Impendulo yethu "ekugxekeni" kukaRory Reid kwesifundo sikaNicole Prause 2013 EEG (Steele et al., 2013)

I-YBOP COMMENTS:

Ngezansi yi-YBOP kaJulayi, impendulo ye-2013 "I-Critique ye-Prause Study" nguRory C. Reid, PhD (uMnyango Wezokwelapha, iNyuvesi yaseCalifornia, eLos Angeles). Kungani sibhale impendulo ku Ukuhlaziywa kukaRory Reid likaNicole Prause “Isifiso sobulili, hhayi ubulili obufanayo, sihlobene Nezimpendulo Ze-Neurophysiological Ezihlotshiswe Izithombe Zobulili"? Ngoba akusikho ukugxeka nakancane. Esikhundleni salokho, ukuvikela okumboziwe kwesifundo se-Prause EEG (Steele et al., 2013). Owokuqala ukupha ukuthi uRory Reid ukhuluma ngoGary Wilson amahlandla ayishumi kulokho okubizwa nge- "critique". Okwesibili, uReid usho izikhathi ezintathu ukuthi uGary Wilson Psychology Today iposi blog ukuhlaziya isifundo sikaPrause akusashicilelwa. Bobabili uReid noPrause bazi kahle ukuthi kungani ilahlekile: I-Prause icindezelwe Psychology Today ukususa hhayi kuphela okuthunyelwe nguWilson, kepha lokhu okuthunyelwe ngamanye ama-blogger amabili. Ekugcineni, ukuhlaziywa kukaRory Reid kwehluleka ukubhekana nanoma yimaphi amaphuzu ethu abalulekile, noma kuchaze ukumelwa kabi kukaPrause kwabezindaba. Esikhundleni salokho, uReid uphambanisa ukugxekwa ngokungachazi kahle lokho okushiwo ukuhlaziywa kwe-YBOP. Qaphela: URory Reid uthe ukuthi ihhovisi lakhe le-UCLA liseduze nakwaPrause (futhi laba bobabili basebenzisa ukuhlala ndawonye).

UPDATE: Ngaphambi kokufika ekugxekeni kukaRory Reid futhi Steele et al.okutholakala kwangempela, okuningi kuye kwavela kusukela ngoJulayi, i-2013. I-UCLA ayivuselelanga isivumelwano sikaNicole Prause (ngoJanuwari, 2015). Akusekho iPrause yezemfundo eye yaqoqa a umlando omude ukuhlukumeza nokuhlambalaza uGary Wilson nabanye, kuhlanganise nabacwaningi, odokotela bezokwelapha, abahlinzayo, izazi ze-psychologists, ozakwabo base-UCLA zangaphambili, abashayeli baseBrithani, amadoda abuyele emuva, ISIKHATHI umagazini wezincwadi, abaprofesa abaningana, i-IITAP, i-SASH, Ukulwa Nezidakamizwa Ezintsha, umagazini wezemfundo Sciences Behavioral, inkampani yomzali wayo MDPI, inhloko yombhalo wezemfundo CUREUS, kanye nomagazini Ukulutha Kwezocansi Nokuphoqeleka. Bheka: Imibhalo kaNicole Prause ehlambalaza futhi ehlukumeza uGary Wilson nabanye abaningi (futhi manje ikhasi lesibili futhi ikhasi lesithathu).

Iphuzu elibalulekile: Ngesikhathi uPrause eqhubeka emangalela ngokuthi "uyisisulu," nguPrause owaqala konke ukuxhumana nokuhlukumeza kubantu kanye nezinhlangano ezibalulwe kuleli khasi. Akekho ohlwini lwamakhasi alandelayo ohlukumeze uNicole Prause. Amanga akhethiwa ngokuthi uyisisulu sokuthi "u-stalking" noma i-misogyny kusuka "kwabashushisi bezithombe ezingcolile" abanakho ivesi elilodwa lemibhalo. Ubufakazi obunikezayo buzikhiqiza ngokwabo: i-info-graphic eyodwa, ama-imeyili ambalwa avela kuye nakwabanye achaza ukuhlukunyezwa, nokuyeka okungamacala amahlanu nokuyeka izincwadi eziqukethe izinsolo zamanga. Uzobona nobufakazi bezikhalazo eziningana ezisemthethweni U-Prause uhambise nezinhlangano ezehlukene zokulawula - eziye zaxoshwa ngokukhululekile noma zaphenywa futhi zaxoshwa. Kubonakala sengathi ulayishe lezi zikhalo ezikhohlisayo ukuze aqhubeke nokubiza izimali zakhe zonke "ngaphansi kophenyo."

I-Prause ayinikezi izibonelo ezikhonakalayo zokuba yilokho okuhlosiwe kokugxila ku-intanethi noma ngabe yi-Twitter, i-Facebook, noma ukuxhumanisa namakhasi ku-YBOP. Ngakolunye uhlangothi, ukuphakela kwe-Twitter ku-Prause kwedwa kuqukethe amakhulu we-tweets engaqondakali futhi engalungile ebhekisela kuWilson nabanye abaningi (U-Prause usususwe mayelana nama-tweets angu-3,000). Ngokumane, u-Prause uye wadala i-mythology ngobufakazi obungaqiniseki, ngenkathi eduze ngokuhambisana nomkhakha wezithombe zobulili ezingcolile, njengoba kungabonakala kulokhu isithombe sakhe (ngakwesokudla) emgqeni obomvu we-X-Rated Critics Organization (XRCO) umkhosi wemiklomelo. (Ngokusho kwe-Wikipedia, the I-XRCO Awards anikezwa yiMelika Izinkampani zokuhlaziya ezibalwe ngu-X minyaka yonke kubantu abasebenzisa ukuzijabulisa kwabantu abadala kanye no-it Yiwona kuphela umklomelo wemiklomelo omdala okhombisa ukugcinwa kuphela ngamalungu embonini.^[1]) Ngamaphepha amaningi, bheka: Ingabe uNicole Prause Uthonywe Ngu-Porn Industry?).

Impendulo yethu kuRory Reid (July, 2013):

Siyajabula ukubona impendulo emibuzweni esiyiphakamisile, noma ngabe iqala njengokuhlaziya umsebenzi kaPrause ngenkathi kugxekwa abagxeki bakhe kuphela. Njengoba amaphuzu amaningi esiphakamisile enganakiwe, noma ephothiwe ukuze abe nencazelo ehlukile, singathanda UDkt Reid ukubuza uDkt Prause ukuphendula imibuzo elandelayo eyengeziwe:

1) Kungani uyihlolile ukuthi okutholakele kwakho kukhombisa ukuthi ucansi lwaluyisifiso “esiphakeme” ngempela ngenkathi isifundo sakho sithola ukusebenza okukhulu kobuchopho kuhambisana nesifiso sobulili esiphansi? Qaphela amagama kaPrause kule ngxoxo:

Iyini ukutholwa okuyinhloko esifundweni sakho?
“Sithole ukuthi ukusabela kobuchopho ezithombeni zocansi akubikezelwanga noma yiziphi izindlela ezintathu zemibuzo ehlukene zobungqingili. Impendulo yebongo ibikezelwe kuphela isifiso sobulili. Ngamanye amazwi, ukuxubana ngokobulili akubonakali ukuchaza umehluko wobuchopho ekuphenduleni kocansi okungaphezu nje kokuba ne-libido ephezulu."

Kepha lokho akwenzekanga, njengoba kuchaze uJohn Johnson PhD lokhu kubhekwa okubukezwa kontanga:

'Ukutholwa okukodwa okuphawulekayo akusho lutho ngomlutha. Ngaphezu kwalokho, lokhu okutholakele okuphawulekayo yi ukungahambisani kahle phakathi kwe-P300 nesifiso sobulili nomlingani (r = -0.33), ekhombisa ukuthi ukuphakama kwe-P300 kuhlobene nesifiso sobulili esincane; lokhu ngokuphikisana ngqo nokuchazwa kwe-P300 njengesifiso esiphakeme. Akunakuqhathaniswa namanye amaqembu okulutha. Akukho ukuqhathaniswa nokulawula amaqembu. Iziphetho ezithathwe abacwaningi yi-quummage ephuma emininingwaneni, engasho lutho ngokuthi abantu ababika inkathazo eqondisa ukubuka kwabo kwezithombe zobulili noma abanakho ukuphendula ngobuchopho obufana ne-cocaine noma ezinye izinhlobo zokulutha izidakamizwa,

2) UDkt. Prause, kungani ukhulume ngeqembu lokulawula "ngaphakathi-isihloko" njengoba lokhu kungabalulekile ku Steele et al.Imiphumela eshiwo kuphela:

"Ukungezwani okukhulu kwe-P300 ukulinganisa okwenziwe ngokocansi, okuhlobene nokungahambisani nokungathandanga, kwakungathandeki kakhulu ezinyathelweni zesifiso socansi, kodwa akuhlobene nokulingana kobulili obufanayo."

Ukuhumusha: Abantu abane-cue-reactivity ku-porn babenesifiso esincane sokuya ocansini nomlingani (kepha hhayi isifiso esiphansi sokushaya indlwabu). Ukubeka enye indlela: abantu abanokusebenzisa okuningi kobuchopho kanye nezifiso ze-porn bangathanda ukushaya indlwabu ocansini kunokuya ocansini nomuntu wangempela. Akuhlobene neqembu likaPrause elibizwa ngokuthi "ngaphakathi-ngesihloko" iqembu lokulawula.

3) UDkt Prause, kungani wenze izicelo ezingasekelwa enkulumweni yakho ye-Psychology Today nakwezinye izindawo? I Psychology Today interview:

Yayiyini injongo yocwaningo?
Ukudumisa: Ucwaningo lwethu luvivinywe ukuthi ngabe abantu ababika izinkinga ezinjalo bafana nezinye izilonda ezimpendulo zabo zobuchopho ezithombeni zobulili. Ukuhlolwa kwezidakamizwa ezidakamizwa, njenge-cocaine, kubonise indlela ephendulelayo yokuphendula ngobuchopho ezithombeni zezidakamizwa zokuhlukunyezwa, ngakho sabikezela ukuthi kufanele sibone iphethini efanayo kubantu ababika izinkinga ngocansi uma eqinisweni, umlutha.
Ingabe lokhu kubonisa ukuthi umlutha wezocansi kuyindabakwane?
Uma isifundo sethu siphendulwa, lezi zithole zingabhekisela enselele enkulu emibhalweni ekhona yocansi "umlutha". Isizathu sokuthi lezi zitholakele zinselele yilokho kubonisa ubuchopho babo abuphendulanga emifanekisweni efana nezinye izidakamizwa ezidakamizwa zabo zokulutha.

Lokhu okushiwo ngenhla ukuthi izifundo zezifundo "aziphendulanga njengezinye izilonda azisekelwa. Ku- Steele et al., izifundo zazifundwa kakhulu nge-EEG (P300) lapho kubukwa izithombe zocansi - okuyikho kanye okwenzekayo lapho imilutha ibuka izithombe ezihlobene nokulutha kwazo (njengakwi lolu cwaningo ku-cocaine umlutha). Ukuphawula ngaphansi kwe Psychology Today interview of Prause, kusho uprofesa ophezulu wezepolitiki uJohn A. Johnson:

"Ingqondo yami isaqhubeka nokufaka isicelo sokuthi ubuchopho babantu bakhe abuphendulanga ngezithombe zocansi ezifana nobuchopho bomlutha wezilakamizo ezithinta izidakamizwa zabo, ngenxa yokuthi ubika ukuphakama okuphezulu kwe-P300 kwezithombe zocansi. Njengabalutha ababonisa ama-spikes we-P300 uma bethulwe ngezidakamizwa zabo zokuzikhethela. Wayengenza kanjani isiphetho esingavumelani nemiphumela yangempela? Ngicabanga ukuthi kungenzeka kungenxa yokuqonda kwakhe lokho abebekulindele. ”

4) UDkt, Prause, bekuyini ukuxhumana phakathi kwemininingwane ye-EEG nayo yonke imibuzo eyi-14 kwi-Sexual Desire Inventory (SDI)? Ngizophendula: bekungekho ukuhlangana okuphawulekayo. Ucwaningo lubika ngokufanele izibalo zesifiso sobulili bodwa, kepha sinesiphetho:

Isiphetho: Impumelelo ukuqonda ubulili obufana nesifiso esikhulu, kunokuxoxwa, kuxoxwa ngakho.

Kungani umhlaba ungafuna "isifiso esiphakeme" lapho izikhonzi nge ukucubungula okukhulu-ukusebenta kwakunakho isifiso esiphansi socansi nomlingani. Ngaphezu kwalokho, ibinzana elithi “isifiso sobulili” liphindaphindwa amahlandla angama-63 ocwaningweni, kanti isihloko sesihloko socwaningo (Isifiso Sobulili, Hhayi Ubungqingili….) Sisho ukuthi ukuvuselelwa kobuchopho okuphezulu ezinkomba kwakuhlotshaniswa nesifiso sobulili esiphakeme. Ngaphezu kwalokho, zonke izihloko zezindaba zamemeza ukuthi "ukulutha ngokocansi" kwakuyisifiso esiphakeme ngempela? Kepha bekungeyona isifiso esiphakeme!

5) UDkt. Reid uthi, "Enye inkinga engingayiphakamisa ukungaphatheki kahle kwami ngokuxoshwa kukaMnu Wilson nge-EEG njengobuchwepheshe." Sivuma kuphi i-EEG njengobuchwepheshe? Eqinisweni, impendulo yethu inezixhumanisi nezifundo ze-2 ezazisetshenziswa i-EEG ngokunciphisa futhi ngokuphumelelayo ekuphenyweni kwezidakamizwa ezidakamizwa. Sivele sisho ukuthi, ngokungafani nezidakamizwa zamakhemikhali, izidakamizwa zokuziphatha ngokocansi zibandakanya iziphakamiso eziningi zokuzicabangela. Ukwenza izimangalo ezibanzi ngokusekelwe ku-activation ye-EEG ayizinhle ngenxa yokulinganiselwa okubuchwepheshe bokubuchwepheshe.

6) Dkt, Prause, buphi ubufakazi bokuthi "inzalo ye-dyadic iyodwa" isetshenziswa kakhulu njengesilinganiso "sesifiso sobulili?" Uqhubeka nokufuna lokhu, kepha okuwukuphela kwesisekelo isifundo esinikezayo ngalesi simangalo siphikisana nesimangalo sakhe (funda i-1, funda i-2. Ngaphezu kwalokho, kanjalo nokuphawula komunye wabathuthukisi be-SDI, Ilana Spector, esathintana naye ngomzamo wokuqonda izimangalo zikaPrause (lapho nje sesithole ukuthi izifundo ezikhonjiwe kuzona ziphikisana nazo). USpector, owasiqinisekisa ukuthi i-SDI kuhloswe ukuthi ilawulwe njengeyunithi eyodwa, uthe, “Isikali sigunyazwe kuphela kusetshenziswa ZONKE izinto zombili zodwa futhi ezinamandla…. Isikali sasingakhelwanga ukuthi sisetshenziswe [njengoba sasilapha] futhi asizange sigunyazwe ngaleyo ndlela. ”

7) UDkt. Prause, ngokuqinisekile uyazi ukuthi isenzo esilandelayo sesifundo sokulutha izidakamizwa sihlolisisa umsebenzi wezobuchopho obangelwa umkhondo. Kungani lezi zihloko zaziyizizathu? amadoda nabesifazane, kuhlanganise ne-7 abangewona abesilisa nabesifazane? Ukufunda ngemuva kokufunda kuqinisekisa ukuthi abesilisa nabesifazane banezimpendulo zobuchopho ezihluke kakhulu ezithombeni noma kumafilimu ezocansi. Izifundo zobuchopho zokulutha ezivumelekile zibandakanya izihloko ezifanayo: ubulili obufanayo, ubulili obufanayo, kanye neminyaka efanayo nama-IQ. Lokhu kukodwa kwehlisa okutholile.

8) UDkt.Prause, ungasiphendulela kanjani isibalo sabangewona abesilisa nabesifazane ocwaningweni lokuzama ukubheka izithombe ezingcolile zobulili obuhlukile - bese uthola iziphetho ezinkulu ngokungabikho kokuhlangana (okubikezelwayo)? Lokhu kubiza nemiphumela yakho.

9) UDkt Prause, kungani izikhonzi zakho zingakahlolwa kuqala? Ukulutha okulindelekile kobuchopho buhlolisisa abantu ababukeziwe ngezimo zangaphambili (ukucindezeleka, i-OCD, ezinye izidakamizwa, njll). Lokhu futhi kubiza imiphumela yakho ngombuzo.

10) UDkt. Prause, kungani usebenzise i-SCS (Sculsivity Scale) uma kungesona isivivinyo esivumelekile sokuhlola ukulutha kwezocansi nge-Intanethi noma kwabesifazane? Yadalwa ngo-1995 futhi yaklanywa ngocansi olungalawulwa ubudlelwane engqondweni (mayelana nokuphenya ngendlala yengculaza). Futhi, lokhu yedwa kuchaza ukuthi kungani kungekho ukuhlobana phakathi kokufundwa kwe-P300 ne-SCS.

Emuva ku-Sexual Desire Inventory (SDI), kanye nesimangalo sikaRory Reid sokuthi ngandlela-thile siphuthelwe yizikolo ze-Solitary SDI: “UMnu. Wilson uzame ukufakazela ukuthi uDkt. Prause uhlulekile ukuhlaziya ngokucophelela i-SDI subscale esetshenziselwa ukutadisha kwakhe“. Funda lokho esikushilo empeleni, uqale lapha. Sichaze ngokucacile ukuthi akukho ukuhlanganiswa okukhona lapho i-SDI yonke isetshenziswa. Lokhu kuyiqiniso. Ngenkathi uSteele et al bebika ukungahambisani okungafani phakathi kokufundwa kwe-EEG kanye nemibono ehlangene ye-SDI, lokhu kutholakala kwazibonakalisa njengesihloko sokutaduka esikhohlisayo futhi izihloko zamanga mayelana “nesifiso sobulili“. Imiphumela yangempela evela ocwaningweni:

"Ukuhlukana okukhulu kwe-P300 ukulinganisa kumuntu owenza ucansi olujabulisayo, ngokuphathelene nokungahambisani nalokho, kwakungenjalo kabi zihlobene nezinyathelo zesifiso sobulili, kodwa azihlobene nezinyathelo zobungqingili. ”

Ukuhumusha: Abantu abane-cue-reactivity ku-porn babenesifiso esincane sokuya ocansini nomlingani (kepha hhayi isifiso esiphansi sokushaya indlwabu). Ukubeka enye indlela - abantu abanokusebenzisa okuningi kobuchopho kanye nezifiso ze-porn bangathanda ukushaya indlwabu ocansini kunokuya ocansini nomuntu wangempela. Kwehluke kakhulu ekuxoxweni nasezihlokweni.

Bheka iThebula 2 kusuka umbhalo ogcwele wesifundo.

Chofoza ukuze ukhulise iThebula 2

Okokuqala, i- "Note" ithi ibanga lokuhlolwa kweSolitary ngu- "3-26," kepha nokho abesifazane basho ukuthi bayedlula. Kususwe ku-26.46 – ngokoqobo kumashadi. Kwenzenjani?

Okubaluleke kakhulu, kepha, uma ngabe i-SPAN Lab empeleni ibikala "isifiso sobulili" isebenzisa i-SDI ephelele, abacwaningi bayo bebengeze inani eliphakeme kakhulu lokushaya indlwabu-amaphuzu angama-23.92 (aphume kwabangu-26) kumaphuzu esifiso esihlukanisiwe asho amaphuzu angama-58 (kokungenzeka okungama-70). Ngakho-ke, "isifiso sobulili" sangempela sisho ukuthi amaphuzu angama-82 (we-96).

Kwenzekani lapho umuntu eqhathanisa imiphumela yangempela (eyi-14-imibuzo) "yokusungula isifiso sobulili" nemininingwane ye-EEG? Akukho ukulungiswa okuphawulekayo nhlobo. Azikho izimangalo ezingenangqondo zokuqeda umqondo "wokulutha ngokocansi," akukho blitz yezindaba enesibindi, futhi asikho isidingo sokwesatshiswa ekusithekeni ukuzama ukusekela okutholakele okuyiphutha. Ngamafuphi, uSteele et al. ukutholakala kokuhlangana okuncane phakathi kokufundwa kwe-EEG nemibuzo bekungaba ukutholwa okungenamdlandla (okuchazwa kalula ngobunye ubuthakathaka bendlela).

Kubalulekile ukuthi wazi ukuthi isifundo siqukethe iphutha lesibili maqondana ne-SDI: “Izinga lezilinganiso ze-SDI zesifiso socansi besebenzisa izilinganiso ezimbili eyakhiwe izinto eziyisikhombisa ngalunye.”Eqinisweni, i-Sexual Desire Inventory iqukethe imibuzo eyisishiyagalolunye ehlanganisiwe, umbuzo omane owodwas, futhi umbuzo OWODWA okungenakuhlukaniswa (#14). I-blitz yezindaba ezithandekayo, eyaphumelela ngalolu cwaningo, isekela izinhloko zokubamba iqhaza emiphumeleni ye-SDI eyingxenye. Noma kunjalo, ukubhala okubhalwe phansi kuqukethe amaphutha amasha mayelana ne-SDI ngokwayo, engenzi ukuzethemba kwabacwaningi.

I-Psychology Namuhla neNicole Prause

Yebo, okuthunyelwe kwethu kwe-Psychology Today kwehlisiwe. Kungukuqonda kwethu ukuthi isuswe ngenxa yezinsongo zomthetho ezingenasisekelo ezibhekiswe ku- "Psychology Today," evela kuDkt Prause uqobo. Empeleni, ngemuva kosuku, i-PT isuse okuthunyelwe kwethu kwangaphambili… mayelana esinye isifundo se-Laban ye-SPAN. Okuthunyelwe okubodwa esisususile eminyakeni engu-4 yokubhuloba kukhona okuthunyelwe okuphathelene nokuPhumela. Hmm. Isayensi ithokoza ngempikiswano evulekile, hhayi loluhlobo lwama-behind-the-scenes okusatshiswa.

UDkt Reid (ngenhla) uxhunywe kabili kokuthunyelwe kwethu kwangaphambili ku- “Psychology Today” (manje okukhombisa ikhasi elingashicilelwe) waphakamisa nokuthi isusiwe ngenxa yenkolelo ye- “Psychology Today” yokuthi iqukethe amaphutha. Njengoba kunikezwe ukuthi nathi ngokwethu sithole izinsongo zomthetho ezinonya, ezingenasisekelo ezivela kuDkt Prause, siyakungabaza kakhulu lokhu.

Yize sizonda ukwenza ukufingqwa kwama-imeyili esidlangalaleni, kulokhu, sinomuzwa wokuthi kuyadingeka ukuze abafundi abanentshisekelo bathole isithombe esigcwele ngamaqhinga kaDkt Prause. Bona lonke ukushintshaniswa kwama-imeyili phakathi kwethu naye (ngezansi). Lokhu kwenzeke ezinyangeni ezedlule, ngo-Ephreli, 2013, lapho “avuza” inguqulo engashicilelwe, engakabuyekezwa yalolu cwaningo (kuphela) kublogi onozwela uDavid Ley, umbhali we Inkolelo-mkhuba yokulutha kocansi. Kamuva wasusa impendulo ethi "Psychology Today". Ngenhlanhla, sabe sesicela abahleli be- "Psychology Today" ukuthi basuse okuthunyelwe kukaLey ngokususelwa ocwaningweni oluvulekile (uPrause ayenqabile ukulunikeza abanye), kwathi i- “Psychology Today” yakususa. (Zahlulela wena: Chofoza lapha ukubona okuthunyelwe kwebhulogi likaDavid Ley, impendulo yethu yebhulogi, kanye namazwana angezansi kokuthunyelwe kwethu - kufaka phakathi Ukushintshana kukaGary noNicole Prause.)

Lapho kuphuma isifundo sokugcina, uPrause ubhalise uBrian Mustanski ukuthi abhale ingxoxo evumayo, lapho uPrause akwazi "ukuphenya" imiphumela yakhe ngendlela ayithandayo. Sithumele impendulo kokuthunyelwe kwakhe, futhi yilokho uPrause asuse i- "Psychology Today".

Khumbula ukuthi iPrause yayinethuba elikhulu lokuphawula emabhulogi ethu okuphendula mayelana nezifundo zakhe ezimbili (kokubili okungatholakala kuwo Izimpendulo Zemibuzo Yezingcingo. Esikhundleni salokho, ukhethe ukungasithathi ngqo. Manje, ufihle ngemuva kokuphawula kwewebhusayithi kaDkt Reid, lapho kungekho mpendulo eqondile kubagxeki evunyelwe.

UPDATE: Kusukela leli khasi laqala ukwenziwa i-Prause iqhubekile nokugxila ku-Gary Wilson nabanye, kufaka phakathi abaphenyi, odokotela bezokwelapha, abelaphi bezengqondo, izazi zokusebenza kwengqondo, ozakwabo abasebenza naye kusuka e-UCLA, umhawu wase-UK, amadoda alulama, ISIKHATHI umhleli wamagazini, amaprofesa amaningana, i-IITAP, i-SASH, Ukulwa Nemithi Emisha, i-Exodus Cry, iphephandaba lezemfundo Sciences Behavioral, inkampani yomzali wayo MDPI, inhloko yombhalo wezemfundo CUREUS, kanye nomagazini Ukulutha Kwezocansi Nokuphoqeleka. Bheka: Ukuhlukunyezwa kukaNicole Prause nokungahloniphi uGary Wilson nabanye

UPDATE: NgoJanuwari 2015: UNicole Prause akasasebenzi yi-UCLA noma esinye isikhungo semfundo.

UPDATE: Kukhona manje ukuhlaziya okubuyekezwa kontanga ka-8 Steele et al., I-2013. Konke kuhambisane nokulandela okulandelayo kwe-YBOP. Konke kuchaza indlela okutholakala ngayo Steele et al., I-2013 inikeza ukusekelwa kwindlela yokulutha kwezidakamizwa ezingcolile. Iphepha # 1 lizinikezelwe kuphela Steele et al. Amaphepha 2-8 aqukethe izigaba zokuhlaziya Steele et al., 2013:

UNicole Prause - Ukushintshaniswa kwe-imeyili kukaGary Wilson:

Mashi 5, 2013

Umbhali we-"The Myth of Sex Addiction," uDavid Ley, neqembu likaNicole Prause ukuze babhale a Psychology Today okuthunyelwe kubhulogi okunesihloko esithi: “Ubuchopho bakho ku-Porn - AKULANDI. ” (Brain On Porn yakho iwebhusayithi Kusungulwe nguWilson.) Kwakumayelana nokungashicilelwa kukaNicole Prause, kepha okusazobuyekezwa ngontanga Ucwaningo lwe-EEG ("Isifiso sobulili, hhayi ucansi, sihlobene nezimpendulo ze-neurophysiological eziphakanyiswe izithombe zocansi").

Kubalulekile ukuthi wazi ukuthi nguLey kuphela othole ukufinyelela esifundweni sikaPrause esingashicilelwe (sashicilelwa ezinyangeni ezi-5 kamuva). Okuthunyelwe kwebhulogi kuxhunyaniswe newebhusayithi kaWilson ethi 'Ubuchopho Bakho ku-Porn' futhi yaphakamisa ukuthi i-YBOP yayithanda ukuvimbela i-porn (okungelona iqiniso).

Iphuzu eliyinhloko: Izinyanga ezinhlanu ngaphambi kokufundwa kwe-EEG ye-Prause (Steele et al., 2013) yanyatheliswa, bobabili u-Prause noLey babheke uGary Wilson kanye iwebhusayithi yakhe.

Mashi 7, 2013

UWilson ushicilele a Psychology Today okuthunyelwe kwebhulogi kuphendula okuqukethwe kokuthunyelwe kukaDavid Ley. Okuthunyelwe kwebhulogi likaLey kanye nempendulo kaWilson ekugcineni kwasuswa ngu Psychology Today abahleli, njengoba isifundo esiyisisekelo besingakatholakali. Ungathola okuthunyelwe kokuqala kwebhulogi likaLey noWilson kufakwe kungobo yomlando lapha. Kubalulekile ukuqaphela ukuthi iposi lebhulogi likaWilson lisho ngokusobala ukuthi beliphendula kuphela uLey's incazelo yesifundo sePrause. Kamuva uNicole Prause wayezomangalela uWilson ngamanga ngokuveza kabi isifundo sakhe (ukuthi nguye kuphela noLey ababonile, futhi babenza izimangalo zomphakathi mayelana - ezazikhona kamuva kuboniswa ukuthi ayinasisekelo).

Mashi 7, 2013

Okuthunyelwe nguWilson ngaphansi kwendatshana kaDavid Ley ecela isifundo:

“Hheyi David - ngiyazibuza ukuthi uzifake kanjani izifundo zakho ezingakashicilelwa, noma okukhulunywa ngazo kwenye indawo. Ingabe uzimisele ukungithumelela ikhophi? ”

UDavid Ley akazange aphendule.

April 10, 2013

Ngokuphendula amazwana angenhla, i-Prause ixhumana no- Psychology Today abahleli kanye ne-imeyili ku-Wilson okulandelayo. E-imeyli, ukuhlaselwa kukaHulumeni uWilson uqobo, futhi ngephutha uthi akazange acele isifundo. Eqinisweni, wayebuze uDavid Ley. I-imeyili:

I-Psychology Namuhla ([i-imeyili ivikelwe])
4/10/13
Ku: [i-imeyili ivikelwe]
Kusuka ku: Nicole Prause
Mnu. Wilson othandekayo,
Akukho emthethweni ngawe ukumela kabi isayensi yethu ungakaze ucele ikhophi yombhalo wesandla. Izophathwa kanjalo. I-athikili yethu empeleni ilinganiselwe kakhulu. Ngokungafani nawe, nginezincwadi ezibuyekezwe ngontanga ezinhlangothini zombili zalolu daba. Uzamile ukuyidicilela phansi ngokuchaza izinto ezingenziwanga. Ngikuphishekela lokhu ngePsychology Today manje, kepha ngingakeluleka ukuthi ususe wena okuthunyelwe ngaphambi kokuba ngiphoqeleke ukuba ngilandele esinye isenzo.
Awunayo imvume yokucaphuna noma iyiphi ingxenye yale imeyili. Kuyinto yokuxhumana yangasese.
Thengisa izincwadi zakho ngokuzimela kwakho. Ungazami ukwenza imali ngemihlane yososayensi abenza imisebenzi yabo. Ngingasho ukuthi lesi sifundo sikutatazelisa ngokusobala ngoba ukwakheka nedatha kunamandla, kepha kuyamangalisa ukuthi awukaze ucele ikhophi yombhalo wesandla bese wenza nje okuqukethwe. Waze wasa.
Nicole Prause, PhD
Ubuchwepheshe bokucwaninga
UCLA

Ngaphezu kwalokho, I-Psychology Abahleli banamuhla badlulisela i-imeyili yesibili esuka ku-Prause:

Usuku: Ngo-Ephreli 10, 2013 5: 13: 30 PM EDT
Isihloko: Beka amazwana ku-Blogs
Kusuka ku: Nicole Prause, PhD
Othintekayo:
Ngamangala lapho ngibona isihloko esabhalwa ngokutadisha imayini nguGary Wilson Psychology Today.
Anginayo inkinga ngaye emele imibono yakhe kanye nokuhunyushwa kwezifundo, kodwa akakwazi futhi angazange afinyelele emayini. Kubuyekezwa futhi akazange acele ikhophi kunoma yimuphi wabalobi. Ngamtshela ukuthi kufanele isuswe. Akakaze enze kanjalo. Yiqiniso, uma ngabe irekhodi lomphakathi, uzokwazi ukufinyelela kulo futhi akwazi ukulimela (ngethemba) ngokuqondile.
Yiqiniso, ukwazi ngokungahambi kahle umuntu ukuthi aziveze ngokungemthetho. Ngithemba ukuthi i-Psychology Today izoyithatha kakhulu lolu daba. Ngizoxhumana namanye amalungu ebhodi, uma kwenzeka ukukhokha kwakho kugcwele futhi kungathatha isikhathi eside ukuphendula.
Siyabonga ngosizo lwakho ekuxazululeni le ndaba.
ngobuqotho,
Nicole Prause, PhD

Izinsongo ezingenasisekelo zomthetho, izimangalo ezingamanga, nokudlala isisulu kuqala kokuxhumana noWilson. Akukho lutho oluthi u-Prause uthi:

UWilson akazange asichaze isifundo sikaPrause noma asimelele kabi nganoma iyiphi indlela. Uphendule kuphela uLey incazelo wesifundo. Funda Okuthunyelwe kwebhulogi likaLey noWilson futhi uzigwebe wena.
Kuze kube namuhla U-Prause awusaphikisanga igama elilodwa ku-Wilson sika-Mashi, i-2013 Psychology Today okuthunyelwe, noma ukuhlaziya uWilson wabhala ngoJulayi ngemuva kokuthi isifundo sakhe se-EEG sishicilelwe. Futhi u-Prause akaphikisi igama elilodwa ezibucayi ezibukeziwe zontanga zocwaningo lwakhe lwe-2013 EEG (1, 2, 3, 4.).
UWilson akenzi lutho ngalolu hlelo.
UWilson ucele ikhophi yocwaningo (U-Prause wenqaba ukukunikeza).
Ukudumisa kuqale konke ukuxhumana noWilson.

I-imeyili kaWilson impendulo kuNicole Prause:

Ngomhlaka Wed, Apr 10, 2013 ngo-3: 14 PM, u-gary wilson <> wabhala:
Sawubona Nicole,
Ngiphawule ngaphansi kokuphawula kwakho. Bheka.
Asenzi mali ngalokhu. Iwebhusayithi yami ayinakho ukukhangisa futhi asamukeli mnikelo. Asinazo izinsizakalo esizithengisayo. Anginayo incwadi engingayithengisa. Incwadi yomkami, evela ku-PT, ayiqondene nezocansi.
Uma ufuna ukulunga ngokweqiniso, sicela usithumelele isifundo esigcwele futhi usinike imvume yokubloga ngakho - njengoba wenza kuDkt Ley.
Ngizolindela ukutadisha kwakho,
UGary Wilson

April 12, 2013

Ezinsukwini ezimbili kamuva u-Prause waxhumana noWilson futhi wasongela esinye isinyathelo somthetho. Ngandlela-thile ulandelwe phansi okunye ukuphawula kukaWilson kusayithi lokuthola kabusha i-porn Ubuchopho Bakho Buvuselelwe. Kuthunyelwe ngentambo ende emayelana neposi lokuqala likaDavid Ley. Ukuphawula kukaWilson bekuhloselwe ukuchaza ukuthi kungani bobabili uLey noWilson Psychology Today okuthunyelwe kususiwe ngu Psychology Today. Lokhu kubonise iphethini ye-Prause ye-cyberstalking, njengoba kungekho ngisho nokuseshwa kwe-Google kungathola lokho okuthunyelwe. I-Prause yazi kanjani ngalolu chungechunge kwisithangami sokubuyiselwa kocansi?

Imeyili ye-Prause:

U-Nicole Prause (nprause@_____)
4/12/13
Mnu. Wilson othandekayo,
Okuthunyelwe kwakho: http://yourbrainrebalanced.com/index.php?topic=7522.50
Uqamba amanga uthi: "Ngiphendule ama-imeyili akhe amabi ngesicelo sokumbona efunda, futhi wenqaba."
Lokhu kuhlambalaza. Sicela ususe lokhu okuthunyelwe noma ngizokwenza ngokulandela isenzo somthetho.
Nicole Prause

UWilson uyaphendula:

Ngomhlaka Fri, Ephreli 12, 2013 ngo-11: 09 ekuseni, uGary wilson <> wabhala:
Othandekayo waseNicole Prause,
Mhlawumbe ubungazi ukuthi unkosikazi wami uthweswe iziqu esikoleni i-Yale law. Angishongo lutho ngokukhululeka. Eqinisweni, izitatimende zami zinembile impela.
I-1) Unqabe ukunikela ngesifundo sakho esingashicilelwe.
I-2) Wayiyingozi futhi usongela, njengoba ukhona manje.
I-3) Ngaphezu kwalokho, usho ngokungamanga ukuthi ngenza imali kubafana abahlukumeza ukuphulukiswa ekuluthweni kocansi.
I-4) Uphinde wakubeka kabi okuthunyelwe kwami kwe-PT, ngoba bekuyimpendulo ecacile encazelweni kaDavid Ley yesifundo sakho esingashicilelwe. Ukhethe ukungayilungisi incazelo kaLey noma wenze isifundo esigcwele sitholakale kimi, noma ngabe ngibuza ngakho esigabeni sokuphawula ngenyanga edlule.
Awusaphinde uphendule imibuzo yami yangempela (evezwe esigabeni sokuphawula):
1) Kungani ukhiphe isifundo sakho kuDavid Ley kuphela? Njengombhali we- "Myth of Sex Addiction," futhi nomuntu othi umlutha we-porn akakwazi ukuba khona, kungani kunguye yedwa okhethiwe?
2) Kungani ungakulungisanga ukutolika kukaDavid Ley kwesifundo sakho? Sekuphele isikhathi esingaphezu kwenyanga, futhi ubeke amazwana kabili kuyo ngenyanga edlule.
3) Ubeke amazwana ngaphansi kokuthunyelwe kukaLey ngenyanga edlule. Ngithumele ngokushesha ukuphawula ngaphansi kwakho ukuphawula, nginemibuzo ethile ebhekiswe kuwe mayelana nesifundo sakho. Lelo bekuyithuba lakho lokuthi bobabili baphendule futhi banikeze isifundo. Awenzanga neyodwa. Kungani?
Ngiyaphila ngokwenza ukushintshana kwethu kube sesidlangalaleni. Ngeke yini kube mnandi uma ufaka icala ngokumelene nama-blogger e-PT ambalwa alinga ukwenza ucwaningo lwakho?
Okuhle kakhulu,
UGary Wilson

Ama-imeyili wokuncoma futhi futhi ngezimangalo ezingasile nezinsongo zomthetho [Qaphela: Akukho Wilson noma umkakhe owake waqala ukuxhumana noPrause. Nguye owabaxhumana nabo ngokuphindaphindiwe futhi wabasongela ngesenzo esingenasisekelo somthetho.]

Kusuka ku: nprause@_________ Usuku: Fri, 12 Apr 2013 15:01:09 -0700
Isihloko: Re: [PT] Ucwaningo nge-Psychology Namuhla
Gary othandekayo,
Lokhu ukwazisa wena nobabili nonkosikazi wakho ukuthi oxhumana naye (wena nomkakho) abafuneki. Ngokulandelela izimiso ezweni lakho lasekhaya (http://courts.oregon.gov/Lane/Restraining.page), noma yimuphi othintana naye ohlukumezayo uzohunyushwa ngokuthi ukuhlukunyezwa okuphathekayo.
Awunayo imvume yami yokwabelana ngalokhu kuxhumana kwangasese kunoma yisiphi isithangami.
Nicole Prause

U-Wilson uthumela i-imeyili yakhe yokugcina ku-Prause, ukusetha irekhodi ngqo: ukuthi nguyena oqala konke okuthintana naye kanye nomuntu oyedwa owenza izinsongo (kanye nezicelo zamanga):

Kusuka: [i-imeyili ivikelwe]

Ku: nprause Isihloko: RE: [PT] Ucwaningo nge-Psychology Namuhla
Usuku: Hla, 12 Apr 2013 15: 44: 12 -0700
Othandekayo waseNicole Prause,
Ukuhlukunyezwa? Angizange ngiqale ukushintshaniswa kwe-imeyili eyodwa nawe, kufaka nalesi.
Owokuqala, owaqaliswa nguwe ku-4 / 10 / 13, lapho une-imeyili yokugcina. Futhi enye engezansi, lapho uzama ukudala umqondo wamanga wokuthi othile uhlukumeza, uma empeleni ungongongela okwesibili.
Nguwe futhi othinte umhleli wePsychology Today ukuphazamisa okuthunyelwe yimi kubhulogi. Unkosikazi wami akazange axhumane nawe ngephasika.
Asidingi imvume yakho.
UGary Wilson

Lokhu bekuyisiqalo nje sikaNicole Prause. Bona: