Critique of "Kodi Zithunzi Zolaula Zimakhudzadi 'Kudana ndi Akazi'? Ogwiritsa Ntchito Zolaula Amakhala Ndi Maganizo Osiyanasiyana Amuna Kapena Akazi Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Akazi Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Amuna Kapena Akazi Akazi Ku America ”(Kohut et al., 2016)

kohut 2016.JPG

Olemba kafukufukuyu adafotokoza kufanana kwa anthu m'njira ziwiri : (1) Kuthandizira kuchotsa mimba, (2) Kuzindikira kuti akazi ndi akazi, (3) Akazi omwe ali ndi maudindo akuluakulu, (4) Kukhulupirira kuti moyo wabanja umasokonekera pamene mkaziyo ali ndi ntchito yokhazikika, komanso modabwitsa (5) Kukhala ndi malingaliro oipa pa banja lachikhalidwe. Kaya mumakhulupirira chiyani, n'zosavuta kuona kuti anthu achipembedzo angapindule kwambiri pakuwunika kwa Taylor Kohut kwa magawo 5 a "kufanana".

Nayi mfundo yofunika: anthu osakhulupirira Mulungu, omwe nthawi zambiri amakhala omasuka, ali ndi kuchuluka kwakukulu kwa anthu ogwiritsa ntchito zolaula kuposa anthu achipembedzo. Posankha njira zisanu izi ndikunyalanyaza zinthu zina zosatha, Taylor Kohut ankadziwa kuti adzagwiritsa ntchito zolaula (zambiri mwa anthu osakhulupirira Mulungu) zomwe zikugwirizana ndi kafukufuku wake wosankhidwa mosamala wa zomwe zimapanga " egalitarianism " (zochepa mwa anthu achipembedzo). Kenako Kohut anasankha dzina lomwe linapanga zonse.

Koma Kohut ananyalanyaza zomwe anapeza mu pepala lake lomwe, zomwe zikutsutsana ndi zomwe adalemba mosamala. Mu Table 2, Zambiri wamwamuna ndi Zambiri wamkazi ogwiritsa ntchito zolaula adapereka "ayi, osati wachikazi”Yankho - poyerekeza ndi omwe sanali ogwiritsa ntchito zolaula. Mwanjira ina, kuchuluka kwakukulu kwa osagwiritsa ntchito zolaula amadziwika kuti ndi "achikazi!" Tawonani momwe tebulo la Kohut limasokoneza mwadala. Amawerenga ngati kuti ogwiritsa ntchito zolaula ambiri amadziwika kuti ndi achikazi. Muyenera kuwunika mawu am'munsi kuti mudziwe kuti malongosoledwe ake ndiabwino.

Komanso, zomwe Kohut adapeza zikutsutsidwa ndi kafukufuku wina uliwonse wofalitsidwa (onani mndandanda uwu wa maphunziro opitilira 40 omwe akugwirizanitsa kugwiritsa ntchito zolaula ndi malingaliro osankhana mitundu, kutsutsa komanso kusalingana pang'ono ). Chidule cha ndemanga iyi ya 2016 ya mabuku awa: Media and Sexualization: State of Empirical Research, 1995–2015 . :

"Kuwonetsa akazi mopanda tsankho pa nkhani za kugonana kumachitika kawirikawiri m'manyuzipepala akuluakulu, zomwe zimadzutsa mafunso okhudza momwe kuwonetsedwa kwa izi kungakhudzire malingaliro a ena pa akazi komanso malingaliro a akazi pa iwo eni. Cholinga cha ndemangayi chinali kupanga kafukufuku woyeserera zotsatira za chiwerewere cha atolankhani. Cholinga chinali pa kafukufuku wofalitsidwa m'magazini owunikira anzawo, achingerezi pakati pa 1995 ndi 2015. Mabuku 109 omwe anali ndi maphunziro 135 adawunikidwanso . Zomwe zapezekazi zidapereka umboni wokhazikika wakuti kuwonetsedwa m'ma laboratories komanso kuwonetsedwa nthawi zonse tsiku ndi tsiku kuzinthu izi kumalumikizidwa mwachindunji ndi zotsatira zosiyanasiyana, kuphatikizapo kusakhutira kwa thupi , kudziona ngati wopanda tsankho, kuthandizira kwambiri zikhulupiriro zachiwerewere komanso zikhulupiriro zotsutsana ndi kugonana, komanso kulekerera kwambiri nkhanza zogonana kwa akazi. Kuphatikiza apo, kuwonetsedwa m'mayesero azinthu izi kumapangitsa akazi ndi amuna kukhala ndi malingaliro ochepa pa luso la akazi, makhalidwe abwino, ndi umunthu wawo ."

Taylor Kohut ali ndi mbiri yofalitsa maphunziro 'olenga' omwe adapangidwa kuti apeze mavuto ochepa kapena opanda chifukwa chogwiritsa ntchito zolaula. Mu kafukufuku wa 2017 , Kohut akuwoneka kuti wasintha chitsanzocho kuti apange zotsatira zomwe amafuna. Pomwe kafukufuku wambiri akuwonetsa kuti akazi ochepa omwe amagwiritsa ntchito zolaula amagwiritsa ntchito zolaula, mu kafukufukuyu 95% ya akazi adagwiritsa ntchito zolaula okha (85% ya akazi adagwiritsa ntchito zolaula kuyambira pachiyambi cha chibwenzi)! Zoona zake: Deta yochokera ku kafukufuku wamkulu kwambiri ku US (General Social Survey) idanena kuti 2.6% yokha ya akazi idapita ku "tsamba la zolaula" mwezi watha. Nkhani ina yotsutsa kafukufukuyu: Kafukufuku watsopano akuti ogwiritsa ntchito zolaula ali ndi 'malingaliro ofanana' - ndiye chiyani? (2015) ndi Jonah Mix.

Webusaiti yatsopano ya Kohut ndi kuyesa kwake kusonkhanitsa ndalama zikusonyeza kuti mwina ali ndi cholinga. Tsankho la Kohut lawululidwa mu chikalata chaposachedwa cholembedwa cha Komiti Yokhazikika ya Zaumoyo Ponena za Kusuntha M-47 (Canada). Muchidulechi, Kohut ndi olemba anzake ali ndi mlandu wosankha maphunziro angapo akunja pomwe akuwonetsa molakwika momwe kafukufukuyu alili pano pa zotsatira za zolaula. Kufotokozera kwawo kolakwika komanso koseketsa kwa maphunziro amitsempha ofalitsidwa pa ogwiritsa ntchito zolaula sikuti kumabweretsa kukayikira za tsankho lawo.

Mu 2019, Kohut adalowa nawo gulu la ofufuza okonda zolaula ndipo akatswiri azachipatala adapanga gulu kuti aba chizindikiro cha YBOP pomwe akuchirikiza poyera makampani opanga zolaula. Onani tsamba ili kuti mudziwe zambiri: Kuphwanya Malamulo Odziwika Bwino Omwe Amachitidwa Ndi Otsutsa Zolaula (www.realyourbrainonporn.com) . Kohut adateteza poyera akaunti ya twitter ya RealYBOP , yomwe idalemba ma tweets opitilira 1,000 onyoza ndi kunyoza zomwe idatcha, "otsutsa zolaula". @BrainOnPorn adaletsedwa pang'onopang'ono chifukwa chozunza ndi kuchitira nkhanza.

Zosintha (2018): Mu nkhani iyi ya 2018 Gary Wilson akuwulula chowonadi cha maphunziro 5 okayikitsa komanso osokeretsa, kuphatikizapo kafukufukuyu ( Kohut et al., 2016): Kafukufuku wa Zolaula: Zoona Kapena Nkhani Yongopeka?


J Sex Res. 2016;53(1):1-11. doi: 10.1080/00224499.2015.1023427.

Kohut T 1 , Baer JL 1 , Watts B 2.

Kudalirika

Malinga ndi chiphunzitso chachikazi, zolaula zimapangitsa kuti azimayi azikhala ochepa powaphunzitsa omwe amagwiritsa ntchito, amuna ndi akazi momwemonso, kuti aziona akazi ngati zinthu zogonana zomwe amuna akuyenera kuwalamulira. Mitundu yambiri yochokera ku General Social Survey idagwiritsidwa ntchito poyesa lingaliro loti ogwiritsa ntchito zolaula amakhala ndi malingaliro omwe amathandizira kusiyanasiyana pakati pa amuna ndi akazi kuposa omwe samakonda zolaula. Zotsatira sizinagwirizane ndi malingaliro ochokera kuchikhulupiriro chachikazi. Anthu ogwiritsa ntchito zolaula amakhala ndi malingaliro ofanana pakati pa amayi omwe ali ndiudindo, kwa azimayi omwe akugwira ntchito zapakhomo, komanso kutaya mimba-kuposa omwe sakonda zolaula. Kuphatikiza apo, ogwiritsa ntchito zolaula komanso osagwiritsa ntchito zolaula sanasiyane kwambiri pamalingaliro awo pabanja lachikhalidwe komanso kudzizindikiritsa kuti ndi achikazi. Zotsatira za phunziroli zikuwonetsa kuti kugwiritsa ntchito zolaula mwina sikungagwirizane ndi malingaliro osagwirizana ndi amuna kapena akazi m'njira yomwe imagwirizana ndi chiphunzitso chachikazi.

PMID: 26305435

DOI: 10.1080 / 00224499.2015.1023427