Mapulogalamu a Nicole Prause kuti akhale ndi mapepala owonetsera za Sayansi ya Chikhalidwe (Park et al., 2016) anachotsedwa

Iyi ndi nkhani yodabwitsa kwambiri momwe a Nicole Prause adagwiritsira ntchito njira iliyonse kuyesera kuti aletse kufalitsa kwa pepala loonedwa ndi anzawo, a Park et al, mu nyuzipepala yotchuka. Pepala lomwe likufunsidwa: Kodi Zithunzi Zolaula za pa Intaneti Zimayambitsa Mavuto Ogonana? Kuwongolera ndi Zipatala zapakhomo (Park et al., 2016). [Monga oyambirira a 2020, Park et al. wakhala zomwe zinatchulidwa ndi zowonjezereka za mapepala owonedwa ndi anzawo a 80, ndipo ali pepala lowonedwa kwambiri m'mbiri ya magazine a Behavioral Sciences].

Zosintha:

Kusintha (Chilimwe, 2019): Pa Meyi 8, 2019 A Donald Hilton, MD adaipitsa pa se mlandu motsutsana ndi Nicole Prause & Liberos LLC. Pa Julayi 24, 2019 A Donald Hilton adasintha madandaulo ake onyoza kuwunikira (1) dandaulo loipa la Texas Board of Medical Examiners, (2) zonamizira kuti a Dr. Hilton adabodza mbiri yake, ndi (3) maumboni ochokera kwa 9 ena omwe adazunzidwa chifukwa chakuzunzidwa kapena kunenedwa (A John Adler, MD, Gary Wilson, Alexander Rhodes, Staci Sprout, LICSW, Linda Hatch, PhD, Bradley Green, PhD, Stefanie Carnes, PhD, Geoff Goodman, PhD, Laila Haddad.)
Kusintha (Okutobala, 2019): Pa Okutobala 23, 2019 Alexander Rhodes (woyambitsa wa reddit / nofap ndi NoFap.com) idasumira mlandu wotsutsana ndi Nicole R Prause ndi Liberos LLC. Onani bwalo lamilandu apa. Onani tsamba ili la zikalata zitatu zamilandu zamakhothi zoyimiriridwa ndi Rhodes: Woyambitsa NoFap Alexander Rhodes akuipitsa mlandu wotsutsana ndi Nicole Prause / Liberos.
(Novembala, 2019): Pomaliza, kufalitsa nkhani molondola pazowunikira zabodza, wonyoza, wozunza, wotsutsa wazizindikiro, Nicole Prause: "Alex Rhod of Porn Addiction Support Gulu la 'NoFap' Amawona Wogwiritsa Ntchito Zolaula za Pro-Zolaula" Wolemba Megan Fox wa PJ Media ndi "Nkhondo zolaula sizimachitika mu Novembala Novembala", Wolemba Diana Davison wa The Post Zakachikwi. Davison adapanganso kanema kamphindi kakang'ono ka 6 kokhudzana ndi zamakhalidwe abwino a Prause: “Kodi Zolaula Zolaula?”.
MDPI ndi nsonga chabe ya madzi oundana. Onani - Malipoti Olakwika a Nicole Prause ndi Njira Zoipa Zogwiritsira Ntchito.
Nicole Prause & David Ley apanga chinyengo pamlandu wonyoza a Don Hilton.
Zakusintha (Ogasiti, 2020): Mu Marichi 2020, a Prause adandifunsa kuti ndisandiyikireko osagwiritsa ntchito "umboni" komanso zabodza zake (ndikunamizira kuti ndikusokosera). Pofunsa a Prause kuti amuletse kudziletsa adadzivulaza, ndikuti ndidalemba adilesi yawo pa YBOP ndi Twitter (cholakwika sichinthu chatsopano ndi Prause). Ndidalemba mlandu a Prause chifukwa chogwiritsa ntchito malamulo mwalamulo (TRO) kuti andiyimitse ndikundizunza. Pa Ogasiti 6, Khothi Lapamwamba la Los Angeles linagamula kuti kuyesa kwa Prause kupeza lamulo loletsa ine adapanga "njira yabodza yolimbana ndi kuchitapo kanthu pagulu la anthu" (lomwe limadziwika kuti "suti ya SLAPP"). Mwakutero, Khothi lidapeza kuti a Prause adagwiritsa ntchito lamulo loletsa kupha Wilson kuti atonthole ndikuphwanya ufulu wake wolankhula momasuka. Mwalamulo, chigamulo cha SLAPP chimakakamiza Prause kuti alipire ndalama za loya wa Wilson.
Kusintha (Januware, 2021): Pembedzero lidasumira mlandu wachiwiri wopanda pake pa ine mu Disembala, 2020 chifukwa chomunamizira. Pamlandu pa Januware 22, 2021 an Khothi ku Oregon linagamula mokomera ine ndipo linapatsa Prause mtengo ndi zina zowonjezera. Khama lolephera ili linali limodzi mwa milandu khumi ndi iwiri Pembedzero linawopsezedwa pagulu komanso / kapena kutumizidwa m'miyezi yapitayi. Pambuyo pazaka zambiri zanenedwe zoyipa, iye wafikira pakuwopseza kwamilandu yeniyeni kuti ayese kutsekereza omwe amamuwulula tidziyanjani ndi makampani azolaula ndi machitidwe ake oyipa, kapena omwe adalumbira m'misuti itatu yoyipitsa yomwe ikumutsutsa.

M'NDANDANDA WAZOPEZEKAMO:

**"Ndani akuyang'ana Anabweza Watch? "**

(Chigawo ichi chinapangidwa pambuyo zigawo 2-9 zinalengedwa.)

Ndinali pansi pa maganizo omwe anthu amawoneka Anabweza Watch pazolemba zodalirika, zowunikidwa bwino za kafukufuku. Pambuyo pazomwe zandichitikira posachedwa, ndingofunsa kuti, "Ndani akuwona Anabweza Watch? ” Kwa ndani kapena ndi chiyani Anabweza Watch kuyankha kuti ukhale woyang'anitsitsa pamene uchita zolemba zosavomerezeka?

Pa Juni 13, 2018 Anabweza Watch (RW) adafalitsa Nkhani yosakwanira komanso yosasamala za zochitika pafupi Sciences makhalidwe pepala Park et al., 2016. Zina mwazolakwikazo, chidutswacho sichidasokoneza mfundo za Nicole Prause zomwe sizinachitike (ndi zosavomerezeka) ntchito yapadera ya 3 kuti mapepala abwezeretsedwe (zolembedwa mu zigawo Zotsatira za 8).

Pemphero, yemwe kale anali wophunzira, mwachiwonekere analankhula ndi anthu a RW ndipo adawadyetsa zomwe ankafuna kuti azilemba - ndipo RW zikuwoneka kuti adawameza ndi kuwafalitsa. Wanga Yankho likuwonekera pansi pa tsamba la Retraction Watch. Komabe, RW inasinthira ndemanga yanga zisanayambe kuzilemba. Pano ine ndikupereka zinthu zambiri zosowa.

Choyamba, ndemanga yanga ndiyotchulidwa ndi imelo yomwe ndinatumizira kwa Adam Marcus ndi Ivan Oransky ya RW patangopita kanthawi kakang'ono. Pambuyo masiku a 3 a maimelo apambuyo ndi am'tsogolo, RW adatumiza zina mwa zomwe zakhala zikuchokera (kuchokera ku imelo yanga), koma adafuna kuti ndichotse zinthu zomwe zinawulula njira zomwe RW sanayambe kugwira ntchitoyi.

Nazi nkhani zambiri.

1) Wolemba wamkulu, ndi mkulu wa asilikali, Andrew Doan MD PhD anapempha kuti Adam Marcus akandiuze kuti ndifotokoze tsatanetsatane wa mapepala (pambuyo pa Marcus atamuuza). Mbuziyi inachita izi chifukwa iye ndi anzanga ena a 6 achita nawo ntchito ku US Navy ndipo "sangathe kuyankhula mwatsatanetsatane pamapepala popanda chilolezo ku ofesi ya boma ya US Navy." Marcus anasankha kuti asandiyankhule. M'malo mwake adathamanga ndi chirichonse Chidutswa chinamupatsa iye. Kuchokera ku email yanga yapachiyambi:

Ndawerenga chidutswa chako, "Journal amaletsa, koma sangathe kubwezera, pepala losemphana pa zolaula pa intaneti. "Monga cholinga chachikulu cha Anabweza Watch ndi umphumphu pakufalitsa, ndikukhulupirira kuti mukufuna kukonza nkhaniyi muzinthu zambiri zofunika. Mu mawonekedwe ake omwe alipo ali ndi zolakwika zambiri komanso zolakwika zambiri. Ndikudandaula kuti simunandiyankhule monga Dr. Doan adalangizira, kotero kuti izi zikanatha kupewa.

2) RW akuluakulu Adam Marcus ndi Ivan Oransky adakopizidwa pa May, 2018 MDPI-Prause mauthenga a email. Monga ndinanena m'modzi mwa maimelo anga kwa RW:

Ndimadera nkhaŵa kwambiri Chotsani Chowongolera kugwiritsa ntchito makina a ma MDPI maimelo omwe Dr. Prause anakukopani. Monga momwe ndatumizira maimelo aja, ndikudziwa kuti pali zambiri zambiri mwa iwo. Bits omwe sanathenso ankaphatikizapo mabodza komanso kuzunzidwa kwa ena ndi Dr. Prause. Ngakhale chithunzi cha Dr. Lin chinali choipa (Chingerezi si chilankhulo chake choyamba kapena chachiwiri), ndikuganiza kuti mawu ake akuyenera 'kumveka' pokhapokha kuti Dr. Prause wakhala akunyoza kampani yake mwachindunji, ndipo mwachindunji kudzera mwa COPE, chifukwa pafupifupi zaka ziwiri zolunjika. Kukhumudwa kwake kumamveka mosavuta. Kupatsa Dr. Prause "kudutsa" pa khalidwe lake loipitsitsa pamene kumuwonetsa kwake kunali kosakoma mtima ndipo, chofunikira kwambiri, amasiya owerenga anu mwachidwi kwambiri.

Tiyenera kuzindikira kuti RW sanalembedwe pa maimelo osatha, kuyambira zaka za 3 zapitazo, pamene Prause anazunza MDPI, asilikali a ku United States, madokotala a 7 Navy, The Reward Foundation, wofalitsa buku langa, ndi zina zotero. Palibe aliyense amene amakonda maimelo ake apadera ku COPE ndi oyang'anira ake.

3) Mu May, 2018 MDPI-Kugwiritsa ntchito mauthenga a imelo, Marcus ndi Oransky anapatsidwa kawiri tsamba lalikulu lomwe likulemba mbiri ya Prause ofufuza ovutitsa, olemba, madokotala, odwala, akatswiri a maganizo, omwe kale anali a UCLA, a UK aumulungu, amuna ochiritsidwa, akuluakulu TIME magazini editor, aphunzitsi ena, IITAP, SASH, Nkhondo Yatsopano, Mankhwala Osokoneza Bongo, MDPI, ndi mutu wa magazini yophunzira CUREUS. Mwachidziwikire, RW sananyalanyaze Prause kulembera khalidwe loipa kuti asindikize chidutswa chake chophatikizidwa.

4) Mu imelo yotsatira ikufunsa chifukwa chomwe RW alephera kulemba ndemanga yanga (yowonongeka), ndinauza Marcus ndi Oransky kuti chiganizo chachikulu cha RW's hit piece chinali cholakwika:

Pamene zinthu zikuyima, ngakhalenso maziko a nkhani yanu ndi abodza. Kugwirizana kwanga ndi The Reward Foundation (TRF) nthawi zonse kunanenedwa momveka bwino, poyamba Sciences makhalidwe Nkhani ndi ndondomeko yaposachedwa (a Choyambirira cha PubMed). Cholinga cha kukonzedwa kwatsopano kumene anali woti amutsutse Dr. Prause wosapitirira Ndondomeko zowononga kuti ndikulandira ndalama kuchokera ku TRF, ndikuti ndikupanga ndalama kuchokera ku bukhu langa (zomwe ndimapeza, ndikupita ku chithandizo).

5) Mu maimelo anga onse kwa RW, ndalongosola momveka bwino mfundo yachiwiri yoyamba m'nkhani yawo:

Ndifunikanso kufotokoza kuti Dr. Prause a "77 mfundo zosasinthika" zomwe akunena sizowona. Ndili ndi zolemba za mfundo izi ndi mayankho a timu athu (ndi zolemba zomwe 25 za "zizindikiro" za 77 sizikugwirizana ndi Sciences makhalidwe pepala).

Onani gawo ili kuti mudziwe zambiri zokhudza Prause zomwe zimatchedwa "zizindikiro za 77," komanso kusagwirizana kwake ndi mapepala athu oyambirira, osiyana kwambiri Yale Journal ya Biology ndi Medicine.

6) Mu maimelo anga onse kwa RW, ndanena mosapita m'mbali kuti Pempheroli linali lonena za kufufuza kwa California:

Kenaka, ndikofunikira kukonza chinyengo cha Dr Prause kuti kufufuza kwa California ku khalidwe lake kwatha ndipo wapambana. Sizatha; wofufuzira wandiitana ine kuti ndichitire umboni mu miyezi ikubwera (tsiku la TBD).

Ndiko kunena kuti Marcus ndi Oransky

(1) sanakonze ndondomeko ya mawu a RW ndi zabodza komanso zonyenga,

(2) umboni wovomerezeka m'ndondomeko yanga yopempha kuti adziŵe bwino za mbiri ya Prause ndi mbiri yozunza ndipo anapitirizabe,

(3) anasankha kuti asalankhulane ndi ine asanayambe kufalitsa, ngakhale wolemba wamkulu wa pepala anapempha kuti achite zimenezo,

(4) mwatsatanetsatane anandiuza kuti ndine wozunza mwa kunena zabodza kuti California kafufuzidwe inatsirizika ndipo adasankhidwa kuti apempherere kwa Prause, ndi kulumikizana ndi Chamoyo Chamasiku Onse nkhani ya zochitika, ndi

(5) sanakonze kapena kusindikiza chidutswa chawo cholemba ngati kusalongosoka, kapena kupepesa poyera kwa olemba ndi magazini omwe mbiri zawo zomwe adazilemba popanda chifukwa.

Zowonjezera zina zomwe zalembedwa pa RW sizinalembedwe mu ndemanga yanga. Ndime yoyamba imati:

"Atasindikiza, otsutsa adapempha COPE kuti ayang'ane papepalalo."

"Otsutsa" ambiri? Anali "wotsutsa" mmodzi yemwe adatumizira MDPI kapena COPE. Anatumizira maulendo ambirimbiri ku United States Navy, adawauza madokotala a 7 pamapepala awo ku mabungwe awo azachipatala, ndipo adasokoneza mafilimu kuti azondisokoneza ine, MDPI, ndi ochita kafukufuku amene amafalitsa mu MDPI - monga gawo lachitetezo chosalepheretsa kulembera ophunzira Yankhani mapepala ndipo mmalo mwake yesetsani kuti mubwezeretsedwe pambuyo pamasom'pamaso ndikuwonetseratu zabodza.

Nkhaniyo inati:

"COPE, yomwe ilibe aliyense wovomerezeka, idatumiza imelo kwa wofalitsa kuti ikadalimbikitsa kuti nkhaniyo ichotsedwe."

COPE inangoganizira za nkhani imodzi (kuchokera pa "zowonjezera" zomwe idadyetsedwa kwa izo): chilolezo. COPE inati:

"Ngati mlanduwu udakambidwa pa umodzi mwa mabwalo athu a COPE, tikuganiza kuti malingaliro ake akadakhala kuti tiganizire zakubweza nkhaniyo pamalingaliro ovomerezeka osatsatira ziyembekezo"… ..

Ngakhale kuti yankho la COPE ndilo lingaliro, pogwiritsa ntchito "zenizeni" zilizonse zomwe zikuyamikiridwa, olemba ndi MDPI amadabwa kwambiri ndi yankho. Zoona zenizeni, madokotala a ku US Navy kuposa ovomerezeka ndi Naval Medical Center yawo - malamulo a consent ya IRB ku San Diego. Bungwe la Medical Naval Policy ya IRB silingaganizire nkhani za odwala osachepera anayi m'nkhani imodzi yokha yofufuza kafukufuku waumunthu ndipo safuna kuti odwala alole kuti alowe m'nkhani. Ngakhale kuti ochita kafukufuku sanafunikire kupeza chilolezo, anapeza milandu iŵiri, mawu ovomerezeka ndi olembedwa. Pachigawo chachitatu chomwe sichidziwika kuti anthu sakudziwika, palibe chilolezo cholembedwera.

Zomwe zinachitika, patsikuli la Dr. Prause, patsikuli lidafalitsidwa, zochita za olemba anzawo a Navy zokhudzana ndi nyuzipepalayi zinawerengedweratu mufukufuku wopita ku Navy. Zotsatira zake? Ndili ndi lipoti lovomerezeka ndi loya wa Navy kutsimikizira kuti olemba awiriwa amatsatira malamulo onse a IRB.

Nkhani ya RW inanenanso kuti:

"Zina mwazomwe akuti ndi m'modzi mwa olembawo, a Gary Wilson, adalephera kufotokoza bwino ntchito yawo ndi Mphoto Yopindulitsa"

Izi ndi zabodza. Monga tafotokozera poyamba, kuyanjana kwathu ndi The Reward Foundation (TRF) nthawi zonse kunanenedwa momveka bwino, poyambirira Sciences makhalidwe Nkhani ndi ndondomeko yaposachedwa (a Choyambirira cha PubMed). Cholinga cha kukonzedwa kwatsopano kumene anali woti amutsutse Dr. Prause wosapitirira Ndondomeko zowononga kuti ndikulandira ndalama kuchokera ku TRF, ndikuti ndikupanga ndalama kuchokera ku bukhu langa (zomwe ndimapeza, ndikupita ku chithandizo).

Popanda kuyang'anira mokwanira, owerenga a RW angafune kukhala osakayikira zowonjezera malemba a blog popanda maphunziro apadera. RW ikuwoneka kuti ikulolera kuti ikhale yogwiritsidwa ntchito ndi mphamvu zowonongeka pokhapokha atachenjezedwa kuti kufufuza kwina kuli kofunika.

Background

MDPI ndi kampani ya makolo a ku Swiss yamanyuzipepala ambiri a maphunziro, kuphatikizapo Sciences makhalidwe. MDPI imatero osati sindikirani makope oyipa. Ndipotu, anafufuzidwa zaka zapitazo atayikidwa molakwika pa mndandanda wa zowonongeka, ndipo atsimikiza kukhala wofalitsa wolondola. Onani: http://www.mdpi.com/about/announcements/534. Mwamuna uja (Jeffrey Beall) amene adapanga zolakwikazo potsiriza adachotsa ntchito yake yonse.

Pembedzero likudandaula ndi MDPI chifukwa (1) Sciences makhalidwe adafalitsa nkhani ziwiri zomwe Prause sagwirizana ndi (chifukwa adakambirana naye mapepala, pakati pa mapepala ambiri ndi olemba ena), ndi (2) Gary Wilson ndi wolemba nawo Park et al., 2016. Pembedzero liri ndi mbiri yakale ya cyberstalking ndi kuipitsa Wilson, zomwe zili mu tsamba lalikulu kwambiri. Mapepala awiriwa:

Katswiri wa sayansi ya zithunzi zolaula pa intaneti: Kukonzanso ndi Kukonzanso (Love et al., 2015)
Kodi Zithunzi Zolaula za pa Intaneti Zimayambitsa Mavuto Ogonana? Kubwereza ndi Malipoti a Clinic (Park et al., 2016)

Pepala lachiwiri (Park et al.) sanayese kufufuza za Prause. Ilo linatchula zofukufuku mu 3 za mapepala ake. Pempho la wolembapo pazokambirana zoonerera anzawo, ilo linayankha lachitatu, pepala la 2015 Pembedzero & Pfaus, pofotokoza a chidutswa cha akatswiri mumagazini amene adatsutsa mwatsatanetsatane pepala. (Panalibe malo okwanira Park et al. kuti athetse zofooka zonse ndi zodzinenera zosalimbikitsidwa Pembedzero & Pfaus, 2015).

Pembedzero nthawi yomweyo anatsindika kuti MDPI isinthe Park et al., 2016. Mapulogalamu apadera kwa akatswiri a maphunziro omwe amavomerezana ndi kusindikiza ndemanga pofotokoza chotsutsa chirichonse. Zotsatira za Sciences kampani ya kholo, MDPI, anapempha Prause kuti achite izi. Iye anakana. Tiyenera kuzindikira kuti masewera a Pray Wilson ndi webusaiti yake nthawi zonse komanso poyera.

M'malo mosindikizira ndondomeko yowonongeka, iye mopanda malire anatembenukira ku zoopseza ndi chikhalidwe cha anthu (ndipo posachedwapa Anabweza Watch blog) kuti amunyozetse MDPI kuti abwezeretse Park et al., zomwe ine ndine wothandizana nawo omwe ali ndi madokotala a 7 US Navy (kuphatikizapo urologists awiri, azimayi awiri a maganizo ndi katswiri wa sayansi). Kuonjezera apo, adauza MDPI kuti adalemba madandaulo ndi American Psychological Association. Kenaka anabweretsa madandaulo ndi mabungwe onse azachipatala. Anapangitsanso madokotala kuchipatala ndi Institute Institutional Review Board, kuchititsa kufufuza kwa nthawi yayitali, yomwe sinapeze umboni wa zolakwa za olemba a pepala.

Pembedzero lidadandaula mobwerezabwereza ku COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics). COPE pamapeto pake adalemba MDPI ndi malingaliro onena zakubwezeretsa, potengera zomwe a Prause adachita kuti "odwala sanavomerezedwe." MDPI idasanthulanso bwino zovomerezeka zomwe madotolo adalemba, komanso mfundo za US Navy zovomerezeka.

Chonde dziwani kuti Naval Medical Center IRB's IRB silingaganizire zonena za odwala ochepera anayi munkhani imodzi kuti ndizofufuza zamunthu ndipo sizikufuna kuti odwala avomereze kuti aphatikizidwe munkhani. Ngakhale ofufuzawo sankafunika kuti avomereze, maulendo awiri, zivomerezo zamlomo ndi zolembedwa zidapezeka. Pankhani yachitatu yomwe anthu osadziwika sakanatha kusokonezedwa, palibe chilolezo cholemba chomwe chidapezeka.

Zomwe zinachitika, patsikuli la Dr. Prause, patsikuli lidafalitsidwa, zochita za olemba anzawo a Navy zokhudzana ndi nyuzipepalayi zinawerengedweratu mufukufuku wopita ku Navy. Zotsatira zake? Ndili ndi lipoti lovomerezeka ndi loya wa Navy kutsimikizira kuti olemba awiriwa amatsatira malamulo onse a IRB.

Choncho MDPI inakana kuchotsa pepalali. Izi zinafotokozedwa kwa COPE, popanda kutsutsa kwa COPE. Malingana ngati ochita kafukufuku amatsatira malamulo a IRB ovomerezeka (zomwe zinalipo pano), palibe vuto. Komabe Pemphero likupitiriza kunena zabodza kuti nkhaniyi siidasinthidwe ndipo "odwala sanaloledwe" ndipo kubwezeretsa ndi koyenera.

Pemphero linadandauliranso ku COPE kuti ndinali ndi mkangano wopanda chidwi wosadziwika. Kumbuyo: Ndinafotokozera mgwirizano wanga ndi The Reward Foundation mu pepala kuyambira pachiyambi. Izi sizitsutsana za chidwi. Mu 2018, nyuzipepalayi inapereka chidziwitso chomwe chinasintha chilankhulo chofotokozera zomwe ndikugwirizana kuti chikhale chonchi (ngakhale ku Prause) kuti palibe kusiyana komwe kunalipo. Ilo limatchula bukhu langa, mfundo yakuti zomwe ndimapeza kuchokera m'bukuli zimapita ku The Reward Foundation, komanso kuti kuyanjana kwanga ndi malo osasinthika. Pemphero likupitiriza kunena (zabodza) kuti ndakhala ndikulandira zikwi za mapaundi kuchokera ku chikondi. Umboni wakuti akulakwitsa akulembedwa kwina kulikonse patsamba lino.

Mbiri ya MDPI isanachitike: Yale Journal of Biology & Medicine, ndi "Janey Wilson"

Nkhani ya Ntchito ya Prause yokhudzana ndi pepala yomwe idasindikizidwa pomaliza Park et al. kwenikweni akuyamba pamaso kuthandizidwa kwa MDPI ndi Sciences makhalidwe. Pepala lapitalo, lalifupi kwambiri, ndi olemba omwewa ndi olemba omwe adalemba nawo Sciences makhalidwe, idaperekedwa koyamba Yale Journal ya Biology ndi Medicine (YJBM). Ndikofunika kuyang'anitsitsa khalidwe linalake papepalali pamene lidayankhidwa YJBM.

Mmodzi mwa owonetsa 2 a pepala adapereka ndemanga yochititsa chidwi ndi zifukwa za 70, ndipo zinakanidwa. Pafupi nthawi imeneyo YJBM anakana pepala, "Janey Wilson"Anayamba kunyoza bukhu langa la wofalitsa, Commonwealth Publishing, ndi chithandizo cholembedwera chimene ndimapereka gawo langa lazomwe ndapeza m'bukuli. (Ndine wolemba Ubongo Wanu Pa Porn: Zithunzi Zolaula pa Intaneti ndi Emerging Science of Addiction.) Nkhani yotsatanetsatane ya "Janey" yowonongeka mwakuya imayikidwa pansi pa tsamba lino.

Zindikirani: Kugonjera YJBM anali malo okha omwe ndikugwirizana nawo ndi chikondi, Maziko A Mphoto (TRF), angapezeke, chifukwa panalibe ponseponse poyera. Mwa kuyankhula kwina, kupatula ku Bungwe la TRF ndi ine ndekha, ndi YJBM Mkonzi ndi olemba awiriwo adadziwa za mgwirizanowu. Komabe, "Janey" adanena kuti ali ndi umboni wokhudzana ndi mgwirizanowu, ndipo adagwiritsa ntchito mgwirizano wanga ndikupanga zolakwa zosiyanasiyana ndi TRF ndi ine. Mayiyu adalemba lipoti losautsa ndi Scottish Charity Regulator, lopanda phindu.

Pambuyo pake, Dr. Prause adamugwedeza YJBM kubwereza ndi zifukwa za 70 + ku bungwe lolamulira (monga gawo la kuyesa kuti pepala lofalitsidwa lichoke), motsimikizira kuti iye waperekadi YJBM ndizosavomerezeka kuyambiranso pepalalo. (Zoonjezeranso umboni kuti iye anali YJBM Wongomaliza watsegulidwa pa nthawiyi Sciences makhalidwe Kutumiza, monga tafotokozera pansipa.) Zodabwitsa ndizakuti, zomwe a Prause akuchita ndikuphwanya malamulo a COPE owunikira anzawo (Gawo 5 la "Malangizo Othandiza Kuchita Zabwino"), Zomwe zimafuna owonetsa kuti asunge chinsinsi chilichonse chimene amaphunzira kudzera mu ndondomekoyi.

YJBM anadziwitsidwa kuti (1) khalidwe lozunza lotengedwa ndi "Janey," (2) "Janey" wotheka kudziwika, komanso (3) chifukwa chakuti "Janey" angakhale ataphwanya malamulo a COPE kwa owerenga anzawo polemba zinsinsi za anthu ine.

Pepalalo linalandiridwa mwachangu YJBM... ndiyeno osatulutsidwa m'magaziniyi pambuyo pa zonse, chifukwa cha chisankho cha nyuzipepala kuti kunali kochedwa kwambiri kuti apangitse zomwe zasankhidwa ndikukumanabe ndi nthawi yake yosindikiza YJBM's nkhani "Yothetsera" yapadera.

***Sciences makhalidwe* Baibulo la *Park et al.***

Ndondomeko yowonjezeredwa ndi yosinthidwa ya pepalayo kenaka inaperekedwa ku nyuzipepala Sciences makhalidwe. Pambuyo pa ndemanga zochepa zowerengera ndikubwezeretsanso zowonjezera izo zinavomerezedwa ngati kubwereza kwa mabukuwo, ndi kafukufuku wamilandu. Maonekedwe ake omalizira anali osiyana kwambiri ndi oyambirirawo YJBM kusonyeza.

Panthawiyi, pepalayi inayambidwa ndi osachepera oposa 6. Anthu asanu adadutsa, ena adatsutsa, ndipo wina anakana mwamphamvu (ndikuganiza ndani?).

Gawo limodzi la ndondomekoyi likuwonekera motere: Papepalayi inakambidwa kawiri, imodzi mwa iwo kukanidwa mwamphamvu, kovomerezeka. Kudabwa ndi kukanidwa koopsa, Sciences makhalidwe adatumizira pepala kuti iwerengedwe kwa owerengera ena a 2. Obwezera awa adadutsa pepala. Sciences makhalidwe adalekerera mwatsatanetsatane pepala koma adalola olemba "kuwongolera ndi kubwezeretsanso." Monga mbali ya njirayi, olembawo adapatsidwa ndemanga zonse ndi olemba (koma osati zizindikiro zawo). Zofuna za oweruzidwazo zinayankhidwa bwino, mfundo ndi mfundo (zilipo pa pempho).

Kuchokera mu ndemanga izi, zinawonekeratu kuti "wolemba ndondomeko" wa Sciences makhalidwe pepala inakambirananso pepalalo YJBM. Pafupifupi gawo limodzi mwa magawo atatu a mfundo za 77 zomwe zinaperekedwa sanatchulepo za Sciences makhalidwe kusonyeza nkomwe. Iwo ankanena za zinthu zomwe zinali okha mulipo mu kale ndemanga ya pepala, yomwe idaperekedwa YJBM.

Mwa kuyankhula kwina, wolemba mwakhama anali atadula ndi kudutsa kutsutsa kwambiri kuchokera ku ndemanga yomwe yachitika china magazini (YJBM), zomwe zinalibe phindu lililonse pamapepala omwe analembedwera Sciences makhalidwe. Izi ndizosafunikira kwambiri. Komanso, Prause potsirizira pake adadziwonetsera yekha kuti ndiye mlembi wa zifukwazi podandaula kwake ku mapulani otsogolera (onani pamwambapa), momwe adamufotokozera YJBM Kuwunika za mapepala omwe satha.

Pomwepo, pamene Prause adafunsidwa kuti awonenso pepalalo Sciences makhalidwe iye mwachiwonekere sanawulule kuti anali atayang'ana kale pepalalo ku magazini ina. Icho chikanakhala chidziwitso chokhazikika chowonetsera kuti chiwonetsere ndemanga yapitayi.

Ndiloleni ndifotokoze mwachidule mapemphero a Prause ambiri pamapepala athu. Apanso, 25 kapena ena a iwo analibe kanthu kochita ndi Sciences makhalidwe pepala Pemphero linafunsidwa ndi Sciences makhalidwe kuti awonenso. Iwo ankanena za kumvera kwawo koyamba pa YJBM. Ichi chokhacho chiyenera kulepheretsa kuwerengera kwathunthu kupitiliza kulingalira.

Komabe, timagwiritsira ntchito ndemanga iliyonse pofufuza mfundo iliyonse yothandiza, ndikulemba mwachidwi ndemanga zonse Sciences makhalidwe ndi olemba ake. Pafupifupi zotsalira zonse za 50 zanenedwa zinali zosagwirizana ndi sayansi, zopanda pake, kapena zinali chabe zabodza. Ena anali kubwereza. Ambiri adadandaula ponena za kupezeka kwa odwala a 3, ngakhale kuti mapepalawa adatumizidwa monga "ndemanga ndi zolemba zachipatala." Ena adanena zokhudzana ndi zina zomwe tazitchula, koma zonenazo sizimangogwiridwa ndi mapepala okhaokha. Zambiri kuposa ndemanga za 10 zinalimbikitsanso kuti madokotala sakanatha kuyesa odwala awo pa zochitikazo (!).

Mwachidule, pamene ndemanga zowonjezera zimawongolera mapepala paliponse, panalibe chifukwa choyenera "kukonza" mapepala ambiri pokhapokha ndemanga za Prause. Zomwe tachita ndi kulimbikitsa pepala lokha ndi ziganizo za 50, kuti owerenga ena asapange zolakwika zomwezo.

Pepalalo linalembedwanso ndipo linakonzedwanso. Kenaka, olemba ena awiri ndi mkonzi woyang'anitsitsa anawongolera ndikuwapereka ndi malingaliro osiyanasiyana, kuphatikizapo ndondomeko kuti awongosolere ngati "ndemanga ndi kafukufuku wamakono." Wokhutira kuti zokhudzidwa zonse zowonetsedwa, Sciences makhalidwe adafalitsa pepala.

Kufuna kubwezera

Nthawi yomweyo Pemphero linayamba kufuna kuti pepala libwezeretsedwe. Mwa zoyesayesa zina, adatumizira uthenga waumembala wosasamala waumembala woopsya MDPI ndi mauthenga oipa ngati anakana kuchotsa pepalali:

"Izi zidasungidwa pa Ogasiti 24, 2016. Tsopano ndi Novembala 12, 2016… .. Ngati sindimva kalikonse mkati mwa milungu iwiri ikubwerayi, tiyamba ndikulemba komiti ya magaziniyo ndi zowona zake. Alonda angapo obwezeretsa kumbuyo amadziwa kale ndikudikirira kumva kuti kuchotsedwa kwawo kukuchitika, koma m'malo mwake adzalengeza zakulephera kubweza ngati kuli kofunikira. ”

Pano pali china chake choopsya cha MDPI pa Mon, Nov 14, 2016:

“Khalidwe la Sayansi ndilo tanthauzo la nyuzipepala ndipo idadziwika pamndandanda wazolemba za Beall mpaka pomwe mudamuwopseza kuti achotsa. Nkhani zoyamba kufalitsa nkhani za izi zikuyenera kuonekera mochedwa sabata ino m'malo ogulitsira dziko. Takupatsani mwayi uliwonse kuti mutulutse pepala labodza ili. ”

MDPI sanagwirizane ndi zodandaula za Prause kapena kuunika kwa pepala, ndipo sanabwezeretse izo, potsata kufufuza kozama zazowonjezera zake. Saga ikupitirira, ndipo chidule cha izo chikuwonekera kumapeto kwa tsamba ili.

Mulimonsemo, atatha kukhumudwa mobwerezabwereza, Pemphero linayamba kutonza MDPI (ndi magazini yake Sciences makhalidwe) monga "zowonongeka" pazolumikizidwe.

**Pemphero limagwiritsa ntchito mafilimu kuti awononge MDPI, ofufuza omwe amafalitsa m'magazini a MDPI, ndi aliyense amene akulemba Park et al., 2016**

Mosakayikira Pemphero likuukira MDPI mu November, 2017, tweeting nkhani yosagwirizana ndi MDPI:

MDPI ikuyankha:

Izi zimapangitsa Prause kuti apite pa Twitter pafupipafupi (ma tweets ake pansipa):

MDPI ikuyankha ku Pemphero:

Mtsogoleri wa MDPI Franck Vazquez, Ph.D, nayenso akuyankha, monganso Pemphero:

Pemphero likupitirira (MDPI sanyalanyaza kuika kwake Twitter):

Kodi Prause akuyesera kuti MDPI iponyedwe kunja kwa PubMed ndi ma indices ena kutengera zabodza zake? Ma tweets atatu kuyambira Ogasiti, 2016 - patangotha milungu ingapo pambuyo pake Park et al., 2016 inasindikizidwa:

Tsamba lachiwiri:

Tsamba lachitatu:

Tsamba lina lochokera ku Novemba, 2017 likusonyeza kuti Prause ikuvutitsa mabungwe oyang'anira za MDPI (https://twitter.com/NicoleRPrause/status/935983476775387136):

Kuchokera mu chidutswa chophwanyidwa chomwe chiri ndi mawu angapo onyenga a Prause: http://www.patheos.com/blogs/mormontherapist/2016/12/op-ed.html. Nkhani imodzi yomwe ikunenedwa ndikuwunikanso kwa madokotala a 7 Navy ndi ine, inayo ndi yolembedwa ndi akatswiri ena, kuphatikiza Todd Love PsyD - yemwe Prause nayenso wasokoneza. Apanso, MDPI idakhululukidwa ndi kuchotsedwa ngakhale Beall asanayambe kulemba.

Pemphero layesetsanso kusokoneza ena Magazini ya MDPI ikufotokoza za kuipitsa MDPI:

----

Pano pali zitsanzo za Pembedzero yosakondweretsa ena pochita nawo / kusindikiza ndi / kulandira mphoto kuchokera ku MDPI:

----

---

Apa Pembedzero imasewera khadi yake yomwe amakonda - kutsutsa ena za misogyny - popanda umboni uliwonse (monga momwe iye wachitira ndi ine ndi ena ambirimbiri).

Zowonjezereka zowonjezereka za misogyny:

Pembedzero zabodza akunena Sciences makhalidwe pepala lomwe iye anagwidwa lidatulutsidwa. Izi ndizozitsutsa komanso zosapindulitsa.

Nkhani ya Twitter ikupitiriza:

"Kubwezeretsa zolaula" ma tweets mindandanda iwiri ya YBOP, zomwe zimapangitsa Prause kutumizira tweet pepala ndi madokotala a Gary Wilson ndi Navy. Pembedzero amanamizira kuti adalemba COPE kuti apereke lingaliro loti achotse. Zonse ndi zamphongo.

Pambuyo pa kufufuza kwa nthawi yayitali, kwanthawi yaitali, MDPI inasankha kusabwereza papepala, ndipo inayambitsa ndondomeko yowonetsera mwatsatanetsatane machitidwe a Pulezidenti opanda ntchito. Atangomudziwa Pulezidenti, adayambitsa kusinthanitsa kwa ma email ndi MDPI, ndikujambula olemba malemba osiyanasiyana omwe amayembekeza kuti atenga mawu ake ndi kufalitsa nkhani zosokoneza. Anabweza Watch watsatira kale zofuna zake.

Ndi 2019 ndipo Pembedzero likupitilizabe kusaka pa intaneti zinthu zosagwirizana kotero ali ndi chifukwa chomuyimbira zabodza komanso nkhani yabodza ya Retraction Watch:

Tweet potengera mayankho awiri a maphunziro ochokera ku YBOP. Palibe mndandanda uli nawo Park et al., 2016.

January 29, 2019:

Pa February 16, 2019, katswiri wa mankhwala opatsirana pogonana anapereka nkhani pa 21st Congress ya European Society ya Mankhwala Ogonana pa intaneti zimakhudza kugonana. Zithunzi zochepa zofotokoza zolaula zogwiritsa ntchito zolaula, zolemba Park et al., 2016, adatumizidwa tweeted. Masewerawa amachititsa kuti Nicole Prause, David Ley, Joshua Grubbs ndi othandizira awo azisokoneza Twitter Park et al., 2016.

Ambiri mwa mauthenga a Prause onse ndi adiresi yaikulu ya Gary Wilson yokonzekera msonkhano wa 2018 ISSM. Mwadzidzidzi ndipo popanda kufotokoza nkhani yanga anachotsedwa mwachinsinsi. Zikuwoneka kuti Dr. Prause ndiye anali kutsogolera kufotokozedwa popeza ndi yekhayo amene anganene kuti (kutchuka)? Iye akhala ndi mbiri yakale yopanga malipoti abodza kwa mabungwe ndi mabungwe olamulira.

Zikuwoneka kuti Prause adadyetsa okonza msonkhano wa ISSM nthawi zambiri kusonkhanitsa mabodza. Mwachitsanzo, ndikuganiza kuti adanenanso kuti adandiuza ku Oregon Board of Psychology (popanda chifukwa) chifukwa chogwiritsa ntchito "psychology popanda chilolezo." Ndikunena izi chifukwa, posakhalitsa msonkhano utatha, ndinalandira kalata yochokera ku Bungwe kukhululukidwa ine ndikuchita chotero (iwo sakanakhoza kuwulula yemwe anali atadandaula zoipa).

Dr Prause amanenanso nthawi zonse kuti anthu, kuphatikizapo okonza msonkhano, kuti ndidzipereke monga pulofesa. Izi ndizonso zoona. (Onani chithunzi ichi kuti mudziwe zambiri: Pitirizani - Pembedzero yonyenga imanena kuti Wilson wanena zabodza zake.) Akhozanso kuwauza okonza mabodzawa mobwerezabwereza kuti ndili ndi choletsa chonditeteza, ndikuti anandiuza ku FBI. Palibe zoterozo "zosalumikizana", ndipo ndanena kale za a lipoti la FBI likunditsutsa ine ndikutsimikizira kuti Prause amanama. M'munsimu muli zitsanzo za Prause's February 16, 2019 Twitter-rage related to Park et al., 2016:

Josh Grubbs kawirikawiri amachirikiza pothandizira pulogalamu yachipongwe pozunza ndi kuwonetsera zabodza za sayansi (kapena maphunziro ake):

Tsiku lomwelo, NatureReviewsUrology (NRU) yatchulapo nkhani, osati papepala lathu. NRU tweet iyi ndi yomwe idakwiya kwambiri pa Twitter kuchokera ku Pause ndipo omutsatira ake akuukira pepala lathu, ngakhale pepala lathu silinanene izi, ndipo sananene chilichonse chokhudza zolaula. Monga pambali, zonena za a Prause za "chidziwitso chabodza" sizabodza ndipo sizichirikizidwa.

Palibe zolembedwa za chilichonse, kupatula zingwe zopanda malire za Prause zosatsimikizika, zonyoza, zomwe zalembedwa pamasamba awa:

Chowonadi ndi chakuti, sindinayitanidwe ngati wokamba nkhani wamkulu ndi ISSM chifukwa cha zoyeserera za Prause ndi chum wake komanso wolemba mnzake Jim Pfaus (membala wa ISSM), yemwe adagwiritsa ntchito mphamvu yake yayitali kuyika zomangira ku komiti ya ISSM. Popeza sindinachite chilichonse cholakwira, Pembedzero linanama zabodza kuti ziwopseze ISSM (motsatira machitidwe ake omwe alembedwa patsamba lino). Chithunzi chojambula cha zokambirana za Gary Wilson pamsonkhano wa 2018 ISSM womwe unachitikira ku Portugal:

Komiti inandipempha kuti ndiyankhule chifukwa: (1) ndinalipo Park et al., 2016, ndi, (2) ndapatsa Nkhani yotchuka ya TEDx, zomwe zinakhudza zolaula-zinachititsa ED. Chithunzi chojambula cha pempho lovomerezeka:

Pama media azachuma, a Prause ati aletsa nkhani yanga chifukwa ndidapereka "zikalata zabodza." Mwachitsanzo, a tweet aku Prause akuukira nkhani ya ESSM, ndikuti Gary Wilson sanaitanidwe chifukwa "adapereka zikalata zabodza":

Umboni wakuti Prause amanama: m'mbuyo ndi ma email, ndinakumbutsa komiti ya ISSM kuti ndinalibe PhD kapena MD (onani m'munsimu). Komabe, komitiyi inalimbikitsanso kuti ndipereke komanso ndikulipiritsa ulendo wanga wopita ku Portugal ngakhale ndikuchotsa (zomwe sizinachitike nthawi zambiri).

Ngakhale zingakhale zochititsa mantha kuti Pemphero lingagwirizane nazo, tiyenera kukumbukira kuti uyu ndi munthu yemweyo yemwe anafotokoza madokotala a 7 madokotala pa Park et al. kwa mabungwe awo azachipatala (mabodiwo adanyalanyaza kuzunzidwa kwa a Prause). Iye ndi munthu yemweyo amene ali naye ananenedwa zabodza kwa zaka 6 kuti adafotokoza Gary Wilson kwa FBI. Munthu yemweyo yemwe mobwerezabwereza, ma tweets abodza awo Fight The New Drug adauza otsatira ake kuti "Dr. Pembedzero liyenera kugwiriridwa ". Munthu yemweyo amene anawombera ndi kupha munthu wina wakale wa UCLA Rory C. Reid PhD. Munthu yemweyo yemwe adalemba nkhani patsamba lolaula, akunamizira kuti Gary Wilson anathamangitsidwa kuchokera ku yunivesite ya Oregon University. Ndipo pitirira izo zikupita.

Ma tweets ambiri akutsutsana ndi nkhani ya 2019 ESSM komanso Park et al., 2016:

Ayi, COPE sananene kuti akuchotsa, ngakhale kuti Pulezidenti adawazunza chifukwa cha zaka 3. COPE itangodziwa kuti malamulo onse ogwilitsila nchito pa Navy adatsatila, zonse zokamba za kubwezeretsa zatha.

Zina zabodza zokhudzana ndi "chizoloŵezi chosokoneza bongo." Mabuku opatsirana monga DSM ndi ICD sagwiritsa ntchito mawu akuti "chizoloŵezi" chofotokozera chizolowezi chirichonse: amagwiritsira ntchito "matenda." Zoona zenizeni, matenda atsopano a zachipatala a World Health Organization Buku, Mayiko Akumayiko Onse a Matenda (ICD-11), ali ndi matenda atsopano oyenera kudziwa chomwe chimatchulidwa kuti 'chiwerewere' kapena 'chiwerewere.' Icho chimatchedwa "Kugonana Kwachiwerewere"(CSBD).

Gawo loyamba lachidziwitso chachikulu likuwonetsa mabodza a Prause ozungulira ICD-11: Debunking "N'chifukwa Chiyani Timakayikirabe za Kuonera Zolaula?? ", Ndi Marty Klein, Taylor Kohut, ndi Nicole Prause (2018). Kuti mupeze mbiri yolondola yokhudza matenda atsopano a ICD-11, onani mutu waposachedwa uwu ndi Sosaiti Yopititsa patsogolo Kugonana kwa Magonana (SASH): "Kuchita Zogonana Mwakugonjetsa" kwasankhidwa ndi World Health Organization monga Mental Health Disorder.

Kugulidwa kwina kwa nkhani ya 2019ESSM:

Pembedzero ndi Ley - monga nthawi zonse, kutetezera zolaula komanso mokweza makampani opanga zolaula.

Popanda chifukwa chilichonse, a Prause amalumikizanso nkhani yonena za Kubwereza ya RefractionWatch yonena za Park et al (3-1-19):

Pemphero limapitiriza, kufalitsa nkhani ya Behavioral Sciences:

Kuzunzidwa kwachinyengo.

Kuchokera mu buluu, Pembedzero Tweets ndi MDPI: Chiwerengero chotsatira chotsitsidwa ndi Norwegian Register chinali cholakwika, chomwe chinakonzedweratu. Onani mafotokozedwe a MDPI Wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:MDPI#Reply_1-APR-2019

Pemphero limadziwa choonadi monga Zambiri mwazinthu zake zowonongeka zasintha tsamba la MDPI Wikipedia, kulowetsa mabodza ake.

Ulalo kwa ndondomeko yoyenerera kuwonetsa kuti MDPI sinatsitsidwe. Ndicho chifukwa chake Pemphero silinagwirizane ndi tsambalo mu tweet yake. Chithunzi chojambula pansipa:

Patapita masiku awiri Prause akudula ulusi wakale wa twitter anali Gary Wilson akukonza Josh Grubbs. Iye akuwombera chithunzi chomwecho cha debunked:

Izi zikuyimira zaka 4 za kuzunzidwa koopsa ndi kuzunzidwa.

April, 2019, David Ley akugwirizanitsa Nikky mu Park et al., 2016:

Ley samachitapo kanthu kuti atsimikizire zabodza zake.

April 27, 2019. Kulemba phokoso lokhalitsa chifukwa chofalitsa mabodza ambiri:

Monga tanenera panali "wasayansi" m'modzi yekha, Pembedzero. Ndipo ayi, palibe maphunziro 8 osatsimikizira.

----

July, 2019 - Amayambiranso, monga a Wikipedia mwina Pembedzero sockpuppet imalowa Zomwezo mu MDPI Wikipedia.

Ulalo kwa ndondomeko yoyenerera kusonyeza kuti MDPI siidasokonezedwe mu 2019 (chinali cholakwika chachipembedzo chimene potsiriza chinakonzedwa). Ngakhale chiwerengero cha 2020 chikhonza kukhala cholakwika, zolembera za ku Norway zimasonyeza "0" - koma "sizinayambe". Onani kuti Pulogalamu ikuyesa kupusitsa anthu polemba tchatikithunzi cha 2 za kuwerengera; imodzi yokhala ndi 2020 yokha, komanso chithunzi cha 2019 cholakwika chomwe chinakonzedweratu. Zithunzi za Prause:

Chiwonetsero choyamba chokha cha 2020

Chachiwiri kusonyeza cholakwika chosadziwika:

Pembedzero ikunena za chiwerengero cha 2019 cha MDPI, monga momwe mukuwonera pa screenshot zowerengera zaposachedwa:

Panthawi imodzimodzimodzi ndi tweet yachinyengo ya Prause a "Latsopano" Wikipedia alias imalowa chiwerengero cha 2020 mu tsamba la Wikipedia.

Franck Vazquez, Ph.D. (Chief Science Science of MDPI ayimbira Prause kuti abodza:

Zikuwoneka kuti chiwonetsero cha 2020 chisinthidwa kumayambiriro kwa chaka.

Poyankha, a Prause akuponya mwana wa 3 wazaka za XNUMX:

Adatelo omwe adanama ndikunamizila kwina zaku Norway. Ulalo wolondola watsamba lililonse patsamba lililonse https://dbh.nsd.uib.no/publiseringskanaler/VedtakNiva1. Sakani pa MDPI ndipo muwona kuti m'magazini awo onse muli "1", kuphatikizapo Sciences makhalidwe, kumene Park et al., 2016 idasindikizidwa.

--------

Ogasiti, 2019: Gulu la a Prause ndi a David Ley mpaka abodza Park et al., 2016. Papepalali adayikidwa mu ulusi anali a Ley akuwonetsa zabodza kafukufuku waboma, ponena kuti zolaula sizipezeka. Nthawi yomweyo Ley amayankha modandaula - kunena kuti olemba adalipira kuti akhale nawo Park et al., 2016 yofalitsidwa:

Gary Wilson amawongolera zabodza za Ley:

Chithunzi cha Nicole Tizonama zabodza zake , ponena kuti olemba 8 "adalipira kuti ayitchule".

Pano akupitanso, pamawu omwewo:

monga CEO wa MDPI adalongosola, mavoti enieni amapezeka ku 2020.

UPDATE (2020): monga mukuwonera, MDPI yakhala ikuwerengedwa ngati # 1 - (ndipo a Prause akhala akunama za za MDPI):

—————————————————————————————

Ndemanga za Prause ndi Ley pansi pa Ogasiti, 2016 Psychology Today zolemba za blog ndi a Mark Castleman. Cholemba cha Castleman chadzaza ndi mabodza pafupifupi Park et al., 2016 ndi Grubbs and Gola, 2016. Castleman amanama za yourbrainonporn.com, ponena kuti timayimira zolakwika zamaphunziro kapena mndandanda wazopanda pake monga nayasayer wina aliyense koma amalephera kupereka chitsanzo chimodzi chonamizira. Amagonanso m'mawu ake oyamba pazomwe YBOP adanena pazokhudza zolaula zomwe zimapangitsa ED. Chilichonse chomwe adanenapo za Park et al. ndi bodza: zomwe zili, zonena zake, cholinga chake, maphunziro amilandu, zomwe akunenapo, mumazitchula. Izi siziyenera kudabwitsa chifukwa a Castleman adasindikiza zolemba zambiri zothandizirana ndi zolaula (zonse zinali zotsutsana komanso zosagwirizana ndi sayansi). Sali wofufuza kapena wothandizira, mtolankhani yekha yemwe ali ndi zolinga. Zolemba za Castleman zidalimbikitsanso kondomachi.biz ngati gwero la chowonadi chokhudza zolaula. Palibe kukayikira kokwanira kuti aPususe ndi Ley atenga nawo gawo pakanthawi kake.

Choyamba ndemanga ya Ley:

Ndemanga zochepa pazabodza la Ley ndikutuluka kwake.

LEY - Lofalitsidwa munyuzipepala yosauka kwambiri pamikhalidwe yachilendo.

Sciences makhalidwe ndi PubMed indexed, mosiyana ndi magazini omwe avomereza zidutswa za Ley 2 (mwachitsanzo Porn Studies Journal, Malipoti Apano Ogonana Amankhwala).

LEY - Palibe m'modzi mwa olemba omwe akuwoneka kuti ali ndi maphunziro azakugonana, kapena zamankhwala ogonana ndipo angapo mwachiwonekere ndi ophthalmologist?

Mtundu wa Ley. Mwa olemba asanu ndi atatuwa panali asing'anga asanu ndi awiri omwe ali ndi ukadaulo wotsatirawu: adokotala awiri, katswiri wa zamankhwala, ndi amisala awiri, komanso dokotala wamkulu. ”Wolemba wina, Dr. Klam, ndi Director of Mental Health ku Naval Medical Center - San Diego. Ponena za ophthalmologist, Dr. Doan onse ndi MD komanso PhD (Neuroscience - Johns Hopkins), ndiye mtsogoleri wakale wa "Addictions and Resilience Research" mu department of Mental Health ku Naval Medical Center. Kuphatikiza pa mapepala omwe ali pazolaula za pa intaneti, a Doan adalemba zolemba zingapo pazolakwika zamakhalidwe / njira zokhudzana ndi matekinoloje, (adafalitsa maphunziro owunikiridwa ndi anzawo asanapange maphunziro a kusekondale).

LEY - Kuwunika kwamankhwala komwe kwatchulidwa m'ndime ya Park ndikovutitsa kwambiri. Pakafukufuku woyamba, olembawo adalongosola kuti adauza wodwalayo kuti "kugwiritsa ntchito choseweretsa choseweretsa kungachititse kuti mitsempha yake ya penile isokonekere," mawu odabwitsa komanso osagwirizana kuti afalitsidwe, osafufuzidwa ndi urological.

Ley akuganiza kuti zinali zabwino kwa madotolo kunena kuti asiye chidole chogonana ndi zolaula (ngakhale oyendetsa sitimayo anali ndi nkhawa kwambiri ndi zoseweretsa zake / zachiwerewere). Chochuluka chochokera ku lipoti la milanduyi chikuwonetsa kuti malangizo a Ley ndiwosokonekera:

Ntchito ya zaka 20 yomwe inagwira ntchito ya ku Caucasus inali ndi mavuto ovuta kugonana m'kati mwa kugonana kwa miyezi isanu ndi umodzi yapitayo. Izo zinachitika koyamba pamene iye anatumizidwa kunja kwa nyanja. Anali ndi maliseche kwa ola limodzi popanda chiwonongeko, ndipo mbolo yake inapita molakwika. Mavuto ake adasintha ndikukwaniritsa zolinga zake panthawi yomwe adatumizidwa. Kuchokera pamene adabwerera, sanathe kumangokhalira kugonana ndi mkazi wake. Anatha kukwanitsa kukonzekera koma sakanatha kusokoneza, ndipo pambuyo pa 10-15 min iye amatha kutaya, zomwe sizinali choncho iye asanakhale ndi nkhani za ED. Izi zimayambitsa mavuto pachibwenzi chake ndi chibwenzi chake.
Wodwala amalola kuvuta maliseche pafupipafupi kwa “zaka”, komanso kamodzi kapena kawiri pafupifupi tsiku lililonse kwa zaka zingapo zapitazi. Analimbikitsa kuona zolaula za pa intaneti kuti zikondweretse. Popeza adakwanitsa kugwiritsa ntchito intaneti yothamanga kwambiri, adangodalira zolaula za pa intaneti. Poyambirira, "zolaula zofewa", pomwe zomwe sizimangotanthauza kugonana kwenikweni, "zidachita chinyengo". Komabe, pang'onopang'ono adafunikira zithunzi zowoneka bwino kapena zowoneka bwino. Adatinso kutsegula makanema angapo nthawi imodzi ndikuonera magawo olimbikitsawa. Pokonzekera kutumizidwa pafupifupi chaka chapitacho, anali ndi nkhawa kuti sangachite zogonana. Chifukwa chake, adagula choseweretsa chiwerewere, chomwe amachiwona ngati "maliseche onyenga". Chipangizochi poyamba chinali cholimbikitsa kwambiri kotero kuti adakwanitsa kupitilira mphindi zochepa.
Mwachikhalidwe, iye analibe mbiriyakale ya matenda aakulu, opaleshoni, kapena matenda okhudza matenda. Iye sanali kutenga mankhwala alionse kapena kupatsirana. Anakana kugwiritsa ntchito fodya koma ankamwa zakumwa zochepa pazipata kamodzi kapena kawiri pamwezi. Iye anali asanatuluke konse kuledzera mowa. Iye adalongosola anthu ambiri ogonana nawo m'mbuyomu, koma kuyambira pachibwenzi chaka chapitacho chibwenzi chake chinali chibwenzi chake chokha. Iye anakana mbiriyakale ya matenda opatsirana pogonana. Pa kuyesedwa kwa thupi, zizindikiro zake zofunikira zonse zinali zachilendo, ndipo kuyezetsa kwake kwachibadwa kunali kosaoneka popanda zipsyinjo kapena masewera.
Kumapeto kwa ulendowo, adamufotokozera kuti kugwiritsa ntchito chidole chogonana kumatha kuyipitsa minyewa yake ndikuonera zolaula za pa intaneti zomwe zidasintha zomwe zidasowetsa chidwi chake. Analangizidwa kuti asiye kugwiritsa ntchito chidolecho ndikuonera zolaula za pa intaneti. Adatumizidwa ku urology kuti akawunikenso.
Pofika nthawi yomwe adawonedwa ndi aurologist patatha milungu ingapo, anali atachepetsa kugwiritsa ntchito zolaula pa intaneti, ngakhale kuti sanathe kusiya. Anasiya kugwiritsa ntchito chidole. Anayambanso kugonana kudzera pachibwenzi ndi bwenzi lake, ndipo ubale wawo udatha.

Umboni wina kuti Ley akuyenera kupereka upangiri wakugonana.

Ndemanga ya a Prause alias (sayimba mtima kuti adziyankhire momwe akumenyera milandu ya 2 kuyambira mwezi wa Ogasiti, 2016):

Ndemanga yopanda pake monga Park et al., 2016 sichinali kuphunzira, koma kuwunikanso. Monga tafotokozera patsamba lino, Pembedzero likunama zamavuto amilandu ndi malipotiwo. Koma mukuyembekezera chiyani kuchokera ku cyberstalker ya MDPI?

Ndemanga ina ya a Prause alias:

Monga pamwambapa, Park inali yowunikira, kotero sizinapereke zoyeserera. Komabe, idali ndi zidziwitso zazikulu poyerekeza ndi 200.

------

Meyi 24-27, 2018 - Pembedzero limapanga zidole zingapo kuti zisinthe MDPI Wikipedia tsamba (ndipo ndi loletsedwa chifukwa chonyengerera ndi kuwononga mbiri)

mu gawo loyambirira Tidafotokoza momwe a Prause adazunzira MDPI ndi magazini yawo Sciences makhalidwe. Tinalembanso mbiri yakale ya Prause yogwiritsa ntchito maina angapo abodza pa Wikipedia (omwe amaphwanya malamulo ake) kuzunza ambiri mwa anthu kapena mabungwe omwe atchulidwa patsamba lino. Mwachitsanzo:

Pembedzero laposachedwa kwambiri la Wikipedia la Prause lidachitika kuyambira Meyi 24th mpaka 27 ndipo lidatenga maina osachepera 6 abodza (otchedwa "zidole zotsekemera" mu Wikipedia jargon). Maulalo otsatirawa amakufikitsani ku zosintha zonse za maina osiyira ("zopereka za ogwiritsa ntchito"):

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Suuperon
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/NeuroSex
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/Defender1984
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/23.243.51.114
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/185.51.228.243
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/209.194.90.6

Masamba anayi oyambirira adasindikiza tsamba la MDPI Wikipedia, pomwe 3 ya 6 inasintha Nofap Wikipedia tsamba, ndi Tsamba la Addiction Sex ndi Tsamba loletsa zolaula. Masamba onse a 3 ndi obwereza a Pemphero. Ngakhale Wikipedia inadziwika kuti mamembala a mamembala ndi a munthu yemweyo chifukwa mayina onse analetsedwa kuti "a puppetry". Titha kukhala otsimikiza kuti Prause amasintha tsamba la MDPI chifukwa:

1) Mndandanda wa maimelo pakati pa MDPI ndi Nicole Prause unayamba pa May 22, ndipo MDPI ikudziwitse onse omwe akuphatikizidwa kuti akonzedwe kanyumba kameneka ndi mkonzi adzabwera. Izi zinakwiyitsa Prause yemwe adayankha ndi zida zambiri ndi zoopseza, kenako anatsutsidwa ndi zifukwa zabodza.

2) Zosintha zinayamba NeuroSex yogwiritsa ntchito amene amasinthidwa okha pamaso pa May 24th chinali kuyesayesa kopambana kuti mukhale ndi masamba ena a Wikipedia akugwirizana ndi Nicole Prause Wikipedia tsamba (February, 2018). Kuchokera ku Tsamba lachinenero cha NeuroSex:

Takulandirani ku Wikipedia. Ngakhale aliyense ali olandiridwa kuti apereke mwachangu ku encyclopedia, kuwonjezera kwanu limodzi kapena zowonjezera zokhudzana ndi tsamba Chithunzi cha Nicole yasinthidwa.

3) Zomwe zili mu Wikipedia zimazungulira chimodzi mwazinthu zomwe Prause adachita: kunyoza ndikuyesera kubweza zomwe zidalembedwa ndi a Gary Wilson ndi madokotala aku US Navy: Kodi Zithunzi Zolaula za pa Intaneti Zimayambitsa Mavuto Ogonana? Kubwereza ndi Malipoti a Clinic (Park et al., 2016)

4) Wikipedia yonse imasintha kalilole pamakalata a Prause tweets ndi maimelo ake ku MDPI (ambiri omwe Wilson awona).

5) Masewiti otchuka amazitcha ali ndi maimelo a MDPI apadera - omwe akufuna kutumiza ku tsamba la MDPI Wikipedia. Nazi zomwe NeuroSex adanena m'mawu ake. (Chidziwitso: Mu maimelo omwe amafanana ndi MDPI, Prause cc'd Chotsatira Chotsatira, mwachiwonekere kuopseza MDPI ndi kubwezera kwa anthu.):

Ndili ndi zithunzi zomwe zimatsimikizira zomwe zimanena (mwachitsanzo, imelo kuchokera kwa wofalitsa, imelo kuchokera kwa mkonzi wolembedwa, etc.). Zowonongeka ndi zolembera zina zikulingalira kulembera ndemanga zowonjezeranso, koma sindingatsimikize kuti iwo adzalumikiza. Kodi ndi bwino bwanji kupereka umboni woterewu kutsimikizira zomwe akunenazo? Monga chithunzi chojambulidwa? Wolemba kwinakwake ndi zithunzi ndi zogwirizana?

Tiyeni tiwonetse zitsanzo zingapo za zosintha za "NeuroSex" (zonama) zokhudzana ndi Gary Wilson ndi Park et al., 2016 - yotsatiridwa ndi ndemanga za Wilson:

Kusintha kwa NeuroSex #1: Gary Wilson anali {{cite web | title = yolipidwa mapaundi 9000 | url =https://www.oscr.org.uk/downloadfile.aspx?id=160223&type=5&charityid=SC044948&arid=236451}} Reward Foundation yokakamira ku US m'malo mwa zonena zotsutsana ndi zolaula.

Ndemanga ya Wilson: NeuroSex yolumikizidwa ndi chikalata chosinthidwa, ponena kuti Gary Wilson adalipira mapaundi 9,000 ndi bungwe lachifundo lachiScotish The Reward Foundation. Masiku awiri m'mbuyomu Pembedzero yabodza kwa wofalitsa nyuzipepala MDPI (ndi ena) kuti, kutengera kufalitsa nkhani zachifundo zaposachedwa (ndi dzina lokonzedwanso, monga momwe ziliri), kubweza ndalama zomwe adapereka kwa wopereka zachifundo adalipira Wilson. Pembedzero silinafufuze zowona zake, ndipo akulakwitsa (kachiwiri). Wilson sanalandire konse ndalama kuchokera ku The Reward Foundation. Gary Wilson adatumiza zonena za Prause kwa Darryl Mead, Wapampando wa The Reward Foundation. Yankho lake lili pamwambapa:

Kuchokera: Mphoto ya Maziko[imelo ndiotetezedwa]>
Kutumizidwa: Lachinayi, Meyi 24, 2018 8: 17 AM
Kwa: gary wilson
Mutu: Re: Zovuta zomwe zidakwezedwa ndi COPE wolemba Nicole Prause. Manuscript ID behavsci-133116

Wokondedwa Gary:

Ndayang'anitsitsa izi. Pembedzero adati:

On 22/05/2018 20: 48, Nicole Prause analemba kuti:
> Zikuwoneka kuti Wilson adalandira ndalama kuchokera ku The Reward Foundation. Zomwe zaphatikizidwa ndi The Reward Foundation Year Report. Pachinthu chilichonse C6 chonena zaulendo womwe umafotokoza zaulendo wa Gary Wilson wokwana mapaundi 9,027.
>
> Ndikupempha kuti kuwongolera kulikonse kuphatikizepo COI iyi yazachuma, kapena nthawi kuti ipatsidwe kuti iwonetsetse kuti izi sizinali mikangano yazachuma.
>
> Nicole Pemphero, Ph.D. Ufuluhttp://www.liberoscenter.com>

Izi zikunena za maakaunti athu apachaka a 2016-17. Mtundu wamaakaunti omwe ali ndi redaction yodziwika adasindikizidwa ndi Office of the Scottish Charity Regulator ndipo akhoza kutsitsidwa pa https://www.oscr.org.uk/search/charity-details?number=SC044948#results, kukopera. Izi zimachitika ndi OSCR popanda kuthandizidwa ndi bungwe lachifundo.

Gawo loyenera lokhala ndi redaction liziwerenga malinga ndi chithunzichi.

Yemwe amatchulidwa mu C6 ndi Darryl Mead, Wapampando wa Reward Foundation. Ndine ameneyo ndipo ndinanena kuti ndabwezeretsanso ndalama zoyendera komanso zina.

Chikalata choyambirira chimati:

Sakutchulidwa za Gary Wilson mu gawo lirilonse la ndalama za Reward Foundation chifukwa kunalibe zolipira kwa iye.

Ndi zabwino zonse,

Darryl Mead

Mwachidule, Prause ananamizira Wilson kuti alandila ndalama kuchokera ku The Reward Foundation. Kenako adalengeza zabodza lake ku MDPI, COPE, Chotsatira Chotsatira, ndi ena, pogwiritsa ntchito chikalata chomwe adalemba (monganso NeuroSex ananamizira Wikipedia poyesa kuyesa kuti mavomerezedwe ake avomerezedwe).

Kusintha, 6-7-18: Popanda chifukwa china chilichonse chomwe sindinatumize ndipo palibe amene anatchula ntchito yanga kapena kunditchula, Prause adalemba ndemanga ICD-11 yokhudza Gary Wilson (iyenera kupanga dzina lolowera kuti muwone ndemanga). M'ndemanga iyi Pemphero limabwereza zonama zomwe ananena pamwambowu ndi MDPI, RetractionWatch, ndi COPE (komanso pa Wikipedia):

M'masiku angapo otsatira Nicole Prause adalemba ndemanga zowonjezera 4 pa ICD-11 yomwe ikuukira Gary Wilson ndikupitilizabe kunena zabodza kuti ndi wolipidwa wogwira ntchito ku The Reward Foundation. Darryl Mead, Wapampando wa The Reward Foundation, pomaliza pake adayankha kuti:

Monga Tinayembekezera, Pemphero linayankha mabodza ena angapo komanso kuwukira.

Kusintha, 6-18-18: Pembedzero linapanga dzina lina la Wikipedia kuti lisinthe fayilo ya Chizindikiro cha MDPI tsamba - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Special:Contributions/185.51.228.245 - ndikuwonjezera izi:

Mu 2016, magazini ina ya MDPI, Sciences makhalidwe, adafalitsa pepala lowunikira lonena kuti zolaula zidayambitsidwa erectile kukanika. Asayansi asanu ndi mmodzi adalumikizana ndi MDPI yokhudzidwa ndi zachinyengo ndi zina m'nkhaniyi, kuyambitsa kuwunika kodziyimira pawokha ndi Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). COPE idalimbikitsa kuti nkhaniyo ichotsedwe.^[31] Mkonzi wolemba pepala, a Scott Lane, adakana kuti adakhala mkonzi. Chifukwa chake, pepalali likuwoneka kuti silinayang'anenso anzawo. Komanso, olemba awiri anali ndi mikangano yosadziwika yodziwika. Kuyanjana kwa Gary Wilson ndi The Reward Foundation sikunazindikiritse bwino kuti ndiwotsutsa, wotsutsa zolaula.
Wilson adalembanso kwambiri muma TV kuti kafukufukuyu "adachitidwa ndi gulu lankhondo laku US", ngakhale pepala loyambirira lidati silikuwonetsa malingaliro a Gulu Lankhondo Laku US. Wolemba wina, Dr. Andrew Doan, anali katswiri wa ophthalmologist yemwe amayendetsa ntchito yolimbana ndi zolaula Real Battlefield Ministries, ndikupempha zopereka kuti alankhule.^[32] Kuphatikiza apo, Committee on Publication Ethics idatsimikiza kuti milanduyi siyabwino, movomerezeka kuti iphatikizidwe. MDPI idakonza zina mwazinthuzi,^[33] koma wakana kutumiza kuwongolera kwa ena kuti akhale nawo pachibwenzi monga tafotokozera ndi Retraction Watch.^[31]

Angapo mwa mabodza pamwambapa adasinthidwa:

Panalibe asayansi a 6 - Prause yekha adalumikizana ndi MDPI.
Kuyanjana kwanga ndi The Reward Foundation kudawululidwa kwathunthu kuyambira pachiyambi. Monga tafotokozera kale, mgwirizano wanga ndi The Reward Foundation (TRF) udanenedwa momveka bwino, koyambirira Sciences makhalidwe Nkhani ndi ndondomeko yaposachedwa (a Choyambirira cha PubMed). Cholinga cha kukonzedwa kwatsopano kumene anali woti amutsutse Dr. Prause wosapitirira Ndondomeko zowononga kuti ndikulandira ndalama kuchokera ku TRF, ndikuti ndimapanga ndalama kuchokera kubuku langa (zomwe ndimapeza, ndimapita kuzithandizo)
Ndinalemba kuti pepalali limakhudza madokotala 7 aku US Navy. Asitikali apamadzi analibe vuto ndi ndemanga zanga.
Dr. Andrew Doan onse ndi MD komanso PhD (Neuroscience - Johns Hopkins), ndiye wakale wa Mutu wa "Addictions and Resilience Research" ku department of Mental Health ku Naval Medical Center. (Kuyambira pamenepo adasamutsidwa ndikulimbikitsidwa, ndipo ali ndi maudindo osiyanasiyana.) Doan adalemba mapepala angapo okhudzana ndi zizolowezi / zodwala zokhudzana ndi ukadaulo (nthawi zina ndi wolemba nawo pepala lomwe mwalemba apa). Mwachidule, iye ndi wolemba wamkulu woyenerera. Mapepala enawa amapezeka apa: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/?term=doan+klam. Opanda phindu, Real Battlefield Ministries (RBM), sanakambirane za zolaula asanalembe pepalalo. Ngakhale RBM ikadakhala ikufotokoza zolaula sizingakhale zotsutsana.
Monga tafotokozera pamwambapa, chisankho cha COPE sichinali chongopeka ndipo sichinagwiritsidwe ntchito papepala lathu ngati madokotala aku US Navy kuposa kutsatira malamulo awo a Naval Medical Center - malamulo a IRB aku San Diego. Ndondomeko ya IRB ya Naval Medical Center ku San Diego silingaganizire nkhani za odwala osachepera anayi m'nkhani imodzi yokha yofufuza kafukufuku waumunthu ndipo safuna kuti odwala alole kuti alowe m'nkhani. Ngakhale ofufuzawo sankafunika kuti avomereze, maulendo awiri, zivomerezo zamlomo ndi zolembedwa zidapezeka. Pankhani yachitatu yomwe anthu osadziwika sakanatha kusokonezedwa, palibe chilolezo cholemba chomwe chidapezeka. Zodabwitsa ndizakuti, pakukakamira kwa a Dr. Prause, atatulutsa pepalalo, zomwe olemba anzawo a Navy adalemekeza za pepalayi zidawunikiridwa bwino pakufufuza kodziyimira panokha ka Navy. Zotsatira? Ndili ndi lipoti lovomerezeka ndi loya wa Navy kutsimikizira kuti olemba awiriwa amatsatira malamulo onse a IRB.

Mu lumbiro lomwe adasuma ku Khothi Lalikulu, Gary Wilson adati Prause (1) adagwiritsa ntchito dzina labodza (Janey Wilson) kunyoza komanso kuzunza Wilson, wofalitsa wake, ndi The Reward Foundation, (2) ananama maimelo, pa Wikipedia, ndi poyankha pagulu ponena kuti Gary Wilson walandila ndalama kuchokera ku The Reward Foundation

Mabodza ndi kuzunzidwa kwa a Prause kwamupeza.

Monga tafotokozera bwino m'gawo lapitalo Gary Wilson amapereka kupita ku The Reward Foundation. Wilson sakulandila ndalama, ndipo sanalandirepo mwayi pa zoyesayesa zake zonse. YBOP ilandila zotsatsa ndipo Wilson sanavomereze zolipiritsa polankhula. Monga momwe zalembedwera m'zigawo izi, Prause wapanga nthano yopanda tanthauzo kuti Wilson akulipiridwa ndi zachifundo zomwe amapereka zomwe buku lake limapereka:

M'malo mwake, izi sizowona. Zigawo ziwirizi zanenedwa muumboni wolumbira wa Gary Wilson, womwe ndi gawo limodzi lamilandu yoyipitsa ya Dr. Hilton yomwe idaperekedwa kwa a Dr. Prause.

Mu lumbiro lomwe adasumira ku Khothi Lalikulu, Gary Wilson adati (mwachilango chabodza) kuti (1) Nicole Prause adagwiritsa ntchito dzina labodza (Janey Wilson) kunyoza ndi kuzunza Wilson, wofalitsa wake, ndi The Reward Foundation, (2) kuti Pembedzero linanama maimelo, pa Wikipedia komanso pagulu pomwe ananena kuti Gary Wilson walandila ndalama kuchokera ku The Reward Foundation.

Onani zovomerezeka zonse: Julayi, 2019: Chovomerezeka cha Gary Wilson: Mlandu wakuwononga a Donald Hilton wotsutsana ndi Nicole R Prause & Liberos LLC. Zolemba zofunikira kuchokera ku lumbiro la Gary Wilson, lomwe ndi gawo la Mlandu woyipitsa a Dr. Hilton adasumira Dr. Prause.

Mwachidule, Nicole Prause adanyoza Wilson ndi Dr. Hilton. Kuphatikiza pa Wilson, Ozunzidwa ena a 8 apereka chikalata cholumbira kukhothi kufotokoza zonyoza, kuzunza, komanso kupereka malipoti oyipa kumabungwe olamulira ndi mabungwe (chabe nsonga ya Phulusa la madzi oundana).

**Pembedzero limanama za Gary Wilson m'maimelo opita ku MDPI, David Ley, Neuro Skeptic, Adam Marcus wa Kuwongolera Penyani, ndi COPE (Meyi, 2018)**

M'mwezi wa Meyi, imelo ya 2018 imasinthana ndi MDPI & COPE, a Prause adakopera ma blogger omwe ali ndi mwayi wowononga mbiri ya MDPI munyuzipepala, ngati angasankhe. Ley blogs on Psychology Today ndipo nthawi zambiri wakhala ngati Mlomo wa Pemphero. Neuro Skeptic ili ndi blog yotchuka yomwe imasiyanitsa zovomerezeka (ndi zina zokayikitsa). Adam Marcus akulemba Yang'anani Penyani. Pembedzero lidakopanso Iratxe Puebla, yemwe amagwira ntchito ku COPE, bungwe lomwe limayang'anira machitidwe azofalitsa. Kale, Adam Marcus wa Anabweza Watch watenga nyambo popanda kufufuza kokwanira.

M'magazini ake onyoza, ma tweets, ndi zolemba za Quora a Prause anena mozindikira komanso zabodza kuti ine (Gary Wilson) ndimati ndine "pulofesa wa" biology "" dokotala "kapena" neuroscientist. " Ndinali Adjunct Instructor ku Southern Oregon University ndipo ndimaphunzitsa matupi aumunthu, matupi athu ndi kudwala m'malo ena. Ngakhale atolankhani osasamala komanso masamba awebusayiti andipatsa mayina angapo olakwika pazaka zambiri (kuphatikiza tsamba lomwe latha tsopano patsamba lawebusayiti lomwe limalankhula zambiri za TEDx ndikufotokozera oyankhula mosasamala osawalumikiza) ndakhala ndikunena kuti ndimaphunzitsa anatomy & zokhudza thupi. Sindinanenepo kuti ndinali ndi PhD kapena ndinali pulofesa. Pembedzero linanama chimodzimodzi kwa omwe amalandira maimelo:

Limbikitsani EMAIL # 1 (5-1-2018)

Pa Lachiwiri, Meyi 1, 2018 nthawi ya 10:11 PM, Nicole Prause >
Kuphatikiza apo, a Wilson tsopano akugwiritsa ntchito bukuli kuti adziwe kuti ndi adotolo pa intaneti kwa odwala omwe sadziwa (omangirizidwa).
NP
Nicole Pemphero, Ph.D. Liberos LLC: www.liberoscenter.com

Pansipa pali chithunzi chomwe Pulojekiti imagwiritsa ntchito "kutsimikizira" kuti ndanena zabodza zanga (komanso, tsamba ili la Gary Wilson kulibenso). Chidziwitso: Mpaka pomwe Prause adatulutsa "umboni" wake, ndinali ndisanawonepo tsambali ndipo sindinalankhulanepo ndi omwe anali nawo, sindinayikenso tsambalo ndipo sindinalichotsepo. Chifukwa chake sindinaperekepo mbiri, kapena zonena za "uprofesa."

Ndinaphunzitsa ku Southern Oregon University maulendo awiri. Ndinaphunzitsanso anatomy, physiology ndi pathology m'masukulu ena angapo kwazaka makumi awiri, ndipo ndidatsimikizika kuti ndiziphunzitsa izi ndi dipatimenti yophunzitsa ku Oregon ndi California. Sindikufuna kuchita nawo zokambirana ndipo sindidalandire chindapusa polankhula. Kuphatikiza apo, YBOP ilandila zotsatsa, ndipo zimachokera buku langa pitani ku chikalata chothandizira.

On tsamba la "pafupifupi" webusaiti ya Keynotes.org inati sikuti ndi bungwe ndipo aliyense angakhoze kutumiza kanema ndi wokamba nkhani: Keynotes.org si bungwe, koma, tsamba lofalitsa ... Keynotes.org imathandizidwa ndi anthu ambiri ndikulimbikitsidwa ndi TrendHunter.com, tsamba lalikulu kwambiri padziko lonse lapansi. Apanso, sindinatumizepo chilichonse patsamba lino, ndipo sindikudziwa kuti ndi ndani amene watsitsa tsambali (kapena analamula kuti lichotsedwe).

Chifukwa chake, ndizotheka kuti a Prause adatsitsa tsambali, ndimayankhulidwe anga a TEDx komanso mbiri yolakwika, kuti apange "umboni" wofuna kunamizira - kenako ndikuwuchotsa. Pambuyo pake Zaka 5 za kuzunzidwa kosalekeza ndi cyber-stalking, zolemba zowonongeka, zotsutsana, mazana a Tweetsndipo mazita ambirimbiri ndi mazana a ndemanga, palibe chomwe chikanatidabwitsa.

Kuwombera pamwambapa kunali gawo la nkhani yokulirapo ya Prause komwe amanamizira kuti andithamangitsa ku Southern Oregon University: Marichi, 2018 - Mlandu Wonena Kuti Gary Wilson Wathamangitsidwa. Munkhani yake, yomwe idalembedwa patsamba latsamba latsamba ndi Quora, Prause adasindikiza zolemba zanga za ntchito ku Southern Oregon University, ndikunamizira kuti ndidathamangitsidwa ndipo sindinaphunzitsepo ku SOU. Monga zonena zake zokhudzana ndi The Reward Foundation, a Prause ananamizira za zomwe zili m'malembawo. Mwa njira, David Ley adalembanso nkhani ya Prause maulendo angapo, akunena kuti andichotsa ku SOU (zithunzi patsamba).

Pomaliza pake, Pembedzero lidaletsedweratu ku Quora chifukwa chondizunza ndipo tsamba lowonera zolaula lidachotsa nkhani yabodza ya a Prause.

------

Mu imelo ku MDPI, COPE, Ley, Neuroskeptic, Adam Marcus wa Anabweza Watch ndi ena Prause amanamizira kuti ndalandira ndalama kuchokera ku The Reward Foundation.

Limbikitsani EMAIL # 2 (5-22-2018)

Ufuluhttp://www.liberoscenter.com> Pa 22/05/2018 20: 48, Nicole Prause adalemba:
Zikuwoneka kuti Wilson adalandira ndalama kuchokera ku The Reward Foundation. Zomwe zaphatikizidwa ndi The Reward Foundation Year Report. Pachinthu chilichonse C6 chonena zaulendo womwe umafotokoza zaulendo wa Gary Wilson wokwana mapaundi 9,027.
Ndikupempha kuti kuwongolera kulikonse kuphatikizepo COI iyi yazachuma, kapena nthawi kuti ipatsidwe kuti iwonetse bwino kuti sikunali kutsutsana kwachuma.
Nicole Pemphero, Ph.D. Ufulu

Pembedzero silinafufuze zowona zake, ndipo walakwitsa. Sindinalandirepo ndalama kuchokera ku The Reward Foundation. Ndatumiza zonena za Prause kwa Darryl Mead, Wapampando wa The Reward Foundation, yemwe adatsutsa zonena za Prause: Onani Pamwambapa Zolemba.

------

Limbikitsani EMAIL # 3 (5-22-2018)

Mu maimelo ake ambiri kwa MDPI (ndi ena), Prause adatchulapo "zodzudzula 77" ndikunamizira kuti sanayankhidwe. Izi zinali zaposachedwa kwambiri:

Lachiwiri, Meyi 22, 2018 nthawi ya 9:36 AM, Nicole Prause>
Ndidapereka lingaliro la 77 isanafalitsidwe yomwe, malinga ndi zomwe zidalembedwazo zidalemba MDPI, idanyalanyazidwa.
Nicole Pemphero, Ph.D. Liberos LLC: www.liberoscenter.com

Izi zikutanthauza kuti Prause anali mmodzi mwa olemba awiri a Yale Journal ya Biology ndi Medicine kusonyeza - motero "Janey Wilson." Monga tafotokozera, ambiri mwa mavuto 77 omwe amatchedwa kuti zovuta adakopera mosasamala ndikuzilemba kuchokera pakuwunika kwa Prause kwa YJBM chiwonetsero; 25 ya iwo inalibe kanthu kochita ndi Sciences makhalidwe kusonyeza. Mwanjira ina, owerengera yekhayo kuti adzudzule pepalalo adadula ndikulemba zodzudzula zingapo pakuwunikanso komwe china magazini (YJBM), zomwe zinalibe phindu lililonse pamapepala omwe analembedwera Sciences makhalidwe. Izi ndizosafunikira kwambiri.

Ngakhalenso kupatula zovutazo, zochepa za mavuto a 77 zingaoneke ngati zovomerezeka. Komabe, timagwiritsira ntchito ndemanga zonse zomwe zimagwiritsidwa ntchito posungirako zidziwitso zothandiza, ndipo timalemba mwachidule ndemanga zonse Sciences makhalidwe ndi akonzi ake. Pafupifupi ndemanga zonse zotsala za 50 zidali zolakwika zasayansi, zopanda maziko, kapena zinali zonama. Ena anali obwerezabwereza. Olembawo adapatsa MDPI mfundo ndi yankho poyankha vuto lililonse lomwe limatchedwa.

Zochita za "Janey Wilson" (Prause)

Onani makope a maimelo enieni pansipa chidule ichi.

Posakhalitsa buku langa lofalitsidwa mu 2015, Prause adalemba kwa wofalitsa wanga kuti adziwe zambiri, pogwiritsa ntchito dzina ("Janey Wilson"). Poganiza kuti "Janey" inali yovomerezeka, a Dan Hind a Commonwealth Publishing adamulangiza kuti gawo langa lazopanga mabuku lidapita ku The Reward Foundation, bungwe lachifundo laku Scottish (Zolemba za PDF za Nicole Prause zomwe amamuzunza ndikuwanyoza).

"Janey Wilson" nthawi yomweyo adadziwitsa bungwe lachifundo kuti Wilson "akudzinamizira poyera kuti ali mgulu la The Reward Foundation," ndikuti ali ndi umboni. Njira yokhayo yomwe angakhalire ndi "umboni" wosagwirizana ndi anthuwa ndikadakhala kuti adawona pepala lophunzirira lomwe ndidalemba. Ndikuphwanya malamulo amakhalidwe abwino pofalitsa kapena kugwiritsa ntchito molakwika zomwe mwaphunzira powunikiranso.

Zomwe "Janey" adachita sizinapangitse mkwiyo ku The Reward Foundation (popeza ndimagwirizana ndi Foundation, ndikugwira ntchito ngati "Honorary Science Officer"). Mopanda mantha, "Janey" kenaka adalengeza The Reward Foundation kwa a Scottish Charity Regulator pazolingalira zachuma komanso zina zomwe akuti adachita.

Chithandizocho chinali chatsopano kwambiri kotero kuti sankafunika kujambulitsa ndalama, choncho sizinali zotheka kuti Reward Foundation ipange zolakwa zonena za "Janey".

Pafupifupi nthawi yomwe "Janey" (1) adalemba The Reward Foundation kuti anene zonena zanga zabodza, ndipo (2) adanenanso zachifundo ku Scottish Charity Regulator, "Janey" adalembanso bungwe la Edinburgh pomwe Zachifundo zimakhala ndi zonama zonena za ine ndi The Reward Foundation (onani pansipa). Gulu la Edinburgh limatchedwa "Malo Okhazikika." Ndi bungwe la ambulera lomwe limakhala ndi mabizinesi ang'onoang'ono osiyanasiyana. "Janey" mwachidziwikire adalemba izi pa redddit / zolaula zolaula forum - Gary Wilson akupindula kuchokera ku YBOP:

Zomwe zili pamwambazi sizosadabwitsa chifukwa Pembedzero wagwiritsa ntchito ma dolozi ambiri kuti atumize, makamaka pama forum obwezeretsa zolaula, za Wilson. Mwa zitsanzo za ndemanga mazana za ma avatar omwe akuwoneka ngati a Prause amatha kupezeka pamaulalo omwe ali pansipa. Ndipo, ali chabe chopereka chosakwanira:

Wina reddit / zolaula zomwe zidawonekera nthawi yomweyo (Pembedzero lidachotsa dzina la abambo ake, monga momwe amachitira atatumiza):

Janey / Prause adanenanso zopanda tanthauzo kuti "ndikulipira" The Reward Foundation pamsonkhano wokambirana wa TEDx womwe udachitika zaka zapitazo, ku 2012. Zinakonzedwa mu 2011, zaka zambiri zachifundo zisanakhazikitsidwe kapena kulinganizidwa. Zachidziwikire, kunalibe chinyengo choterechi chomwe chimafunikira. Ndinali ndi ufulu wopereka ndalama zanga zamabuku kwa aliyense nthawi iliyonse, kapena kuziyika m'thumba mwanga. Ndasankha Reward Foundation chifukwa ndimalemekeza cholinga chake chophunzitsira.

Palibe bungwe (la Scottish Charity Regulator kapena la Melting Pot) lomwe silinayankhe "Janey," popeza sanapereke umboni uliwonse, ndipo sanadzizindikiritse, akumanena kuti ali ndi "whistleblower" (ngakhale anali wogwira ntchito kapena , ndipo sanali pachiwopsezo). Chikondicho chikadapanda ubale wolimba, wolemekezedwa ndi Melting Pot, ndikadakhala kuti zidafunsidwa kale kuti akapereke ndalama ku Scottish Charity Regulator, zonena za "Janey" zabodza zitha kuwononga mbiri ya bungweli ndikuyambitsa kuwononga nthawi, kuwunika mtengo, ndi zina zambiri.

Pambuyo pa 2016, Pulezidenti adadzitcha "Janey Wilson" pamene adafuna kuti (Dan Hind wa Commonwealth Publishing) (mobwerezabwereza ndi osapindula) tsimikizani kulumikizana kwanga ndi chikondi cha ku Scotland chotchedwa The Reward Foundation Prause. Kulemba ma MDPI (wofalitsa wapamwamba wa pepala lomwe tafotokozedwa kale) ndi bungwe lolemba mabuku (COPE), Prause anauza Hind a Commonwealth kuti iye adamulembera kale izi.

Komabe, kalata yokhayo yomwe Hind anali nayo ndi aliyense wokhudza Wilson ndi The Reward Foundation inali ndi "Janey," ndipo wanena izi m'munsimu. Chifukwa chake, Pemphero tsopano ladziwika yekha monga "Janey" wakale. Pamene Hind sanayankhe pazomwe Pemphero limanena mobwerezabwereza, adafunsa zidziwitso kudzera pa webusayiti ya Commonwealth - limodzi, mwachizolowezi, pomunamizira komanso kumuopseza:

Mungafune kulimbikitsa omwe ali ndi tsambalo lomwe mudapanga kuti mufotokozere kuti wolemba wake adagwidwa akuti "adapereka" kuchokera kubuku lomwe lidalowa mthumba mwake. A Hind alephera kuyankha atafunsidwa ndi Committee on Publication Ethics. Ndikuganiza kuti simungafune kuti dzina lanu litengeke ndi chinyengo chotere mwanjira iliyonse.

Pembedzero likuwoneka kuti likukhulupirira kuti gawo langa lopeza ndalama limapita ku bungwe lachifundo laku Scottish, lomwe ndidalemba kuti ndikulumikizana nawo pamapepala awiri ophunzirira omwe adasindikizidwa mu 2016, zikutanthauza kuti mwanjira inayake ndikungotenga ndalamazo (kuchokera m'buku langa lomwe) - motero amakhala ndi mkangano wotsutsana, womwe ndi chifukwa chake, m'maganizo mwake, kuti pepala langa lichotsedwe. Kodi aliyense Kodi izi zimapangitsa kuti mukhale ndi lingaliro lililonse?

Ndipotu, sindiri ku Bungwe lachikondi, ndipo ndithudi sindinanene za bukuli ndikulipindula chifukwa cha zopereka zanga zosasinthika. Zomwe zandichitikira, chiyanjano changa tsopano ndi chachinsinsi, monga momwe tatchulidwira m'mapepala onse omwe ndinawasindikiza ku 2016. Mwachidule, palibe chobisika kapena chosayenera, ndipo palibe kutsutsana kwina kulikonse - ngakhale kuti Prause akunena mwachidwi komanso poyera.

Pasanathe masiku angapo Nicole Prause (monga iyemwini) amatumizira imelo MDPI kuti iwauze kuti abwerere Park et al., 2016, Nkhani za Twitter "zolaula" zinaukira Mary Sharpe wa The Reward Foundation. Pa tweet @pornhelps onse koma amavomereza kuti ndi Pembedzero:

Pembedzero, wa Kinsey grad komanso wophunzira wakale, amadzitcha katswiri wazamaubongo, ndipo akuwoneka kuti wayamba koleji zaka 15 zapitazo. Pasanapite nthawi kuchokera pamene tweet yovumbulutsa "zolaula" zidachotsa akaunti yake ya Twitter komanso tsamba lawebusayiti (pornhelps.com) - monga zinawonekeranso kwa ena kuti Prause nthawi zambiri amatumizira mawu ndi nkhaniyi ndikuthandizira webusaitiyi.

Magawo otsatirawa a Pembedzero tsamba perekani zitsanzo za Pembedzero ndi "zolaula" panthawi imodzimodzi ndikuukira ndi kuwononga zina mwazokonda za Prause (amuna omwe amayendetsa zolaula, ofufuza zolaula, TIME mkonzi Belinda Luscombe, yemwe adalemba nkhani yolembedwa Pembedzero silidavomereze):

pomwe: Mu Meyi, Pembedzero la 2018 linanamizira wofalitsa nyuzipepala MDPI (ndi ena) kuti, kutengera kufalitsa kwa anthu posachedwapa (ndi dzina lokonzedwanso, monga muyezo), zolipiritsa zomwe analipira wogwira ntchito zandalama adandilipira. Ndatumiza zonena za Prause kwa Darryl Mead, Wapampando wa The Reward Foundation, yemwe adatsutsa zonena za Prause: Onani Pamwambapa Zolemba.

----

Maimelo ena ochepa omwe atchulidwa munkhani ya "Janey":

2015

[Kusinthana kwa "Janey" ndi wofalitsa wanga]

Kuchokera: Daniel Hind
Tsiku: Thu, Mar 26, 2015 nthawi ya 10:15 AM
Mutu: RE: Kuda nkhawa ndikupanga phindu ngati kusachita phindu ku Melting Pot

Anandilankhula ndi munthu wotchedwa Janey Wilson Loweruka. Kusinthana kwathunthu pakati pathu kudulidwa ndikudulidwa pansipa. Monga mukuwonera ndinamuuza kuti ndalama zomwe wolemba amalemba zimaperekedwa ku Reward Foundation.
Ndiyenera kuti ndakufunsani, ndikuganiza. Pepani ngati ndayambitsa zovuta zosafunikira kwa aliyense.
Dan

-----------

Tsiku: Thu, 26 Mar 2015 16:59:12 +0000
Mutu: Fwd: Zolemba za Wilson
Ku: xxxx
ku :xxx

———- Kutumiza uthenga ———-
kuchokera ku: Dan Hind
Tsiku: Lachiwiri, Mar 24, 2015 pa 9:33 AM
Mutu: Re: Zolemba za Wilson
Kwa: Janey Wilson[imelo ndiotetezedwa]>
Charity Commission ndi kaundula wa mabungwe othandiza anthu ku England ndi Wales. Reward Foundation imalembetsedwa ku Scotland.

Nayi mndandanda wake pa Scottish Charity Register -
https://www.oscr.org.uk//charities/search-scottish-charity-register/charity-details?charitynumber=sc044948
Ku UK maudindo ambiri aperekedwa ku Nyumba Yamalamulo yaku Scottish, kuphatikiza kulembetsa mabungwe othandizira, zikuwoneka.
Ndikukhulupirira izi zithetsa chisokonezo chilichonse,
Ine wanu mowona mtima,
Dan Hind

â € "

Lachiwiri, Mar 24, 2015 nthawi ya 7:15 AM, Janey Wilson[imelo ndiotetezedwa]> analemba:

Wokondedwa Dan Hind,
Zikomo chifukwa cha zambiri. Sindingayang'ane, koma ndine wokondwa kuti ndidatero. Bungweli silinalembetsedwe ku UK:
http://apps.charitycommission.gov.uk/Showcharity/RegisterOfCharities/registerhomepage.aspx
Uwu ndi kaundula waboma, chifukwa chake sindikudziwa komwe ungakhale. Mungafune kuchenjeza wolemba wanu kuti mwina akutenga nawo mbali pachinyengo. Sindingagule kutengera izi, ndipo sindikuganiza kuti wina aliyense ayenera.
J

---

Pa Mon, Marichi 23, 2015 nthawi ya 4:42 AM, Dan Hind adalemba:

Wokondedwa Ms Wilson,
Chuma cha wolemba chimathandizira Reward Foundation, bungwe lolembera ku UK.
http://www.rewardfoundation.org/
Ine wanu mowona mtima,
Dan Hind

Pa Sat, Mar 21, 2015 nthawi ya 6:17 AM, Janey Wilson[imelo ndiotetezedwa]> analemba kuti:

Hi,
Ndinawona kuti zomwe zatuluka m'bukuli zonse zikufufuza. Ndi bungwe liti lomwe likupindula? Ndikufuna kuwona ngati ndingathe kulemba pamisonkho yanga kuti ichotsedwe.

---

[Kusinthana kwa "Janey" ndi The Melting Pot]

Pa 25 Marichi 2015 nthawi ya 12:08 Mohammad Abushaaban[imelo ndiotetezedwa]> analemba kuti:
Mary - ndikuyembekeza kuti mukukhala olimba.
Ndalandira izi modabwitsa kuchokera ku imelo yabuluu kuchokera kwa a Janey Wilson…
Mukumudziwa munthu ameneyu?
Muwerenge ndipo mundidziwitse malingaliro anu.
zikomo
Lolemba

———- Kutumiza uthenga ———-
Kuchokera: Janey Wilson[imelo ndiotetezedwa]>
Tsiku: 25 Marichi 2015 nthawi 04:09
Mutu: Zokhudzidwa ndi kupeza phindu ngati zopanda phindu ku Melting Pot
kuti: [imelo ndiotetezedwa]
Wokondedwa Mohammad Abushaaban,
Ndikulemba chifukwa chodandaula ndi The Reward Foundation yomwe ili ku Melting Pot, yomwe ikuwoneka ngati yopanda phindu. Mu 2012, Mary Sharpe anali ndi udindo wosankha olankhula TEDX ku Glasgow. Adapanga chisankho chodabwitsa kwambiri chokhala ndi wothandizira kutikita minofu yemwe alibe maziko a neuroscience, Gary Wilson, amvekere za neuroscience ya "zolaula". Nkhaniyi inali yosauka kwambiri ndipo pakadali pano ikufufuzidwa za sayansi yake yabodza ndi TEDX. Tsopano, a Wilson akuwoneka kuti akulipira a Mary Sharpe mwayiwu.
Makamaka, akugulitsa buku ndipo zonse zomwe apeza m'bukuli akuti akupita ku The Reward Foundation kuti "akafufuze":
www.tolandalama.com
Komabe, Mary Sharpe si wofufuza, alibe chidziwitso cha sayansi, ndipo mabungwewa sapereka njira yoti asayansi weniweni agwiritse ntchito ndalamazi. Ndalamazo zikuwoneka kuti zikupita thumba lake, mwina posinthana ndi zomwe TEDX amamukonda kale. Othandizanso asankha kuti asapereke poyera maulalo azachuma chawo.
Ndaperekanso dandaulo ili ku Scottish Charity Register. Ndikukupemphani kuti muganizire zofufuza momwe Akazi a Sharpe angagwiritsire ntchito sayansi yabodza kutengera anthu omwe akukhudzidwa. Izi sizikuwoneka ngati zikugwirizana ndi zolinga zilizonse zomwe zili patsamba la Melting Pot.
J

Mohammad Abushaaban, Wogwirizira Bizinesi
Zida zamphamvu zopanga kusintha kwa chikhalidwe
Msewu wa 5 Rose, Edinburgh, EH2 2PR
Nambala: +44 (0) 131 243 2626/3
www.TheMeltingPotEdinburgh.org
Kampani Nambala: SC291663

Kuchokera: Janey Wilson[imelo ndiotetezedwa]>
Tsiku: 22 April 2015 nthawi ya 17:21
Mutu: Re: Kuda nkhawa ndikupanga phindu ngati kusachita phindu ku Melting Pot
Kwa: Mohammad Abushaaban[imelo ndiotetezedwa]>
Tsopano ndili ndi zolembedwa kuti Gary Wilson yemweyo akuti ndi membala wa Reward Foundation. Ngakhale sanalembedwe patsamba latsopano la webusayiti (http://www.rewardfoundation.org/who-we-are.html), Izi zikuyimira kulakwa kopitilira muyeso. Amati "adapereka" ndalama zomwe adapeza m'buku lake kuti zifufuze, zomwe zikupita ku bungwe lachifundo lomwe lilibe mapulani ofufuzira ndipo ndi m'modzi mwa iwo. Mary Sharpe mwina sangadziwe kuti akunena izi, sindikutsimikiza, koma tsopano wazinena pagulu.

---

Monga tafotokozera pamwambapa, pepala loyambirira komanso losiyana kwambiri lomwe ndidalemba ndi madokotala a 7 US Navy, Paki, et al., idatumizidwa koyamba mu Marichi, 2015 kwa Yale Journal ya Biology ndi Medicine monga gawo la "Kuledzera" kwake. Pepala ili linali malo okha omwe mgwirizano wanga ndi Reward Foundation ungapezeke panthawi yosinthana kwa "Janey", popeza kunalibe kwina kulikonse. Chifukwa chake "Janey" amayenera kuti adatumizidwe YJBM kuti muwone.

---

2016

Pembedzero lolumikizana ndi wofalitsa wanga, a Dan Hind, ndikudzitcha kuti "Janey Wilson"

Kuchokera: Nikky [imelo ndiotetezedwa]
Kutumizidwa: 03 Novembala 2016 21:27
kuti: Dan Hind;
Cc: Dr. Franck Vazquez | CEO | MDPI; Iratxe Puebla; [imelo ndiotetezedwa]; Martyn Rittman; Dr. Shu-Kun Lin; Jim Pfaus
phunziro; Re: Buku wopindulira ndalama
Bambo Hind,
Tili ndi imelo yapita yochokera kwa inu yotsimikizira kuti Gary Wilson watumiza zonse zomwe adapeza m'buku lake ku bungwe lomwe akugwiradi ntchito, The Reward Foundation. Mutha kusankha kuti musatsimikizire izi ku Committee on Publication Ethics, koma imelo yapitayi imatha kuperekedwanso kwa iwo.
Wolemba wanu adalephera kufotokoza kusamvana kwake kwakusangalatsidwa m'mabuku ambiri tsopano kuti adzipindulire yekha ponena kuti "apereke" ndalamazo kwa anthu (komanso kwa inu). Izi ndizodziwika pagulu kuti mwina mutha kulembedwa kuti muthandizire kuwulula kapena kupindula, monga mungakondere.
NP
Nicole Prause, Ph.D.
Kafukufuku: www.span-lab.com
Liberos LLC: www.liberoscenter.com
323.919.0783

--------

Imelo kwa wopanga tsamba la Dan Hind:

Kuchokera: Jamie Kendall[imelo ndiotetezedwa]>
Kutumizidwa: 04 Novembala 2016 11:32
kuti: Daniel Hind
phunziro; Fwd: Lembani wopindulira ndalama
Moni Dan,
Ndinawauza kuti ndikutumizirani chilichonse chomwe chingakupatseni.
Jamie
Jamie Kendall MA (RCA)
www.kukhalancom.fi
Yambitsani uthenga:
Kuchokera: Nikky[imelo ndiotetezedwa]>
Mutu: Fwd: Bukhu lopindula ndi ndalama
Tsiku: 3 Novembala 2016 nthawi ya 21:31:24 GMT
kuti: [imelo ndiotetezedwa]
Wokondedwa Bambo Kendall,
Mungafune kulimbikitsa eni ake atsamba omwe mudapanga kuti afotokozere kuti wolemba wawo adagwidwa akuti "adapereka" kuchokera m'buku lomwe lidalowamo mthumba mwake. A Hind alephera kuyankha atafunsidwa ndi Committee on Publication Ethics. Ndikuganiza kuti simungafune kuti dzina lanu litengeke ndi chinyengo chotere mwanjira iliyonse.
NP
Nicole Prause, Ph.D.
Kafukufuku: www.span-lab.com
Liberos LLC: www.liberoscenter.com
323.919.0783

Chidule cha nkhaniyi:

Marichi, 2015 mtundu wakale wa Park et al. idaperekedwa kwa Yale Journal ya Biology ndi Medicine. Kugonjera kwa YJBM anali malo okhawo omwe ndimayanjana nawo ndi bungwe lachifundo la The Reward Foundation (TRF), amapezeka, popeza kunalibe kwina kulikonse.
Pakati pa Marichi 21^stndi Epulo 22^nd a 2015, "Janey Wilson" adatumiza maimelo angapo kwa a Dan Hind a Commonwealth Publishing, Mohammad Abushaaban a Malo Osungunuka Edinburgh (yomwe ili ndi The Reward Foundation), ndi Woyang'anira Wachifundo ku Scottish. Zonse zili ndi zonena zosavomerezeka zakulakwitsa. Zikuwoneka kuti zikuwoneka kuti ndizosiyana ndi kalembedwe kamene "Janey" anali kwenikweni Nicole Prause - yemwe pambuyo pake adatsimikiziridwa.
The YJBM adadziwitsidwa zamakhalidwe oyipitsa (omwe m'modzi mwa owunikira adawayankha "Janey Wilson"). Atanenedwa kuti a Dr. Prause atha kukhala kuti ndiwo amachititsa maimelo odabwitsa komanso kukanidwa koyamba kwa pepalalo, pepalalo lidalandiridwa mwachangu… kenako osasindikizidwa pambuyo pake, potengera kuti akuti anali atachedwa kuti akwaniritse nthawi yomaliza YJBM's "Zovuta".
Mtundu watsopanowo wa pepalalo udatumizidwa ku magaziniyo Sciences makhalidwe. Anthu anayi adawunikiranso pepalalo ndi 3 kuvomereza ndi Pembedzero (monga tidazindikira pambuyo pake) ndikuzikana ndi mndandanda wake wa "zovuta za 77".
Ambiri mwa mavuto ake 77 omwe adatchedwa kuti malembo adakopedwa mosasamala ndikuzilemba kuchokera pakuwunika kwa Prause kwa YJBM kugonjera, popeza 25 mwa iwo sanachite kanthu ndi Sciences makhalidwe pepala.
Ndi mavuto ochepa mwa mavuto 77 omwe angawoneke kuti ndi ovomerezeka. Olembawo adapatsa MDPI mfundo ndi yankho poyankha vuto lililonse lomwe limatchedwa.
Park et al. idasinthidwa ndikuwunikanso owunikanso ena awiri.
Posakhalitsa Park et al., 2016 idasindikizidwa, a Prause adayamba kampeni yawo kuti atulutsenso pepalalo, kutumiza mauthenga ambiri ku MDPI, COPE, Navy, mabungwe azachipatala a adotolo, komanso wofalitsa wanga (ndipo mwina PubMed, FTC ndi ndani akudziwa kwina kulikonse) .
MDPI idapatsa Prause mwayi wofalitsa ndemanga zawo Park et al, mu Sciences makhalidwe. Pembedzero lakana. Ngati pepalalo silinali lokwanira, ikadakhala nkhani yosavuta kuyipusitsa ndi ndemanga yovomerezeka.
Chakumapeto kwa 2016, Prause adadzitcha "Janey Wilson" pomwe adafunsa (mobwerezabwereza komanso osachita bwino) kuti wofalitsa wanga tsimikizani Kulumikizana kwanga ndi bungwe lachifundo laku Scottish lotchedwa The Reward Foundation to Prause polemba. Potengera onse MDPI (wofalitsa wamkulu pamapepala omwe atchulidwa pamwambapa) ndi bungwe loyang'anira zamakhalidwe, a Prause adauza a Dan Hind a Commonwealth kuti anali atamulembera kale izi. Komabe adangolemberana za kulumikizana ndi "Janey."
Ngakhale anali wankhanza pomuzunza, ndipo nthawi zambiri amanama za ine komanso zomwe zili papepalalo, Prause pomaliza pake adangokhala ndi nkhani ziwiri zokha zomwe COPE angaganizire (2) Udindo wa Gary Wilson wopandaudindo ndi The Reward Foundation, (1) Chivomerezo cha anthu atatu omwe awonetsedwa zochitikazo.
Ngakhale ndimamvera chisoni kwambiri COPE, ndipo ndikuwona kuti kumenyedwa kwa Komiti yawo kuyenera kuti kudapirira, m'malingaliro mwanga, palibe chifukwa chomveka chobwezeretsera kapena kudzudzula (ngakhale kuwongolera koteroko sikulakwa kwenikweni), monga
1. Kulumikizana kwanga kopanda malipiro ndi The Reward Foundation sikunali kutsutsana kwenikweni ndipo mgwirizano wanga unali utawululidwa kale mu pepala loyambirira, ndipo
2. Navy amatsatira malangizo ake ovomerezeka (omwe safuna kwenikweni aliyense zivomerezo zolembedwa zamakalata ndi odwala ochepera 4). Ngakhale zili choncho, mochuluka mwa kusamala ndi madotolo, chilolezo cholemba chokwanira chidaperekedwa kwa anthu awiri. Kachitatu, sizokwanira kudziwa chilolezo zomwe zidaperekedwa papepalalo. Kafukufuku waku US Navy adatsimikizira kuti madotolo amatsatira malamulo onse a IRB.

Ngakhale ena atha kutsutsana nane, zikuwonekeratu kuti palibe mfundo izi zomwe zimakhudza "chinyengo" kapena machitidwe olakwika, monga a Prause akupitilizirabe.

Zikuyenda bwanji apa?

Kwa zaka onse a Prause ndi Ley akhala akugwirizana kuti achititse manyazi, kuvutitsa komanso kubaya anthu pa intaneti omwe akhala akuchenjeza za zovuta za porn kapena kufalitsa kafukufuku wofotokoza zovuta za porn. Posachedwa, a Prause ndi Ley adayendetsa ntchito zawo zopanda malingaliro komanso nthawi zambiri zosagwirizana ndi malamulo othandizira zolaula. Mwachitsanzo, 0n Januwale 29, 2019, Prause adapereka fayilo a ntchito yamalonda kuti mupeze YAKOBRAINONPORN ndi YAKOBRAINONPORN.COM. Mu Epulo 2019, gulu lotsogozedwa ndi a Prause ndi Ley adachita kuphwanya malamulo kosagwirizana ndi malamulo of YourBrainOnPorn.com popanga "RealYourBrainOnPorn.com.

Potsatsa masamba awo osavomerezeka, "akatswiri" omwe amadzitcha okha adapanga akaunti ya Twitter (https://twitter.com/BrainOnPorn), njira YouTube, Facebook tsamba, ndipo adafalitsa cholengeza munkhani. Poyesanso kusokoneza anthu, atolankhani atinamizira kuti amachokera ku tawuni ya kwawo kwa Gary Wilson - Ashland, Oregon (palibe m'modzi mwa akatswiri "amakhala ku Oregon, ngakhale ashland). Dziwani nokha ngati "akatswiri" apititsa patsogolo zokonda za makampani zolaula kapena chowonadi chofufuzira chaukadaulo mwakugwiritsa ntchito mndandanda uwu wa ma tweets a RealYBOP. Wolemba Dr. kalembedwe kolakwika, ma tweet amaonetsa phindu la zolaula, amanenetsa zochitika zenizeni za kafukufuku, ndi Anthu omwe ali ndi mabungwe ndi mabungwe A Prause akhala akuzunza kale.

Kuphatikiza apo, "akatswiri" adapanga akaunti ya Reddit (wosuta / sayansi) kupezetsa zolaula zowonongeka reddit / zolaula ndi reddit / noFap ndi pulogalamu yotsatsa, kudzinenera kugwiritsira ntchito zolaula kulibe vuto lililonse kusokoneza YourBrainOnPorn.com ndi Gary Wilson. Ndikofunikira kudziwa kuti Prause, amene kale anali wophunzira, ali ndi mbiri yakale yakale Kugwiritsa ntchito alendo ambiri kuti alembe pazolowera zolaula. (YBOP tsopano anachita nawo milandu motsutsana ndi a Prause ndi omwe amagwirizana nawo).

Mu Julayi wa 2019, David Ley ndi awiri mwa odziwika bwino a RealYBOP "akatswiri" (Justin Lehmiller ndi Chris Donaghue) adayamba kuchita nawo poyera makampani opanga zolaula. Onse atatu ali pa gulu laupangiri wamasiye Alliance Health Alliance (SHA). Mukuwombana kopanda ndalama, David Ley ndi SHA ali kulipidwa ndi makampani ojambula zolaula chimphona chachikulu cha xHamster kulimbikitsa mawebusayiti ake (ie StripChat) ndikuwonetsetsa kuti ogwiritsa ntchito zolaula komanso zolaula ndizabodza!

Zambiri pa Nicole Prause

Mu 2013 wakale wa UCLA wofufuza Nicole Prause anayamba kufotokozera poyera, kunyoza ndi kuwombera njinga Gary Wilson. (Prause sanagwiritsidwe ntchito ndi bungwe la maphunziro kuyambira Januwale, 2015.) Patapita nthawi yochepa, adayambanso kutsogolera ena, kuphatikizapo ochita kafukufuku, madokotala, odwala, akatswiri a maganizo, omwe kale anali a UCLA, akuthandizira ku UK, amuna omwe amachira, TIME magazini editor, apulosi angapo, IITAP, SASH, Nkhondo ya Mankhwala atsopano, Eksodo Cry, NoFap.com, RebootNation, YourBrainRebalanced, magazini yophunzira Sciences makhalidwe, kampani yake ya makolo MDPI, madokotala a ku United States a Navy, mutu wa nkhani yophunzira CUREUS, ndi magazini Kugonana & Kukakamira.

Pamene amathera nthawi yambiri akuzunza ena, Prause amalima mwanzeru - ndi umboni wotsimikizika - nthano kuti iye anali "wozunzidwa" Mwa ambiri amene sanayesere kutsutsa zomwe ananena motsutsana ndi zotsatira za zolaula kapena momwe akufufuzira zolaula. Pokana kuthana ndi kuzunzidwa kosalekeza komanso zonamizira zabodza, YBOP adakakamizidwa kulemba zolemba zina za Prause. Onani masamba otsatirawa. (Zowonjezerapo zachitika kuti sitili ndi ufulu woulula - popeza omwe akuvutika ndi a Prause akuopa kubwezera.)

Pachiyambi Pembedzero inagwiritsira ntchito mayina ambiri abodza kuti azilembapo zolaula zowonongeka, Quora, Wikipedia, ndi ndemanga Ndime pamutu. Pemphero silinkagwiritsira ntchito dzina lake lenileni kapena nkhani zake zachikhalidwe. Zonsezi zinasintha pambuyo poti UCLA wasankha kuti asadzayambitse mgwirizano wa Prause (kuzungulira January, 2015).

Omasulidwa kuchokera ku kuyang'aniridwa kulikonse ndipo tsopano akudzigwira ntchito, Pemphero likuwonjezeranso azimayi awiri ofalitsa / othandizira kuchokera Media 2 × 3 ku kampani yake yaying'ono ya "Othandizira." Media 2 × 3 pulezidenti Jess Ponce akudzifotokoza yekha ngati Wophunzitsira wa ku media wa Hollywood ndi katswiri wodziwika bwino.) Ntchito yawo ndi nkhani zapadera muzolengeza akuphatikizapo Prause, ndikumpeza kuyankhulana mu zolaula zolaula komanso malo amodzi. Njira zolakwika za asayansi wosalingalira.

Pembedzero linayamba kutchula dzina lake kukhala mabodza, anthu ambiri omwe amazunza anthu ambiri komanso mabungwe omwe amachititsa anthu kuti azikhala nawo. Popeza cholinga chachikulu cha Prause chinali Gary Wilson (mazana ambiri omwe amawonetsera mafilimu omwe akutsatiridwa nawo pamasewero a email), zinakhala zofunikira kufufuza ndi kulemba ma tweets a Prause ndi posts. Izi zinachitidwa chitetezo cha omenyedwa, ndipo ndizofunikira pazomwe zilipo m'tsogolo.

Posakhalitsa zinaonekeratu kuti ma tweet ndi ndemanga za Prause sizinkachitika kawirikawiri zokhudza kafukufuku wamagonana, neuroscience, kapena nkhani ina iliyonse yokhudzana ndi luso lake. Ndipotu, mapepala ambiri a Prause angagawidwe m'magulu awiri ogwirizanitsa:

Thandizo losadziwika mwachindunji la zolaula: Zosokoneza & ad hominem Ndemanga yolunjika kwa anthu ndi mabungwe omwe amawatcha kuti "olimbana ndi zolaula" (nthawi zambiri amati ndi omwe amachitiridwa nkhanza ndi anthu komanso mabungwe). Zolembedwa apa: tsamba 1, tsamba 2, tsamba 3ndipo tsamba 4.
Chithandizo chachindunji cha zolaula:
- makamaka FSC (Mgwirizanowu waulere), AVN (Nkhani Zamavidiyo Akulu), opanga zolaula, ochita masewero, ndi mapulogalamu awo
- zosawerengeka zosawerengeka za kafukufuku wa zolaula ndi kuukiridwa pa maphunziro a zolaula kapena ochita kafukufuku wolaula.

Masamba otsatirawa ali ndi zitsanzo za ma tweets ndi ndemanga zokhudzana ndi #2 - thandizo lake lamphamvu pa malonda azolaula komanso malo omwe adasankhidwa. YBOP ndiye akuganiza kuti nkhanza za a Prause zakhala zikuchitika kawirikawiri komanso zosasamala (akumamunamizira kuti ambiri omwe amamuzunza chifukwa "akumusata," "misogyny," "kulimbikitsa ena kuti amugwirire," komanso "kukhala Nero-Nazi") , kuti tikakamizike kupenda zolinga zake. Zinthuzi zimagawidwa m'magawo akuluakulu a 4:

Ngakhale palibe umboni woti aliyense wa omwe adazunzidwa a Prause akunena kuti Prause amalandila ndalama kuchokera kuzogulitsa zolaula, aliyense akhoza kukhululukidwa chifukwa chodzifunsa ngati is chifukwa chotsogoleredwa ndi makampani opanga zolaula. The Masamba apemphero patsamba lino ndi nsonga chabe ya Prause Iceberg yayikulu kwambiri. Adalemba kangapo, kuwukira aliyense komanso aliyense amene angawonetse zolaula zitha kubweretsa mavuto. (Pembedzero posachedwa adatsuka akaunti yake ya twitter ya 3,000 kapena zambiri zomwe zimapatsa ma tweets.) Wakhala akuteteza bizinesiyo nthawi iliyonse, monga momwe mtsogoleri wolipirira wogulitsa amayenera kuchitira. Zachidziwikire kuti a Prause, omwe amakhala ku LA, amasangalala ndi ubale wabwino ndi makampani azolaula. Onani izi Chithunzi cha iye (kumanja) mwachiwonekere chinatengedwa pamapepala ofiira a X-Rated Critics Organization (XRCO) phwando la mphoto. Malinga ndi wiki pediya,

"The XRCO Awards amaperekedwa ndi American X-Rated Critics Organisation chaka ndi chaka kwa anthu ogwira ntchito zosangalatsa zachikulire ndipo ndizopadera zokha zotsatsa malonda zomwe zikuwonetseratu zokhazokha zogwiritsidwa ntchito kwa anthu ogulitsa ntchito.^[1]"

Zithunzi zomwe zidatengedwa pamalipiro a 2016 XRCO (Pembedzero & holo yodziwika bwino ya zolaula Melissa Hill kumanzere kumanzere). Chonde dziwani: Pali umboni wosatsutsika wosonyeza kuti makampani opanga zolaula adalipira ndalama zankhaninkhani kwa zaka zambiri. Nkhani ya Sexology imawonekabe kuti ikutithandiza pa zolaula. Chifukwa chake, umboni patsamba lino uyenera kuwonedwa mozama. Mwaona Hugh Hefner, International Academy of Research Research, ndi Purezidenti Wake Woyambitsa kuti amvetsetse momwe amalonda oonera zolaula ogwira ntchito zolimbitsa thupi amagwiritsa ntchito Kinsey Institute. Pembedzero ndi Kinsey grad.

Zambiri pa David Ley

Mikangano yazachuma ya David LeyCOI) zikuwoneka.

COI #1: Pakuwombana kopenyeka kwachuma, David Ley ndi kulipidwa ndi makampani opanga zolaula za chimphona cha X-hamster kutsatsa masamba awo ndikutsimikizira ogwiritsa ntchito kuti kuzolowera zolaula komanso chizolowezi chogonana ndizabodza! Makamaka, David Ley ndi omwe angopangidwa kumene Alliance Health Alliance (SHA) akhala ogwirizana ndi tsamba la X-Hamster (Strip-Chat). Mwaona "Stripchat imagwirizanitsa ndi Health Health Alliance kuti igwiritse ntchito bongo lanu lomwe limakhala ndi nkhawa":

Bungwe loyambitsanso za Health sex Alliance (SHA) gulu laupangiri akuphatikiza David Ley ndi ena awiri "Akatswiri" a RealYourBrainOnPorn.com (Justin Lehmiller & Chris Donahue). RealYBOP ndi gulu la poyera zolaula, omwe amadzitcha “akatswiri” otsogozedwa ndi Chithunzi cha Nicole. Ili ndi gulu lomwe pano kuphwanya malamulo kosamaloledwa ndi kuphwanya malamulo kuloza ku YBOP yovomerezeka. Mwachidule, omwe akuyesera kuti ateteze YBOP akulipiridwanso ndi makampani azolaula kulimbikitsa mabizinesi awo, ndikuwatsimikizira ogwiritsa ntchito kuti zolaula ndi ma cam sizimabweretsa mavuto (onani: Nicole Prause ali pafupi, amagwirizana pagulu lazamalonda ngati zolaula ngati zolembedwa patsamba lino).

In m'nkhaniyi, Ley amatsutsa kukweza kwake kotsatsa zolaula:

Inde, akatswiri azaumoyo omwe amagwira ntchito limodzi ndi malo ogulitsa zolaula amakumana ndi mavuto ena, makamaka kwa iwo omwe amafuna kuti azikhala opanda nkhawa. "Ndikulakalaka [olimbikitsa zolaula] onse azakuwa, 'Onani, David Ley akuchita zolaula," akutero Ley, yemwe Dzinali limatchulidwa pafupipafupi ndi zonyansa m'magulu ogonana ndi maliseche ngati NoFap.

Koma ngakhale ntchito yake ndi Stripchat mosakayikira imamupatsa chakudya kwa wina aliyense wofunitsitsa kuti amulembe ngati wakondera kapena mthumba la malo oonera zolaula, a Ley, malonda amenewo ndi oyenera. "Ngati tikufuna kuthandiza [oonera zolaula], tiyenera kupita kwa iwo," akutero. "Umu ndi momwe timachitira izi."

Kukondera? Ley akutikumbutsa za madokotala otchuka a fodya, komanso mgwirizano wa Zaumoyo Pathupi umatikumbutsa za Sukulu ya Fodya.

COI #2 David Ley ndi kulipidwa kuti mupewe zolaula komanso zolaula. Pamapeto pa izi Psychology Today Blog positi Ley akuti:

Kuulura: David Ley wapereka umboni pamilandu yokhudza milandu yomwe imakhudzana ndi zachiwerewere. "

Mu tsamba latsopano la 2019 David Ley adapereka ntchito zolipiridwa zabwino:

David J. Ley, Ph.D., ndi katswiri wazamisala komanso woyang'anira wotsimikizika wa AASECT wokhudza zachiwerewere, ku Albuquerque, NM. Wapereka umboni waukatswiri komanso umboni wazamalamulo milandu ingapo kuzungulira United States. A Dr. Ley amadziwika kuti ndi akatswiri pazachinyengo zabodza zokhudzana ndi chiwerewere, ndipo adatsimikizika ngati mboni waluso pamutuwu. Iye wachitira umboni m'makhothi aboma ndi feduro.
Lumikizanani naye kuti mupeze ndandanda wa zolipiritsa ndikukonzekera nthawi yoti mudzakambirane za chidwi chanu.

COI #3: Ley amapanga ndalama pogulitsa mabuku awiri omwe amakana kugonana ndi zolaula ("Nthano ya Kugonana Kwachiwerewere, "2012 ndi"Porn Ethics for Dicks,"2016). Pornhub (yomwe ili ndi chiwembu cha porn GiantGeek) ndi amodzi mwa malonjezo asanu osindikiza kumbuyo omwe alembedwa ku Ley's 2016 zokhudza zolaula:

Chidziwitso: PornHub anali akaunti yachiwiri ya Twitter kuti mubwezeretse njira yoyamba ya RealYBOP kulengeza tsamba lake la "katswiri", ndikuwonetsa kuyanjana pakati pa PornHub ndi Akatswiri a RealYBOP. Zopatsa chidwi!

COI #4: Pomaliza, David Ley amapanga ndalama kudzera Semina za CEU, komwe amalimbikitsa malingaliro okana-kukana omwe adalembedwa m'mabuku ake awiri (omwe mosasamala (?) amanyalanyaza maphunziro ambiri ndi kufunikira kwa chatsopanocho Kuzindikira Kakugonana Kwamisala mu buku la World Health Organisation's diagnostic. Ley amalipiridwa zolankhula zake zambiri zokhala ndi malingaliro okonda zolaula. M'mawonetsero awa a 2019 Ley akuwoneka kuti akuthandizira ndikukulimbikitsa kugwiritsa ntchito zolaula za achinyamata: Kupanga Kugonana Koyenera ndi Kugwiritsa Ntchito Zolaula Zoyenera Kuchita Achinyamata.

**June, 2019: MDPI (kholo la kampaniyo Sciences makhalidwe) amafalitsa Mkonzi za machitidwe osayenerera a Nicole Prause omuzungulira zoyesayesa zosatheka kukhala nazo Park et al., 2016 wachotsedwa**

Ndemanga ya MDPI yokhudza machitidwe a Prause (omwe alembedwa pamwambapa):

21 June 2019
Ndemanga pa Park, B., et al. Kodi Zithunzi Zolaula Zimayambitsa Mavuto Ogonana? Kubwereza ndi Malipoti Achipatala Behav. Sci. 2016, 6, 17
Mu August 2017, Sciences makhalidwe inafalitsa nkhani [1], yomwe ikuphatikizapo kafukufuku wa anthu atatu mu US Navy. Papepalali tinakonzanso momwe timasinthira, kuphatikiza kuwunika kwa anzawo, ndipo adavomerezedwa kuti asindikizidwe. Kuyambira pamenepo, talandira madandaulo angapo kuchokera kwa munthu m'modzi yemwe akuti pepalali ndi lolakwika kwambiri ndikufuna kuti nkhaniyi ichotsedwe. Mu ndemanga iyi tikufuna kubwerezanso kuti njira zolondola zidatsatiridwa pakugwiritsa ntchito zolembedwazo ndikutsutsa pagulu zina mwazomwe zanenedwa. Committee for Publication Ethics (COPE) idalingalira zina mwa izi ndipo tili othokoza chifukwa cha upangiri wawo komanso mgwirizano wawo. Tikufunanso kuthokoza olemba chifukwa chothandizana nawo.
Chimodzi mwazomwe zidaperekedwa papepalali ndikuti chilolezo chofunikira sichinapemphedwe kuchokera kwa anthu atatu omwe awonetsedwa m'maphunziro omwe aperekedwa. Malinga ndi malangizo a olemba omwe adatumizidwa pa Sciences makhalidwe webusaitiyi, chilolezo chodziwitsidwa chiyenera kupezeka pamaphunziro omwe angakhale kuti pali vuto lililonse loti anthu atha kudziwika. Atafunsidwa kuti atsimikizire mfundoyi, olembawo adatsimikiza kuti chilolezo chidapezeka kwa anthu awiri ndikuti chachitatu sichinafotokozeredwe papepalapo kuti avomereze. Ofesi yosindikiza yawona makope osinthidwa a fomu yovomerezera akugwiritsidwa ntchito ndipo yakhutira ndi zomwe olemba analemba.
Vuto lina linali loti mkonzi wamaphunziro pankhaniyi samadziwa kuti akupanga chisankho chomaliza chovomereza kuti [1] isindikizidwe. Sciences makhalidwe imagwiritsa ntchito template yokhazikika poyitanitsa osintha kuti apange chisankho chomaliza chovomereza zolemba pamanja, zomwe zidachitidwanso pano. Chiyambire kudandaula, mkonzi woyambirira wamaphunziro adatiwuza kuti samadziwa kuti ndiudindo wake papepalali. Tidawunikiranso zomwe anzawo akuchita ndi mkonzi wamkulu (yemwe kale anali) a John Coverdale ndikupanga chisankho kuti zolembedwazo siziyenera kuchotsedwa pachifukwa ichi. Mu Correction yofalitsidwa [2], chidziwitso cha mkonzi wamaphunziro adasinthidwa.
Zonena zambiri zakusemphana chidwi kwa olemba zidapangidwa mokhudzana ndi [1]. Mkangano umodzi wokha wosagwirizana ndi ndalama womwe udawonetsedwa udatsimikiziridwa ndipo pepalali lasinthidwa [2].
Zotsatira zake, MDPI yasintha malangizo ake kwa olemba kuti afotokozere momveka bwino zavomerezo ndi kuwongolera olemba m'derali. Zofunikira ndi mfundo zathu sizinasinthe ndipo tikupitilizabe kutsatira malangizo operekedwa ndi COPE.
Tikukhulupirira kuti mkangano womwe udazunguliridwa ndi pepalayi udachokera pakusiyana kwamalingaliro malinga ndi momwe amathandizira anthu omwe amagwiritsa ntchito zolaula zambiri, ndipo sanalimbikitsidwe ndi nkhawa zenizeni zakukonza zomwe zili papepalalo [3]. Malingaliro athu ndikuti njira yolondola yothetsera kusamvana koteroko ndikupereka zifukwa ndi zotsutsana pazosinthidwa ndi anzawo, zasayansi pomwe mikangano yonse yazosangalatsa ya onsewa yaululidwa moyenera. Kudzudzula panokha kulibe malo pankhaniyi ndipo kuyesa kutseka iwo omwe ali ndi malingaliro otsutsana pochotsa ntchito zawo m'mabuku si njira yolondola. Tikudziwa kuti olemba ndi owerenga ambiri amafufuza kafukufuku m'njira yothandiza komanso yochita nawo chidwi ndipo tikufuna kulimbikitsa njira iyi kuti gulu lonse lofufuzira lipindule.
Zothandizira
[1] Park, BY; Wilson, G .; Berger, J .; Christman, M.; Reina, B.; Bishopu, F .; Klam, WP; Doan, AP Kodi Zithunzi Zolaula za pa Intaneti Zimayambitsa Mavuto Ogonana? Kubwereza ndi Malipoti Achipatala. Sci. 2016, 6, 17.
[2] Park, BY et al .; Kukonzekera: Park, BY, et al. Kodi Zithunzi Zolaula Zimayambitsa Mavuto Ogonana? Kubwereza ndi Malipoti Achipatala Sci. 2016, 6, 17. Behav. Sci. 2018, 8, 55.
[3] Marcus, A. "Zolemba zimakonza, koma sizibweza, zotsutsana pazithunzi zolaula pa intaneti". Anabweza Watch. Ipezeka pa intaneti: https://retractionwatch.com/2018/06/13/journal-corrects-but-will-not-retract-controversial-paper-on-internet-porn/ (yopezeka pa 13 June 2018) ndi https://web.archive.org/web/20180913124808/https://retractionwatch.com/2018/06/13/journal-corrects-but-will-not-retract-controversial-paper-on-internet-porn/ (zosungidwa pa 13 Seputembara 2018).

Ndemanga za Gary Wilson pa chiganizo chotsatira:

Mkangano umodzi wokha wosagwirizana ndi ndalama womwe udawonetsedwa udatsimikiziridwa ndipo pepalali lasinthidwa [2].

Monga ndalongosolera ndemanga yanga yobweza Watch (yomwe idawunikidwa pang'ono ndi Retraction Watch!), Mgwirizano wanga ndi The Reward Foundation udali papepala loyambirira, ndi mtundu wakale woperekedwa ku The Yale Journal of Biology & Medicine koyambirira kwa 2015. Ndemanga yanga:

Zomwe sizikudziwika m'nkhaniyi ndikuti mgwirizano wanga (wa Wilson) ndi The Reward Foundation udawululidwa kuyambira koyambirira (onani mtundu woyambirira wa PubMed, wofalitsidwa mu Ogasiti, 2016 - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5039517/). Malangizowo adasindikizidwa kuti anditeteze, poyesa kuletsa Dr. Prause kuti asapitilize kunena kuti ndikulipidwa ndi The Reward Foundation ngati lobbyist, kapena "kulipidwa basi." (Adafotokozera pagulu malingaliro angapo opanda maziko okhudzana ndi ziphuphu zanga.) Mukukonzekera kwa magaziniyi, mutu wokha wa buku langa ("Your Brain On Porn: Internet Pornography and the Emerging Science of Addiction") ndikuwonetsanso bwino gawo lomwe sindinapereke. ku The Reward Foundation adawonjezeredwa. Apanso, izi zinali kuteteza zonena zina zakusokonekera kwachuma komwe kungachitike. Mtundu wokonzedwa: http://www.mdpi.com/2076-328X/8/6/55/htm

Mwachidule, kukonza kumeneku kunatanthauza kuti anditeteze ku Prause ndi zonama zake zabodza patsamba lino.

Juni, 2019: Kuyankha kwa MDPI ku ku Tsamba la MDPI Wikipedia (yomwe yasinthidwa ndi sockpuppets angapo a Nicole Prause)

Pasanapite nthawi Park et al., 2016 idasindikizidwa Pembedzero lidapita ku warpath yolimbana ndi MDPI, Behaeveal Science, komanso olemba a Park et al., Akugwiritsa ntchito njira zingapo zowukira mobisa komanso zobisika (zolembedwa patsamba lino - Zopempherera kuti zikhale ndi mapepala owonetsera za Sayansi ya Chikhalidwe (Park et al., 2016) adabwezeretsedwa ). Njira imodzi yowukira inali yosintha MDPI Wikipedia tsamba pogwiritsa ntchito ma aliases angapo (sockpuppets), omwe amaphwanya malamulo a Wikipedia. Pakadali pano tazindikira osachepera 30 mwina zodandaula.

Tiyeni tiyambe ndi wogwiritsa ntchito Wikipedia NeuroSex, omwe anali ndi maulemu ena osachepera 8 - onse omwe adaletsedwa monga Zokopa za Wikipedia za NeuroSex. Matenda okhudzana ndi kugonana kwa amuna kapena akazi okhaokha, ma sockpuppets ake, ndi ma sockpuppets ena a Prause asintha Wikipedia, ndikulemba zabodza zokhudza Gary Wilson, Park et al. ndi MDPI (Zolemba za PDF za Nicole Prause zomwe amamuzunza ndikuwanyoza).

Mwachitsanzo, NeuroSex adaikapo zambiri zowonetsera ma Prause tweets ndi kutenga zomwe zatchulidwa mwachangu ndi maimelo a Prause ndi MDPI (zambiri zomwe Wilson wawona). NeuroSex adatero ali ndi maimelo a MDPI apadera - omwe akufuna kutumiza ku tsamba la MDPI Wikipedia. Nazi zomwe NeuroSex adanena m'mawu ake. (Chidziwitso: Mu maimelo omwe amafanana ndi MDPI, Prause cc'd Chotsatira Chotsatira, mwachiwonekere kuopseza MDPI ndi kubwezera kwa anthu.):

Ndili ndi zithunzi zomwe zimatsimikizira zomwe zimanena (mwachitsanzo, imelo kuchokera kwa wofalitsa, imelo kuchokera kwa mkonzi wolembedwa, etc.). Zowonongeka ndi zolembera zina zikulingalira kulembera ndemanga zowonjezeranso, koma sindingatsimikize kuti iwo adzalumikiza. Kodi ndi bwino bwanji kupereka umboni woterewu kutsimikizira zomwe akunenazo? Monga chithunzi chojambulidwa? Wolemba kwinakwake ndi zithunzi ndi zogwirizana?

Tiyeni tiwonetse zitsanzo zingapo za zosintha za "NeuroSex" (zonama) zokhudzana ndi Gary Wilson ndi Park et al., 2016 - yotsatiridwa ndi ndemanga za Wilson:

Kusintha kwa NeuroSex # 1: Gary Wilson anali {{cite web | title = yolipidwa mapaundi 9000 | url =https://www.oscr.org.uk/downloadfile.aspx?id=160223&type=5&charityid=SC044948&arid=236451}} Reward Foundation yokakamira ku US m'malo mwa zonena zotsutsana ndi zolaula.

Gary Wilson ndemanga: NeuroSex yolumikizidwa ndi chikalata chosinthidwa, ponena kuti Gary Wilson adalipira mapaundi 9,000 ndi bungwe lachifundo laku Scottish The Reward Foundation. Masiku awiri m'mbuyomu Pembedzero yabodza kwa wofalitsa nyuzipepala MDPI (ndi ena) kuti, kutengera kufalitsa nkhani zachifundo zaposachedwa (ndi dzina lokonzedwanso, monga momwe ziliri), kubweza ndalama zomwe adapereka kwa wopereka zachifundo adalipira Wilson. Pembedzero silinafufuze zowona zake, ndipo akulakwitsa (kachiwiri). Wilson sanalandire konse ndalama kuchokera ku The Reward Foundation. Pembedzero labwerezanso bodza lomweli kwina.

Zotupitsa zitatu za NeuroSex yemwe adasintha tsamba la MDPI Wikpedia (maulalo akuwonetsa mndandanda wazosinthira thumba lililonse):

Zowonjezera zina za NeuroSex (Prause) omwe asinthanso MDPI (mwina alipo enanso):

Zolemba zina zambiri zidalembedwa kumapeto kwa gawo ili: Epulo-Meyi, 2019: Sockpuppets awiri a "NeuroSex" (SecondaryEd2020 & Sciencearousal) amasintha Wikipedia, ndikuyika ulalo wa RealYourBrainOnporn.com ndi mabodza onga a Prause

Kufikira kulengeza kwa MDPI:

Zilengezo zochokera ku MDPI 19 June 2019
Kuyankha kwa MDPI Wikipedia Article
Wikipedia ndi chinthu chofunikira kwambiri chodziwitsa anthu za mderalo ndipo MDPI imathandizira kuyesetsa kufalitsa chidziwitso, chomwe chikugwirizana kwambiri ndi zolinga za MDPI. Tsoka ilo, akonzi ena a tsamba la Wikipedia lokhudza MDPI alibe chidwi. Izi zimasiya nkhaniyi kukhala yosakondera komanso yopanda chidziwitso chazambiri zomwe MDPI ikuchita. Zosintha zilizonse zomwe zingawonjezeredwe patsamba zimachotsedwa mwachangu. Tayesapo kangapo kuti tikambirane ndi akonzi a Wikipedia kuti tikonze nkhaniyo, koma osapambana. Chifukwa chake, pakadali pano, sitikuvomereza Wikipedia ngati gwero lodalirika lodziwitsa za MDPI.
Kuti mumve zambiri za MDPI, onani https://www.mdpi.com/about/history. Kuphatikiza apo, pali magulu ena achitetezo omwe amapezeka pamagazini a MDPI monga http://qoam.eu/journals, ndi Publons (https://publons.com/journal/?order_by=num_reviews_last_one_year).
Pafupifupi magawo atatu mwa magawo anayi a nkhani ya Wikipedia imafotokoza nkhani zotsutsana, kutchula 4 mwa zikalata zoposa 200,000 zomwe zidasindikizidwa, nthawi imodzi pomwe mamembala 10 a komiti yolemba adasiya ntchito (mu 2018 tinali ndi mamembala opitilira 43,000 a Board of the editors komanso a Guest Editors), ndikuphatikizanso pamndandanda wa Jeffrey Beall, wodziwika ngati gwero lotsutsana ndi mwayi wotseguka komanso komwe MDPI idachotsedwa (onani yankho lathu Pano). Ngakhale sitikutsutsana ndi mitu yomwe ikutchulidwayi, njira yomwe amaphunzitsira ndiyosocheretsa.
Mayankho ku mitu ina yomwe ikupezeka amapezeka pa:
Zodabwitsa Zaku Australia (Zakudya Zakudya): https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/4/4/258/htm.
Andrulis pepala (Moyo): https://www.mdpi.com/2075-1729/2/1/213/htm.
Kusintha komiti yolemba (Nutrients): https://www.mdpi.com/about/announcements/1389.
Ndemanga pa Park, B., et al. Kodi Zithunzi Zolaula Zimayambitsa Mavuto Ogonana? Kubwereza ndi Malipoti Achipatala Behav. Sci. 2016, 6, 17: https://www.mdpi.com/about/announcements/1616.

Kampani yayikulu ya makolo yomwe imatumiza ziganizo ziwiri zovomerezeka zokhudzana ndi mchitidwe wosayenerera wa PhD yopanda tanthauzo ikhoza kukhala yopanda tanthauzo.

Kulemba kwa Nicole Prause kuti akhale ndi pepala lofufuzira za Sayansi ya Chikhalidwe (Park et al., 2016) akubwezeretsedwa

M'NDANDANDA WAZOPEZEKAMO:

**"Ndani akuyang'ana Anabweza Watch? "**

Background

Mbiri ya MDPI isanachitike: Yale Journal of Biology & Medicine, ndi "Janey Wilson"

***Sciences makhalidwe* Baibulo la *Park et al.***

Kufuna kubwezera

**Pemphero limagwiritsa ntchito mafilimu kuti awononge MDPI, ofufuza omwe amafalitsa m'magazini a MDPI, ndi aliyense amene akulemba Park et al., 2016**

Meyi 24-27, 2018 - Pembedzero limapanga zidole zingapo kuti zisinthe MDPI Wikipedia tsamba (ndipo ndi loletsedwa chifukwa chonyengerera ndi kuwononga mbiri)

**Pembedzero limanama za Gary Wilson m'maimelo opita ku MDPI, David Ley, Neuro Skeptic, Adam Marcus wa Kuwongolera Penyani, ndi COPE (Meyi, 2018)**

Limbikitsani EMAIL # 1 (5-1-2018)

Limbikitsani EMAIL # 2 (5-22-2018)

Limbikitsani EMAIL # 3 (5-22-2018)

Zochita za "Janey Wilson" (Prause)

Maimelo ena ochepa omwe atchulidwa munkhani ya "Janey":

2015

[Kusinthana kwa "Janey" ndi wofalitsa wanga]

[Kusinthana kwa "Janey" ndi The Melting Pot]

2016

Pembedzero lolumikizana ndi wofalitsa wanga, a Dan Hind, ndikudzitcha kuti "Janey Wilson"

Imelo kwa wopanga tsamba la Dan Hind:

Chidule cha nkhaniyi:

Zikuyenda bwanji apa?

Zambiri pa Nicole Prause

Zambiri pa David Ley

**June, 2019: MDPI (kholo la kampaniyo Sciences makhalidwe) amafalitsa Mkonzi za machitidwe osayenerera a Nicole Prause omuzungulira zoyesayesa zosatheka kukhala nazo Park et al., 2016 wachotsedwa**

Juni, 2019: Kuyankha kwa MDPI ku ku Tsamba la MDPI Wikipedia (yomwe yasinthidwa ndi sockpuppets angapo a Nicole Prause)

Links Quick

M'NDANDANDA WAZOPEZEKAMO:

"Ndani akuyang'ana Anabweza Watch? "

Background

Mbiri ya MDPI isanachitike: Yale Journal of Biology & Medicine, ndi "Janey Wilson"

Sciences makhalidwe Baibulo la Park et al.

Kufuna kubwezera

Pemphero limagwiritsa ntchito mafilimu kuti awononge MDPI, ofufuza omwe amafalitsa m'magazini a MDPI, ndi aliyense amene akulemba Park et al., 2016

Meyi 24-27, 2018 - Pembedzero limapanga zidole zingapo kuti zisinthe MDPI Wikipedia tsamba (ndipo ndi loletsedwa chifukwa chonyengerera ndi kuwononga mbiri)

Pembedzero limanama za Gary Wilson m'maimelo opita ku MDPI, David Ley, Neuro Skeptic, Adam Marcus wa Kuwongolera Penyani, ndi COPE (Meyi, 2018)

Limbikitsani EMAIL # 1 (5-1-2018)

Limbikitsani EMAIL # 2 (5-22-2018)

Limbikitsani EMAIL # 3 (5-22-2018)

Zochita za "Janey Wilson" (Prause)

Maimelo ena ochepa omwe atchulidwa munkhani ya "Janey":

2015

[Kusinthana kwa "Janey" ndi wofalitsa wanga]

[Kusinthana kwa "Janey" ndi The Melting Pot]

2016

Pembedzero lolumikizana ndi wofalitsa wanga, a Dan Hind, ndikudzitcha kuti "Janey Wilson"

Imelo kwa wopanga tsamba la Dan Hind:

Chidule cha nkhaniyi:

Zikuyenda bwanji apa?

Zambiri pa Nicole Prause

Zambiri pa David Ley

June, 2019: MDPI (kholo la kampaniyo Sciences makhalidwe) amafalitsa Mkonzi za machitidwe osayenerera a Nicole Prause omuzungulira zoyesayesa zosatheka kukhala nazo Park et al., 2016 wachotsedwa

Juni, 2019: Kuyankha kwa MDPI ku ku Tsamba la MDPI Wikipedia (yomwe yasinthidwa ndi sockpuppets angapo a Nicole Prause)

Links Quick

**"Ndani akuyang'ana Anabweza Watch? "**

***Sciences makhalidwe* Baibulo la *Park et al.***

**Pemphero limagwiritsa ntchito mafilimu kuti awononge MDPI, ofufuza omwe amafalitsa m'magazini a MDPI, ndi aliyense amene akulemba Park et al., 2016**

**Pembedzero limanama za Gary Wilson m'maimelo opita ku MDPI, David Ley, Neuro Skeptic, Adam Marcus wa Kuwongolera Penyani, ndi COPE (Meyi, 2018)**

**June, 2019: MDPI (kholo la kampaniyo Sciences makhalidwe) amafalitsa Mkonzi za machitidwe osayenerera a Nicole Prause omuzungulira zoyesayesa zosatheka kukhala nazo Park et al., 2016 wachotsedwa**