"Katswiri wa sayansi ya zithunzi zolaula pa intaneti: Kukonzanso ndi Kuonjezera" - Excerpt criticing Steele et al., 2013

Lumikizani ku pepala loyambirira - "Kulondola pa Zolaula Zapaintaneti: Kubwereza ndi Kusintha" (2015)

Zindikirani - mapepala ena owunikiridwa ndi anzawo ambiri amavomereza kuti Steele et al., 2013 imathandizira mtundu wa zolaula: Zolemba zotsatiridwa ndi anzawo Steele et al., 2013

Kufotokozera momveka bwino Steele et al., 2013 (ndemanga 303):


Kufufuza kwa EEG pa omwe akudandaula za mavuto owonetsa maonekedwe awo pa zolaula za pa intaneti wanena kuti neural reactivity ku zofuna za kugonana [303]. Phunziroli linalinganizidwa kuti liyang'ane mgwirizano pakati pa ERP amplitudes pakuwona zochitika zamaganizo ndi zachiwerewere komanso zochitika zokhudzana ndi kugonana ndi chilakolako cha kugonana. Olembawo anatsimikizira kuti kusagwirizana pakati pa mafunso okhudzana ndi kugonana kwa anthu komanso kuganiza kuti P300 amplitudes pakuwona zithunzi za kugonana "kulepheretsa kupereka chithandizo cha zitsanzo za kugonana kosagonana" [303] (p. 10). Komabe, kusowa kwa mgwirizano kungakhale bwino kufotokozedwa ndi zolakwika zomveka mu njira. Mwachitsanzo, phunziroli linagwiritsa ntchito dziwe lopanda ntchito (amuna ndi akazi, kuphatikizapo 7 omwe si amuna kapena akazi okhaokha). Kafukufuku wokhudzana ndi ubongo poyerekeza ndi ubongo wa chizolowezi chowongolera thanzi labwino kumafuna maphunziro omvera (kugonana komweko, mibadwo yofanana) kukhala ndi zotsatira zabwino. Malinga ndi maphunziro a zizolowezi zolaula, zatsimikiziridwa bwino kuti amuna ndi akazi amasiyana mozama mu ubongo ndi kuyankha mozizwitsa ku zofanana zogonana zogonana [304, 305, 306]. Kuonjezera apo, mayankho awiri owonetsetsa sakuvomerezedwa kwa ogwiritsa ntchito a IP osokonezeka, ndipo nkhanizi sizinawonedwe kuti ziwonetsedwe zina zowonongeka kapena vuto la maganizo.

Komanso, zomwe zatchulidwa m'nkhaniyi, "Zotsatira za kugonana kwachiwerewere monga chikhumbo chachikulu, osati zosokonezeka, zimakambidwa" [303] (p. 1) zikuoneka kuti palibe malo omwe akuwona kuti phunziroli likupeza kuti P300 matalikidwe amatsutsana kwambiri ndi chilakolako chogonana ndi mnzanu. Monga tafotokozera ku Hilton (2014), kupeza izi "kumatsutsana ndikutanthauzira kwa P300 monga chikhumbo chachikulu" [307]. Kufufuza kwa Hilton kukuwonetsanso kuti kusapezeka kwa gulu lolamulira ndi kulephera kwa teknoloji ya EEG kuti athetse pakati pa "chilakolako chogonana" ndi "kugonana" kumapangitsa Steele et al. zovuta zosatheka [307].

Potsiriza, pepala lalikulu (mapepala apamwamba a P300 kwa zithunzi zachiwerewere, zokhudzana ndi zithunzi zopanda ndale) zimapatsidwa chidwi chochepa mu gawo la zokambirana. Izi siziyembekezereka, monga momwe anthu ambiri amapezera ndi mankhwala ndi intaneti akuwonjezeka P300 matalikidwe okhudzana ndi zosakhudzidwa pokhapokha ngati akuwonekera pazithunzi zomwe zikugwirizana ndi chizoloŵezi chawo choledzera [308]. Ndipotu, Voon, et al. [262] anapereka gawo la zokambirana zawo pofufuza zofufuza za P300 izi zisanachitike. Voon et al. Kupereka kufotokozera kufunika kwa P300 yomwe sinalembedwe mu pepala la Steele, makamaka ponena za kukhazikitsa mankhwala osokoneza bongo,

"Choncho, ntchito yonse ya DACC mu maphunziro a CSB ndi P300 zomwe zachitika mu kafukufuku wa CSB wapitawo[303] zingasonyeze njira zofananamo zofanana zowonongeka. Mofananamo, maphunziro awiriwa amasonyeza mgwirizano pakati pa izi ndi chikhumbo chochuluka. Apa tikuwonetsa kuti ntchito ya DACC ikugwirizana ndi chikhumbo, chomwe chingasonyeze chiwerengero cha chilakolako, koma sichitsutsana ndi zomwe zimakondweretsa pazomwe zimakhala zolimbikitsa. "[262] (p. 7)

Tsono ngakhale olemba awa [303] adanena kuti kuphunzira kwawo kunatsutsa kugwiritsa ntchito njira yolekerera kwa CSB, Voon et al. adalemba kuti olemba awa amapereka umboni wothandizira chitsanzo.