Hanyoyin Ciniki na Rubuce-rubucen Kasuwanci (PCES): Mai amfani ko a'a?

PCES na haifar da sakamako mai mahimmanci wanda ya samo rayuka na batsa

Sabuntawa: A cikin wannan gabatarwar NCOSE ta 2018 - Binciken Batsa: Gaskiya ko Almara? - Gary Wilson ya fallasa gaskiyar da ke bayan bincike 5 da masu yada farfaganda suka ambata don tallafawa ikirarinsu cewa babu jarabar batsa ko kuma cewa amfani da batsa yana da matuƙar amfani. Ana sukar PCES daga ƙarfe 36:00 zuwa 43:20.

————————————————————————————————————

Wannan rubutun ya yi magana ne game da tambayoyin amfani da batsa da aka sani da Sikelin Tasirin Amfani da Batsa (PCES) . Nazarce-nazarce da dama sun yi amfani da shi, tare da takardar da ta ƙirƙiri PCES ( Hald & Malamuth , 2008 ) da ƙarfin hali sun kammala da cewa " Matasa 'yan Denmark sun yi imanin cewa batsa ta yi tasiri mai kyau a fannoni daban-daban na rayuwarsu ."

Binciken kawai yana auna tasirin "tsinkaye" na batsa. Wannan kamar tambayar kifi abin da take tunani game da ruwa, ko kuma kamar tambayar wani yadda rayuwarta ta canza ta girma a cikin Minnesota. Lallai, tambayar samari game da tasirin batsa ba kamar shiga cikin mashaya ba ne a 10 na dare kuma tambayar duk masu ba da shawara yadda giya ke shafar daren Juma'a. Irin wannan hanyar ba ta ware tasirin batsa ba. Ya bambanta, kwatanta rahotannin masu amfani da rahotanni na waɗanda ba masu amfani ba ko bin mutanen da suka daina batsa zai ƙara bayyana ainihin tasirin batsa.

A zahiri, sakamakon cewa matasan Denmark suna son batsa ba abin mamaki ba ne (kodayake bayan an yi bincike sosai, wasu daga cikin sakamakon binciken suna da matukar zargi). Binciken ya fito ne a shekarar 2007, kuma an tattara bayanan sama da shekaru goma da suka gabata, a shekarar 2003—kafin a yada bidiyon batsa a shafukan intanet , kafin a fara amfani da waya, da kuma kafin wayoyin komai da ruwanka. Rahotannin alamun batsa masu tsanani (musamman a tsakanin matasa masu amfani) sun fara bayyana a cikin shekaru goma da suka gabata. Shekaru goma da suka gabata, yana yiwuwa matasan Denmark da ke amfani da batsa ba su lura da matsaloli da yawa ba. Ana iya ɗaukar batsa ta intanet a matsayin taimakon al'aura, ko kuma aƙalla mara lahani.

Kamar yadda binciken cewa samarin Danes waɗanda aka ɗauka amfani da batsa amfani ba su da ma'ana saboda zamaninsa, ba mu damu da karanta dukan binciken ba ko duba tambayoyin PCES-har sai an yi amfani da shi a cikin binciken kwanan nan. Lokacin da muka kalli PCES a zahiri munyi suma. Da alama ƙarancin kaɗan ne amma sha'awar masu yin sa don nuna cewa yin amfani da batsa “tabbatacce ne,” kuma wasu maganganun nasa sun wuce yarda. Ka yi la'akari da waɗannan:

1. Da farko, wannan binciken, "ya gano cewa maza da mata gabaɗaya sun ba da rahoton ƙananan ko matsakaici sakamako masu kyau na shan batsa mai ƙarfi da kuma ƙarancin illa, idan akwai, irin wannan shan."

  • A wasu kalmomin, Amfani da batsa ya kasance mai amfani tare da 'yan kaɗan, idan akwai, drawbacks.

2. Bugu da ƙari, "Bayan an shigar da duk masu canji a cikin lissafin, masu canji guda uku na asalin jima'i sun ba da gudummawa mai mahimmanci ga tasirin da ke da kyau : yawan amfani da batsa, fahimtar gaskiyar batsa da kuma yawan yin al'aura."

  • A wasu kalmomin, da karin batsa da kake amfani da shi, da gaske da gaske ka gaskanta shi ne, da kuma yadda ka kara da shi, mafi yawan abin da ke faruwa a kowane bangare na rayuwarka. Ba wasa ba.
  • Yin amfani da ƙididdigar masu binciken, idan kai ɗan shekara 30 ne wanda ke yin al'aura zuwa batsa sau 5 a rana, batsa yana ba da gudummawa ta musamman ga rayuwarka.
  • A hanyar, sakamakon PCES ya yi ba goyi bayan bayanin da ya san batsa a matsayin ainihin amfani. Abin da ya bambanta kamar yadda kake gani daga zurfin nazarin nazarin binciken da ke ƙasa wannan sakon.

3. Mafi ban mamaki, "An gano cewa rahoton tasirin amfani da batsa gaba ɗaya yana da alaƙa mai ƙarfi da inganci ta hanyar layi tare da yawan shan batsa mai ƙarfi."

  • Saboda haka, mafi mahimmancin kallon batsa daya shine mafi girma a cikin rayuwarka. Hankali 15-shekara-shekara: Ka lura da batsa mafi tsanani, tashin hankali zaka iya samun haka kai ma, za ka iya samun kwarewa masu yawa.
  • Lura cewa masu binciken ba sa ma cewa akwai kararrawa, inda yawa zai zama da lahani idan aka kwatanta shi da matsakaici amfani. Sakamakon su shine, "isari koyaushe shine mafi kyau." Abin al'ajabi, a'a?
  • A gaskiya ma, PCES “sun samo” cewa ba Yin amfani da batuttukan yanar gizo na yanar gizo yana kawo sakamako mai kyau.

Ta yaya za a iya samun ma'anoni guda 3—gwargwadon wahalar batsa, gwargwadon yadda kake ganin gaskiya ne ( sic ) , da kuma yadda kake yin lalata da shi—koyaushe ana danganta su da fa'idodi mafi girma?

Da farko, babu wani wuri a cikin yanayi da "Ƙari koyaushe ya fi kyau" ke bayyana. Ƙarin abinci, ƙarin ruwa, yawan iskar oxygen, ƙarin bitamin, ƙarin ma'adanai, ƙarin rana, ƙarin barci, ƙarin motsa jiki….akwai wani abu da ke haifar da mummunan sakamako, ko ma mutuwa. To ta yaya wannan motsawar guda ɗaya za ta zama banda? Ba zai iya ba.

Abu na biyu, idan duk abin da ka san shi ne amfani da batsa, ba ka da masaniya game da yadda yake shafarka har sai ka bar (kuma mafi yawa ba don watanni ba).

Na uku, tambayoyin PCES, da yadda ake lissafin su, an tsara su don gano cewa “ƙari koyaushe ya fi kyau.”

A sauƙaƙe, PCES koyaushe tana gano cewa ƙarin amfani da batsa yana dacewa da mafi girma a cikin dukkanin nau'ikan 5 na ƙididdiga masu kyau a rayuwar mutum: 1) Rayuwar Jima'i, 2) Halaye Game da Jima'i, 3) Ilimin Jima'i, 4) Hankali / Halaye Ga Mata, 5) Rayuwa Gaba .aya. Wadannan binciken da ba a yarda da su ba suna kusan kusan kowane binciken da ya yi amfani da matakai masu sauki na tasirin batsa. Misali:

Tambaya: wacce ke samar da cikakken hoto: (1) daruruwan karatu ta amfani da hanyoyi daban-daban, (2) ko wata tambaya mai cike da kurakurai (PCES) wacce ta gano cewa “rashin amfani da batsa” da gaske yana munana a gare ku?

Bari mu ga yadda PCES ke ƙirƙirar sakamakon sihiri.

Aiwatar da tambayoyin PCES zuwa rayuwa

Ka sanya kanka a cikin matsayin matasa maza masu amfani da batsa na yau. Ka ga kowace irin batsa da ake iya tunaninta a cikin bidiyo mai inganci, kuma nau'ikan vanilla ba sa ƙara tayar da hankalinka. Haka nan kana fama da ɗaya ko fiye daga cikin waɗannan alamun da aka ruwaito sosai: rashin sha'awar abokan zama na gaske, jinkirin jima'i ko jinkirin fitar da maniyyi tare da abokan zama na gaske, ƙaruwa zuwa rikitar da dandanon batsa, da kuma wataƙila ma rashin halayyar damuwa ta zamantakewa da rashin kwarin gwiwa. Amma ba ka taɓa daina amfani da batsa na dogon lokaci ba don gano, ko ma zargin , ko ɗayan waɗannan alamun suna da alaƙa da amfani da batsa ɗinka.

Idan aka ba da yanayinka, shin za ku iya samun ƙarshen abin da bai kai ƙima a PCES ba? Ba ma tunanin haka. 7 shine mafi girman maki ga kowace tambaya. Daga cikin tambayoyin PCES 47, 27 (mafiya yawa) suna da “tabbatacce.” Wannan yana faruwa ne saboda masu binciken sun ɗauka cewa “ilimin jima’i” na iya zama mai kyau kawai. Don haka, tambayoyin 7 na "karin" game da ilimin jima'i basu da takwarorinsu. Wannan zato ne mai ban sha'awa, kamar yadda muka ga yawancin masu amfani da batsa suna ba da rahoton cewa sun gani kuma sun koyi abubuwa daga batsa waɗanda suke fata da gaske su manta.

A kowane hali, ta yaya matashi mai amfani da batsa wanda aka bayyana a sama ya ci waɗannan samfurin tambayoyin "tabbatacce"?

14. ____ Shin ka ƙara wa iliminka game da jima'i ta dubura? "Eh! = 7 "

15. ____ Shin ya shafi ra'ayinka game da akasin jinsi? "Ina tsammanin haka ne. Taurarin batsa suna da kyau. = 6 "

28. ____ Gabaɗaya, shin ya zama ƙarin amfani ga rayuwar jima'i? "Ee, ban taɓa yin al'aura ba tare da shi ba." = 7 "

45. ____ Shin ya sa ka zama mai sassaucin ra'ayi game da jima'i? "Babu shakka. = 7 "

Ga wasu daga cikin tambayoyin 20 "mara kyau":

2. ____ Shin ya sa ka rage haƙuri ga jima'i? "Shin kana wasa ne? Ina kallon jima'i na tsawon sa'o'i a kowane mako. = 1 "

25. ____ Ya rage ingancin rayuwarka? "Ba zan iya tunanin rayuwa ba tare da batsa ta ba, don haka a'a. = 1 "

40. ____ Shin ka haifar da matsaloli a rayuwar jima'i? "A'a, ni budurwa ce." = 1 "

46. ​​____ Gabaɗaya, yana haifar maka da damuwa game da aiki idan kana yin jima'i da kanka (misali, yayin yin jima'i)? "Shin kana wasa ne? 'Ba shakka. = 1 "

Bayan haka, masu binciken sun raba amsoshin masu amfani zuwa rukuni da dama: 1) Rayuwar Jima'i, 2) Ra'ayoyi Game da Jima'i, 3) Ilimin Jima'i, 4) Fahimta/Halayen Mata, 5) Rayuwa Gabaɗaya. Ba kamar rukunin Ilimin Jima'i ba, sauran rukunoni 4 suna da tambayoyi "masu kyau" da "marasa kyau". Ga waɗannan rukunoni, masu binciken sun ba da rahoton ko matsakaicin mai kyau ya fi matsakaicin mara kyau. A zahiri, suna ba mu bambance-bambance tsakanin matsakaicin tambayoyi "masu kyau" da "mara kyau" ga rukunoni 4, ba tare da nuna mana ainihin matsakaicin matasan 'yan Denmark ba. A wata ma'anar, duk da mun san amsar wasu tambayoyi "masu kyau" na iya zama mai zafi, amma maki na tambayoyin "mara kyau" da ke da alaƙa sun yi ƙasa sosai har yaɗuwar da ke tsakaninsu ta isa ta ba da hoto na ƙarya wanda 'yan Denmark suka ji daɗi sosai game da batsa, lokacin da, a zahiri, ba su ji batsa yana da amfani sosai ba, amma kawai ba su ga wani abu mai yawa a cikin hanyar amfani da shi ba ( Duba duka PCES )

Idan wannan ba za a iya fahimta ba, duba bayanin da ke ƙasa—wanda wani babban farfesa ya bayar wanda ke yawan duba binciken ilimin halayyar ɗan adam. Ya kuma nuna cewa, sabanin ka'idar masu binciken cewa maza suna ganin ƙarancin mummunan tasirin amfani da batsa fiye da mata, maza a zahiri sun ba da rahoton mummunan tasirin da ya fi mata a fannoni biyu: Rayuwar Jima'i da Rayuwa Gabaɗaya. Masu binciken ba su tattauna waɗannan binciken ba, wanda a bayyane yake bai yi tasiri ga sakamakon batsa mai kyau ba. Duk da haka mun ga suna da ban sha'awa saboda a cikin shekarun da suka gabata maza masu amfani da batsa masu sauri sun ƙara ba da rahoton matsalolin aikin jima'i da sauran alamu waɗanda ke sa rayuwa ta zama ƙasa da daɗi.

Baya ga al'amurran da suka shafi fasahar da suka shafi sama, akwai wasu matsalolin da ke damunmu game da PCES:

  1. Rage halayen rayuwa, lalacewa da dangantaka, da kuma wani jima'i ba tare da wani jima'i ba, suna cikin daidaito a cikin PCES tare da koyo game da ayyukan jima'i da kuma mafi yawan dabi'un kirki game da jima'i.
  2. Yawancin mutane suna yin amfani da batsa tun lokacin balaga (ko ma a da) amma ba su taɓa yin jima'i ba. Ba za su iya yiwuwa su san yadda ya shafi ra'ayinsu game da akasin jinsi ko rayuwar jima'i ba. Idan aka kwatanta da menene? Ga waɗannan mutane, tambayoyin PCES da yawa sunyi daidai da tambayar yadda ake ka 'yar uwa ta shafi rayuwar ku.
  3. Yawancin mutane ba su da cikakkiyar fahimtar abin da alamun cutar ke haɗuwa da amfani da batsa har sai watanni bayan sun daina amfani da shi, don haka koda kuwa suna da shi mai tsanani bayyanar cututtuka (jinkirta kawowa, erectile tabarbarewa, zubar da jima'i, asarar janyo hankulan abokan hulɗa, mai tsanani ba tare da kulawa ba, matsalolin taro, ko ciki), usersan masu amfani na yanzu zasu haɗu da irin waɗannan alamun tare da amfani da batsa ta Intanit-musamman idan aka ba da kalmomin marasa ma'ana da PCES ke amfani da su: “cutar” “ingancin rayuwa.”

A wasu kalmomin, ana iya lalata auren ku kuma kuna iya samun ci gaba na ED, amma maki PCES ɗin ku na iya nuna cewa batsa ta kasance mai kyau a gare ku. A zahiri, idan kai ɗaya ne daga cikin jinsin mutane waɗanda ba su amfani da batsa na Intanit, ƙirarku ta PCES na iya nuna cewa rashin yin amfani da batsa yana da lahani a rayuwar ku saboda kawai kuna iya sani ne game da ayyukan vanilla. Kamar yadda mai dawo da mai amfani da batsa ya fada bayan kallon PCES:

“Haka ne, Na bar jami'a, na sami matsaloli game da wasu abubuwan maye, ban taɓa samun budurwa ba, na rasa abokai, na ci bashi, har yanzu ina da ED kuma ban taɓa yin jima'i a rayuwa ta ainihi ba. Amma aƙalla na sani game da duk tauraron tauraron dan adam yana aiki kuma ina hanzarta zuwa kowane matsayi. Don haka ee, asali batsa ta wadatar da rayuwata ba iyaka. ”

Wani kuma:

"Na san yadda ake saka dildo a cikin dubura ta kware, amma yarana suna zaune a wani gari saboda abin da tsoho na ya samu a kwamfutarmu."

Ta karfafa masu bincike su tambayi tambayoyi masu muhimmanci

A ina ne karatun ke yin tambaya ga ƙungiyar mafi yawan hatsari (matasa) tambayoyin da zasu bayyana irin bayyanar cututtuka da suke ƙara yawan rahoto a yau? Kamar,

  • “Shin zaku iya yin al'aura zuwa karshe ba tare da Batsa ta Intanet? ”
  • "Shin kun zama ba mai kuzari sosai ba tun lokacin da kuka fara amfani da batsa ta Intanet?"
  • "Shin har yanzu kuna iya kammalawa zuwa nau'ikan batsa na Intanet da kuka fara da su?"
  • "Shin kun haɓaka zuwa nau'ikan batsa na Intanet da kuke damun ku?"
  • "Shin kun fara tambaya game da yanayin jima'i tun lokacin da kuka fara amfani da batsa na Intanet?"
  • "Lokacin da kake kwatanta tsinkayenka yayin amfani da batsa ta Intanit zuwa tsararrunku tare da abokin tarayya na gaske shin kuna lura da matsaloli tare da na biyun?"
  • "Lokacin da kuka gwada ikon ku na ƙarshe yayin amfani da batsa na Intanit da ikon ku na ƙarshe tare da abokin tarayya na gaske kuna lura da matsaloli tare da na biyun?"

Abin farin ciki, binciken da masana kimiyyar jijiyoyi ke yi yana bayyana cewa amfani da batsa na iya haifar da canje-canje a kwakwalwa da suka shafi jaraba . Sakamakon waɗannan nazarin jijiyoyi ( da kuma nazarin da ke tafe ) sun yi daidai da jarabar intanet sama da 280 "nazarin kwakwalwa" , wanda da yawa daga cikinsu sun haɗa da amfani da batsa ta intanet. Sabanin "sakamakon" na PCES sama da 80 sun haɗa amfani da batsa da matsalolin jima'i da ƙarancin gamsuwar jima'i da dangantaka. Yana bayyana cewa komai yawan tambayoyin da aka gina don shawo kan jama'a cewa amfani da batsa ta intanet "mai kyau ne," idan masu amfani suna ba da rahoton matsalolin aikin jima'i, wasu alamu masu tsanani, da jaraba da ke warwarewa lokacin da suka daina batsa, irin waɗannan tambayoyin ba su isa ba ta hanyoyi masu mahimmanci. Ga yawancin masu amfani da batsa masu sauri a yau, batsa yana tabbatar da " rashin jima'i ."

Rikicin da ke tsakanin hukumomi abin tunatarwa ne mai kyau cewa tsari ba lallai bane ya zama garantin al'ada . Mataki ne mai tsawo tsakanin "daidaitacce" da kuma ma'anar cewa hali na yau da kullun shi ma "daidaitacce ne," ko ma "mai lafiya." Duk da haka "daidaitacce" a zahiri yana nufin cikin sigogin aiki mai kyau . Komai yawan mutane da ke shiga cikin wani hali ko yadda suke son sa, idan ya haifar da ilimin cututtuka, masu binciken lafiya na gaskiya ba za su sanya sakamakon a matsayin "daidaitacce ba." Ka yi tunanin shan taba a shekarun 1960. A yau, likitocin urologists suna ba da rahoton adadi mai ban mamaki na samari masu fama da ED, wani yanayin da yawancin masu ba da lafiya da tsoffin masu amfani da batsa ke haɗuwa da shan batsa ta Intanet fiye da kima.

Duk wanda ke sha'awar tasirin batsa zai yi kyau ya karanta fiye da kanun labarai da ƙarshe bisa ga sakamakon tambayoyin PCES. Yi nazari kan dukkan binciken. Shin masu binciken sun yi tambayoyi da za su gano manyan alamun da wasu masu amfani da batsa a yau ke ba da rahoto? Shin sun kwatanta masu amfani da su da tsoffin masu amfani, don ganin tasirin cire canjin amfani da batsa? Shin sun yi tambayoyi ne kawai waɗanda za su jawo, misali, bayanai masu kyau game da batsa? Shin an tattara shaidun kuma an yi nazari a kansu bisa ga alhaki? Shin masu bincike sun tantance waɗanda suka yi jaraba, ta amfani da gwaji kamar sabon s-IAT (Gwajin jaraba ta Intanet na ɗan gajeren lokaci) wanda wannan ƙungiyar Jamus ta ƙirƙiro?

Kawai saboda kuna son hakan ba zai amfane ku ba

Fiye da komai, ku yi shakkar nazarin batsa bisa ga tasirin da kuka fahimta. Waɗannan ba za su iya gaya mana komai game da sakamako mai kyau da mara kyau na batsa ba, duk da haka suna yin labarai masu daɗi da ban sha'awa, waɗanda masu amfani da batsa masu yawa ke dogara da su don yin la'akari da ci gaba da amfani da su duk da alamun gargaɗi da alamun. Duba, misali kwanan nan " Kiyasin Kai na Ayyukan Jima'i na Kan layi da ke da Alaƙa da Sha'awa a Jami'a da Al'umma ." Ta yi amfani da gajeriyar sigar PCES, kuma, ba abin mamaki ba, ta gano cewa mahalarta sun ba da rahoton sakamako mafi kyau fiye da mara kyau daga amfani da batsa.

Haɗarin irin wannan karatun shi ne, da dabara suna inganta kuskuren imanin cewa "Idan ina son batsa sosai, to yana da tasiri a kaina." Wannan yana daidai da ƙirƙirar binciken da ke tabbatarwa yara cewa idan suna son hatsi mai ruɓaɓɓen sukari yana da kyau a gare su.


"Nazarin wani mummunan tunani ne na tunani"

Babban jami'in farfesa a jami'a mai yawa, wanda yawancin 'yan uwansa ke nazarin bincike na ilimin kimiyya, ya kara damuwa game da tsarin PCES:

Babbar matsala da wannan binciken ita ce masu binciken sun yanke shawarar cewa za su iya ƙirƙirar ma'aunin tasirin "mai kyau" da "mara kyau" ta hanyar da ta dace kawai bisa ga kalmomin abubuwan. Wannan ya sa suka gudanar da nazarin ma'auni a matakin ma'aunin da aka riga aka ƙaddara mai kyau da mara kyau maimakon a matakin abubuwan da aka ƙayyade. Da sun yi nazarin ma'aunin matakin abu, da sun gano cewa abubuwan da ke magana kan yanki ɗaya (rayuwar jima'i, rayuwa gabaɗaya, da sauransu) duk an ɗora su akan abu ɗaya maimakon akan abubuwa masu kyau da mara kyau daban-daban. Da an sami wannan sakamakon, wannan yana nufin cewa abubuwan suna tantance ci gaba da ma'aunin sakamako mara kyau maimakon bambance sakamako masu kyau da mara kyau. Kuma idan wannan shine sakamakon, da ba zai yiwu a fassara ko matsakaicin ma'aunin ya nuna mafi kyau fiye da mara kyau ba.

Kawai saboda matsakaicin matsayi yana sama da tsakiyar tsakiyar (misali> 24 akan abu 8, 7-ma'auni Likert ma'auni inda maki zai iya bambanta daga 8 zuwa 56), wannan ba yana nufin cewa maki yana nuna sakamako mai kyau na gaske ba. Ba za a iya karɓar rahoton kai tsaye ta ƙimar fuska ta wannan hanyar ba. Idan za su iya, kuma mun nemi rukuni na mutane su kimanta nasu ilimin, za mu ga cewa mutane gabaɗaya sun fi matsakaita cikin hankali. Masu binciken kamar suna sane da wannan matsalar, yayin da suke tattauna batun fahimtar mutum na farko da na uku game da tasirin watsa labarai a gabatarwar labarin. Sannan suna ci gaba da ɗaukar tsinkayen kai da rahotanni kai tsaye da ƙima.

... Amfani da gwaje-gwajen t don kwatanta hanyoyin yana da matsala. Hakika, za ku iya ƙididdige gwaje-gwajen t kuma ku sami sakamako kamar waɗanda aka ruwaito a cikin Tebur 4. Amma wannan ba yana nufin cewa sakamakon yana da ma'ana ba. Misali, ɗauki bambancin maki 1.15 a cikin matsakaicin maki na Rayuwa a Gabaɗaya ga maza. Masu binciken ba sa bayar da rahoton ainihin ma'ana, kawai bambance-bambancen ma'ana ne , don haka bari in ƙididdige wasu hanyoyi. Bari mu ce samfurin yana da matsakaicin maki na 24.15 akan ingantaccen Life a Gabaɗaya da 23.00 akan mummunan Life a Gabaɗaya (dukansu ma'auni ne na abubuwa 4, ma'auni na Likert mataki 7, don haka maki na iya bambanta daga 4 zuwa 28). Domin wannan ya zama bambanci mai ma'ana, maki na 23 ko 24 ko duk abin da ke kan sikelin ɗaya dole ne ya wakilci matakin girma iri ɗaya a ɗayan sikelin. Amma ba mu san hakan ba, saboda dalilai iri ɗaya cewa ba za a iya ɗaukar maki sama da tsakiyar maki ya zama "sama da matsakaici ba." Bugu da ƙari, ba mu san ko hanyar ita ce 24.15 idan aka kwatanta da 23.00 ba ko kuma wani abu kamar 6.15 idan aka kwatanta da 5.00, wanda hakan zai cancanci wata fassara daban.

A takaice, da a ce ni mai bita ne a kan wannan rubutun, da na ƙi amincewa da shi bisa ga rashin isasshen hanyoyin ƙididdiga da kuma matsalolin ra'ayi daban-daban. … Ba zai yiwu ba, idan aka yi la'akari da yanayin bayanan, a yanke hukunci mai ƙarfi.

[Mun tambayi 'yan tambayoyi masu biyowa]

Na farko, masu binciken sun kirkiro sikelin Ilimin Jima'i a matsayin daya daga cikin abubuwan da suka hada da "tasirin sakamako mai kyau" saboda sun dauka cewa karin ilimin jima'i koyaushe abu ne mai kyau. Ba kamar sauran abubuwan haɗin sakamako huɗu ba, babu wani mummunan fasali na Ilimin Jima'i. Kamar yadda zan iya fada, kawai nazarin inda suka bar sikanin Ilimin Jima'i shine lokacin da suka gudanar da gwaje-gwaje tsakanin halaye masu kyau da marasa kyau na kowane gini (Table 4). Wannan ya kasance daga larura - babu mummunan ilimin Ilimin Jima'i don kwatanta shi da Ilimin Jima'i mai kyau.

Ba ka tambaya ba, amma ba zan iya yin tsokaci a kan wannan ma'aunin Ilimin Jima'i ba. Babu shakka, manyan maki a kan sikelin suna nuna fahimtar mahalarta ne kawai game da samun ilimi, wanda ba garantin cewa waɗannan fahimta suna wakiltar ingantaccen ilimi ba . Sa'a ga mutumin da yake tunanin ya koyi abin da mata ke so ta hanyar kallon batsa. Na biyu, kodayake ni da kaina ina tsammanin samun ilimi kusan koyaushe abu ne mai kyau fiye da rashin samun ilimi, wa ya san ko ya kamata a sami mummunan kama da ma'aunin Ilimin Jima'i mai kyau ko a'a? Har ma zan iya tunanin wasu abubuwa, misali, "Na ga wasu abubuwan da nake fata ban gani ba." "Na koyi wasu abubuwan da nake fata ban gani ba." Masu binciken sun yi zato da yawa game da abin da ke "mai kyau," wataƙila bisa ga al'adun Denmark (misali, yin gwaji, kasancewa mai sassaucin ra'ayi na jima'i).

Dangane da tambayarka game da ingancin sikelin, wannan mahimmin ra'ayi ne a cikin auna tunanin mutum, amma wanda ma masana da yawa suka kasa fahimta. Don faɗi cewa binciken Hald-Malamuth ya inganta PCES yana da ƙima. Ba wanda zai iya gwada ingancin mizanin tunani tare da nazari ɗaya. Kimanta ingancin mizanin tunani yana buƙatar shekaru na bincike na shirye-shirye wanda ya haɗa da bincike da yawa. Haƙiƙa tsari ne wanda ba ya ƙarewa, inda muke ƙara koya game da ingancin ma'auni, amma ba za mu taɓa kafa lamba ta ƙarshe don ingancin gwajin ƙwaƙwalwa ba (kamar “gwajin yana da inganci 90%”).

Cikakken bayani game da tabbatar da gwajin ilimin halayyar ɗan adam wani labari ne da Lee Cronbach da Paul Meehl suka rubuta a shekarar 1955. Karanta kuma ka fahimce shi kuma za ka san ƙarin bayani game da ingancin gwajin ilimin halayyar ɗan adam fiye da yawancin masana ilimin halayyar ɗan adam: http://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Cronbach/construct.htm.

Ga takaitaccen taƙaitaccen labarin Cronbach-Meehl: A faɗi cewa gwargwadon aikin gina tunanin mutum yana da inganci shine a faɗi cewa bambance-bambance na maki akan mizanin ya dace da sauran ma'aunai ta hanyar ka'idar da aka tsara ginin. Don haka muna tantance ingancin gwajin hankali ta hanyar ba shi ga rukunin mutane, tare da tattara wasu bayanan da ka'idarmu ta ce ya dace da ginin da ake zargin jarabawar ta wakilta, da kuma bincika ko maki a jarabawar ya yi daidai da sauran bayanan kamar yadda aka annabta ta ka'idar. Sakamakon tabbatarwa yawanci ana haɗe shi, tare da wasu masu tallafi da kuma wasu abubuwan da basu tabbatar ba, wanda shine dalili ɗaya da yasa baza mu iya kafawa ga kowane lokaci daidai yadda ingancin gwaji yake ba. Al'amari ne na fifikon tabbatar da hujjoji marasa tabbaci. Ko da kuwa sakamakon bai yi daidai ba, ba za mu iya cewa tabbas ko gwajin ƙwaƙwalwar ba shi da inganci ko kuwa akwai wani abu da ke daidai da ka'idar da ta yi hasashen. Ingancin gwaji shine gwajin-ka'idar kamar yadda aka fahimta gaba ɗaya a cikin kimiyya.

A cikin binciken Hald-Malamuth, a zahiri babu ingantaccen gwaji sosai, duk da wani dogon sashe mai taken "Tabbatar da Tambayoyin Amfani da Batsa (PCQ)." A cewar ka'idar Hald da Malamuth ta rashin tsari na sakamako mai kyau da mara kyau daga batsa, akwai nau'ikan sakamako masu kyau da mara kyau da aka gani, kuma nau'ikan sakamako masu kyau daban-daban ya kamata su haɗu da juna, kamar yadda ya kamata nau'ikan sakamako marasa kyau daban-daban. Tebur 1 da 2 sun gabatar da sakamakon da ke tabbatar da wannan hasashen, don haka ana iya ɗaukar wannan a matsayin wani tallafi ga ingancin PCQ. Masu binciken sun kuma yi iƙirarin cewa tasirin mai kyau da mara kyau ba su da alaƙa da juna (ma'ana ya kamata su haɗa sifili), amma ba sa bayar da rahoton alaƙa tsakanin ma'aunin sakamako masu kyau guda biyar da ma'aunin sakamako marasa kyau guda huɗu a cikin Tebur 1 da 2. Ina zargin suna ɓoye bayanai marasa tabbas . Sun bayar da rahoton cewa jimlar dukkan ma'aunin PCQ mai kyau yana da alaƙa da r = .07 kawai da jimlar dukkan ma'aunin PCQ mara kyau, amma ina mamakin dalilin da yasa suka ɓoye bayanai game da alaƙar da ke tsakanin nau'ikan tasirin sakamako masu kyau guda biyar daban-daban da kuma nau'ikan tasirin sakamako masu kyau guda huɗu.

Hald da Malamuth rahotanni, kamar yadda ya kamata, dogara da kimantawa ga Sikakinsu, kuma wadannan lambobi duka masu kyau ne. Amma dogara ba shi da inganci. Ƙididdiga zai iya zama cikakkiyar amintacce amma har yanzu ba shi da inganci mai kyau. Tabbatar da amincin duka sune dukiyoyi masu mahimmanci na gwaje-gwajen gwaji, amma sun kasance abubuwa daban-daban guda biyu.

Hald da Malamuth sun ba da rahoton gwaje-gwaje na hasashe guda uku waɗanda suka dace da ka'idarsu ta tasirin batsa mai kyau da mara kyau, don haka suna da ɗan tasiri kan ingancin PCQ. Hasashensu na farko shine cewa tasirin da aka gani mai kyau ya fi tasirin da aka gani mara kyau. Ina tsayawa kan abin da na rubuta a baya game da waɗannan nazarin, wanda aka ruwaito a cikin Tebur 4: bai dace ba ga masu binciken su gudanar da gwaje-gwajen t-gwajin kwatanta hanyoyin kowane sakamako mai kyau da hanyoyin tasirin mummunan da ya dace, domin ba za mu iya ɗauka cewa matsakaicin "3" akan sikelin sakamako mai kyau yana da ma'ana iri ɗaya da "3" akan sikelin tasirin mummunan da ya dace ba. Wataƙila mahalarta sun fi son bayar da rahoton sakamako mai kyau fiye da mara kyau saboda an yarda da batsa a Denmark. Don haka wataƙila "3" akan sikelin tasirin mummunan ya fi kama da "4" akan sikelin tasirin mai kyau. Kawai ba mu sani ba, kuma babu wata hanyar da za a iya sani daga yadda aka tattara bayanan. Don haka sakamakon da aka ruwaito a Tebur 4 dole ne a ɗauki shi da babban ƙwayar gishiri , wataƙila mashin gishiri gaba ɗaya.

Na lura cewa marubutan sun yi wata dabara mai ban dariya a cikin Tebur 4, suna kwatanta tasirin da ya dace da mara kyau. Maimakon bayar da rahoton hanyoyin da za a bi don ma'auni mai kyau da mara kyau (kamar yadda suke yi wa bambance-bambancen jinsi a Tebur 5), suna bayar da rahoton bambance-bambancen ma'ana ne kawai . Misali, matsakaicin bambanci tsakanin tasirin da ya dace da mara kyau ga maza shine 1.54. Dole ne ku je Tebur 5 don ganin cewa wannan 1.54 shine bambanci tsakanin 2.84 don tasirin da ya dace ga maza da 1.30 don tasirin da ya dace ga maza. Tabbas, bambancin 1.54 yana da mahimmanci a kididdiga kuma yana da mahimmanci bisa ga D na Cohen (amma kawai idan muka ɗauka cewa sikelin da ya dace 3 = sikelin da ya dace 3). Duk da haka, bari mu kalli cikakken ƙimar ma'aunin tasirin da ya dace, 2.84 akan sikelin 1-7. Tunda 4 shine tsakiyar maki, rabin tsakanin 1 (ba kwata-kwata ba) da 7 (zuwa babban mataki), 2.84 ba shi da kyau sosai a cikakkiyar ma'ana.

Ka'idar masu binciken ta biyu ita ce maza za su bayar da rahoton sakamako masu kyau da marasa kyau fiye da mata . Sakamakon ya goyi bayan hasashen cewa maza za su bayar da rahoton sakamako masu kyau. Duk da haka, sabanin ka'idarsu, maza kuma sun bayar da rahoton sakamako masu kyau [fiye da mata] a fannoni biyu: rayuwar jima'i da rayuwa gabaɗaya . Ko dai akwai matsala game da ingancin ma'auninsu ko kuma tare da ka'idarsu cewa maza suna ganin sakamako marasa kyau fiye da mata. Me kuke tunani?

A ƙarshe, masu binciken sun yi hasashen cewa abubuwan da suka shafi asali na iya alaƙa da tasirin batsa da ake gani, kuma wasu daga cikin waɗannan abubuwan sun yi daidai kamar yadda aka annabta. Babban alaƙar tasirin mai kyau shine tare da amfani da batsa, r = .51. Masu amfani da suka fi ƙarfin hali suna ba da rahoton mafi kyawun tasirin . Kamar yadda masu binciken da kansu suka yarda, wannan binciken haɗin gwiwa ba zai iya gaya mana matakin da shan ƙarin batsa ke haifar da sakamako mai kyau idan aka kwatanta da shan barasa mai yawa wanda ke haifar da tunani da son yin imani da tasirin mai kyau ba . Don rikodin, kodayake masu binciken ba su tattauna wannan ba, Tebur 6 kuma yana nuna kyakkyawar alaƙa tsakanin amfani da mummunan tasirin , r = .10. Ya fi ƙanƙanta, amma yana da mahimmanci a kididdiga.

Ɗaya daga cikin abubuwan da masu bincike suka yi daidai ba daidai ba (a baya), shine dangantaka tsakanin digiri na ainihi a batsa da kuma sakamako mai kyau. Shafin 6 yana nuna cewa mummunar dangantaka ce (r = -.25), kuma wannan ya tabbatar da nauyi beta (β = -.22) a cikin nazarin da aka yankewa a cikin Table 7. Magana mara kyau yana nufin cewa da mafi gaskiyar ra'ayi da batsa, da Kadan tabbataccen sakamako. Amma marubucin wannan labarin ya ci gaba da kwatanta ma'anarta (kuskure), wannan hakikani yana da alaƙa da tasiri. Kwafi!

Ina fatan waɗannan maganganun suna da amfani. Zan yi farin cikin amsa duk wata tambaya da kuke da ita. (Addedara girmamawa)