. Johnson Ph.D. a ranar 22 ga Satumba, 2013 - 9:00 na dare

Har yanzu hankalina yana cike da damuwa a yayin da ake faɗar da'awar cewa ƙwaƙwalwar ajiyarta ba ta amsa hotuna na jima'i kamar ƙwaƙwalwar ƙwayoyi masu ƙwayoyi suna amsa maganin su ba, saboda an ba da rahoton mafi yawan karatun P300 don hotunan jima'i. Kamar dai 'yan maye waɗanda ke nuna P300 spikes lokacin da aka gabatar musu da maganin da suka zaɓa.

Ta yaya zata iya yanke hukunci wanda yake akasin ainihin sakamakon? Ina tsammanin za a iya yi mata abubuwan da ta fahimta - abin da take tsammanin samu. Na rubuta game da wannan a wani wuri.
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/cui-bono/201308/preconceptions-may-color-conclusions-about-sex-addiction

Rubutun Johnson na Psychology Today : Tunani na Gaba Zai Iya Zama Kammalawa Game da Jarabawar Jima'i . Babban abin da za a yi la'akari da shi: A cikin rubutunsa Johnson ya bayyana halayen Prause a bayan fage, kamar barazanar shari'a (kamar yadda ta yi da Wilson) da kuma cin zarafin editocin Psychology Today da barazana, tilasta musu su cire rubuce-rubuce biyu na shafin yanar gizo suna sukar ikirarin da Prause ba ta da goyon baya (1 - sukar Gary Wilson na " Steele et a l., 2013″ , 2 - sukar Robert Weiss, LCSW & Stefanie Carnes PhD ). Ya kuma bayyana karɓar imel masu tayar da hankali da barazana daga Prause:

Lokacin da na fara ɗaukar wannan rubutun a shafin yanar gizo kuma na fara rubuta shi kimanin wata guda da ya wuce, manufara ta farko ita ce in bayyana dalla-dalla hanyoyin da na ga masu goyon bayan ɓangarorin da ke adawa da muhawarar suna ƙara ko tsawaita muhawararsu fiye da ainihin bayanan da ke cikin binciken. Daga baya na canza ra'ayina lokacin da na lura da wata mummunar magana mai tayar da hankali da ke tasowa tsakanin mahalarta muhawarar. Ba muhawara game da abin da bayanan suka nuna a hankali ba, amma barazanar ad hominem, gami da barazanar ɗaukar mataki na shari'a. Na ga wani rubutu a shafin yanar gizo na PT ya ɓace, a bayyane yake saboda ɗaya daga cikin ɓangarorin ya nemi a cire shi. Har ma na sami wasu imel da suka fusata da kaina saboda ɗaya daga cikin ɓangarorin ya ji cewa na yi tambayoyi game da fassarar da ta dace ta binciken da ake magana a kai a cikin wani dandalin kimiyya.

Don haka, na yanke shawarar fitar da yatsana daga ɗakin a hankali. Na kuma yanke shawarar ci gaba da wallafa abin da na riga na rubuta wata guda da ta wuce, kawai don gabatar da misali na iƙirarin da na yi na cewa kimiyya ba wani abu ne da aka yi niyya ba, kuma masana kimiyya na gaske na iya shiga cikin aikinsu da kansu da kuma motsin rai. Wannan cece-kucen da ake yi shi ma kyakkyawan misali ne na wani yanayi da masu bincike na Amurka ke yawan kimanta sakamakon kimiyya mai laushi.

Wannan ya fusata Prause wanda ya yi jayayya (ta amfani da sunayen karya) da Johnson a cikin sashin sharhi na rubutunsa na Psychology Today game da binciken EEG na Prause na 2013 (lura cewa Johnson ba shi da ra'ayi game da jarabar jima'i). Tabbas ne cewa "wanda ba a san shi ba" shine Nicole Prause; wataƙila Jen H ma haka yake.


YABO & JOHNSON “MUHAWARA”

https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/556243#comment-556243}

Jen ta gabatar a ranar 21 ga Satumba, 2013 - 5:44 na yamma

Mun gode Dr. Johnson,

Ni ma na kasance cikin ƙuƙwalwa a kusa da waɗannan, ƙarancin zuciya, mafi muni, jaraba da jima'i.

Mafi kyawun sa'a ya kamata ka yanke shawarar jefa kanka cikin rami. Zan yi fatan samun wani kyakkyawan aiki a kan batun nan gaba.

gaisuwa

Jen H., CSW

Kalmar sha'awa ita ce kalmar da ake amfani da ita! {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/556450#comment-556450}

An gabatar da shi ta John A. Johnson Ph.D. a ranar 22 ga Satumba, 2013 - 9:10 na dare

Na gode da ra'ayinka, Jen.

Ga alama a gare ni cewa sha'awar shi ne takobi mai kaifi biyu. A gefen kirki, sha'awar ga wani abu yana nufin mutumin yana son zuba jari da yawa a kan wannan batu. Me yasa wani zaiyi wani abu sai dai idan yana sha'awar hakan?

A gefe guda, idan mutum mai sha'awar ya riga ya yi tunaninsa, duk wani ƙarfin makamashi zai kasance a kan yiwuwar yiwuwar, daidai ko kuskure. Kuma idan kuskure, sha'awar kaiwa ga makanta ga gaskiya.

Ina iya dakatar da waɗannan muhawarar kuma bari masu bincike masu hikima su yanke shawara.

Shafin yanar gizo zuwa zamba? {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/565636#comment-565636}

An gabatar da shi ta hannun wanda ba a san shi ba a ranar 2 ga Nuwamba, 2013 - 6:26 na dare

Kamar yadda kuka ambata, wannan muhawarar tunda cike take da ajanda. Koyaya, danganta muhawarar kimiyya da wasu bazuwar mutumin da ke ƙoƙarin siyar da littattafai? Ta yaya wannan ya inganta? Ina kuma tsammanin kun rasa ma'anar binciken… duk mutane suna nuna tsarin. Wannan rukunin (1) yayi kama da kowa, kuma (2) don tabbatarwa, ma'aunin kwakwalwa ba shi da alaƙa da kowane ma'auni na luwadi (kodayake yana son yin jima'i da abokin tarayya). Ban san dalilin da yasa ba ta da alaƙa da sha'awar yin al'aura ba, kodayake marubutan sun gudanar da sikelin duka kuma suna magana game da dalilin da yasa hakan.

Wataƙila na rasa ma'anar {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/565666#comment-565666}

An gabatar da shi ta John A. Johnson Ph.D. a ranar 2 ga Nuwamba, 2013 - 9:39 na dare

Idan batun binciken shine ya nuna cewa "duk mutane" (ba wai kawai wadanda ake zargi da lalata da jima'i ba) suna nuna karu a cikin P300 amplitude lokacin kallon hotunan jima'i, kunyi daidai – Ban fahimci batun ba, saboda binciken yana amfani da jima'i ne kawai jaraba. Idan binciken * ya yi aiki da ƙungiyar kwatanta marasa lafiya kuma suka gano cewa sun nuna P300 karu, to, masu binciken za su sami hujja game da da'awar cewa kwakwalwar waɗanda ake kira masu lalata da maza suna yin daidai da waɗanda ba sa shan magani , don haka wataƙila babu wani banbanci tsakanin waɗanda ake zargi da shan addican kwaya da waɗanda ba sa shan su. Madadin haka, binciken ya nuna cewa wadanda suka bayyana kansu da kansu sun nuna karuwar P300 saboda abin da suka bayyana da kansa “jaraba” (hotunan batsa), kamar yadda masu shan hodar iblis ke nuna karuwar P300 yayin da aka gabatar da hodar iblis, masu shaye-shaye suna nuna karuwar P300 lokacin da gabatar da barasa, da dai sauransu.

Game da abin da alaƙar da ke tsakanin faɗakarwar P300 da sauran ƙididdiga suka nuna, babban mahimmin haɗin kai shi ne * mummunan * haɗi tare da sha'awar yin jima'i tare da abokin tarayya. A takaice dai, thearfin ƙwaƙwalwar ƙwaƙwalwa ga hoton jima'i, ƙarancin sha'awar * mutum ya yi jima'i da mutumin gaske. Wannan sauti ne a wurina kamar bayanin wanda ya daidaita akan hotuna wanda yake da matsala haɗuwa da jima'i da mutane a rayuwa ta ainihi. Zan iya cewa wannan mutumin yana da matsala. Ko muna so mu kira wannan matsalar "jaraba" har yanzu ana iya jayayya. Amma ban ga yadda wannan binciken yake nuna * rashin * jaraba a cikin wannan samfurin ba.

Don sanin na, matsayina ba ta ƙunshe da haɗi zuwa ƙwararren ɗaliban ƙoƙarin sayar da littattafai ba. Shafin yanar gizo na Kwalejin Nazarin ya shafi gudummawar da mutane da dama suke sha'awar muhawarar, kuma na gayyaci masu karatu suyi hukunci akan kansu abin da hujjojin zasu iya samu. Ban lura da tallan tallace-tallace a kan wannan shafin ba.

To, zan kasance {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/565897#comment-565897}

An gabatar da shi ta hannun wanda ba a san shi ba a ranar 3 ga Nuwamba, 2013 - 8:37 na yamma

Da kyau, Zan kasance mai sa zuciya kuma ban ɗauka cewa marubucin wannan rubutun PT ko kuma marubutan labarin binciken suna da son kai ba. A gefe guda, wannan canjin (hotunan batsa da ke da mafi girman canji) Ina iya kimantawa an maimaita ta a kalla dakunan gwaje-gwaje 100 a cikin sarrafawa. Yana da karko sosai. Hakanan, sarrafawa shine ainihin mutanen da suke kan ƙarancin / ɓacewar ƙarshen ginin sha'awa. Sauye-sauye (ba haɗin kai ba) aka gudanar, ana iya yin suka saboda rashin ƙarancin ƙarshen kyakkyawan wakilci, amma kewayon ginin yana da wakilci. A ƙarshe, ba mu san cewa ba a tattara iko ba. Ilimin kimiyya yana da hankali. Zai iya zuwa kafin ka jefar da masanin kimiyyar tare da mashin din (ha!)

Wannan ya ce, akwai tambayoyi da dama da wannan binciken ya ta da:
1. Ta yaya mutumin da ke fuskantar matsalolin jima'i zai amsa?
2. Menene zai canza tare da nau'o'in hotuna?
3. Me game da fina-finai?

Babban tambaya, kodayake, shine… me yasa aka ɗauki dogon lokaci kafin ayi karatu irin wannan da farko? Haƙiƙa, yakamata masu goyon baya da masu haɗaka su kunyata saboda ƙarancin matakin ilimin kimiyya a wannan yanki.

Akwai ainihin masana kimiyya masu rubutun ra'ayin yanar gizo game da wannan batun idan kuna buƙatar ingantattun hanyoyin. Wannan mai rubutun ra'ayin yanar gizo ne wanda ya bayyana bashi da wata hujja kuma yayi kurakurai da yawa a cikin "bita". Har ma zan ba ku hanyoyin haɗin ilimin kimiyya na jaraba. PT bai kamata ya dogara da bita mai dadi irin wannan ba. Wataƙila an yi nufin ya zama sharhi ne game da son zuciya cewa marubucin PT ya zaɓi hanyar haɗi ne kawai daga mai rubutun ra'ayin yanar gizo wanda ba masanin kimiyya ba?

Fatan da kake da shi game da ni ya dace {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/556243#comment-556243}

An gabatar da shi ta John A. Johnson Ph.D. a ranar 3 ga Nuwamba, 2013 - 9:50 na dare

Ina iya samun damuwa a kan wannan batu, amma idan na yi, ban san su ba, kuma lallai ba lallai nake ƙoƙarin ƙoƙari na skeke muhawarar ɗaya hanya ko wata. Don haka kai ne daidai ka ɗauka cewa duk abin da kake so a cikin rubuce-rubuce ba na da niyya ba ne. Ko masu marubuta na binciken suna da gangancin son zuciya, ba zan iya fada ba. Ina tsammanin suna son nazarin su ya nuna cewa maganganun da ake yi na jima'i na jima'i ba su da bambanci daga amsawar wadanda ba'ayi ba don magance jarabar jima'i. Sun yarda da rahotannin a cikin kafofin yada labaran cewa bincikensu ya sanya shakku kan batun jima'i da jima'i. Amma ba shakka ba tare da ƙungiyar masu kula da marasa amfani ba don nuna cewa maganganun da ke tsakanin ƙungiyoyin biyu ba su da bambanci, da'awar lalata ra'ayi game da jima'i jima'i bai wuce ba.

Kuna cewa ba mu sani ba ko an sarrafa rukunin sarrafawa. Dangane da wannan tambayar a cikin dandalin kimiyya, masu binciken sun ce ba su da rukunin kulawa saboda babu wanda ake bukata, cewa mutanensu sun yi aiki a matsayin ikon kansu a cikin tsarin abubuwan cikin su. Na gano cewa amsar ba ta da ma'ana saboda kawai kwatancen da aka yi da abubuwan da suke ciki shine martani na P300 ga nau'ikan abubuwan daukar hoto. Wannan ya nuna cewa karuwar P300 ta kasance mafi girma don hotunan batsa ya fi na sauran hotunan. Amma ko girman girman ya yi daidai ko ya bambanta da waɗanda aka bayyana da kansu waɗanda ba sa shan magani, ba mu sani ba. Idan akwai binciken daga ɗaruruwan dakunan gwaje-gwaje akan wannan, da marubutan zasu iya yin wannan kwatancen. Amma ba su yi ba.

Idan masu bincike sun hada da kansu da aka ba da labarin cewa ba su da ha'inci a cikin binciken su, haɓakar da ke tsakanin P300 amplitude da kuma sha'awar yin jima'i tare da abokin tarayya sun kasance sun fi karfi fiye da yadda suke nunawa. Sakamakon haɓaka da aka samo an rage su saboda ƙuntatawa a cikin P300 amplitude. Don haka sun yi wa kansu rashin kwance ta hanyar ba tare da wani samfurori da suka hada da mutanen da ba su bayar da rahoton matsalolin da ke kula da su na yanar gizo na erotica ba.

Ina amfani da kalmomin koma baya da daidaitawa tare. Ko mutum ya gudanar da sauƙaƙan sauƙaƙan ragowa ko ɗayan siffofin sake komowa da yawa, duk fasali ne na tsarin layi na gaba ɗaya. Mun taƙaita daidaiton haɗin Pearson tare da ƙaramar harafi r, wanda ke tsaye don sake komawa baya. Kada mu sa-ido a kan abubuwan da ba daidai ba.

Saboda ba ni da wani matsayi a cikin muhawarar jima'i, ba na so in zaɓi kawai a kan wannan binciken bincike game da cin zarafi ba wai masu sukar jarabawar binciken ba. Shafin da na alakanta shi yana dauke ne da sake dubawa wanda tabbas akwai son zuciya ta hanyar su, kodayake kuma ba na son yin hasashe kan ko son zuciya da gangan ne ko a'a. Ni marubucin ɗayan abubuwan sake dubawa a wannan rukunin ya tambaye ni don in duba sukar tasa kafin a buga ta, don haka na yi, kuma na bayyana abin da nake tsammanin daidai ne kuma ba daidai ba a cikin suka. Ya bi wasu, amma ba duka ba, na shawarwarina don sake yin suka game da sukarsa. Don haka, ee, akwai kura-kurai a cikin bita saboda ba duk shawarwarina aka bi ba. Na nuna wannan shafin ne kawai a matsayin wuri na farawa don batutuwan da ake tattaunawa. Idan za ku iya samar da hanyoyin haɗi zuwa ingantaccen sharhi (ko dai jarabar-buri ko anti-buri), wannan zai zama babban sabis ga waɗanda ke cikin masu sauraro waɗanda ke sha'awar batun jima'i.

Kamar yadda na ce, babban abin da nake sha'awa shi ne abubuwan da suka shafi halayyar mutum da ke shafar gudanar da fassarar binciken kimiyya, fiye da batun jarabar jima'i ta kowane fanni. Wataƙila ya kasance da sauƙi a gare ni in nuna shafin mai bi na gaskiya game da batun jarabar jima'i don kwatanta yiwuwar abubuwan halayyar halayyar mutum da ke shafar fassarar bincike fiye da mafi tsayayyen wuri, tsaka-tsakin yanar gizon da ƙwararrun masu binciken jima'i ke kula da shi. Idan akwai irin wannan shafin da ake zargi da nuna son kai (ba da son rai ba), Ina so in sami adireshin URL don in gani da kaina ko da gaske ba son zuciya bane. Neman tattaunawa mara son kai game da jarabar jima'i zai zama na farko a gare ni.

Craptastic {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566091#comment-566091}

Jen ta gabatar a ranar 4 ga Nuwamba, 2013 - 4:02pm

Lalle ne. Sauti a gare ni kamar marubucin zai yiwu ya biya mafi girma ga sauraron ku, kafin a buga shi.

Ateiyayya don nuna abin da ke bayyane mai raɗaɗi a nan, buuuut, ana iya cewa cikin aminci cewa idan babbar muhawarar da ta shafi bugawar mutum ita ce inganci, maimakon abin da ke ciki, akwai matsala tabbatacciya.

Matsala ga ilimin halayyar ɗan adam gaba ɗaya {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566277#comment-566277}

An gabatar da shi ta John A. Johnson Ph.D. a ranar 5 ga Nuwamba, 2013 - 11:14 na safe

Haka ne, idan matsala ba ta bayyana ba, ya kamata. Wannan matsala ba abu ne na musamman ba, ko da yake, ga wannan batun. Yana gudana a fannin ilimin kimiyya.

Masanan ilimin halayyar dan adam suna samun horo sosai a cikin tunani mai mahimmanci, wanda nake nufi neman aibi a cikin binciken bincike da samar da wasu fassarar sakamako, cewa yawancinmu mun sami hauhawar jini na aikinmu mai mahimmanci da kuma ƙyamar aikinmu mai haɓaka, mai kirkirar abubuwa. Masana ilimin halayyar dan Adam ba zasu daɗe suna ɗaukar kurakurai a cikin tsarin karatun da ba sa tallafawa abubuwan da suka riga suka yi imani da su. Wannan nuni ne na matsala tare da koyar da ilimin halayyar gaba daya. Babu wani binciken da ya dace da cikakkiyar hanya, har ma da karatun da aka buga wanda ya sami cikakken bita. Abu daya ne samun damar samun nakasu a karatun da ke yanke hukuncin da baka so; wani abu ne don tsarawa da gudanar da bincike wanda ke samar da goyan bayan mara ma'ana don ra'ayi daban.

Eh, kada a karkatar da hankalinka {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566638#comment-566638}

An gabatar da shi ta hannun wanda ba a san shi ba a ranar 6 ga Nuwamba, 2013 - 6:58 na dare

Eh, ba don karkatar da hankali ba amma “Mun taƙaita daidaiton haɗin Pearson tare da ƙaramin harafin r, wanda ke tsaye don koma baya” tabbas ba. Ragewa yana gano kuskuren daban da yadda ya dace. A sauƙaƙe za ku iya gaya wa ainihin waɗanda suka karanta karatun da aka duba… idan sun ce “daidaitawa” ba su san abin da aka yi ba a ƙididdiga (mutumin da ke hanyar haɗin ku ya yi kuskure ɗaya). Kar ka zama mutumin!

Duk da haka dai, ban sami adadin masu rubutun ra'ayin yanar gizo na kimiyya suna magana game da wannan batun ba, amma akwai wasu daɗi masu kyau, daidaitaccen bita da zaku iya ambata:
Wasu PT blogger da ilimi addictions guy:
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/addiction-in-society/201307/the-apocryphal-debate-about-sex-addiction

Daga babban guy kokarin ƙoƙarin samun liwadi cikin DSM:
https://web.archive.org/web/20160313043414/http://rory.net/pages/prausecritque.html

Wani mutumin da ya wallafa a kan buri, ko da yake ba game da wannan binciken ba:
https://web.archive.org/web/20150128192512/http://www.sexologytoday.org/2012/03/steve-mcqueens-shame-valid-portrayal-of.html

Tabbatacce ya buge mai ba da ilimin warkarwa a cikin Oregon don ikon su don daidaitawa daidai. Ban yarda da waɗannan duka ba, ba shakka, amma wannan ita ce ma'anar. Wadannan aƙalla suna nuna mai kyau da mara kyau, alhali sukar da aka ambata a zahiri ƙarya ce (misali, marubutan SNP sun tattara kuma sun ba da rahoton duk sikelin SDI). Yana da kyau koyaushe kar a inganta bayanan karya!

An ɗauko daga binciken {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566673#comment-566673}

An gabatar da shi ta John A. Johnson Ph.D. a ranar 6 ga Nuwamba, 2013 - 10:29 na dare

Bari in faɗi daga binciken, wanda na zahiri ya karanta kafin rubutawa na post. Daga http://www.socioaffectiveneuroscipsychol.net/index.php/snp/article/view/20770/28995:

“An kirga abubuwan da Pearson ya yi daidai a tsakanin ma'ana masu yawa da aka auna ta taga ta P300 da kuma bayanan tambayoyin kai-da kai. Iyakar abin da ya kai ga mahimmancin shi ne bambancin maki da aka lasafta tsakanin tsaka tsaki da yanayi mai kyau na jima'i a cikin taga ta P300 tare da sha'awar yin jima'i tare da ma'aunin ma'auni, r (52) = - 0.332, p = 0.016. "

Haka ne, masu bincike sun gudanar da wasu nazari na sharudda akai-akai, amma zaka iya ganin daga sama da cewa sun kirga Pearson coalfficients.

Bugu da ƙari kuma, Ina kula da cewa sakewa da daidaitawa ba abubuwa ne daban biyu ba. Ina sane da cewa wasu mutane suna cewa daidaiton daidaito, r, "kawai" jadawalin adadi ne na ƙarfin alaƙar linzami tsakanin x da y, yayin da koma baya yana nufin kimanta ko dai x ko y dangane da layin da ya fi dacewa , ko dai y '= bx + a ko x' = ta + a. Amma idan muka sake komawa y akan x, darajar mafi kyau ga gangare, b, ita ce r * Sy / Sx. Auki kowane littafi akan ƙididdigar halayyar mutum (misali, Quinn McNemar) kuma karanta tattaunawa game da daidaitawa da koma baya.

Mun gode da kara wadannan bayanan. Na saba da matsayin Peele (Stanton Peele hakika halastaccen ƙwararren masani ne akan batun), kuma na karanta littafin Rory Reid, amma ba rubutun James Cantor ba (kodayake na saba da girmama tunaninsa). Waɗannan ƙarin nassoshi sabis ne ga waɗanda suke son ƙarin bayani.

An sake yin kuskuren bincike {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566683#comment-566683}

An gabatar da shi ta hannun wanda ba a san shi ba a ranar 6 ga Nuwamba, 2013 - 11:15 na dare

"Don bincika kai tsaye alaƙar da ke tsakanin bambance-bambancen nisan yanayi a cikin P300, an lasafta matakan koma baya na matakai biyu."

Ni mai ba da shawara ne a kan ilimin lissafi, kuma kuna ba wa kanku kunya. Kalmar kurakurai ta bambanta tsakanin koma baya da daidaitawa… su ne, a zahiri “abubuwa biyu ne daban”. Yaya a duniya kuke aiki a cikin ɓoye? Akalla ku kaurace wa ɗalibai na!

Ban tabbata dalilin da yasa kake {https://www.psychologytoday.com/comment/566750#comment-566750}

An gabatar da shi ta John A. Johnson Ph.D. a ranar 7 ga Nuwamba, 2013 - 9:32 na safe

Ban tabbata ba dalilin da ya sa kuka ba da abin da aka samo daga binciken ba, "an ƙididdige matakan koma baya biyu," lokacin da na riga na yarda cewa nazarin masu binciken ya haɗa da koma baya da yawa da ƙididdigar haɗin gwiwar Pearson.

Kamar yadda na ce, "Haka ne, masu binciken sun kuma gudanar da wasu sharudda da yawa game da koma baya, amma kuna iya gani daga abin da muka ambata a sama cewa sun kirga daidaitattun daidaito na Pearson."

Dalilin da yasa na fitar da zancen, “An kirga abubuwan da Pearson yayi. . . ”Saboda kun nuna cewa ni da mai sukar ba mu karanta karatun ba. Ka ce, "A sauƙaƙe kuna iya gaya wa ainihin waɗanda suka karanta binciken da aka duba reviewed idan sun ce 'haɗin kai' ba su san abin da aka yi ba a cikin ƙididdiga (mutumin da ke haɗin haɗin ku ya yi kuskure ɗaya)."

Idan kana son kulawa da rikici da daidaitawa abu ne daban-daban, zama bako. Ban san ko wane ɗalibanku ba ne saboda kun kasance m. Ko da na yi, ba zan dame su ba. Ba na jin kunya game da aiki na a matsayin mai ilimin ilimin psychologist; Ina fatan cewa za ku sami aikinku mai gamsarwa.